Jedi: Fallen Order Has Just Saved EA's Star Wars
Respawn will bring balance to this farce.
After spending the past few months being nothing more than an extremely awkward E3 tease, EA have finally revealed Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order to the world.
Weeks of hints, poster reveals and leaks preceded it, but Fallen Order’s first trailer was unveiled at the Star Wars Celebration in Chicago. The video was sadly entirely CG, with no actual gameplay being shown off, but it was still a confident step forward and - along with the interviews with Respawn developers - it’s painted a pretty clear picture of what the game is going to be.
Set after the events of Episode 3 but before 4 - a time period which is no stranger to Star Wars video games - Fallen Order picks up with one of the only surviving padawans of the Emperor’s Order 66. The trailer was dark, gritty, and established a pretty compelling premise about a Jedi trying to bring as little attention to him as possible. But it was also distinctly Star Wars, and it’s difficult to not get excited even if fans have been burned so many times before.
The question is, then: Will it turn the tide of EA’s troubled Star Wars universe?*
--
*Yes.
7. The Failed Previous Attempts
You don’t need me to tell you that the publisher’s handling of the galaxy far far away has been terrible. At this point, five years into their deal with Disney, the publisher have cancelled more Star Wars games than they have released.
Visceral games’ Ragtag, a single-player focused heist game headed up by Uncharted’s Amy Hennig, was the first to be cancelled, with the studio itself being shuttered at the same time.
That project was handed off to EA Vancouver, with the aim of being transformed into an open-world live-service, a project which was again canned by the publisher a few years later in favour of a smaller title.
Even though fans never actually saw these games in action, their loss was deeply mourned. In theory, they represented everything fans wanted from a new Star Wars; story-driven, single-player titles that explored areas of the universe players had never seen.
The games EA actually released, however, were the antithesis of this. The original Star Wars Battlefront was a decent enough effort, but it felt particularly clear that the game was rushed out in order to release alongside The Force Awakens. Lacking content, depth and shipping with no story mode, the shooter was great in small doses, but was very clearly designed for a casual market in order to cash in on Star Wars hype as much as possible.
6. Single-Player, Story-Driven And NO Microtransactions
While ultimately solid, Battlefront 2 was hit hard by the need to tear out its controversial in-game purchases, but by then the damage was done.
Consequently, Jedi: Fallen Order has everything stacked against it. In the wake of EA’s handling of not only the Star Wars license, but other major disasters like Bioware’s Anthem, the lack of faith in the company is not at all disturbing, but instead totally earned.
However, if anyone can turn things around, it’s Respawn.
Everything they’ve said about the upcoming game has been nothing but positive. For the longest time, fans assumed there’d be some kind of multiplayer, live-service element considering Respawn’s prior titles and EA’s approach to game development in general, but the studio has confirmed that Fallen Order will be single-player only and have no microtransactions.
Wait, what?
Even though it goes against everything EA has said in the past - and why they cancelled Ragtag - Fallen Order will embrace single-player and double down on its narrative focus.
The publisher has publicly acknowledged that single-player is not their jam - even telling shareholders it was one of the reasons Battlefield V underperformed. If Fallen Order is a success, it might finally get it into their thick skulls that not everything has to be multiplayer driven, especially when it comes to Star Wars.
5. It's Built On An Engine That Actually Works
Perhaps an even bigger way it could turn the entire franchise around though, is its use of Unreal Engine 4. Now, a shift in game engine might not seem like a such a huge deal on the surface, but when it comes to pretty much every game EA has published since the dawn of the new generation, there’s always been one recurring issue: Frostbite 3.
Whether it was Bioware RPGs like Dragon Age: Inquisition, Mass Effect: Andromeda and more recently Anthem, or huge mainstays like FIFA, pretty much every team that’s worked with the technology for anything other than a first-person shooter has reported intense struggles. Though the engine is robust and downright beautiful, it was designed specifically for the purpose of creating FPS blockbusters.
