Ranking All Of Microsoft's First-Party Studios Worst To Best
With all these devs under their belt, Microsoft has its army for the next generation.
Rewind back a few years and Microsoft’s collection of first-party studios was pretty underwhelming. They had a couple of in-house developers that focused on tentpole franchises (e.g. Halo, Gears and Forza) and that was pretty much it. It all looked especially meagre compared to Sony’s vast and muscular collection of first-party devs pumping out game-of-the-year calibre exclusives.
It hadn’t helped either that Microsoft Studios gained a reputation for being not very developer-friendly. Fortunately, in 2017, a regime switch occurred as Phil Spencer took the position as Vice President of the Gaming Division. He was keen to mend bridges, creating a fresh environment where developers would receive funding and operate with hands-off freedom from the publisher.
Since then, the tides have changed with Microsoft buying up many enticing companies, especially over the last couple of months. It will admittedly take a few years before the dividends of this power-play pay off though, with it likely coinciding with their next-generation console.
Still, there's no denying these are exciting times, and it's worth sifting through their new and improved first-party slate to assess the kind of future fans can look forward to.
14. The Initiative
Notable Games: Nothing, as yet
In Development: An unknown triple-A project
This brand-new studio was created with, well…the initiative of creating the type of AAA story-driven exclusive games that Sony has found such success with. It's a rather exciting shift for Microsoft, since their big exclusives tend to prioritize multiplayer over single-player campaigns.
Fortunately, the staff roster reads like a who's-who of great games, with Darell Gallagher (producer of Tomb Raider reboot), Christian Cantamessa (lead writer/designer of Red Dead Redemption), Drew Murray (game director of Sunset Overdrive) and Brian Westergaard (lead producer on the God Of War reboot) leading the charge, amongst several other cream-of-the-crop team members.
So with all that talent, how come it's on the bottom of the list? That’s because so far they’ve made zilch - so there’s not much to judge them on.
Yet, in a couple of years when what they've been cooking up is unleashed, one can expect their pole position to shoot way up.
13. Microsoft Casual Games
Notable Games: Solitare, Mahjong
In Development: Er, more casual games
Sporting one of the most appropriate studio names in the industry, this developer pumps out exactly what it says on the tin; casual games by Microsoft, specifically those you can play on Windows 10 and phones - and for free even.
They focus on taking classic, old-school products and making them run and interact with modern devices, in turn, creating ideal software to play when you want to kill time on your commute or when your boss is on his bathroom break.
It's a savvy business move on Microsoft's part to grab a piece of the casual market - but it's not terribly sexy either, is it? Hence the lower ranking.
12. Lift London
Notable Games: 3D Paint
In Development: Unknown
Announced in 2013 as Microsoft's first European studio built from the ground up, Lift arrived with a mandate to specialise in products tied to the Hololens and F2P devices.
Since then, the Hololens as a consumer-based product has been left by the wayside, especially since Kinect died and VR stepped in on the scene. The studio has instead been helping out in a support role on some mobile and indie games.
There's no denying that Lift holds an incredibly talented team, but with their priority and purpose kind of scuppered, Microsoft needs to find them a suitable project - perhaps working on new tech for next-gen machines?
11. Undead Labs
Notable Games: State Of Decay 1 & 2
In Development: State Of Decay 3
A fairly recent buy from Microsoft, the company snatched up the creators of Xbox's exclusive zombie co-op action/survival series. It's not a total win, however, since critics and gamers have been mixed on the franchise so far.
The first entry (released on Xbox 360) was the little game that could; rough-around-the-edges but with smart and addictive concepts amongst the flaws. Then the sequel came out on Xbox One and showed zero improvements; it was basically just as buggy, flawed and graphically ugly as the first - only this time the response was less sympathetic.
Labs have always enjoyed a loyal working relationship with Microsoft, and perhaps now as full-time employees, the company will be able to step their game up and deliver a refined and polished experience with the upcoming third State of Decay instalment.
10. Compulsion Games
Notable Games: Contrast, We Happy Few
In Development: Unknown
Acquired by Microsoft just this year, Compulsion has only held a brief period as an active studio but still managed to gain a reputation as one of the more compelling indie developers out there - yet one, that has been struggling to make a breakthrough game.
