PS5: 7 HUGE Mistakes Sony Are Making

You'd think they'd see (dual)sense.

By Scott Tailford /

Sony

Talk about a 180 degree turnaround.

Advertisement

During the September 16th PS5 showcase, PS5 fans rejoiced at footage of the all-new Final Fantasy XVI, were blown away by Demon's Souls gameplay and further satisfied by a price point right in line with Microsoft's Xbox Series X.

Even the incredible value proposition that is the Xbox Series S now has stiff competition as the disc-less PS5 is "only" another 100 dollars/pounds for the full next-gen experience. Across the board it was positivity for all... until all hell broke loose.

Advertisement

With various retailers opening pre-orders despite Sony saying customers would be notified to avoid going out of stock, this was only the beginning. Further digging unearthed everything from PS5 exclusives going cross-gen to price hikes, lies concerning timed exclusives and more.

Advertisement

It seems Sony have been playing quite the devious game when it comes to public perception, and though we think they're "For the Players", you need only look to their attitude when launching the PS3, to see how greedy they can become.

7. Putting Former PS5 Exclusives On Last-Gen Hardware

Guerrilla Games

One of the weirdest things to come out of the recent events, Spider-Man: Miles Morales, Horizon: Forbidden West and Sackboy: A Big Adventure are all now forwards-compatible with the existing PS4 hardware.

Advertisement

Whilst a great move for PS4 owners, it came as a massive blow to those forking out the money to play dedicated next-gen games.

With Xbox doubling down on accessibility and feature parity across generations i.e. ensuring you can play whatever comes out on current hardware for the next few years, it brings about the question:

Advertisement

What do we actually need these new systems for?

Worse still, this change in release platforms stands in direct opposition to Sony's previous comments. Their own Jim Ryan made the case for "something new, something different, that can really only be enjoyed on PS5", adding that the team "believe in generations", and that they wouldn't be considering cross-gen releases.

Advertisement

Whether you actively want cross-gen output for the good of consumers is besides the point. Sony built a marketing strategy around "buying into" next gen, but now a meaningful part of that has been lost.

6. Lying About Pre-Orders

Insomniac Games

A whopper of a lie and something that seems to have come more from retailers deciding to put their pre-orders live than anything on Sony's end (though they haven't done anything to help since), post-showcase the likes of Walmart, GAME, ShopTo.net etc. all started taking pre-orders for the PS5.

Advertisement

This stands in direct opposition to comments from PlayStation's Head of Marketing, Eric Lempel, who told Geoff Keighley that you'll "know when pre-orders will happen. It’s not going to happen with a minute’s notice."

Even more on the nose considering what's happened, he continued,

Advertisement

"We’re going to, at some point, let you know when you can pre-order a PlayStation 5, so please don’t feel like you have to go run and line up anywhere until you receive official notice on how that will work.”

Of course, nothing came from Sony despite them having an official pre-order registering system, leading to millions of potential buyers being greeted with "Sold Out" responses instead.

Advertisement

5. (Seemingly) Lying About Console Exclusives

Square Enix

I say "seemingly" as for now all we have is a source from Eurogamer, but turns out... Final Fantasy XVI isn't a "PS5 console exclusive" after all.

Advertisement

At least, not in the way that wording implies.

Instead of being tied to the PS5 in perpetuity (like the Final Fantasies of the late 90s were to PlayStation 1 and FF X on PS2), the reality is that FF XVI is a TIMED exclusive.

Advertisement
Square-Enix

Its first period is reportedly a 6 month window of total medium exclusivity, where even the PC version has to hold off, then another 6 months of being on PS5 and PC.

Only after this, will the game apparently come to Xbox Series S/X.

Advertisement

This is the same trick Sony pulled with Final Fantasy VII Remake, throwing enough cash at the already money-hungry Square Enix, to secure a year's worth of console exclusivity. It gets them a win in the eyes of fans and optically, makes it appear like the game is a "console exclusive", even if that's not the case.

Whilst timed exclusives are a separate discussion, having your advertising say "Console exclusive" during an event watched by millions, is quite the deceptive play.

Advertisement

4. A Half-Baked Approach To Legacy Collections

Sony

Like going cross-gen last minute with their biggest titles, the all-new "PS Plus Collection" feels like another response to Microsoft's increasingly phenomenal Game Pass service.

Advertisement

Where on that platform, all new first-party games are included with the same monthly price - alongside past generations as far back as the original Xbox - Sony's nearest offering is PS Now. The ill-fated service was initially based exclusively around streaming, but has turned into a substantial body of downloadable titles, past and present, available for a separate monthly fee.

