Mass Effect: Ranking Every Main Squad Member In The Original Trilogy

Mass Effect Squad Members Ranked - Renegade Or Paragon!

By Tyler Rigby /

The Mass Effect trilogy was a science fiction epic that followed Commander Shepard as they travelled the galaxy trying to stop the apocalyptic Reapers from wiping out all life in the known universe. Shepard had help from an assortment of squad mates that would accompany him on different missions, from other humans to different alien species such as proud Turians, noble Asari or battle hardened Krogans.

Advertisement

Mass Effect had a rich lore with each species having long and entangled histories that only added to the scale of the story being told. This was no different with the characters themselves. In addition to being shaped by the past of their people, Shepard's crew had their own layered backstory that fed into who they were.

The trilogy boasted the concept that player choice mattered meaning some of the characters on this list could've been in all three games or only one. The trajectory of the narrative would shift depending on the player's choices which means that depending on the circumstances, a lot of these characters could turn out very differently per playthrough.

Each squad mate was unique and developed and would evolve as the story progressed. The range of character development on display was akin to a sprawling television series spanning several seasons. This means the characters were incredibly written and made the Mass Effect games all the more unforgettable.

20. James Vega

The anticipation for the third game in the series was at an all time high for the franchise. It was going to be the end of Shepard's journey and a goodbye to all the characters and relationships the player had developed with them over hours of gameplay. So, if you're going to introduce a brand new addition to the squad, then they better be exceptional. James Vega was not exceptional.

Advertisement

A marine in the Systems Alliance, James joined the crew of the Normandy SR-2 after the Reapers invaded Earth. Reluctant to leave his fellow humans behind, James started off as instantly grating as he failed to see the bigger picture at stake. James quickly became the least interesting character on the ship, with no history with Shepard to bounce off and an unengaging backstory compared to the other Mass Effect 3 introduced character Javik.

The last thing the third game needed was another dull human character. With so many great squad mates from Mass Effect 2 not returning to the Normandy, James felt like he was taking someone else's spot.

19. Jacob Taylor

There's nothing terribly wrong with Jacob, he's fully developed, he isn't annoying, but his worst sin is that he's just so boring. A slight charisma vacuum on a ship full of colourful and complex characters leaves him as the most forgettable member of the squad in Mass Effect 2.

Advertisement

Jacob's loyalty mission is also the worst of the bunch. Whereas others provided new shading to companions or exciting missions to play through, Jacob's mission took us on a robot shooting trip on an island in search of his missing father. None of it was particularly engaging stuff.

A Cerberus operative who is with you from the start of Mass Effect 2, you'll stop bringing Jacob on missions before anyone else as you continue to work through your dossiers. You'll also stop talking to him first as it feels like he has less dialogue to experience than any other squad member. Overall, Jacob may just be the most forgettable of all companions in Mass Effect.

18. Morinth

Morinth is more of an interesting character than she is a good companion. The criminal daughter of squad member Samara, Morinth is the target of Samara's loyalty mission. When the two eventually are locked in a biotic battle, the option is available to kill Samara and have Morinth assume her identity on the Normandy.

Advertisement

The choice is dark and perfect for a Renegade Shepard but Morinth feels stunted in terms of potential character development compared to her mother. Morinth is an Ardat-Yakshi, a succubus-like Asari who kills her victims when she drains them during sex. Such a character keeps her at a certain emotional distance making the player's connection to her low.

Morinth just doesn't quite fit into the squad dynamics and ends up feeling out of place. That being said, the opportunity for the player to essentially kill themselves by sleeping with Morinth was an unneeded yet rather amusing addition to the game.

17. Zaeed Massani

Zaeed was one of two DLC companions for Mass Effect 2. A fearsome and unsociable bounty hunter, Zaeed was a full Renegade squad mate that left no room for middle ground. His loyalty mission involves him tracking down an old enemy of his that you have to complete by doing the Renegade option, otherwise he's practically guaranteed to die in the suicide mission.

Advertisement

This kind of narrow choice is not usually favoured within the trilogy which can make it seem slightly frustrating. That being said, Zaeed himself can be fun. Grouchy and unapproachable at all times, Zaeed can provide decent humour as he hates everything around him. His war stories of his time as a mercenary can also be genuinely interesting for players that enjoy those in-universe anecdotes.

Being a DLC character Zaeed's dialogue is limited, as is his screen time in Mass Effect 3. Javik feels more integrated into the Normandy and Kasumi has a better recruitment mission which sadly leaves Zaeed as the worst downloadable companion on the squad.