Consequently, when EA made it law that all of their first-party studios needed to adopt the technology wholesale, a good chunk ran into trouble. According to reports, Frostbite just doesn’t have the tools or the baseline systems for something like a third-person shooter, or an open world game, or an RPG. Each time a team has had to start a project, they’ve had to develop even the basic tools from scratch that other studios have ready and waiting, easily accessible.
Unsurprisingly, Frostbite 3 was also cited as a major issue on Amy Hennig’s Ragtag. When discussing why progress was going so slow on that project, a former developer in the know was quoted as saying that:
“It was missing a lot of tools, a lot of stuff that was in Uncharted 1. It was going be a year, or a year and a half's work just to get the engine to do things that are assumed and taken for granted."
Jedi: Fallen Order has managed to buck this trend entirely. It’s being made on Unreal Engine 4, which should offset a lot of the development difficulties the previous Star Wars team encountered.
This could explain how the project has been turned around so fast. Even though it started development after Ragtag, it was hinted that Respawn’s game was actually further along in production than that title when it was cancelled.
4. Respawn's Unique Creative Freedom
But you might be thinking: why? Why is Respawn allowed this freedom when Visceral wasn’t?
Well, the reason the developer has managed to be able to avoid so many trends that have plagued all of EA’s other games - a focus on live-services, microtransactions, Frostbite 3 - could be because the game was in production before Respawn were actually bought by EA.
That purchase went down in 2017, when Fallen Order was already in production, so the studio didn’t have as many in-house mandates to live (or die) by.
This is both a blessing and a curse though; it means that Fallen Order can operate slightly outside of the EA system, but it could also mean that it’s a one-off, and afterwards they’ll be forced to adopt the regular tools.
Hopefully, though, if Fallen Order does well under these conditions - and considering just how much bad press the likes of Frostbite and live-service mandates have gotten EA over the past few months, it might inspire them to consider changing their stance across the board.
This wouldn’t only help their Star Wars universe, but hopefully free up creativity and productivity across EA’s first-party slate in general.
3. Melee Combat And Force Powers
Of course all of this hinges on, you know, Fallen Order actually being good. While Respawn have said all the right things, and the CG trailer was pretty, it doesn’t really show anything.
Gameplay tidbits can be pieced together, though. There was a huge focus on force powers rather than lightsaber combat, which seemingly indicates you'll be throwing enemies about as much as you'll be cutting them in half.
Also, just to let you know this is a Respawn game, there was even a wall-running segment which did look a little odd, but seems to emphasise the mobility of the title, and how force powers will be used outside of combat.
Combat should be something the game excels with, as Stig Asmussen joined Respawn all the way back in 2014 to lead Fallen Order. His pedigree as the head of God of War 3 should offer vital expertise when it comes to third-person melee combat - something which the team hasn’t yet attempted in a game.
2. Respawn Haven't Failed Yet
Likewise, while EA have bought and ground up plenty of studios over the years, Respawn have been one of the most resilient partners.
The two Titanfall games have been incredible, with the second being one of the best first-person shooters of the generation so far, with their underperformance mostly stemming from frustrating business decisions from EA, like the first title’s exclusivity and sandwiching the second between Call of Duty and their own Battlefield 1.
Even the game that should have been their downfall, the free-to-play, battle royale game Apex Legends, turned out to be a surprise hit. The title literally didn’t have any promotion because EA knew everyone would freak out at what they made Respawn do, and yet it was awesome.
1. The Tide Is Turning
Consequently, while it might sound like a utopian pipe dream to hope that Fallen Order will be able to save this franchise, if there’s anyone who can do it, it’s Respawn.
With enough time, effort and freedom, developers working on EA’s Star Wars games have been able to make great products. Battlefront 2 completely bombed at launch, yet the devs at DICE have continued to tweak the game, adding new maps, modes and characters and now it’s a damn fine shooter.
Too little too late? Sure, of course it is, but it shouldn’t be understated just how well they’ve turned the ship around.
That was just the starter course though, and Fallen Order, with its lack of microtransactions, single-player focus, and different engine might be the proof in the pudding EA need to change their ways.
Or it might be force-choked to death under the vice-like grip of the publisher. Let’s hope not though.