Pokémon: Every Gen 1 Game Ranked

Gotta play 'em all.

By Cameron Davies /

There are so many Pokémon games. You'd think that this wouldn't be the case with the first generation, as most franchises take a while to go beyond a single entry, but that couldn't be any further from the truth.

Advertisement

The first generation contains multiple mainline entries and spin-offs. The franchise was so popular in the late 90s and early 2000s and Nintendo wanted to capitalise on the series as much as possible, so they let anybody make their own Pokémon game.

This led to a lot of titles that can be called a "gen one Pokémon game", so let's rank them.

Firstly, it's important to establish what won't be included as there are a lot of random things that are technically gen one.

Arcade machines "Dance! Pikachu" or "Print Club Pokémon B" are incredibly rare and barely talked about, so they're omitted. Same goes for digital toys like "Pokémon Electronic Hand-Held Yahtzee" or "Pokémon Pikachu". Finally, "Monthly Coin Toss: Pokémon Card Magazine" won't be included as it's not a game, it's a digital magazine.

Ground rules are: No matter how obscure, as long as the game can be played on a console or PC, it'll be here.

16. PokéROMs

Every PokéROM is basically the same. Think of it like how once you've played Pokémon Red you've basically played Pokémon Blue, these are essentially just different versions of the same game, just instead of two, there are 50 of them.

Advertisement

PokéROMs were released in three waves. There is The Premiere Series which contains 10 PokéROMs, The Movie Series which contains another 10, and The Mystery Series, which has the other 30.

Basically, each of them has a Pokémon on its disc. That is the mascot of that game.

When you first load the game up you must play Concentration where you match an equation with its answer. After that you can play a board game where you must answer questions, some of these are related to Pokémon some of them are just your standard educational questions.

But that's not it, you can also look at screenshots from the anime or pictures of your mascot Pokémon. Can you tell why this is at the bottom of the list?

PokéROMs are an interesting part of Pokémon history but that's it, the most notable thing about them is just how many there are. Gotta buy 'em all.

15. Pokémon Play It!

Pokémon Play It! is known for one thing: The abomination above.

Advertisement

The conversation surrounding Pokémon Play It! starts and stops there, with people laughing at how the game contains the worst CGI in anything.

The thing is, there's still a game beyond the CG that's worth discussing, just not a very good one.

Pokémon Play It! is a tutorial for the Pokémon TCG and a bad one at that. You play against one opponent, the monster that is Julie. You can pick between four different decks to use because you're not even allowed the joy of creating your own one here.

You can't even pick which deck Julie plays with because that would be too much fun. She'll always pick the fighting deck unless you pick that in which she'll pick the water deck.

These aren't even full decks, they're half decks because apparently playing a full game of the Pokémon TCG isn't necessary to learn how to play it.

14. Hey You, Pikachu!

Playing Hey You, Pikachu! genuinely makes you feel like you've gone insane. You'll spend hours just screaming at your television hoping that Pikachu will just do what you say.

Advertisement

Having a virtual pet not always listen to you can be an effective way of making them feel like a living creature and if the mic worked perfectly here then the times where Pikachu doesn't listen would be infrequent enough to not be that annoying.

The problem is the mic barely works so when it finally does the last thing you want is for Pikachu to ignore you.

But what do you do in Hey You, Pikachu!?

You hang out with Pikachu and get him to do simple tasks. This sounds quite relaxing on paper but because of Pikachu's apparent deafness and ignorance, it's just frustrating.

The only thing that puts it above the far less stressful PokéROMs and Pokémon Play It! is that Hey You, Pikachu! is at least a full game and saying goodbye to Pikachu is actually quite a touching ending.

As much as you hate the yellow rat whilst playing you'll have definitely developed some kind of attachment to him by the end of it and saying goodbye is quite sad even if he does end up coming back.

13. Pocket Monsters Stadium

What we know as Pokémon Stadium is actually Pokémon Stadium 2 in Japan, we never got the first entry as it is genuinely awful and feels like a tech demo more than an actual game.

Advertisement

This unfinished feeling title doesn't have any of the fun mini-games from the sequel, basically every mode requires you to connect a copy of a mainline generation one game to play, and it doesn't even have every Pokémon, it only has 40 of them.

