First things first, I think we should get in the spirit of things. Remembering that APB, GTA, and Saints Row are all sandbox games based on committing a massive amount of violent crimes, go punch your neighbor in his crotch. When he falls to the ground in excruciating pain, several hundred dollars will appear floating above his body. Don't worry if this seems strange to those of you living in countries other than the U.S.A. Violence always results in the generation of American money. After you've squatted on your neighbors face a few times for effect, you should hop in his car and take the nearest sidewalk to the nearest game store, so you can spend your hard earned cash on a nice relaxing sandbox crime game. "But which one?", I literally hear you asking from my hiding place under your bed, "they all seem the same". True, it's hard to distinguish one graphic, unnecessary, morally unjustified violent act from another, but there are ways of doing it. Luckily there are experts to help us make those distinctions. Most of those experts are criminal psychologists or forensics specialists, but there are also less trained, somewhat full of crap experts like myself who can help out. And even though you are using your much quieter, somewhat nervous voice this time, I can still hear you saying, "which game should I choose, Clayton? Which game?" Don't worry. I've used my lack of training to help you figure out which cathartic experience works best for you by devising a system of measuring enjoyment that I call the "Dead Civilian" system. See, I'll try to equate how much fun each part of each game is to an activity I know you sick puppies enjoy, killing the innocent bystanders in games. Therefore, the more dead civilians, the more fun it must be!!! Let's get started. The Contenders: 1) Grand Theft Auto - the biggest and baddest of all sandbox games, Grand Theft Auto pioneered the genre. Sure, there were some predecessors (none fun), but nothing like GTA had ever been seen before. It, in effect, created a new genre. Since the days of top down running and gunning, the GTA series has done a lot of growing up, and a lot of blowing up. But it remains one of the most profitable game series out there and one of the most famous. 2) Saint's Row - If GTA is the father of sandbox games, Saint's Row is the slightly awkwardly drunk eldest child, that never really gets invited to family events, but somehow always knows when they're happening. Saint's Row came out in a time when realism was the most important word in gaming, and Saint's Row did not give two halves of a rat's ass about being realistic. The cartoonish violence and lack of anything resembling the real world made Saint's Row an instant hit with gamers who wanted a return to the glory days. 3) All Points Bulletin (APB) - A newer, different kind of sandbox game, APB is an MMO based in a cops and robbers world on meth. Rather than tooling around town building an empire, players tool around completing long, multi-point missions in large groups, while other players try to hunt them down in the streets. In effect, it's a team deathmatch in the center of a living, breathing city.
Car-nage (get it?)
Lets start with the aspect that most sets these games apart. Even though the basic principle of driving is the same in each game, the three take three different approaches to the actual driving. GTA (recently) has made a stab at trying to be more realistic. The driving has reflected that, with much more accurate portrayals of the way cars handle. Saints Row, on the other hand, has stuck with classic cartoonish drifting and sliding around on the road like the cars simply dont have brakes. And finally, APB just sucks. If you havent played APB, driving in the game is one of the most frustrating gaming experiences from any triple A game ever made. The online aspect of APB creates a lot of opportunities for fun (like telling your brother-in-law to get online, then just spawn camping him), but lag in a precision game is a very big problem. Every time you turn your vehicle, the command is delayed by at least half a second. Sure, that might not sound like that much to those of you who arent currently on drugs and therefore at one with the moment, but a half a second delay can cause problems even when youre just trying to get out of the parking lot. In effect, the driving is ruined for a large number of players, by totally removing the fun and immersion of being able to lead your own friends on a high speed chase. Grand Theft Auto, however, nails the immersion. Vehicular travel in GTA IV gained a measure of accuracy just short of a NASCAR game. Rather than screeching out of control and taking every corner at 100 kph, the driving in GTA IV required precision and control. Rather than flipping a million times and exploding every time someone dropped a penny on the street, the car physics were designed to simulate actual traffic, a goal which many feel GTA IV achieved. Good on them. But theres one problem with that. Driving realism in a game about a Russian immigrant who has friends that air drop jeeps and machine guns in the middle of the city just doesnt make sense. Sure, its cool to know they can do it, but GTA never really gets around to explaining why the only remotely realistic thing in the game is the driving. Its not as if beating people to death and taking their floating, then getting sentenced to 5 minutes in prison is all that accurate. Saints Row takes a much older approach: make the physics as cartoonish as everything else in the game. The driving is on par with games like Road Rash or Carmageddon, where drivers spend most of their time with their foot either jammed on the gas or their white knuckled grip pulling back on the hand grip. Its a relic from a time when turning meant crashing into a building in a way that points you in the direction you wish to go, and pedestrians were worth points. Sure, it might not make all that much sense that cars explode upon the tiniest bump. And no, I dont feel as if I am reliving a highly realistic high speed chase when I ram through 1000 SWAT vans with my sewage truck. But damnit, this is America. And I deserve to feel like Ive escaped from that reality at least once in a while. Its my right as an American to pretend I dont live here. Final Tally: APB: 1 Dead Civilian - to be honest, the civilian might even have a gun for self defense, so it's not even like you get joy out of it. GTA: 2 Dead Civilians - realism has its place, but it seems out of place in this game Saint's Row: 3 Dead Civilians - this is a world in which cars are more like ballistic missiles than vehicles. It's a world I approve of.
