GTA 6: 8 Unexpected Risks Rockstar Must Take
GTA cannot become stale.
With the entertainment world forever fascinated by the likes of the MCU and superhero cinema in general, it's easy to forget there's another massive project in the works; one with arguably more stakes and money riding on it. GTA 6 is, for want of a better word, Rockstar's riskiest and most anticipated work yet.
We've had the medium-shaking, generation-defining delights of the PS2 trilogy, the tonal-shifting GTA IV and the almost apologetically ridiculous, wounds-healing GTA V, but GTA Online? Now that became something else entirely. Rockstar as a company were so utterly blown away by the success of the multi-million dollar-making online component to GTA V, they've... all but stopped making games. Where once we had everything from Bully to The Warriors, Manhunt to, erm, Table Tennis, the 2010s have only saw Red Dead Redemption 1 and 2, alongside a LOT of GTA Online DLC packs.
Going into GTA VI, clearly both Rockstar and Take Two are crunching the financials on multiplayer vs. single player, dynamic player interactions vs. sandboxes filled with A.I. Whatever GTA VI ends up being, it can't just be a glorified expansion to GTA Online, set in a new environment.
8. Release GTA Online As A Standalone Game
There is one home truth to GTA Online: Those who play it, ONLY play it, and those who don't... couldn't care less. There is no such thing as a casual GTA Online player, and to a good half of GTA's fanbase, the idea of playing online just isn't why they come to the franchise. Instead, they want missions, incredibly fun scenarios that come from various A.I. scripts bashing into one another at random - in short, they want the GTA that was established back in part three, done in new and increasingly fun ways.
For the others - and the substantial financials back this up tenfold - they're more than happy spending hundreds and thousands of dollars on Shark Cards, to amass digital collections of cars and homesteads. You can live an entire digital life inside GTA Online, and these two contrasting approaches to essentially "one game" should be separated.
Let GTA Online be its own behemoth; give it battle royale modes and maybe even release it as a free to play game (Shark Cards make millions a day in microtransactions no matter what). Only then can we have a dedicated team of Rockstar's finest putting their all into the narrative side of the franchise.
7. Cast The Whole Game With A-Listers
Rockstar have noted in the past that they moved away from identifiable voices because an audience will only hear the actor, but I respectfully disagree.
Something that used to exemplify the older GTAs, we haven't had a celebrity/star-studded voice cast since San Andreas. Yes, GTA's IV and V had the occasional cameo, but it was nothing on everyone from Samuel L. Jackson to Sean Ryder popping up to voice some loveable individuals.
Put simply: There's no major reason not to make GTA the biggest franchise in town when it comes to production.
All-star voice casts gave us scores of loveable characters, padding out the worlds they were in and making their respective instalments all that more fun to get through. At this stage, GTA is big enough that Rockstar could get anybody, so let's see some legends of cinema make an appearance.
6. Embrace The "Eyes Of The World" Controversy
Once the world's most dangerous franchise, GTA almost neutered itself coming out of GTA IV. Following Rockstar's maturation of the series direction to tell a more traditional tale about how manufactured the American Dream can be, GTA V had a much talked-about torture scene... but that was it.
Even said torture scene felt forced, like some ageing punk band trying their best to reconnect with those anarchic roots that once ensnared them a fanbase in the first place. Thankfully, it resulted in a formula for financial success like nothing else, and yet... something was lost.
GTA's entire appeal is voyeuristically indulging in the darkest desires of humanity's preternatural bloodlust. It exists as a black mirror to western society; a way to act out, say things that shouldn't be said, and do anything that simply isn't acceptable in real life.
GTA V let us do all these things, almost in a cartoon fashion, but with more narrative weight, specific scenarios that reflect real-world woes and characters with real motivations, GTA could be the politician-scaring behemoth it once was, all over again.
5. Take Major Influence From Storytelling Heavyweights To Write Something Truly Great
Another ongoing facet of narrative design in gaming is self-reflection. GTA IV attempted to write a full story about the allure of the criminal life to an ex-soldier looking to just get things done and move on, and GTA V's Trevor was absolutely a comment on how the average person plays GTA, but neither of these landed.