The appeal of the Pokémon Stadium games is getting to see your Pokémon fight in 3D, and that's kind of lost when well over two-thirds of the creatures are barred from entry.

The weirdest thing is, there are 3D models for all 151 gen one Pokémon in a model viewer found in this game. You'd think if you went through the effort of making a model for every Pokémon they'd make them all playable. Well, apparently they were going to be playable in a cancelled Nintendo 64DD expansion disc.

So yeah Sword and Shield weren't the first time they locked Pokémon behind DLC although at least The Isle of Armor and The Crown Tundra got released.

12. Pokémon Play It! Version 2

If you go straight from Pokémon Play It! to Pokémon Play It! Version 2 and are amazed then you have been tricked. This is still an awful digital card game, it's just miles better than the original. If the original was a 1/10 this is a 3/10, it's still awful.

Advertisement

There is more to it though at least.

Pokémon Play It! Version 2 is still designed primarily to teach you how to play the TCG but this time it has actual challenges, more than four decks, your opponent Julie (she returns) will now actually use a variety of cards, you can actually play with full decks so that's nice, and the game does a better job at actually teaching you how to play.

There's also a quiz where you can earn certificates. Cool, I guess.

There's also kind of a deck builder. You can't use a custom deck in-game because that would be way too much fun but you can learn what goes into one and create an in-game list of what cards you'll need to try and seek out outside of the game to make your perfect real-life deck. So yeah, this mode has the same capabilities as a pen and paper.

11. Pokémon Project Studio Red & Blue

The developers of Pokémon Project Studio had some nerve to split it into two versions. It's already a bit cheeky for the main RPG's to do it but a PC game about creating arts and crafts that you can print out should never be split into two games.

Advertisement

Also, unlike the RPG's the differences between the two versions are actually big enough here to encourage kids to buy both Red and Blue. Each game has 81 Pokémon to put into your arts and crafts with some Pokémon being in both but most of them being exclusive to one of the versions. You'll have to install both of them if you want access to all 151 generation one Pokémon.

Ok, but what can you do in the game?

Well, you can create greeting cards, signs, banners, envelopes, calendars, postcards, certificates, stickers, and crafts like paper gym badges and masks.

Whilst definitely not for anybody over the age of 10, kids could probably have a lot of fun with this. If it wasn't for the fact that you need to buy both versions to have everything it'd be slightly higher on the list. Only slightly though.

10. Pokémon Puzzle League

Pokémon Puzzle League is just Puzzle League / Panel de Pon with a Pokémon anime theme.

Advertisement

You play as Ash as you try to become the Puzzle Champion because he clearly knows that it'll be a while before he becomes the Pokémon Champion.

Ash must compete in the Puzzle League Tournament where he plays Puzzle League against the Kanto gym leaders, the Elite Four, and Gary among others. I guess not only is Kanto obsessed with Pokémon battles but they also love puzzle games.

The game concludes with a "climactic" battle with Mewtwo and Ash being crowned champion, good for him.

Look, Pokémon Puzzle League is arguably the least original game on this entire list minus the PokéROMs but at the end of the day, it's still Puzzle League which is inherently fun. There's also bad N64 renditions of the Pokémon anime music which has some charm to it.

Pokémon Puzzle League is fun, it's no wonder that everybody has forgotten about the game, but it's fun.

9. Pokémon Pinball

Pokémon Pinball has no right to be as good as it is. It manages to mesh the gameplay of Pokémon and pinball in a surprisingly genius way.

Advertisement

How do you catch Pokémon?

You throw a ball at them.

How do you play pinball?

You hit a ball around.

Make that ball a Pokéball and the objective hitting a Pokémon in a pinball board a certain amount of times with that ball to catch it and you've got a nice mixture of the two gameplay styles.

They even managed to stop themselves from splitting the game into Pokémon Pinball Red and Pokémon Pinball Blue which seeing that there are two boards in the game, one called the Red Board and the other the Blue Board it was definitely something that at least crossed the developer's minds.