Murder-O-Meter
Ahhhhhhh murder. Just say it with me, murder. It sounds fun, because it is fun..in a video game. And there are so many different types of video game murder. Theres shooting a demon in the face with a mini-gun murder, more than a bit creepily ultra-realistic murder from modern shooters, even murder of stupid deer in hunting games. Dont you just hate deer? Anyway, there are many kinds of murdering, and what works for you may not work for the next guy. So, which game will provide you with the most entertaining murderocracy? Thats a system of government I made up about murdering your favorite candidate instead of voting; there are still kinks in the plan. But plans aside, which of these games truly has the most engaging combat system? GTA has always taken a unique perspective on combat. The basic system in which the game takes place (main character kills a million people a day in ways that make Michael Bay want to cry) requires that the player very hard to kill, and that the combat not really reflect what it would really feel like to get shot with a rocket in the face. But, at the same time, GTA has increasingly worked in things like accurate gunplay or cover mechanics, while phasing out things like health packs and mini-guns. The result has been a series of shootouts that let the player feel a little bit of the rush of realism, but keep the feeling of power from being able to stomp 20 guys without that much trouble. The game does run into some difficulty, though when it comes to combat AI. NPCs tend to really just do whatever the hell makes the least sense, like running back and forth aimlessly when under fire, or charging headlong at a guy with a machine gun. APB has a lot going on in their combat. Well, thats actually a lie. The combat in the game is insanely simple, like a hot dog with nothing on it. It just doesnt make sense. But it does work for some people. With no locational damage, a variety of splash damage tactics, and a good mix of long range, close up, and mid chase gun fights, APB makes for some serious melees. True, there isnt a whole lot of skill involved in the APB combat system, but theres not a whole lot of skill involved in eating a hot dog either, and I enjoy that. Then theres the one factor that truly makes APB stand out in combat, the fact that you are playing against other players. In a sandbox game like APB, with other players chasing you through the city, just about anything can and will happen. Its an element that makes the game substantially less predictable, and therefore a lot more rewarding. Saints Row never really has put all that much thought into their gunplay. Players tend to stand around in the middle of the street with twin rocket launchers, screaming obscenities while you annihilate entire armies. Sure, its fun, but the combat is less than entertaining when there is rarely any challenge in it. There is, however, something to be said for a game that allows you to use a massive rubber dildo as a weapon. It almost makes up for the combat mechanics; almost. Final Tally: Saint's Row: 1 Dead Civilian- Blasting your way through badguys can be fun, but it just doesn't hold up in such a long game GTA: 2 Dead Civilians - The combat grows better with every single game that gets made, and it can be very engaging, but the poor AI holds the excitement back when you realize you can exploit the crap out it. (Disclaimer: I have never actually exploited anything in a way that resulted in crap. That's gross.) APB: 3 Dead Civilians - It may be simple, but it works well. Car chases, holding out against an attack, and the frantic desperation of not having any idea what the other player may do makes APB's gunfights always exciting.
