Halo 5 Vs. Black Ops 3 Vs. Star Wars Battlefront: Which One Is Best?

2015's FPS giants slug it out for supremacy...

By Jack Pooley /

There's probably never been a busier or better time to be an FPS nut, what with three of the genre's biggest shooter franchises battling it out for supremacy right now. Halo 5, Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 and Star Wars Battlefront have all recently landed in gamers' laps, and each is hopeful that they'll stand tall as the 2015 King of the FPS. The field has never been more crowded nor the questions more loaded: can Halo 5 successfully leap to the new-gen of gaming, will Call of Duty find a way to innovate, and is it possible for Battlefont live up to all those ridiculously high expectations? It's time to compare the three games in all the major areas (single player, multiplayer, DLC, sound, graphics, value for money and overall appeal) to see which comes out on top. Given how much of a strain the current busy gaming climate is causing on everyone's wallets, maybe you'll only throw down cash on one FPS this Christmas season, and so here's an assessment of each game's core strengths and weaknesses, along with an ultimate recommendation of where your cash should go...

11. Graphics

Halo 5: While it has a familiar style consistent with the previous games in the series, it's majorly impressive that Halo 5 can pull down a steady 60 FPS throughout, largely due to a dynamic resolution scaling system, in which the resolution fluctuates on-the-fly. It's incredibly silky smooth, even if some of the animations are a little janky-looking on occasion, and it's far from the most visually impressive game of the year. Black Ops 3: As usual, the latest CoD is all over the place visually: parts of the campaign look absolutely gorgeous, but other areas invite hilariously low-res textures, and the multiplayer in particular just doesn't look much improved upon last year's Advanced Warfare. Not bad by any means, just not especially impressive. Battlefront: An outstanding looking game across the board, Battlefront maintains an easy 60 FPS and boasts some of the best-looking textures of any game to date. The rocks, the snow, the character models: they all look terrific, and thoroughly enhance the Star Wars-themed experience. WINNER: Battlefront is the easy victor here, hands down.

10. Single Player

Halo 5: 343 promised that Halo 5's campaign would be roughly twice the length of Halo 4, so it stings that this isn't the case at all. On Normal difficulty, it can be comfortably beaten in 5-6 hours, which is only marginally longer than the previous game, but that's only where the complaints begin. The mystery of "Has Master Chief become a villain?" isn't much of a mystery at all, the Locke vs. Chief feud that the game was marketed on is downplayed entirely in the main game, several of the main missions involving the player just walking around for a few minutes, and you barely play as Master Chief. What a disappointment. Black Ops 3: The regular campaign is roughly two hours longer than the usual CoD offering, which is a pleasant surprise, but unfortunately, it's also wildly nonsensical and loses itself in an admittedly ambitious attempt to take the typical CoD narrative in a whole new direction. What makes up for this, though, is that completing the regular campaign unlocks the Nightmares version, a remix which features zombies and tells a whole new story. It's awesome, and compensates largely for the original campaign's shortcomings. Battlefront: Not much to see here. There's training missions, fairly tedious battles against the AI and a wave-based Survival Mode, but DICE haven't really put much effort into any of it, so unless your Internet connection dies, you probably won't give it much consideration. WINNER: Black Ops 3 is the least-questionable of the three, so the default winner. The vanilla campaign is definitely problematic but Nightmares is a breath of fresh air.

9. Multiplayer: Maps

Halo 5: Yes, the maps are fun to play (especially Plaza), but they feel fairly samey and lacking in diversity. There's not a lot of imagination in the design, and it'll probably have you craving some of the classic maps from earlier games. Black Ops 3: A rock solid selection of maps this year, given a pleasant boost by the wall-running mechanics that allow enhanced verticality (though Treyarch could certainly have done more with this), and also the addition of some underwater combat possibilities. The best map by far is Combine, unless you count the pre-order exclusive Nuketown 2065, which is an absolute riot too. Battlefront: What maps are there look beautiful and are exceptionally well-designed, but there just isn't enough. There are 12 maps spread across the nine game modes, but modes such as Walker Assault and Supremacy desperately need more than four maps each, and given that the game only features four planets out of the box, things do end up feeling a bit similar after a while. If you want more, you'll have to stump up the cash for the DLC. WINNER: Black Ops 3's maps don't reinvent the wheel but they're by far the most consistent ones here, and the wall-running allows for some potentially insane movement combinations.