Now it's still not too high on the list because at the end of the day Pokémon Pinball is still just pinball, it would take a lot more than what this game offers to make pinball anything special but still, the game's pretty good.

8. Pokémon Stadium

Nowadays there is no reason to go back to Pokémon Stadium other than to play a few really good mini-games. From that perspective, it doesn't deserve to be this high on the list but when you remember the context of the games' release it's clear that the game is worthy of quite a bit of respect.

Advertisement

It's easy to forget what the actual fights in the mainline generation one Pokémon games looked like but let's just say they left a lot to be desired. As kids you'd imagine an awesome fight taking place as you use your entire team to attempt to take out the Elite Four; then you'd watch the anime and see fully-fledged battles and start to desire something more than the Game Boy could offer.

That's where Pokémon Stadium came in, the game allowed kids to actually fight with their Pokémon, no imagination needed.

And since you could fight with any of the 151 gen one Pokémon you'd be able to use your favourite, something that the original Pocket Monsters Stadium sorely lacked.

It offered kids something they couldn't get anywhere else at the time, and because of that, Pokémon Stadium deserves this spot on the list.

7. Pokémon Trading Card Game

With any successful TCG, there's inevitably a ton of video games.

Advertisement

These games do two things. One, they teach new people how to play. Two, they give those who don't have friends who like the game the chance to actually play it.

Pokémon Trading Card Game does both of these things perfectly whilst still feeling like a Pokémon game.

It doesn't forget its origins being heavily based on the mainline gen one Pokémon games. You meet a weird professor names Dr. Mason who gives you the option of three decks to start with, one based on Squirtle, one on Charmander, and one on Bulbasaur (the correct choice).

You must explore Trading Card Game Island to beat the eight Club Masters who are basically the Gym Leaders, before you're allowed to challenge the Grand Masters who are basically the Elite Four. Also, it wouldn't be a real Pokémon game without a rival, you have a rival named Ronald which might be the worst rival name ever and now I want McDonald's.

So yeah, it feels like a real Pokémon game and with the actually really impressive art and variety of cards this is also a really good way to get into the TCG.

6. Pokémon Snap

With how varied and interesting every Pokémon species is, the idea of observing them in their natural habitat sounds way more appealing than just making them fight each other.

Advertisement

If the first thing you think of when you see a living creature made entirely of magnets is "I wonder how well it can beat up other monsters" you need help.

Let's just look at the living creature made entirely of magnets.

It's that idea of just watching and learning about each Pokémon that makes Pokémon Snap so compelling. It's relaxing just taking pictures of the creatures in their natural habitat and doing some lite puzzle-solving to work out how to get the best snaps.

And those puzzles are great, figuring out how to evolve a Magikarp into a Gyarados was amazing, getting those Jigglypuff to sing for you was fun, and the Pokémon Signs added a level of mystery to the experience and were a joy to figure out

Yeah, it would be nice if the game contained all original 151 'mons but Pokémon Snap still works as a nice little experience that you can 100% in a couple of hours.

5. Pocket Monsters Red And Green

If you think that there are only three versions of the original Pokémon mainline games with Red, Blue, and Yellow then you're in for a surprise. There are technically seven of them starting with the original versions, Pocket Monsters Red and Green.

Advertisement

Pocket Monsters Red and Green were only released in Japan and translate to Pokémon Red and Green although it's important to know that this Pokémon Red is different from the Pokémon Red we got in the west.

One of the most interesting differences is that the layout of Cerulean Cave is completely different than it is in all later gen one games.

What makes these games the worst of the gen one mainline games is that they're much more buggy and the sprites are mostly awful.

Of course, differences also exist between Pocket Monsters Red and Pocket Monsters Green. Red is missing Sandshrew, Sandslash, Vulpix, Ninetales, Meowth, Persian, Bellsprout, Weepinbell, Victreebel, Magmar, and Pinsir whilst Green is missing Ekans, Arbok, Oddish, Gloom, Vileplume, Mankey, Primeape, Growlithe, Arcanine, Scyther, and Electabuzz.

That and if you play them on a Game Boy Colour, Pocket Monsters Red will have a red colour palette whilst Green will have a green palette.

