GTA 6: 10 Things Rockstar Must AVOID From Red Dead 2
Maybe don't take three separate animations to pick something up?
Rockstar Games' Red Dead Redemption 2 received lots of praise for a captivating role-playing experience, allowing you to be a cowboy in a fully realised period of 1899 and the cusp of the 20th century.
Yet the game wouldn't be quite as whole without its compelling characters, drama-filled debacle within the Van der Linde gang, and the many pressures from those who oppose their outlaw ways.
However, the final product being so focused on the narrative inadvertently hinders gameplay.
Many times you'd be yanked out of the experience because you're faced with a prolonged sequence of animations, suddenly have to shoot up a town despite being a high honor protagonist, or realise that combat encourages going behind cover, only to pop up and hit an auto-locked target over and over.
GTA 5 might have some of the shortcomings listed too, but with a hotly anticipated sequel of GTA 6, we expect to see better from this meticulous crew of developers at Rockstar.
It'll take something mighty special to top GTA 5, but considering the risks taken in Red Dead Redemption 2, there should be a way to find a happy medium.
10. Recycling Maps For Nostalgia Sake
After completing the main story line in RDR2, you could finally travel past Blackwater and explore the western area of the map.
However this area is a clear homage to the previous game, since there are no side quests and no clear objective to complete. All you could do is soak in the familiar lands of New Austin.
If you spent a lot of time in Armadillo in the first game, you'll see a stark difference. RDR2's Armadillo was dilipated, boarded up, and plagued by cholera. As John Marston in the epilogue, you couldn't help these people, nor influence them.
The residents will just stay curled up in the closed down train station or other assorted places, and stay that way. It's neat to see how landmarks evolved from one game to the other, but if it doesn't have much to offer gameplay-wise, does it deserve inclusion?
If GTA 6 is going to be taking place in Vice City, it is important Rockstar don't fall victim to this once more, and deliver a service in these areas that harmonises with the gameplay set up beforehand.
9. Forcing The Player Into A VERY Slow Walk
If Rockstar made it so you can only walk around camp to slow down and communicate with the gang, it showed a reliance on the actor's motion capture performance over gameplay. The game was advertised as a role-playing experience, and there are other systems that support this. However, by slowing Arthur down so much at camp, it feels jarring, and something that you have to tolerate over time.
If they gave the player more leeway, they'd feel more attached to Arthur when embodying his character - rather than have the game almost "take over" during these scenes. It incentivises a linear narrative, when the game could benefit from giving the player total free reign, since they do in most other scenarios throughout the story.
If Rockstar must, they should spare the slow walk for dramatic climaxes such as when Arthur begins suffering from TB.
Slow walking in such crucial areas should be avoided in GTA 6, since that franchise highlights how you are the embodiment of chaos in a whacky and crude take on America. The player should be able to move as freely as possible, and Rockstar need to find another way to deliver impactful narrative moments.
8. A Moral System That Contradicts The Story
The honour system was a nice concept, and made the illusion that your Arthur could be a despicable man or a good man, depending on your game decisions.
This didn't realise itself until the end of Arthur's story, when in the third act Arthur breaches from Dutch van Linde's leadership and decides to help John and his family. Based off this, it was clear that Arthur was supposed to be an honourable man.
Yet in the main quest you are also forced to kill all the inhabitants of Strawberry and other towns. Even when you went back to these locations, they'd be refilled and you could gain your honour back by waving your hand to passersby and paying a fee.
For GTA 6 they should avoid this mechanic, since it didn't offer much variety in RDR2, or perhaps retool it to have a system that doesn't clearly clash with the central focus of the game. If done well it could add flavour, such as approaching a mission through stealth or going in loud.
Speaking of which...
7. Outdated Gun Combat
The way you were able to approach shootouts in RDR2 left much to be desired. Different weapon types were closer to reskins than multiple ways to approach gunplay. With the exception of the sniper rifle's scope and arrows, if you shoot with a revolver, it's as effective as a shotgun, repeater or pistol.
Polishing your guns was a welcome addition, but didn't punish you for forgetting, since in the early game any damage was effective, and in the late game you had the small arsenal mentioned above.
It would be pleasant to see level designs that pushed for other weapon use, such as the shotgun for close corridor encounters, pistols when in disguised events, and a sniper when the distance is simply too far. One step further would be the option of subduing guards silently so law enforcement isn't called for.
This would be a far greater improvement to the cover mechanic used, since you were like a whack-a-mole, peaking out for auto-locked damage, then ducking again to avoid sustaining any injuries yourself.
6. The Abundance Of Realistic Animations
The amount of time spent looting bodies, cutting up hunted down animals, and opening drawers was insane in RDR2.
On their own they were only a few seconds long, but as you often do these one after the other, they become laborious quite fast. Especially when you had to do 3 different animations just to stow an item on your horse or your person.
It was an odd inclusion considering shaving and trimming had no animation, and smoking a cigarette was one puff and thrown away.
