Mass Effect Andromeda - Ranking Every Character From Worst To 'Best'

Tempest vs. Normandy. Normandy wins. Flawless victory.

By Scott Tailford /

Bioware

It's not very often you get a video game franchise people actively want to hate, but coming off the back of Mass Effect 3's middle-finger-to-the-face ending, Andromeda was going to have to pull out all the stops to re-right the ship, restore peoples' faith in the property and ostensibly, justify the madness of doing a fourth instalment in the first place.

Advertisement

It did not.

Needless to say, whilst there's a lot to like about the new combat mechanics, multiplayer and overall sense of open-world immersion, Mass Effect Andromeda is markedly worse than the original trilogy that inspired it, more in-line with a copycat Steam project than something made by the same developer.

Advertisement

One of the biggest components of said trilogy's success was an immaculately written cast of characters. Next to the Uncharted's Nate n' Sully relationship or the brommando love-ins of Gears of War's Delta Squad, Mass Effect's first three games had just as many personality-driven high points as it did set-pieces and intergalactic sociopolitical pondering.

Jump to Andromeda and... well, your new crew aren't anywhere near the shiniest of stars like those of the Normandy. They're not all bad, but, well, you'll see...

Advertisement

15. Foster Addison

BioWare

Pegged to be the "Take no sh*t", 'I'll-actively-look-down-on-you-until-you-prove-yourself' commander archetype, Addison's introduction is hilariously bad, not only because her lines are atrocious ("My face is tired from dealing with... everything") but also the delivery ("What happened to... PATHFINDER") and the complete failure on behalf of Bioware to cast an imposing voice, or render a face that didn't look like a balloon with a face drawn on it.

Advertisement

Across the game her arc plays out just as you assumed it would - she eventually learns that you're just trying your best, and that's okay! Huzzah! - yet the execution of this character and everything she's about falls just so flat, it's genuinely amazing how this made it to retail.

Advertisement

14. Liam Kosta

Bioware

Speaking of performances that are astonishingly bad, Bioware tried to do a "He's just a down to Earth guy!" thing with Liam, which routinely fails because voice actor Gary Carr was either told to do (or not told to stop doing) a weirdly stilted, rushed pronunciation of everything.

Advertisement

Watch any cutscene with him and all the inflections and intonations are off, and that's just basic speech. Factor in emotions like rage or sequences that require humour and levity, and it falls apart even more.

Advertisement

Liam means well, as I imagine Bioware did too, but the reality is a character that only drinks beer, fixes up a car and goes on jaunty Star-Lord style space missions because his character model does, not because the character as performed feels like it would.

13. The Archon

Bioware

Y'know how everyone criticises Marvel for not being able to write good villains? Somehow Bioware thought they should copy, as The Archon is as cookie-cutter and bland as it gets.

Advertisement

He's Apocalypse from the last X-Men movie, Ronan from Guardians of the Galaxy or Nero from 2009's Star Trek reboot. Which is to say, he's evil for evil's sake, loves to monologue, and has an entire 'purpose' revolving around spouting the most overblown sinister statements possible.

Advertisement

The final duel with him goes on for so long too, you'll grow incredibly tired of everything Bioware recorded for him to throw your way. Yes, sure, we're "all going to BURN"... man, wake me up when they patch in some motive.

12. Suvi Anwar

Bioware

Suvi should've been loveable, and to certain sects of the Mass Effect fandom, she probably is, but there was something about how Bioware recorded her lines that just sounded incredibly 'off'. Like how Scotty's Scottish accent in Star Trek is that little bit too fake.

Advertisement

Granted, actress Katy Townsend is from Glasgow, Scotland, but whether it's the high fidelity microphones Bioware used or the weirdly stilted attempts at philosophical conversation Suvi completely randomly brings up, she comes across as being written to be the 'cute pilot with the awesome accent', rather than having a reputation accrue naturally over time.

Advertisement

11. Kallo Jath

Bioware

On the other side of the cockpit is Kallo, a character I almost forgot to include here, as short of being awesome because he's another Salarian on your squad (R.I.P. Mordin), brings nothing to the table.