16. Samara

An Asari Justicar and an extremely powerful biotic who is nearly 1,000 years old. Her quest for justice in the universe is a religion to her and that allows for several interesting conversations to take place.

Advertisement

Samara will talk to Shepard about Asari culture and philosophy and provides some of the most in depth discussions out of all the squad mates. Her backstory of the ongoing hunt for her murderous daughter Morinth is heart-breaking and Samara is portrayed as someone who is following a code that is bigger than herself.

Her final confrontation with Morinth is epic as is her return in Mass Effect 3 at the Ardat-Yakshi monastery. She is easily one of the most powerful squad mates in the trilogy. That being said, her dedication to her beliefs makes for strong conversation but, like her daughter, she ends up feeling emotionally distanced. Sadly, this leads to the player not feeling overly connected to Samara even if they do think she's really cool.

15. Kasumi Goto

The second DLC character for Mass Effect 2 and a master thief, Kasumi brought a mischievous misbehaviour to the Normandy. While the majority of the characters in the trilogy are very focused on the ongoing conflicts and are often serious, Kasumi enjoys a more care free attitude and fun-loving approach to everything she does.

Advertisement

Her heist loyalty mission features great call backs and unique elements and feels far more unique to Zaeed's straightforward loyalty mission. Her chaotic personality masks the loss she feels for her former partner well enough without making her transition into a character that is dominated by her past.

Her design is awesome as are her manic quips and observations. Kasumi is a great squad mate but, like Zaeed, the dialogue feels more limited compared to the characters in the main game which prevents her from being higher on this list.

14. Kaidan Alenko

Depending on your choices, Kaidan is either in all three games or only one. In the most famous choice the player gets to make in the original Mass Effect, during the mission on Virmire, the player must decide whether to save Kaidan or to save Ashley. It's a difficult choice and knowing the surviving character will appear in the following game then return as a full squad member in the third instalment means the choice is particularly weighted.

Advertisement

A biotic in the Systems Alliance marines, Kaidan unfortunately started the trend of relatively boring human companions on the Normandy. Thankfully for him, his appearance in three games gives him an edge over characters like Jacob and James. His history with the crew and with Shepard makes him instantly more likable even if at a base level he's just fine.

Kaidan feels forever entwined to Ashley as their surviving fates are incredibly similar. Unfortunately, Ashley is more interesting.

13. Ashley Williams

She may be more interesting than Kaidan, but only just. Ashley was also an Alliance marine who joined the Normandy in the first game. Her trajectory mirrors Kaidan's, if she survives she went on to be at odds with Shepard's Cerberus connections in Mass Effect 2 before becoming a Spectre and re-joining the Normandy in Mass Effect 3.

Advertisement

Ashley is a more problematic character than Kaidan which instantly gives her more room to progress and change than it does him. Ashley was an (almost) proud racist of non-human species and the player's main insight into the kind of xenophobic attitudes certain members of the Systems Alliance possess.

If she survives Virmire, her prejudices begin to shift and she grows and becomes a more likable member of the team. Like Kaidan, the reason she places so highly on this list is her three games of history that builds up and allows the player to get to know her.

12. EDI

Originally, EDI was just the Artificial Intelligence unit installed on the Normandy SR-2 in Mass Effect 2 until she got a physical upgrade in the final game and became a fully fledged squad member. EDI is one of the most humorous characters in the trilogy as she attempts to learn and understand human behaviour and master jokes.

Advertisement

EDI acquiring a cybernetic body in the Mass Effect 3 was a welcome surprise as she already felt like a fully fleshed out member of the crew in the previous game. Her building relationship with Joker, which becomes romantic, is endearing and sweet and provides some of the most wholesome content in the series.

She has becomes a staple member of the Mass Effect franchise and her obtaining a body only solidified that fact. Ironically, despite being just an A.I., her relationships and developing consciousness has resulted in making EDI one of the most human characters in the trilogy.

11. Javik

If James was a poor choice for a character introduction in the final game, Javik was the perfect choice. The last surviving Prothean who had been in stasis for 50,000 years after the Reapers had destroyed his entire civilisation and people, Javik made for an exceptional addition in the fight against the Reapers.

Advertisement

The Protheans had been built up over the course of three games with the idea that they were these incredible and incomparable beings that created so much in the universe. Javik was a brilliant contrast as an imperialistic war machine that had been born during the Prothean/Reaper war. He may not have been the idealistic image of a Prothean but he was their angry and vengeful shadow that fitted into the Normandy's crew like a glove.

