Ranking Every Dark Souls 2 Boss From Worst To Best

Does the worst in the trilogy have anything worth remembering?

By Adam Hogg /

FromSoftware

Dark Souls 2 was a great game burdened by a lofty predecessor. If given any other name and sold under any other pretence, it's likely that the game would be heralded as one of 2014's best. However, when considered as a sequel to the flawed masterpiece that is Dark Souls, the cracks start to show. And that fact is no clearer, than when you look at the boss list.

Advertisement

Boasting some forty-one bosses, the game manages to outdo every other Souls game in the sheer amount of encounters on hand, but that doesn't do the game any favours. For every great boss the game seems to have, there are far too many mediocre, lazy and downright terrible ones to count. Though, I am going to rank them all. All 41.

Whilst difficulty does stand as an operative factor in the ranking, lore, boss arena, atmosphere and overall quality measure in equal standing. A boss can be incredibly difficult, but still, stand as an absolutely terrible experience.

Advertisement

From bosses that were ripped straight from Dark Souls and some that get repeated across its own runtime, to those that are actually the series' finest and everything else in between, here is my ranking of all forty-one bosses in Dark Souls 2, from worst to best...

41. Prowling Magus & The Congregation

FromSoftware

A problem that Dark Souls 2 suffers from is pointless bosses that exist for no reason beyond, 'let's put a boss there'. This is one of those instances. A group of regular enemies in a boring an unimaginative room. Easily killable and almost one-shottable even if you're a normal player, this boss stands as just lazy. It is one of the bosses that would improve the game immensely by simply not existing or just by taking the boss name away.

Advertisement

If it were a regular room in the game, it would be better. Hell, it would be one of the best rooms in the game. But by calling it a boss, you draw attention to how poor and unimaginative it really is.

40. Royal Rat Vanguard

FromSoftware

Similarly to the last entry, this boss is a collection of normal enemies, enemies that you have been fighting throughout the level prior to the boss. The only remarkable feature that distinguishes it as a boss (beyond the boss name and health bar) is the fact that it is a fight against an endless number of rats. Last long enough and the real boss drops down. Shock and awe, it's another rat. This would be the worst boss in Dark Souls 2, but they gave the boss rat a mohawk, so it gets bumped up that little bit. Mohawks are cool...

Advertisement

39. Royal Rat Authority

FromSoftware

A popular theme throughout Dark Souls 2 bosses is the idea of having multiple enemies. And this is perhaps one of the most annoying and pointless ones out there. The boss itself is a giant rat dog reminiscent of Sif from Dark Souls 1 but without the charm and endearing lore. However, the room has multiple smaller dogs that inflict toxic and if you can't kill them before the Authority arrives then you might as well kiss the attempt goodbye. It's obvious that they were trying to mimic Sif, but they forgot everything that made him exceptional and ended up with a boring, frustrating inconvenience of a boss.

Advertisement

38. The Gank Bros

FromSoftware

Whilst, not their official name, the Gank Bros are a far more apt description than their actual names which take up more space than its worth. Comprising of three NPCs, the boss ends up being a gank fight against the player. Each NPC has a unique look and fighting style, but they don't compliment each other in any way, resulting in an unfair fight for the player. Most of the time is spent running away until you can get a clean hit before running some more. It's unfair difficulty and just a tedious annoying fight.

Advertisement

37. Twin Dragonriders

FromSoftware

The Twin Dragonriders are the first example on this list of a copy-pasted boss, and unfortunately, it's a type of boss that is all too commonplace in Dark Souls 2.

Advertisement

Having already fought one Dragonrider, two just seems a bit... cheap, especially considering how the first was a pretty easy fight. However, in saying that, the twins are the worst encounter.

Easy to defeat (like really, really easy) and just unimaginative. The fight is more of a hassle and while the twin dynamic adds a little more, it is ultimately a poor boss that would have been better by not being a boss and just being a normal encounter.

Advertisement

36. Covetous Demon

FromSoftware

This boss... this boss is so strange. On one hand, it's an ugly behemoth that resembles Jabba the Hutt, has a poor move set and is more laughable that challenging. But on the other hand, there is something endearing about just how demonstrably pathetic he is. He is by no means a great boss, in fact, he is pretty terrible, but there is something charming about him that bumps him up from the lower positions.

Advertisement

Covetous Demon just just looks a bit, well, goofy, and he is enjoyable to fight, even if he is absolutely terrible as a boss.

35. The Last Giant

FromSoftware

Being the intended first boss of the game, there can be some leeway in terms of difficulty as he tends to be easier, but the Last Giant is pretty unremarkable. A relatively easy fight that boasts little to no challenge and a generally unremarkable encounter. The one interesting note that he has, is the link between him and the Giant Lord boss. It is heavily implied they are one and the same giving the fight with the Last Giant a degree of gravity one subsequent playthroughs. Whilst not hitting the same notes as Sif in terms of time-travelling emotional punch, it does enough to distinguish him.

Advertisement

34. The Dragonrider

FromSoftware

One of the earlier bosses, the Dragonrider is really, really easy. He has a few unique mechanics that give the impression that the developers tried to make him unique, but they aren't incredible. There is the floor raising mechanic, in which you have to find levers to make the boss room bigger and make the fight easier. However, he can be easily knocked off the edge if you don't pull any of the levers, negating any difficulty. He looks cool at least, but he his impact is somewhat lessened by the appearance of other Dragonriders later on.

Advertisement

33. Old Dragonslayer

FromSoftware

This is almost an insult to one of the greatest bosses in video games. The Old Dragonslayer is Ornstein, but with silver armour, dark magic instead of lightning, and absolutely none of the charm of the first game's encounter.

Advertisement

Why? Because Ornstein was easy on his own, it was the addition of Smough made him difficult; a fact that Dark Souls 2 ignores and just chucks Ornstein in for no reason. The only reason he ranks this high is because Ornstein was a pretty good fight, and he still is, even if his appearance is shoehorned in.