Niko's character was undone by the very actions we were allowed to partake in; his cutscene dialogue portraying a different person to every action in between. And Trevor? He was so unbelievably OTT, doing everything from making comments about eating people to butchering friendly characters just trying to help him, that any comment he could've made on GTA as a franchise was completely obscured.
Now, GTA absolutely doesn't need to do anything in the way of Uncharted 4's family life-loving Drake or God of War's self-reflective Kratos, but if Rockstar could make their own franchise a focal point for millions of future conversations on violence in games and its appeal... that wouldn't be half bad.
4. Custom Voiced Protagonist W/ A Variety Of Roles To Play
Perhaps the answer to GTA's never-ending problem with believability and ludonarrative dissonance (when a character's actions in-game betray how they act elsewhere) is to have a completely custom character from the beginning - but with a fully voiced performance backing them up?
Comparisons would be the original Mass Effect trilogy (which, discarding the ending, made our choices feel impactful throughout) and Fallout 4, both in terms of fully voiced - yet custom - protagonists.
Both these games came with myriad dialogue options and branching paths, and though GTA doesn't need to upend its cutscenes or general pace, many will remember how in GTA III, you could choose to kill mission-giver Kenji if you accepted a hit from someone else, changing the way that plot played out.
Things like this would give GTA such a great sense of immersion, letting Rockstar get away from writing specific "characters" and instead, a blank slate we can point at whatever we like.
3. The Entire Story Played From A Cop's Perspective
What's the craziest thing GTA could do, that no one would expect, and yet it'd be insanely cool to see?
Flip the entire setup of the franchise, and let us play as the police. From multiple protagonists letting you approach situations from a variety of directions at once, to taking part in cop chases with a full array of spike strips and deployable items, it'd work perfectly.
Older GTAs have routinely let us do "Vigilante" missions where the latter was playable, and games like The Getaway: Black Monday or Sleeping Dogs showed how great rule-bending/undercover thriller stories can be incredibly engaging.
Because if there's one thing GTA has never had, it's a story the game is worth playing to see through.
2. Drastically Different Animation Set For Movement & Gunplay
Think about movement and gunplay in GTA - it's serviceable at best, right?
From spongey cover systems to lock-ons or manual targeting mechanics that never quite feel as tight as they should, this extends to just how we interact with the world overall.
Back when San Andreas dropped, we all remarked in amazement at the ability to mantle over a fence, or in The Warriors, how you could maintain a sprinting speed while vaulting over a variety of objects.
All that seems to have gone away in GTA overall, as a system not unlike Uncharted's blend of "platforming"/climbing and aiming in all directions while on the go or mantling/dangling from ledges would aid in combat tenfold.
Games like The Wheelman and Sleeping Dogs gave us the ability to jack cars on the move, too - a gameplay mechanic that helps immensely in getaways, but of course, might be too "OTT" for GTA.
1. Ditch The Numbers & Soft Reboot The Franchise
At what point do you ditch the numbers and start all over again? At what point do you acknowledge that GTA is so huge, it serves multiple audiences all striving for different things?
Right now we can say that GTA is for 1. Those who like offline single-player A.I. sandboxes, 2. The same again, but in a more mature sense, a la GTA IV, and 3. Multiplayer gamers who want to live digital lives inside an entire metropolis of transactions and shared wealth.
Maybe GTA can be all of these things... and maybe it would be better off soft-rebooting itself, ditching the numbers and going with either a definitive "Grand Theft Auto" label with a new direction, or "GTA: Retribution"/any plot-related buzzword.
The latter lets Rockstar flex their storytelling muscles as they once used to, whilst the former establishes GTA as a platform not unlike FIFA/Madden or even Call of Duty.
We're seeing Call of Duty: Black Ops 4 ditch its single-player for the sake of testing the waters on COD as a "platform" rather than a series of sequels, and this could be healthier for a portion of GTA's fans too.