4. Pocket Monsters Blue

Pocket Monsters Blue is different from the western Pokémon Blue, don't worry, we'll get to the Red and Blue we got in the west in a bit.

Advertisement

After the huge success of Pocket Monsters Red and Green, a third Japan-exclusive version was made to fix many of the bugs found in the first two games. The game also changed all the Pokémon front sprites to be less horrific and changed up the layout of Cerulean Cave.

Whilst, Pocket Monsters Blue is technically a better game than Red and Green due to its many changes Blue does seem a bit like a cash grab. It was released less than a year after the first two versions. It must have felt a bit weird to buy a game just to have the definitive version come out less than a year later begging for your money.

It's not even like Pocket Monsters Blue allowed you to catch more Pokémon than in the first two games, there are 11 missing Pokémon here just like there is in the previous two entries with the missing 'mons here being Ekans, Arbok, Vulpix, Ninetales, Mankey, Primeape, Bellsprout, Weepinbell, Victreebel, Electabuzz, and Magmar.

3. Pokémon Red & Blue

What we got as Pokémon Red and Blue in the west is actually an amalgamation of Pocket Monsters Blue, Red, and Green. They're basically Pocket Monsters Blue but Pokémon Red has the Pokémon from Pocket Monsters Red and Pokémon Blue has the Pokémon from Pocket Monsters Green.

Advertisement

Now that we have that out of the way, Pokémon Red and Blue are iconic for a reason: They're great.

Maybe a little buggy but journeying through Kanto with your team of Pokémon, battling the Gym Leaders before you take on the Elite Four and your rival Blue who has become the champion is a lot of fun.

Kanto has its memorable locations like the birthplace of many-a creepypasta Lavender Town, Viridian Forest, and the Celadon Game Corner where many kids got addicted to gambling.

Whilst some of the Pokémon designs we were first introduced to here like Pidgey, Rattata, and Geodude are a bit basic by today's standards, gen one also gave us fan-favourites like Charizard, Mewtwo, and of course Pikachu.

The differences in both games are much more minor here than in later generations only having different Pokémon available to catch and either a red or blue colour palette if you play it on the Game Boy Colour.

2. Pocket Monsters Yellow

Yeah, the Japanese version of Pokémon Yellow is technically different from the version we got in the west.

Advertisement

Generation one is the only real-time that this happened, if you play the Japanese version of any game from generation two onwards it'll be the same game as the western counterpart, it's just that Pokémon took a while to come to the west with every new version building upon the last entry to enough of an extent to be regarded as a separate game by weird people on the internet like me.

So what makes Pocket Monsters Yellow different from Pokémon Yellow?

Pokémon Yellow came out after the Game Boy Colour whilst Pocket Monsters Yellow didn't.

Because of this, Pocket Monsters Yellow has a yellow colour palette over the entire game if you play it on the Game Boy Colour similarly to how Pokémon Red, Green, and Blue work whilst Pokémon Yellow has a completely custom colour palette that easily makes it the definitive gen one experience.

The only reason to play Pocket Monsters Yellow over Pokémon Yellow is if you really like the colour yellow. Or you know, you're Japanese.

1. Pokémon Yellow

Pokémon Yellow is easily the best generation one Pokémon game. Firstly as mentioned earlier, if you play this on a Game Boy Color you'll get an actual custom colour palette which makes this the best looking gen one mainline game.

Advertisement

That's not all that was added though, Pokémon Yellow is inspired by the anime so is full of fun events straight from it like starting off with a Pikachu who refuses to go in a Pokéball, fighting Jessie and James, and even acquiring all three starters throughout your journey.

There's also the surfing Pikachu minigame if you have a Pikachu that knows Surf. This was hard as the only way to get one was from Pokémon Stadium or from an event but it's a nice extra if you can get your hands on a surfing Pikachu.

The only negative this has over Pokémon Red and Blue is that there are slightly more Pokémon you can't catch. In comparison to the other games' 11 we have 13: Weedle, Kakuna, Beedrill, Ekans, Arbok, Raichu, Meowth, Persian, Koffing, Weezing, Jynx, Electabuzz and Magmar.

But still, the positives outweigh the negatives.

Advertisement