Chaos
Sandbox crime shooters are fun for a lot of reasons. For instance, they allow you to get the experience of drinking 6 40's in a row and then spending $300 at a fried chicken place without the hassle of getting out of bed. They also provide a uniquely entertaining experience when you play with friends, because the game can be about any task you wish it to be. People can take turns competing to see who can stomp the most grandmas, pick up the most litter, take out the most mailboxes, or cause the most deaths. And since all but one of those sounds like an entertaining and engaging competition, how much chaos a player can generate becomes a major determining factor in how fun a sandbox can be. Every GTA game since the beginning of time has thrived on causing chaos. As the player commits more crimes, the police become less and less interested in totally ignoring your crime spree. The more the police become involved, the harder it is to avoid committing crimes like shooting them, which just draws more attention. The exponential increase in sirens and bullets per square inch of your body usually results in total chaos, with hundred of police, federal agents, and even the National Guard coming at you like a truly disturbed pig at a delicious BLT. The ensuing sociopathic storm of explosions could feature anything from SWAT vans, to tanks, to F-15s screaming across the city intent on blowing up anything within 50 meters of you, and doing exactly that. Planes crashed into buildings, entire squadrons of police cars flew off overpasses, and civilian traffic got reduced to a post apocalyptic pile of burnt out metal. Saint's Row was also quite chaotic, even if it was in a much more childish manner. Though it's harder to get things to such an insane level of authority involvement in Saint's Row, and the silliness of it all does detract from the power trip one gets from leading the police on a city wide chase, there is a simple pleasure in plastering half the city with feces. And that really is what it all boils down to. While GTA is out murdering hookers, Saint's Row is spending it's time throwing itself in front of traffic to get insurance money. The resulting chaos is less less like a riot and more like a clown riot. I'm not sure why I linked that....I just....I had to google "clown riot". Anywho, we come now to APB, which, in this race, isn't even a contender. Sure, things can get heated when two or three opposing groups happen upon each other and a large gun battle takes place, but for the most part, APB is small scale compared to the competition. Police response usually doesn't escalate all that much above what you might expect for a run of the mill neighborhood assault. Incidentally, you might want to consider relocating, as your neighbor has likely called the police by now. Final Tally: APB: 1 Dead Civilian - a lack of escalation limits the chaos to what you can personally sow GTA: 3 Dead Civilians - nothing gets the blood pumping like a tank chase through LC Saint's Row: 3 Dead Civilians - it might not make any sense, but the 1000 burning squad cars really DO need to be covered in crap, and you're gonna enjoy doing it.
Catharsis-O-Meter
How many people reading this article have actually killed someone, today? It's OK, you can be honest. Just raise your hand. No hands came out of my computer monitor, so I will assume that none of my readers go around mowing down nuns with a SAW just for the hell of it. Yet, you do feel drawn to the violence of sandbox games. It relieves your stress to drive on the sidewalk like a drunk mall Santa (or a normal mall Santa who just can't take it anymore.) It lets a bit of the tension and anger out every time you blast the rude lady at the chicken restaurant. But why? Well, it's a little thing psychologists call "catharsis". Other people call it that as well, because that's the right word. Catharsis is the idea that you can get a small amount of the pleasure you are seeking by doing something (or pretending to do something) that is related to what you really want to do. It's the whole reason people go home and yell at their kids after a hard day at work, or get a bit of a rush out of throwing pee filled water balloons at strangers and pretending they're your boss. Well, catharsis has a special place in the hearts of every person who enjoys a good sandbox game. Why? Well, that's what a sandbox game is about: put you in a world that allows you to spew your hate at it in any way that you see fit. You could follow the story, or you could get over your girlfriend recently dumping you for a doctor by hanging out at the hospital and beating every person in scrubs to an absolute pulp. Catharsis. APB really lands a solid blow on the human psyche. There's just something about outwitting, outrunning, outgunning, or just plain sucker punching another human being. The thought of knowing that somewhere out there someone is just trying to finish a mission or level up before to go to bed, but can't because you waste them the moment they start the mission is just plain satisfying. It really plays to that primal urge we humans have to make each other eat mud just for the hell of it. And, in fact, since I've been playing, I've noticed a marked decrease in the number of violent threats I make to my middle school students. GTA cathartic benefit was of a different kind. Since players of APB spend most of their time duking it out with other players, the catharsis comes from the relief of victory. GTA players, however, spend most of their time committing heinous violent crimes on authority figures and innocents. Rather than sticking it to a single person, you're getting the pleasure that everyone gets from fighting the man, and telling the people who keep you in line (cops) to bite it. In short, you're releasing a life time of repressed anger and and fear of authority