Contrast was a platformer with an alluring concept, stunning art and a wonderful story but it underwhelmed with the actual gameplay. Similar complaints and results followed We Happy Few, which released this year after a large build-up of hype - and then pretty much disappeared into thin air soon after.
This new relationship with Microsoft is intriguing though; perhaps with a publisher throwing money and resources their way, Compulsion can blossom into the exciting developer it has the potential to be - or it could just weed out its uniqueness. Let's stay hopeful then!
9. 343 Industries
Notable Games: Halo 4, Halo 5: Guardians
In Development: Halo: Infinite
Built from scratch by Microsoft for the daunting task of continuing the Halo franchise after Bungie left, 343 were given the double-edged sword of progressing Master Chief's story after his satisfyingly open-ended finale.
So, Halo 4 was never going to meet expectations, yet it was a stronger game than most recognised it as, sporting a solid (but safe) campaign with a good storyline and bloody gorgeous graphics.
Since then 343 have fumbled the ball though; a broken and buggy launch for Halo: The Master Chief Collection was followed by the highly underwhelming Halo 5: Guardians. It was a one-two punch that pissed off fans and led to a franchise hiatus.
Now, with enough time for gamers to grow hungry for the brand, the ball is in their court for Halo: Infinite - let's hope they're up to the task.
8. The Coalition
Notable Games: Gears Of War 4, Gears Of War: Ultimate Edition
In Development: Gears 5
Similar to Bungie with Halo, Epic Games were eager to sell off the Gears Of War franchise to Microsoft and move on to greener pastures after wrapping up their run- so who would be there to pick up the slack?
The Coalition was constructed with the purpose of filling the series' shoes, a big order no doubt, but at least it was led by Rod Fergusson (the original producer on Gears 1). They jumped into development with a remaster of the original game, followed by a proper fourth instalment - unfortunately, both were a bit underwhelming.
The Ultimate Edition looked polished but its mechanics were painfully dated, while Gears 4 sported likeable new characters yet the gameplay and plot beats were overly familiar - where was Gears' next step forward?
Thrillingly Gears 5 looks to hold a deep storyline with plenty of dramatic twists, plus new enemy types (finally!) - here's hoping it delivers the fresh new life the franchise desperatelt needs.
7. InXile Entertainment
Notable Games: Wasteland 2, Torment: Tides Of Numenera, Bard's Tale IV
In Development: Wasteland 3
A brand new member of Microsoft’s first-party studios, InXile features several key members formerly of the troubled Interplay Entertainment.
The company launched in 2004, finding its feet with low-key money jobs (Line Rider 2, Super Stacker) and failed attempts at mainstream success (Bard's Tale's reboot and Hunted: The Demon's Forge). Things picked up in 2014 though, when the company reached out to Kickstarter and basked in ridiculously successful campaigns for Wasteland 2 and Torment: Tides Of Numenera.
It etched out a specific niche for the studio; they returned to a distinct style of old-school RPGs with the added value of them being made by several veterans from that era. It brought back the rich and complex lore and mechanics but also kept the same action and graphics of that period - it was a warts-and-all type experience.
For a studio that has always seemed like they were living hand-to-foot, this new acquisition puts them in a very interesting position. Imagine what they could do with a full-fledged RPG funded by a Triple-A budget?
6. Mojang
Notable Games: Minecraft
In Development: Updates for Minecraft, of course
Talk about the ultimate video game success story; Markus Persson built the pixelated open-world of Minecraft completely on his own for its pre-alpha release. That tiny indie would then go on to become a worldwide phenomenon, earning billions for him and his company, Mojang.
This creative studio has been relegated to a Minecraft resource now though - sure, they've made other games, but can you name them? The focus has always inevitably returned to this cash cow.
Persson was eventually bought out by Microsoft in 2014, who became full owners hell-bent on a mission to put it on every platform underneath the sun (even rival consoles the Switch and PS4).
As long as Minecraft stays popular, Mojang will stay busy and profitable, but happens when it isn't? Fortunately, Microsoft won't be facing that problem anytime soon.
5. Turn 10 Studios
Notable Games: Forza Motorsport series
In Development: Forza Motorsport 8
Created in 2001 by Microsoft, this developer was fueled with the steadfast intention of taking Sony's championed Gran Turismo head-on and to fill the awkward racing car-sized gap in the Xbox user base.