However, despite official patents pointing towards PlayStation 1, 2, 3 and 4 games being emulated inside the PS5, the reality of accessing the PlayStation legacy comes from PS Now and the new "PS Plus Collection".

Advertisement

The latter is comprised almost entirely of first-party PS4 games, alongside a smattering of others including Batman: Arkham Knight, Persona 5 and Resident Evil VII. Either way, this points to Sony maintaining a split approach to their own history, rather than Xbox's "pay once, get everything" mandate.=

Either you continue to pay for PS Now - a service drastically overshadowed by Game Pass - with no ground rules on platform inclusion, or you pay an additional fee for PS Plus, just to get PS4 games.

Advertisement

How hard is it, to give us a legacy service - Virtual Console style - that provides access to the last 25 years of PlayStation?

3. No Physical Backwards Compatibility

Naughty Dog

Something that spins off from the PS Plus Collection "taking care of backwards compatibility" - the fact Sony still don't care about honouring past physical purchases.

Advertisement

Obviously there's a very plain business reality to digital storefronts - it lets Sony set price points and keep them sky-high, just like Nintendo - but unlike the Xbox Series X, there's no way to insert a disc that isn't a PS4 game, and have it work.

Again, it's something that differentiates Sony from Microsoft and their approach to the next generation, but when you have the open goal of hardware emulation right there - the fan-pleasing reality of playing all PlayStation games on one system - it's a travesty to not take the shot.

Advertisement

No doubt this is so Sony can sell our childhoods and memories back to us with separate purchases, rather than letting us access the discs we already own, but it's another thing Xbox is simply doing better.

2. No Clarity On Future PS5 Exclusives

Sony

At time of writing various industry insiders are hearing rumblings that newly-announced show-stealer God of War: Ragnarok is also a cross-generation title for PS4 and PS5.

Advertisement

Thankfully we know the likes of Ratchet & Clank: Rift Apart were built from the ground up with PS5 in mind - likewise with Demon's Souls and its instant loading when warping from location to location - but you have to wonder:

What exactly is a PS5 exclusive, to Sony?

Advertisement

Is it a game that has certain render modes, load times and graphics options - ray tracing, particle effects etc. - impossible on current hardware? Or is it something that fundamentally can ONLY be done on newer machines?

If it's the former - like the supposed difference between Xbox Series S and Series X versions - that's only going to lead to drawbacks when seeing what these systems can do.

Advertisement

The latter "next gen only" approach is what the PS5's marketing was based around; it's what the industry's history of console cycles has always played out like, and it's what scores of us were investing in.

There's nothing wrong with cross-gen releases for consumers who invested in your previous consoles, but - as developers are starting to state - if we're crafting next-gen games releasing in a years' time for what's available now, that feels like a step backwards.

Advertisement

1. Hiking Next-Gen Game Prices To $80/£70

Sony

With all these issues in mind, Sony are still taking the bold step of hiking first-party prices up an additional $20/£20, to $80/£70 as standard.

Advertisement

As a wider talking point, the debate around video game pricing has raged for decades, and the industry DOES have a point:

Video game production and development costs have skyrocketed, especially across the last generation, yet the consumer price point stayed the same. NES cartridges were retailing for around $50 back in the 80s, and that goes for the PS2 as well.

Advertisement

Basically, something had to give, and it's not that creatives behind the scenes don't deserve one HELL of a pay packet for working themselves stupid for 3-5 years at a time.

Only, VERY few titles this generation came close to proving that a triple-A design model even works. Red Dead Redemption 2, The Last of Us 2, Final Fantasy VII Remake - these are the outliers, and even then, their development time stretched closer to a decade.

Advertisement

The vast majority of "high-end" triple-A titles fail, or take literal months to fix. Your Anthems, Battlefront 2s, NBAs, FIFAs - titles from the likes of Activision, EA, 2K and Square Enix - these are simply not worth an increased premium cost next generation, because they haven't been for the last seven years.

In theory it's first-party titles that should be cheaper - not leading the way for greedier companies like the aforementioned to follow. Sony's bottom line is bolstered by a half-grand unit cost per console, rather than third-parties relying entirely on software.

Advertisement

2K have weighed in that this year's NBA 2K will be $70 on PS5 and Xbox SX, with Ubisoft maintaining (for now) that next-gen pricing will be the same as current hardware.

Either way, next-gen prices are going up, but without a reliable business model in the current day, can we really say they're going to be worth the money?

Advertisement

Taken alongside the messiness of what "next gen" even means or brings, it leads to far more questions than answers.