Advertisement

Conversations with him go nowhere, he has more memorable moments from interrupting other peoples' dialogue trees or presenting you with a bizarrely 'humorous' binary decision on the design of the ship's interior, has no loyalty mission, and plays no significant role in the story.

Advertisement

At least Joker was constantly on-hand to offer advice, save your skin in a firefight or - in the Extended Cut of ME3 - save the crew during the final stand against the Reapers. Both Suvi and Kallo are paltry stand-ins, known more by their accent and race respectively, than any particular character traits.

10. Sarah Ryder

Bioware

When both Ryder twins are written with 99% of the same dialogue, it comes down to voice acting and animation to distinguish the two, as therein lies quite a substantial difference between Sarah and Scott.

Advertisement

Sarah is... well, horrendous. Selecting and tinkering with one of the preset faces gets you around the broken facial animation rendering, but voice actor Fryda Wolff delivers some very basic line reads throughout. The portions of Andromeda where humorous beats or entire punchlines hinge on her delivery always fall flat, as does a significantly terrible scene between her and Suvi.

Bioware are clearly going for "awkward high school romance", but it feels scripted and acted by adults who've only heard about teen fiction through mistranslated ancient texts. Have a listen...

Advertisement

Sadly, considering Jennifer Hale knocked it clean out the stratosphere in the original trilogy as FemShep, Wolff was always going to have a tough time matching up, but her lines are simply just not passable.

Advertisement

9. Gill Brodie

Bioware

If you're playing a gay male Ryder, Gill is one of the best romances you can embark on, coming complete with multiple dates, some nicely personable exchanges, and even letting you have some agency in the outcome of him wanting to father a child.

Advertisement

That said, if you don't chase these things down, Gill will remain in the ship's engine room, and I'd wager you'll totally forget about him, as Mr. Brodie plays zero part in the crew's dynamic, nor does he factor into the story.

Advertisement

This ain't no Kaylee from Firefly or Star Trek's Scotty where the engineer is a crucial part of making a getaway or igniting the ship's thrusters in the heat of battle, either. Gil just... is, and that costs him immeasurably in the memorability stakes.

8. Vetra Nyx

Bioware

Vetra skirts by on her angular, Garrus-connoting good looks, and one of the best loyalty missions in the game that actually features - shock horror - an impulse action during dialogue! What is this, Mass Effect?!

Advertisement

Yes, the latter feature has all but been removed from Andromeda, but as a large portion of Vetra's character is staying mindful of her younger sister, you will get to literally pull the trigger and save her life at one key moment.

Advertisement

Although Bioware wrote Nyx as this somewhat shielded, wheeler dealer-type with plenty of black market connections, the reality is that aside from her one loyalty mission, even taking Vetra out on missions doesn't yield any meaningful or charming dialogue.

A missed opportunity.

Advertisement

7. Dr. Lexi T'Perro

Bioware

Why oh why, did Bioware get Natalie Dormer in to play a character that is fundamentally in the background?

Advertisement

It feels like they wanted you to have a somewhat familiar face when awaking in Andromeda, but Lexi doesn't have a whole lot to her other than "The job comes first"/"Take your vitamins!"/"Stop putting yourself in danger because I'm your doctor!" to round out her interactions.

Advertisement

Still, being Dormer's elegant pipes are backing her up, at least Lexi's voice acting and presence on the ship is strong. She's a confident character with an opinion on every major event in the game, and Bioware including a clash between fellow Asari, Peebee, over the two's contrasting approaches to business and pleasure was a stroke of genius.

6. Alec Ryder

Bioware

Yup, a character who's only in the game for one mission manages to make a stronger and more lasting impression on those you can take across the cosmos for the majority.

Advertisement

That's partly thanks to Alec's optional memory fragments filling out his motivations, but also due to the lack of quality scripting across the board. Still, being an N7 operative, Alec is most commonly associated with that dogged sense of space-age warfare, though there is a brilliant line when you first open the Remnant cave together, as he states, "These are the moments that make it all worthwhile".