8. DLC

Halo 5: 343 have confirmed that there will be no single-player DLC for the game, and that all 15 multiplayer DLC maps will be free to players. In a statement about the widely-lauded decision, they said, "When you have paid map packs and content, you divide the player base into two groups: the haves and the have-nots." Though paid cosmetic DLC is almost certainly coming in the future, this is a highly refreshing move. Black Ops 3: There's nothing out of the ordinary here: the Season Pass grants you access to a total of 16 new maps for almost as much as the cost of the base game, which has always been a pretty divisive price point among gamers. On the plus side, it will apparently feature some remastered maps from World at War and previous Black Ops games. Battlefront: Given how few maps are in the final game, this one's a sore point. The Season Pass goes for £40 (the same cost as the game) and will presumably feature the content that many feel should've been in the base title, namely extra maps and probably more fan favourite hero characters such as Yoda and Chewbacca. WINNER: Halo 5 took a stand, and it's very much appreciated.

7. Split-Screen Multiplayer

Halo 5: It doesn't have it, sadly. In order to maintain that steady 60 FPS, as well as a prevailing industry belief that people aren't interested in split-screen anymore, it was ditched from Halo 5 despite being a major staple of previous games in the franchise. What a shame. Black Ops 3: Offline multiplayer allows up to four-player split-screen for both regular MP and Zombies, while online still caters to two-player split-screen. Yes, the visuals look decidedly uglier across four boxes and the black bars are supremely annoying, but hey, at least they put some effort into actually making it happen. Battlefront: The main "single player" components of Battlefront can also be played co-op with a friend online or, more importantly, via split-screen, but again, it's a pretty meager offering. If the game allowed the pair of you to go online together to play Walker Assault and the other multiplayer modes, then they might've been onto something. WINNER: Black Ops 3 crushes the other two here in terms of, well, everything.

6. Weapons

Halo 5: Weapons have always been a strong suit for the Halo series, with its eccentric and varied array of armaments. The Magnum is arguably over-powered with its awesome stopping power but it's great fun to use, while the new energy sword known as the Prophet's Bane is great for p***ing people off online. And that's without even mentioning the chaotic possibilities of vehicles... Black Ops 3: There's your usual array of weaponry here, but what takes BO3's loadout to the next level is the addition of Specialists, nine class types which each feature one special weapon and one special ability. The insanely powerful weapons include a grenade launcher known as the War Machine, an explosive bow and arrow known as the Tempest, and the possibly OP Gravity Spikes, which will launch the player forward at an enemy with tremendous force, killing anyone in the radius. Battlefront: The game features a dozen guns, though sadly there's not much variation between them (except the OP DL-44), and there aren't any customisation options to speak of. Disappointing. WINNER: Black Ops 3's Specialists are a major breath of fresh air, even if the core weapons are pretty much business as usual, but the fact you'll only use a Specialist weapon for a few seconds per round makes it hard to give them much weight. Halo, on the other hand, is as consistently excellent in this area as ever and the sure winner.

5. Multiplayer: Overall

Halo 5: Oh, what a joy it is to ride Warthogs once again. Halo 5's multiplayer may not feature the most impressive map selection, but it's an absolute blast all the same. Gone are the connection problems that basically ruined The Master Chief Collection, and the addition of the new Warzone mode helps bring even more diversity to the suite. Black Ops 3: It doesn't reinvent the wheel, but BO3's multiplayer is as absurdly addictive as ever. With regular MP and Zombies to boot, there's a ton to keep you busy here, and the wall-running abilities help differentiate the game a little from Advanced Warfare. Battlefront: Ridiculously enjoyable and presenting a sense of scale that's been missing from the multiplayer shooter since, well, Battlefield 4, Battlefront makes the most of its Star Wars theme while serving up an agreeably casual-centric shooter. It's not the most sophisticated online FPS ever, but it's ridiculously fun all the same, whether you're in a war of attrition on the ground or taking to the skies in Fighter Squadron mode. WINNER: All strong showings here, but Halo 5's meaty gunplay and array of options makes it feel the most diverse and entertaining.