Perhaps not the nicest or most humble of crewmates, Javik would often clash with other squad mates as he struggled to understand the differences in culture and customs. Still, Javik was walking trauma who had one single minded goal that had been hyped up over three games, and it worked phenomenally.

10. Legion

After killing hundreds of the mute synthetic lifeforms known as the Geth in the first game, it would come as an understandable shock to encounter not only a friendly Geth than could talk, but one that was brandishing some of Commander Shepard's N7 armour. Legion was made up of 1,183 Geth programs inside one mobile unit that was unlike any Geth previously encountered.

Advertisement

Bringing well explored questions about consciousness and a right to live to the franchise, Legion sought to sever the connection between the Reapers and the Geth so its people could leave in peace. This continues into the third game where Legion is a large component of the Quarian/Geth conflict in which Legion does its best to secure the best resolution for everyone.

Legion's addition to the squad comes very late in Mass Effect 2 meaning its time with the Normandy is likely to be the shortest out of all squad members in the entire franchise. This is a real shame as he looks and sounds awesome and is one of the best characters in all three games.

9. Grunt

The Krogan clone who was bred to be a super soldier by a warlord is one of the most exciting companions in Mass Effect 2. Grunt was grown in a tank, and after the player frees him from that tank he essentially grows up on the Normandy.

Advertisement

Grunt struggles with an identity crisis for most of the game, trying to work out who he is and who he wants to be while also fighting and feeding his urge for violence. Shepard slowly becoming a friend to him over the course of the journey and then helping him join a clan of his people feels incredibly well earned.

Once Grunt becomes Urdnot Grunt and sets out on his own in Mass Effect 3, it is actually rather heart-warming to see how far he's come even if he still loves destroying his enemies. He has a fantastic bombastic energy and his lack of a filter gives him some memorable moments of hilarity.

8. Miranda Lawson

Voiced by the incredible Yvonne Strahovski, Miranda was a high ranking Cerberus operative whose loyalties were always in question. She had a mercurial nature that made the player always second guess every decision she made.

Advertisement

After a streak of mundane human characters, Miranda managed to bring genuine intrigue to the Normandy and growing close to her could be difficult as it felt like she could easily be playing Shepard at every turn.

Her traumatic past concerning her father and sister gave her some shading that allowed her to become a far more sympathetic character and one that was less guarded. Whereas other loyalty missions (well done or otherwise) could feel like the motions of the game at times, Miranda's felt like an honest progression of her relationship with Shepard that allowed her to open up to him and ask for his help.

Even though other Mass Effect 2 companions will place higher than her, Miranda felt like the quintessential companion of that game and her use towards the end of Mass Effect 3 reinforces that.

7. Jack

By far, the most angry member of the squad. Jack has been used as an experiment for biotic potential ever since she was a child and as a result, it has left her severely scarred. Her bald head and tattoo-covered look is as iconic a look as any and she is easily the best human companion on the Normandy.

Advertisement

As damaged a character as could be possible, Jack focuses her issues into her violent tendencies and no nonsense behaviour that can make getting to really know her rather difficult. She's similar to Miranda in that sense which makes their slight rivalry fitting and enjoyable to diffuse (or make worse if you want one of them to wind up dead at the end).

Her backstory of abuse is suitably tragic but her ability to overcome her past and go on to succeed in Mass Effect 3 is satisfying on the highest level to see. Jack deserves a happy ending more than most and if she survives then she'll get just that.

6. Thane Krios

An assassin with a perfect memory that also had a conscience and felt bad about every kill he ever did... that he could remember in perfect detail. Thane was a contemplative character who was driven by his regrets and morals close to the end of his life.

Advertisement

The quiet Drell suffered from a debilitating disease known as Kepral's syndrome that would soon kill him. This added element of a ticking clock served to set him aside from every other character in the trilogy. Whereas all other squad mates are fighting for their own survival (and the greater survival of the universe), Thane is unburdened by such pressure as his fate is sealed.

All that is left for Thane is to make amends for the things he did in his prime, attempting to save his relationship with his son and doing some actual good through his work with Shepard. Thane's emotional arc of guilt and redemption comes full circle in Mass Effect 3 after he is critically injured in a fight with Kai Leng and soon succumbs to his disease in hospital. Some of the most beautiful writing in the whole series is reserved for Thane Krios.

5. Mordin Solus

With the slightest of minor tweaks, Mordin could have easily been a villain. The only Salarian crewmate in the trilogy, Mordin was a ruthless and murderous scientist that was responsible for engineering the Krogan genophage that is responsible for the mass infertility that has crippled the Krogan species.

