How Bioware Can SAVE Mass Effect On Next-Gen Consoles
It's time.
Of all the game developers whose reputations waned (or flat-out died) this generation, Bioware's hurts the most.
Because going into the PS4 and Xbox One era, they'd only just stumbled.
Mass Effect 3 ended in a landmark negative fashion, and considering their calibre as one of the best Western RPG devs of all time - with franchises like Knights of the Old Republic and Dragon Age under their belt - it was assumed they'd easily recover.
Oh, how wrong we were.
Dragon Age: Inquisition way back in 2014 was a solid enough affair - if not one marred by disastrous pacing that elongated opening levels to the point of putting millions of people off - but from there, we only saw one disaster after another.
New monster-hunting IP Shadow Realms was canned despite clearly being far along in development, internal fighting led to Mass Effect Andromeda being a total laughing stock at launch, and the Hail Mary that was Anthem felt like Destiny clone without that game's dedication to community and consistent rollouts of content.
All told, the last 7 years have been shockingly poor for Bioware, and whilst we can point the finger at EA for slicing Mass Effect 3 into various DLC chunks, the blame ultimately lies with poor management and lacklustre company direction.
Going forward, Bioware need to reconcile with the fact their founders have left; that many key staff including Mass Effect 2 writer Drew Karpyshyn gathered up more ex-members and started new dev team, Archetype. They need to remember what made the rest of those teams so special, and even if the golden years are behind them, there has to be something worthwhile on the horizon.
Where to start? With their biggest self-made IP, Mass Effect. And how?
Well, three steps.
1. Remind The World Why Mass Effect Matters
It started as the codename "EA HD" on EA's business report for the next financial year. The term was connected to various titles that will be coming between now and April 2021, and the "EA HD" project assumedly meant something like revisiting Dead Space, SSX or another beloved property.
Then, thanks to VentureBeat giving the game away in May, we can pretty confidently say this is in fact, the full Mass Effect HD trilogy.
What's interesting to note though, is all three Mass Effects are already backwards compatible on Xbox One. There's no way Bioware and EA sit things out for this long - falling back on base emulation - only to re-release the same titles with minimal work done.
I have to imagine this reworked trilogy is more like a Crash N. Sane, Spyro Reignited or the recently confirmed Mafia trilogy and Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 1 & 2 remakes, which have received complete visual overhauls and content additions respectively.
We're certainly living in the age of the remake, and Mass Effect has been on millions of players' request lists since Andromeda failed to provide anything positive. Finally delivering Mass Effect on new consoles has to be something special, and I don't mind waiting another year, if EA are making Unreal Engine 5-sized strides with their own Frostbite tech.
Overall though, people need to be reminded why this IP matters.
The last truly great Mass Effect was 2010 (Mass Effect 2), and there's an entire upcoming generation whose first interaction with the brand was Mass Effect Andromeda. Every day that isn't remedied is a negative, and if for some reason the leaked EA HD moniker isn't Mass Effect, it damn well needs to be as soon as possible.
2. Soft-Reboot With An All-New Younger Dev Team
The reason Bioware don't need to worry about losing the majority of their original key staff?
Because Bioware is more than just a handful of people. Yes, these individuals gave us those immaculate original titles, but there's an entire fandom built up for a decade and a half, that grew alongside Mass Effect and the studio's other IPs.
Many who idolised Bioware in their younger days are hopefully now working at the studio or would certainly respond to hiring calls, presenting ideas from a hybridised fan/developer perspective that would progress the IP overall.
It's also worth mentioning that Mass Effect's original Creative Director Casey Hudson is back at Bioware after leaving across the 2010s, and for N7 day 2018 he noted that "every day" he comes into the studio "dreaming about what the next great Mass Effect game will be".
Whilst this is great energy to have - and Hudson is a powerful and important creative force - I think he should be entirely in a consultant role. Have Hudson on-hand to bounce ideas off - to be the keeper of all-things Mass Effect, who has the final say on whether something "can" or "can't work".
Other than that though, let's have Mass Effect feel energised, fresh and purposeful again. Not losing its way with crafting systems and barren open-worlds, appealing to no one.
A Bioware made of industry veterans and newcomers, providing a bold new vision for what this IP can be, without being tied to nostalgia and what went before. THAT can be Mass Effect all over again.
And lastly...
3. Ditch Shepard And Forge A New Path
Mass Effect Andromeda got a LOT wrong, but it nailed a great way to branch off from the original games, whilst only mentioning them every now and then.
The Andromeda Initiative - spurred on by a "mysterious benefactor" believing Shepard's mention of the Reaper invasion, thereby creating a "plan B" of travelling 600 years into a new galaxy - allowed for the perfect amount of old-meets-new.
... In theory.
In execution, Andromeda couldn't satisfy either side. We never found out who the mysterious third party was because the writers likely hadn't decided yet, and the excitement in talking to Garrus' father Castis overshadowed every new character, as they were all so poorly written.
Going forward, Mass Effect needs to commit to a wholly new story and setting. Like Bioware did with Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic back in 2003, set your game plenty of time before or after the defining events of that canon (in Star Wars' case, it was A New Hope and a few thousand years), then explore everything afresh.
If we're delving into the past, tap into the mentalities that resulted in the First Contact War between the humans and the Turians. If it's the future, what state is Earth and the Citadel's races in, after a huge amount of time since the Reaper invasion? Are humans scattered amongst the stars, as Earth's natural resources were totally wiped out?
Building a new Earth, rediscovering cultures, societal issues and charting a course through dialogue, one memorable character at a time would be supreme Bioware fodder.
Anything that references the older games should never be the focal point. We're confidently moving on from what went before, and save for the occasional fun cameo or text log, everything needs to stand on its own.
Mass Effect has millions more stories to tell, across a huge bevy of races and mentalities. With a new dev team revitalised from the pop culture energy of an HD trilogy remake, they only need to pick one.