Advertisement

In the flashbacks too, we see that despite Alec being a genius engineer with a brilliant mind for creating a revolutionary A.I. in the form of SAM, he always put his family first, rounding out his motivations nicely - which is more than can be said for the rest.

5. Cora Harper

Bioware

Target of all sorts of hate campaigns in the lead-up and post-release, Cora was assumed to be some sort of 'intentionally less attractive female' included to 'appease the SJWs' - which in-game, couldn't be farther from the truth.

Advertisement

For one, she's clearly not unattractive by any means, and two, Bioware write her as a consummate professional; someone who's trained for years as Alec Ryder's second-in-command, only for the title of Pathfinder to fall to his kin instead. Cora has to deal with this contrast of duty and personal desire, and that's before she reveals her role as an Asari huntress, where she worked as one of Talein's Daughters; a group of fearsome Asari commandoes.

Advertisement

I actually really loved how in Andromeda, you can totally play Cora as a best friend, being there's no real reason why she would sleep with the person who 'took her job'. Fundamentally, this became the strongest relationship I built across the game, one forged from a mutual respect on where both individuals stood in the wake of Alec Ryder's passing.

4. Scott Ryder

Bioware

Onto the best Ryder, and as mentioned with Sarah, Tom Taylorson just does a much better job at delivering the script than Fryda Wolff. His humour mostly works, there's a lot more conviction where necessary as emotional stakes get added to the events of the story - and across the board, Scott Ryder feels more believable in his role of 'amateur officer becoming the hero.'

Advertisement

Like Gears of War 4's Liam McIntyre who voiced Marcus' son, JD Fenix, Scott Ryder is yet another Nathan Drake clone, but at least his line deliveries and humorous moments actually land most of the time time - which is more than can be said about Sarah.

Advertisement

3. Peebee (Pelessaria B'Sayle)

BioWare

None of the characters in Andromeda are all that rounded, but Peebee succeeds in being written as very forthright and honest. Bioware attempt to nod your way and raise their eyebrows when Peebee is introduced by literally mounting your character for a few seconds, but following that, a lot of her interactions are thankfully more charming than forced.

Advertisement

She's played up as a sort of fanatical nerd; someone who adores 'Remtech' (Remnant technology) more than most, and who'll happily flirt back if you so choose. Whilst she insists on a 'no strings attached' romance (and you can do the heave-ho in a no gravity escape pod, if you like), actually building a meaningful relationship afterwards is very satisfying come the game's end.

Advertisement

2. Nakmor Drack

Bioware

Drack is the cigar-chomping Jesse Ventura-in-Predator of the group. He's old, he's seen some things, has survived them too, and won't hesitate to call people out on any bullsh*t along the way.

Advertisement

Like a lot of Andromeda's 'humour' that feels as though it was written by someone conceptualising fan fiction on Twitter, there are some instances of Drack trying to be 'down with the kids' or not realising he's being had by Andromeda's version of The Nigerian Prince scam, but ultimately, he's a great pick for any mission.

Advertisement

Being we didn't even get a Krogan squadmate in Mass Effect 3, having Drack sprint past you and decimate enemy forces with shoulder barges and rifle-butts is just bliss, helping create - just for a second - that Mass Effect feeling of old.

1. Jaal Ama Darav

Bioware

Jaal takes the top spot, simply because 1. He's one of only four new races, 2. He looks like a cross between Final Fantasy X's Kimahri and a squid, and 3. This cool, calm demeanour belies a cautious, emotionally-open interior.

Advertisement

In quite a cool - if not slightly forced - turn, Jaal is not a strict, patience-filled warrior. Instead he'll talk to you about sewing items for the crew, or will happily open up about all manner of issues that are troubling him.

Advertisement

The Angara don't know how to conceal their emotions, and although you'll likely side with Jaal just because he looks great and is the only new race on your team, exploring the galaxy and receiving his comments on everything as you go is a solid bonus.

--

Advertisement

Who are your worse and best characters? Let us know in the comments!