NBA Live 18 Hands-On: 7 Things We Learned

It's (back) in the game.

By Lukasz Muniowski /

Let's get this right out of the way: there's plenty to like about NBA Live 18. The demo is surprisingly good fun, which suggests the full release will hopefully be like that as well, unlike numerous entries in this once-storied franchise.

Advertisement

The demo was made available on the 11th of August, and it doesn't feature many gameplay options. Apart from drills, online streetball and Warriors versus Cavs in a NBA-Finals-Game-Seven-Baby, its main part is the introduction to The One, called The Rise.

In this limited version of the mode, the player will be able to fight their way back to relevance on the streetball circuit, and then improve their draft stock in a rookie game. Once that game is over and the player is drafted, the mode is over as well. After all, The One career mode is the selling point of NBA Live 18.

Still, when taking into consideration the disappointment that followed EA Sports' previous basketball releases, the demo is very encouraging and indicates that the full game can be at least a step in the right direction.

7. It's Way Better Than NBA Live 16

NBA Live 16 wasn't that good to begin with, which makes it really easy to top, but NBA Live 18 makes the previous game look like a relic.

Advertisement

The gap between both games is colossal. NBA Live 16 was extremely frustrating, the passes were very easy to steal, the shots that should go in didn't, etc. The player models and their movements were not only unnatural, they were simply funny.

In NBA Live 18, there's more consequence involved in the events on the court. The most important part of the improvement is the defense, which is more natural now. A dart informs you where your opponent is going to move. Although sometimes defense can get frustrating as well, especially when attempting to steal the ball, it's still a huge improvement over the previous entry.

All in all, passing is improved, shooting is improved, and blocking is actually better than in any other basketball video game.

6. At Times It's Better Than NBA 2K17

Judging from the demo, NBA Live 18 is not as natural or fluid - more on that in a minute - as NBA 2K17, but that doesn't mean that at times it isn't better than the competition.

Advertisement

The one-button bounce pass is probably the best addiction to the offensive game. In NBA 2K17, a rushed touch of a pass button often led to a dumb lob and a turnover. It makes all the difference when the team is on the attack and every play counts.

The arenas look better, some animations are better, the players don't disappear suddenly during huddles. Another "huddles feature" that NBA Live handles better are the timeout substitutions, which are just easier to do than in the NBA 2K17. It's a small thing, but really helpful when you need some time to think.

NBA Live 18 is a game of spurts and in spurts it really looks better than NBA 2K17. The problem is that in other moments it looks worse than a game that's one year senior to the EA Sports product. And this isn't encouraging.

5. 'The One' Seems Fun

Your player is known as The Comeback Kid, but you learn about that nickname only after he... makes a comeback, from a presumably career-ending injury. This doesn't make a lot of sense, however, it's the only confusing moment during The Rise.

Advertisement

A torn ACL, sprained MCL and a torn meniscus have put an end to many careers. Fortunately, your player is able to bounce back and makes a name for himself on the streetball circuit. When he returns to college he regains his reputation as one of the best prospects in the country and is ready to join the NBA.

What makes The One so much fun is that it doesn't pretend to be ambitious or smart. It isn't a story of a person who has to face serious adversity in order to make a career in the NBA.

Yes, there is a friend/teammate here, but he's not annoying, nor is he even necessary for the story to continue. He's helpful in jump-starting your career back and might as well be gone after that.

There's no narrative that you must subject your player to and instead you just play the game, which in the end, is all that counts.

4. Fluidity Is The Main Issue Regarding Animation

Player animations are a huge plus of this game. When LeBron James drives into the lane and attempts a lay-up or a pass, he does it just like LeBron James. When James Harden makes a shot he celebrates with a cooking dance, just like the real James Harden.

Advertisement

The players not only look similar to their real-life counterparts, they act EXACTLY like them. This adds realism to the overall experience, even though players don't interact with each other as often as they should.

Getting to these stunning animations is the hard, rather awkward part. Players bringing up the ball look strange, as if they couldn't combine dribbling and walking in a straight line, however the real problem occurs during cutscenes or changes of pace.

Whenever a player is forced to change his stance or position, he moves as if a couple of frames were cut out. The change is instant, not gradual, which takes away the fun from observing players behave as they do during actual games.

3. Over-Reliance On Presentation Is A Bit Suspicious

Even though the in-game animations showing in-game players acting as real ones are a welcome addition, it seems that they mask a deeper issue, which may be the lack of significant progress in some departments regarding the final product.

Advertisement

Demos can get buggy, but this one seems polished, so what if EA put so much work into the demo to build up the hype for a new NBA Live, and the game will not deliver, AGAIN?

A deal with ESPN may also hide the holes in the essence of every sports game - the gameplay. The fact that ESPN's Steven A. Smith and Max Kellerman discuss your custom player on First Take is one thing, but seeing them do it with the same passion as in real life is a very nice touch. Their dialogue doesn't seem forced or fake.

However, the scenes with them take around ten minutes of the already short demo, and you can't skip through! It's as if the player is forced to appreciate them, embrace the realness, but this should come naturally and involve actions on the court, not the presentation.

2. Players Still Look Strange

The introduction of the Frostbite engine to FIFA 17 made the game look more natural than ever. Players no longer looked like they were floating on the field - instead interacting with it, which made for a vast improvement in the game's sense of realism.

Advertisement

That's why the fact that the NBA Live team haven't switched to it from Ignite is a noticeable problem, and not to be ignored. The game needs an upgrade in this department ASAP, the athletes presented in it are not as "light" in real-life as they are in the game.

Yes, they look much, much better than in NBA Live 16, but they don't have the same realness as in the 2K version of NBA. One can make the argument that there they seem "heavier" which can be considered a valid point only by someone who has played Live games forever and only recently switched to 2K.

Live players have a rather triangular shape of the upper body, which makes them look like dream-athletes or superheroes rather than, well, people. Despite his superhero traits, LeBron James is still a human being.

Plus, his head isn't that big.

1. The Main Issue Is Still Not Fixed

The main problem regarding NBA Live 16 was that it was reacting unbelievably slow.

Advertisement

When trying to pass to an open teammate, either during a fast-break or a set play, often he was already in a far worse position once the ball reached him. In that department, NBA 2K17 is far superior, as once you press a button the pass is made immediately, for better or worse.

NBA Live 18 has failed to address this issue, at least in the demo.

The game has a slow reaction-time on defense as well. Often pressing the "steal" button doesn't have much utility, as once the ball is in the right position and the gamer pushes the button, the player reacts way too slow and the chance for the steal is lost - often at the cost of a foul call.

So, while NBA Live 18 has a lot of potential and can be enjoyable, it's impossible to escape frustration when it comes to wasted opportunities regarding open shots or interceptions.

Advertisement