Unfathomably, it managed to do just that, as the devs successfully established the Forza Motorsport franchise, launching first on the original Xbox, and only going from strength to strength ever since.
Then came the Forza Horizon off-shoot (which they co-developed with Playground Games) that expanded the series into a fun open-world, arcade-like experience. That spin-off has even managed to become arguably superior to Motorsport over the years - with Turn-10 getting less of the credit in that equation.
4. Rare
Notable Games: GoldenEye 64, Banjo Kazooie, Sea Of Thieves
In Development: Battletoads, Perfect Dark 3 (rumoured)
The tale of Rare is one of two eras; the Nintendo era and the Microsoft era. The former is remembered quite fondly as they partnered with the company in the mid-’90s and created several landmark titles in quick succession.
Then in 2002, Microsoft outright bought them. Sadly, the games just didn’t have the same spark (e.g. Grabbed by the Ghoulies) and then they attempted to return to iconic titles with disappointing results (e,g. Perfect Dark Zero). It was a sad state of affairs as the once-great giant had fallen - and was then regulated to creating Kinect titles for years to come.
Recent times have seen the company rejuvenated slightly, with Rare Replay reminding us of why they were great in the first place, and Sea of Thieves being their first proper big-budget release in years. Whilst reactions to the latter have been mixed, it showcased that there's still a pulse in the studio and Microsoft is willing to encourage it going forward.
Regardless, they're going to have to put in some hard work to win back gamers, but this ranking is also influenced by their legacy and the truck-load of incredible liscences they hold on to (and could start to use again).
3. Playground Games
Notable Games: Forza Horizon series
In Development: Fable sequel (rumoured)
Brought in to develop racing spin-off series Forza Horizon, Playground co-developed the title with Turn 10 Studios - yet the fresh and popular approach to the series is often credited to this studio.
As mentioned, the Horizon series has arguably surpassed the original Forza Motorsports lineage and, in some ways, even Sony’s Gran Turismo - as Forza Horizon 4 became the must-play racing game of 2018.
Microsoft acquired the studio earlier this year, in a move that surprised no one. What's more unexpected, however, is that the publisher is using the developer for more than just pumping out countless Horizon games.
Playground have confirmed they've been working on a large-scale open-world RPG, with many leaks pointing to an all-new Fable instalment. The idea of this talented and tech-savvy developer taking on a new challenge with a cherished I.P. is drool-worthy indeed.
2. Ninja Theory
Notable Games: Heavenly Sword, Hellblade: Senua's Sacrifice
In Development: A Star Wars VR Series: Vader Immortal
A freshly acquired first-party studio - this is a big-time win for Microsoft, as Ninja Theory is one of the most beguiling creators of action games working today.
Starting with the goofy Xbox-exclusive Kung-Fu Chaos before switching sides for the PS3-exclusive Heavenly Sword - which is likely to become one of the most ridiculously underrated games of that generation - their games are like an alluring blend of thoughtful indie with Triple-A stylings.
They're also responsible for the multi-platform Enslaved: Odyssey to the West, which, believe it or not, happens to be another ridiculously overlooked game of that generation.
After that failed to find commercial success, they were forced to take several commission gigs so they could finance their first full-blown indie game; Hellblade: Senua’s Sacrifice, which was a rich experiment that featured the company completely let off the leash.
With the constant financial pressures they faced through the years, the chance for them to create a new, big-budget property without concession is electrifying.
1. Obsidian Entertainment
Notable Games: Fallout: New Vegas, Pillars Of Eternity, South Park: Stick Of Truth
In Development: Unknown RPG
What a prize Microsoft Studios has just gifted themselves with!
Made up of several industry veterans, Obsidian got off to a bumpy start with strong games that were let down by rushed productions (e.g. KOTOR 2, Alpha Protocol). However, then they made Fallout: New Vegas, which is vastly considered the best modern entry in that franchise.
Since then it's been strength to strength from South Park: Stick of Truth to the Pillars of Eternity series. At present they are considered the company in the RPG world.
This deal indicates larger things though; Obsidian had developed an Xbox One launch game named Stormlands for several years. Growing frustrated from a heated production they eventually walked - leaving bad blood in the water. If they have now let themselves get outright bought by the publisher, the pastures have definitely turned green.
With a big studio footing the bill and giving them total creative freedom - this could be the beginning of a beautiful friendship.