figures that dictate what kinds of behavior are and are not tolerated in public. You know you can't talk back to the cops when they catch you with your pants around your ankles in the park, even if you weren't doing anything wrong. You know that if you get pulled over and harassed for 30 minutes for no reason, you just have to deal with it. Because if you open your mouth, it's going to get filled with pepper spray and then electrocuted. But for those moments when you're in GTA, it's the other way around. Saint's Row also plays to the urge to buck authority so hard it lands you in a shallow grave. However, while GTA specifies which rules you should be ignoring, Saint's Row is a virtual playground in which you get to do pretty much whatever you wish. The principle is the same: you're telling all those people who keep you down exactly where to stick it. However, while GTA tells you the cops keep you down, Saint's Row lets you decide that maybe the trash guy is the real enemy, or your neighbors house, or laws that tell you where you should or shouldn't vomit. In short, while GTA plays to the anti-authoritarian in all of us, Saint's Row plays to the total sociopath in all of us. Final Tally: APB: 2 Dead Civilians - it just feels great to know you're ruining someone's day Saint's Row: 3 Dead Civilians - screw the universe for having laws of physics GTA: 3 Dead Civilians - being told not to drive on the sidewalk is pretty much fascism
Customization-O-Meter (I'm really not good at puns, sorry)
It's no secret that having a character in the game look like you makes the game more fun. It's just simple math. Wait...no it's psychology. My bad. It's called character identification, and it's a major principle of game theory. The idea is that the more you can tweak the way the character looks to make it how you look (or how you want to look) the more you will feel involved in the game. GTA has never really been all that interested in excessive customization.GTA did allow players to start dying/cutting their hair, buying new clothes, and modifying their cars, but the selection has always been pretty limited. The game's level of customization reflects the focus. GTA tells a story. Each game has a different story about a specific person in a specific point in time, and that has created some restrains on the ability to customize. San Andreas offered the highest level, and a surprisingly addictive "working out" minigame that increased player's musculature. Other than San Andreas, though, most GTA games have been limited to mostly just the clothes you wear when you're out smashing. Saint's Row kicked up the bar a notch with their character customization. Players got to choose their race, gender, body type, hair cut, and a ridiculous beard. And, if you changed your mind, you could always go to a plastic surgeon to get things switched about. Saint's Row also has a pretty extensive tattoo and clothing selection. However, the cake goes to APB, which allows players more customized options than a Thai bathhouse (spoiler: there really aren't many options in the bathhouse.) Players get to customize cars to a ridiculous level, spray painting and loading them up, can buy from an unparallelled number of haircuts (each of customizable length), probably thousands of combinations of clothes, and guns. Of course, usually that just means a bunch of people with green mohawks, but at least the option is there. Final Tally: GTA: 1 Dead Civilian - this game is a lot more about destruction than creation Saint's Row: 2 Dead Civilians - The Row starts out strong with the customized body, but the end game choices just aren't all that abundant APB: 3 Dead Civilians - you could probably create exact replica of your favorite actor or actress (including their clothing) using this system.
End Game
And now it's time to count up the corpses and see who comes out on top....of the corpses. Third Place: APB- 10 Dead Civilians APB offers a game that fits a very specific niche, online sociopathic criminals. You would think it would be a larger group of people, but the recent move to free-2-play would prove otherwise. While it provides some extremely fun experiences, it just doesn't have the well thought out and sustainable basic gameplay that makes GTA and Saint's Row so replayable. Sure, it's fun for a time, but that time is quite short. Second Place: GTA: 11 Dead Civilians Though no one in their right mind would argue that GTA isn't entertaining, their drive towards more linear story mode has resulted in the loss of a lot of the childish fun that once made it great. That's not to say that you can't still go nuts on a police station with an assault rifle, it just won't make that same satisfying noise that it used to. And The Winner Is...........Saint's Row: 12 Dead Civilians There you have it, the king of the crappiest, most violent, anarchistic kingdom in videogames. Even though it could be argued that the competition looked better or was executed better, the argument comes down to one simple truth: Saint's Row still lets the player set the rules in the sandbox. The other games had better sand, and better castles, but Saint's Row's sandbox was whatever you wanted to make it, and in the end, that's the reason we play sandbox games. If you have made it this far in the article, the police are most likely in or approaching your home. Your neighbor is a bit of a narc for having called the cops on you. Though you might regret it, I'm quite glad you hit him in the crotch. I'm really quite proud of you. As the police enter your home and begin to pepper spray you for no reason, remember that your actions were not the fault of me, this website, or any videogames you might have played. Don't forget to mention that last part. Just because you won't be able to play GTA from you cell doesn't mean you should rob the rest of us of the experience.