4. Sound

Halo 5: The Halo series has always been strong as far as weapon sounds are concerned, and Halo 5 is no different. Kazuma Jinnouchi's score is meanwhile an improvement over the previous game's, and the voice acting is rock-solid across the board. Black Ops 3: Gun sound effects are as crisp as ever, though like many CoD games the musical score is relatively forgettable, to the point that all the music tends to blur together. Voice work from the likes of Christopher Meloni and Katee Sackhoff in the campaign is great, despite the questionable material they're made to work with. Battlefront: Close your eyes and soak in that Star Wars goodness. This game sounds fantastic: John Williams' recognisable score combines superbly with composer Gordy Haab's effort to make stylistically consistent new music, and the blaster and vehicular sounds are extremely faithful to the movies, but the one area where Battlefront falls down is the voice acting. Darth Vader and Han Solo impersonators are hilariously unconvincing, sadly. WINNER: Despite those dodgy imitations, Battlefront has such a firm handle on the Star Wars soundscape that it has an almost unfair advantage here. Terrific.

3. Gameplay: Overall

Halo 5: The Halo series has always had impeccable gameplay and the fifth time continues the tradition: there's a real weight to the combat that a lot of other shooters lack, and the diversity of vehicular carnage only makes it that much more epic. Black Ops 3: Single player is largely still a by-the-numbers "follow and shoot" affair, but the wall-running adds a lot to the game's personality. How much you'll like it will depend on your tolerance for twitch shooting and questionable hit-boxes, however. Battlefront: Casual-focused but highly enjoyable, Battlefront captures the feel of a big-scale Star Wars fight even if it might not be deep enough for many players. The lack of customisation options and absence of a worthwhile progression system are definite flaws. WINNER: Halo 5's single player is fairly underwhelming, but that superb multiplayer will likely keep you coming back for more even as your interest in BO3 and Battlefront tapers off.

2. Value For Money

Halo 5: The campaign is disappointingly short, but there's a ton of multiplayer variety to keep you going, and the promise of 15 free DLC maps is a major feather in the game's cap (though let's wait to celebrate until they actually show up). Black Ops 3: There's never been a CoD game more worth its asking price: the divisive campaign is several hours longer than usual, there's an additional campaign on top of that, along with Zombies and regular Multiplayer. That's an easy 40-50 hours of gameplay right there. Battlefront: The lack of maps is a major problem here, for though the nine multiplayer modes are pleasantly diverse, it feels like EA and DICE have been incredibly greedy in asking for another £40 to get the "full" experience. WINNER: Black Ops 3 is the easy winner, no question.

1. Overall

Halo 5: The latest Halo makes a continued case for the franchise's relevance even when the story isn't especially satisfactory. In pure shooter terms, the campaign is still plenty enjoyable, if totally overshadowed by that stupendously entertaining multiplayer suite. Black Ops 3: Another confident entry in the smash series, BO3 certainly could've done much more to innovate and in many ways feels too similar to Advanced Warfare, but it's also got a few nifty tricks up its sleeve which will leave Infinity Ward with their work cut out for next year's game. Above all else, you certainly get a lot of content for your cash. Battlefront: In many ways the most disappointing of the three games, Battlefront is great fun when you're battling across Hoth, desperately trying to bring a Walker down, but content is on the thin side and it lacks the depth of the aforementioned games. On a technical level, though, it's absolutely terrific. Whether it's a rental or a purchase will depend on your tolerance for repeating the same maps over and over again, and your opinion on season passes. WINNER: None of the games are especially innovative but all are entertaining in their own way. Of the ten prior points, you'll notice that Black Ops 3 and Halo 5 scored 4/10 wins a-piece while Battlefront snagged just 2/10 (both of which were tech categories). So, which game is best? Though BO3 is by far the most appealing shooter for the casual crowd (even if Battlefront is far more simplified overall), Halo 5 is still the most refined and enjoyable of the three games. Yes, the lack of split-screen is a major bummer and the campaign is "meh", but the ludicrously addictive multiplayer combat is satisfying in ways that CoD simply isn't. For better or for worse, these games are all driven by their multiplayer, so that's where most of the stock has to be put. It's like the classic comparison of a hamburger and a steak: CoD does a fantastic job as a casual shooter to dive into now and then, but Halo 5's more considered mechanics and lack of twitchiness make it the clear winner overall.