Advertisement

Mordin was very focused on the big picture; if he had to kill a thousand to save a million, he'd do it without a second thought. Despite that, he had an affable and approachable disposition usually thanks to his bursting excitement at any sort of scientific revelation.

In Mass Effect 3, Mordin sees the error of his ways and seeks to find a cure for the genophage. His last conversation with Shepard on Tutchanka can be one of the most emotional moments of the series (depending on how you play it) as Mordin admits the genophage was a mistake and he has to sacrifice himself to right his wrong.

A layered and fascinating character, Mordin was the best new squad mate Mass Effect 2 had to offer and has the best closure out of all the squad members.

4. Liara T'soni

Dr. T'Soni went from being a naive and empathetic Asari scientist to a ruthless and cold successor to the infamous Shadow Broker. Appearing in all three games and a squad mate in 1 and 3, Liara is one of the most fleshed out characters in the series.

Advertisement

After her adventures with Shepard in the first game, Liara hardens up and matures into a far more cerebral presence while also hanging onto her moral core. Being raised by a strict and controlling mother in Matriarch Benezia, Liara ends up growing into a hybrid of her mother and the more optimistic young scientist you encounter in the first game. This gives Liara a realistic sense of flaws and attributes.

She is also significant for being the first LGBTQ+ romance option in the franchise as both a male and a female Shepard can romance her. As Kaidan and Ashley both struggle with Shepard in Mass Effect 2, Liara can also feel like the default romance throughout the trilogy. She is distanced at first in Mass Effect 2 but the relationship can be rekindled before being fully developed in Mass Effect 3. The romance options with Liara are exceptionally well written for both male and female Shepard throughout.

3. Urdnot Wrex

Like Kaidan and Ashley, Wrex is in either one game or all three. The original Krogan companion was iconic and simply a blast in the first game. The possible choice to shoot him dead on Virmire was one of the first instances that your choices actually have consequences, but honestly no one would want to kill a character that was this much fun.

Advertisement

After he left the Normandy, Wrex grew in acclaim and status on his home world to the point where he unites all the Krogan clans of Tuchanka to face the Reaper threat. His increase in power doesn't change his friendship with Shepard however, which is particularly touching.

Wrex is boisterous and aggressive but also fiercely loyal which made him a great companion. In the phenomenal Citadel DLC for the final game (which itself felt like a celebration of all these characters), Wrex got a chance to re-join the crew and go on missions with Shepard which was one of the most satisfying inclusions to a stellar DLC.

Wrex may very well be the most synonymous companion when you consider squad mates in Mass Effect and that's a testament to a great character who was only on the Normandy for one full game.

2. Tali'Zorah Nar Rayya

One of two characters that is a squad mate in all three games. The young and enthusiastic Quarian engineer slowly gains confidence over the trilogy. Being a Quarian means she has to stay inside her augmented suit or else she risks getting sick and maybe even dying.

Advertisement

Tali is always upbeat and positive and is especially awkward in social situations. This makes her a particularly endearing presence on the Normandy as she is clearly out of her depth. As the games go on, Tali becomes more involved in the politics of her people and situations surrounding their creations, the Geth. Tali becomes a leader and this is reflected in her name as she goes from ship to ship (nar Rayya to vas Neema to vas Normandy).

Tali as a romance option is also well executed, as the relationship feels more tender and innocent reflecting Tali's personality. Her choice to reveal her face to Shepard feels gratifying in particular.

Tali is on the Normandy for three games, and this allows for hours of extra development that other characters simply aren't capable of having. She feels especially kind and a good person which not all of the characters on this list can boast. If you've ever got her drunk, you know she's also adorably hilarious.

1. Garrus Vakarian

Whether he's your awkward love interest or your sniping brother-in-arms, Garrus is the closest thing to Shepard's archetypal best friend and companion. A member of the Normandy crew for all three games, Garrus feels like a genuine support system and ally for Shepard to rely on throughout the trilogy.

Advertisement

As a member of the Turian species, Garrus has extensive military training and is a strategic expert. Watching him become notorious as the vigilante Archangel on Omega felt like a natural progression for a crusader like Garrus. He is sarcastic to the point where he'll quip in the face of danger to lighten the mood but he is suitably lethal where you have no choice but to take him seriously.

More than any other entry on this list, you will select Garrus for a mission no matter which game it is. As they experience more adventure and danger together, Garrus' history with Shepard grows which only enriches the relationship between the two.

He had a great look even before a near fatal explosion scarred his face, but Garrus would joke about his appearance even then just to show that he'd never lose that wit. Regardless of whether he's in the middle of some calibrations or not, Garrus is the best squad mate in all of Mass Effect.

Advertisement