It would be clever to leave this finer detail to events that don't happen as frequently, such as planting dynamite on a hard surface, or looting from a safe. Both instances work well to keep the pressure in a gun fight and occur too little to become tedious.
GTA 6 should entirely avoid this and play into the action of the game. The longer it takes to do the average thing, the more players lose interest. Excluding the fact that RDR2 gained in character what it lost in gameplay, GTA 6 should be the opposite, encouraging players to dig into all aspects of the game untouched by drawn-out animations.
5. Accidentally Leaving Weapons Behind (On Your Horse)
The last thing you want when going into a western gunfight is realise that you've left your primary weapon on your horse.
When this happens you funnily tried to whistle your horse into battle and run after it so you can get your trusty repeater, or rifle for the battle. Even though there are plenty of enemy guns that could have be repurposed, they were never effective enough as a custom firearm. This is again due to the realism adopted by Red Dead Redemption 2.
Arthur will often get tired of carrying guns on his back and place them on his horse's saddle. So even if you do want to switch your weapon, you'd have to do it preemptively, with no notion about what is to come of the mission ahead.
This kind of quirk is something that will need to be ironed out in GTA 6 since it doesn't fit with the tone of that franchise and is plain annoying after it happens the first time in RDR2.
It would be an incredible oversight if GTA 6 managed to have this system in their game, as you could carry all weaponry holstered on your person in the previous entries.
4. Shortage Of Unique Set Pieces
The length of Red Dead Redemption 2 provided its fair few gunfights. This included fighting beside Native Americans and outlaws, and in one example, being able to air balloon over a prison. However, it took a decent amount of hours to progress to the more extreme set pieces this game had to offer.
Until then, you wouldn't get anything as iconic as the blizzard beginning until robbing the bank in Valentine. This left gameplay feeling samey, where it should be trying it's best to sell all the combat possibilities and interactions with surroundings to the audience.
For the majority of the game, you galloped on your horse, chatted to gang members who rode alongside you, and were tasked to collect goods or information from one place to the next. Before obtaining what's wanted, you'd have to dispatch of a sizeable militia, then scurry or hold of an attack at the mission's end.
Rinse, repeat.
For GTA 6 it would be fantastic to start on a big action set piece, like how the characters in RDR2 constantly refer to the botched robbery in Blackwater. With the vehicles, new weaponry and scaling buildings available, the potential for impressive and dynamic stages would be endless.
3. A Forgotten Economy
The Red Dead Redemption 2 economy could've been great. With it being more centred on realism, we could have gotten merchants that would not only offer you items for cash, but reject items you try to sell back to them. And in the case of butchers, only take a certain amount of harvest due to the demand of the product.
Yet, when you loot the bank in Valentine, you no longer have to worry about getting cash as you're given a great deal from just this single mission.
A far more balanced or considered economy would have made you sympathise with the gang's struggle more, and also make it so there'd be trickier situations where you have to be creative to get cash.
GTA is a franchise about heisting and stealing cars, so it's essential Rockstar get this correct, retaining a balance of tension to get money and being satisfied with the reward of a big score.
It would make each gun or car you buy more cherished and important, since you saved the cash in order to purchase it.
2. A Half-Baked Online Mode
Rockstar has made moves, adding new content such as bounty missions and other activities, in order to make the online experience better than what Red Dead Online had on release.
Before it was an empty landscape where you'd have to be creative with your friends in order to make it worthwhile. But there was only a certain number of things you could do before experiencing everything the virtual cowboy landscape had to offer.
When GTA 6 will inevitably add online mode to their game, it will have to contend more with GTA 5 over that of Red Dead Online. But what they can learn is patience in getting to a better product, since they didn't get too much sales for RDR2 when online was debuted and definitely less so in micro-transactions.
Another issue they'd need to avoid is having essential kit and customisation unavailable at lower levels, and/or behind expensive in-game price tags. Everyone entering GTA 6 Online should be able to start with no worries about obtaining a vehicle or high firepower weapon to participate in missions with their buddies or strangers.
1. That Slow Pace
The most important thing to take away from this list is the game's speed.
Since we'll be more familiar to the suburban environment of GTA 6, it'll need to keep the pressure on, and introduce story and game elements quickly so we can roam the world unconfined, then find what the map has to offer at our own leisure.
RDR2 used New Hanover as its tutorial area, with all the interest being focused on Valentine. Later on, you either rode your horse to further away quest markers or used fast travel. With the countless amount of unique transports you could insert into GTA's modern setting, the missions could be stretched out in sheer distance, making the player get familiar with the mechanics while offering faster ways to progress, bit by bit.
Offering more variety early on will rectify the issue Red Dead Redemption 2 had with pace, and grant GTA 6 an early advantage.
Lastly, GTA 6 doesn't need as ludicrous an opening as you'd expect from a Saints Row game, but utilising a good hook would be beneficial. It gets players invested and moving through the plot quickly and steadily.
With this in place, the player would be the one to decide how quickly they complete the main storyline.