Ranking EVERY Nintendo Console From Worst To Best
The House of Mario’s hardware legacy.
Nintendo have had a long history in the console market. Starting off as a card games manufacturer in 1889, the Kyoto-based company moved towards video games in the 1970s with their Color-TV Game console, containing a single game between its four versions. They later moved to the wildly successful Game & Watch console, and arcade releases such as Donkey Kong.
But it wasn’t until the Nintendo Entertainment System that Nintendo established themselves as one of the big companies within the home hardware industry. The system is widely credited with moving the industry away from the crash which had threatened to kill the business in 1983.
Since then, hardware has remained a high priority for Nintendo, boosted by a strong first party games library that captured home and handheld console markets alike, with the recent Nintendo Switch looking to cover both. It’s not always been smooth sailing however, with a variety of challengers competing over the decades for the top position and an experimental history that’s ranged from innovative to critical failures.
It was a key philosophy of Gunpei Yokoi, the game designer that helped bring Nintendo into games development, that production should focus on “Lateral Thinking with Withered Technology”. This involved prioritising use of existing technologies in new ways as opposed to chasing expensive cutting edge technology trends. It’s an approach evident with the majority of Nintendo hardware. But which did it best?
14. Virtual Boy
Chances are that if you’ve heard about the Virtual Boy before, you’re aware why this ranks as the worst Nintendo console of all-time. Marketed as the first 3D console, it released back in 1995 across Japan and North America, working as a table-top portable system. Making use of stereoscopic 3D graphics through a head-mounted display and a parallax effect to create depth illusion, it was the first “virtual reality” experience on consoles.
Commercially and critically, the Virtual Boy was a complete failure and only saw 22 games released in its lifetime. Even after cost-cutting measures by Nintendo, such as utilising a red monochrome display as opposed to full colour, retail cost was a significant factor (Especially when compared to the Game Boy), being seen as too high for a system that critics viewed as a stop-gap between the SNES and N64.
It was also rushed to market, with internal resources being increasingly favoured to the N64 at this time. It became widely criticised for lack of portability, the monochrome display, minimal immersion and for health concerns, with a lot of players reporting headaches and nausea after use. Nintendo laid blame on Gunpei Yokoi for the Virtual Boy’s failure, who resigned shortly after, and the console was quickly discontinued less than a year later.
13. Game & Watch
Before the Game Boy saw Nintendo dominate the handheld market, Game & Watch was where their handheld efforts first began. Designed by Gunpei Yokoi, Game & Watch was a series of electronic games, with each model featured a single game. If you wanted a new game, this required buying a new model as each title was built-in. Releasing across 1980 until 1991, it was Nintendo’s first major success in the industry and sold 43 million units.
It featured a wide range of releases over its lifespan, including key franchises such as Donkey Kong, Legend of Zelda and Mario and most games featured a “Game B” within the unit, normally a more difficult version of that title. It left a lasting legacy in its design, creating the modern D-Pad design in controllers whilst the Nintendo DS/3DS later reused the two screen approach present in some models.
By modern standards though, dedicated consoles no longer hold up and Nintendo have since moved onto better things, with its follow up, the Game Boy, allowing you to play multiple games via cartridges. With its continued representation in Super Smash Bros via playable character Mr Game & Watch and compilation releases, it’s clear Nintendo still look back fondly on their roots.
12. Wii U
Nintendo brought themselves back as a major force thanks to the Wii’s which became the 6th best-selling console of all time. Despite these sales, it was seen as a separate class of console, lacking HD capabilities and online infrastructure that gamers had come to expect. Seeking to build upon this, the Wii U released back in 2012 as Nintendo’s first HD console to match the Xbox 360/PS3.
Featuring full backwards compatibility with the Wii, Nintendo struggled to establish the Wii U as its own, independent console. Few argued about its base capabilities but critics took issue with the Gamepad's controller gimmicky nature, containing an inbuilt screen which acted similarly to the DS' touchscreen. It also fell victim to poor marketing as many consumers were unaware of what made the Wii U different and arrived too late in the generation, as Sony and Microsoft prepared to release the PS4 and Xbox One, leaving the Wii U significantly under-powered by comparison.
Third-party support quickly dwindled and its library became reliant on first party exclusives. Not to say these were bad games, quite the opposite, but this did little to convince potential adopters outside the hardcore fanbase. Considering most exclusives have now been ported to Nintendo Switch, there’s little reason to look back.
11. Game Boy Colour
Whilst the Game Boy saw Nintendo dominate handheld gaming, it quickly became apparent during the 1990s that a more powerful console was required to replace the aging handheld. Swapping the monochrome display for a colour screen and custom 8-bit processor, its successor finally arrived in 1998 in the form of Game Boy Color.
As with many Nintendo consoles, its biggest strength lied in the games library. Seeing the next generation of Pokémon launch through Gold and Silver, alongside new Zelda, Mario and Wario Land games, it sold well and led to combined sales of 118 million between Color and its predecessor.
It was never easy following up the Game Boy though and the Color’s biggest fault was not doing enough to build upon the original. Providing little more than a slight processing power boost and coloured graphics, it was a sufficient short-term upgrade to the original but got replaced by the Game Boy Advance only three years later, eventually being discontinued in 2003.
10. 3DS
Having successfully innovated with the DS, Nintendo saw little reason to change their approach for its successor. Retaining the two-screen setup, full backwards compatibility and Nintendo’s virtual console service, the 3DS could display stereoscopic 3D effects without the need for accessories. Launching in 2011, it was ultimately successful but did little to innovate.
That is not to say that Nintendo didn’t try, as the console it also featured augmented reality mini-games, multimedia capabilities and an expanded digital library alongside the 3D effect. But a lot of these features were not well utilised, with the 3D feeling incredibly gimmicky as opposed to a gameplay necessity.
There’s no denying the 3DS served its purpose well though, selling 75 million units and becoming home to another fine generation of games. But when even Nintendo ignored the main new feature of the 3DS by the end, it just shows how unessential it was to begin with.
9. Game Boy Advance
The original Game Boy was a revolution for Nintendo, establishing a dominant position in the handheld market that continues to this day. Even at its prime however, it was technologically inferior to competitors and its successor, the Game Boy Color, did little to build on the original. Four years after GBC launched, it was finally time for a significant upgrade.
Nintendo brought out Game Boy Advance in 2001 to great success. Featuring a 16-bit processor, its hardware closely matched the SNES, was backwards compatible with previous Game Boy titles and featured a strong library. This varied from new franchises like Golden Sun and WarioWare, sequels to Pokémon, Mario, Donkey Kong and F-Zero, and a wide range of NES and SNES ports.
It didn’t break the mold but proved a necessary evolution to the Game Boy lineup, with the 2003 SP redesign bringing in an illuminated screen that’s now standard for handheld consoles. Coupled with a solid games library, it sold 81 million units and was a fitting send-off to the Game Boy brand, followed up by the Nintendo DS in 2004.
8. Gamecube
N64 may have been Nintendo’s first big step into the 3D-era but the Gamecube was where they built upon this. After criticism from developers the previous generation, Nintendo discarded cartridges the miniDVD format for the Gamecube. It received wide praise for its new controller, and boasted a stellar library, but failed to find a foothold in a market dominated by the PS2. Ultimately, it made 21 million sales.
There are numerous reasons for this, limited online support being one of them alongside lack of multimedia features when compared to competitors. Like many Nintendo consoles, it also struggled to retain third-party support, losing initial exclusives like Resident Evil 4. Gamecube releases often sold significantly worse than their Xbox/PS2 versions.
It holds an enduring legacy with Nintendo fans, providing some of the 6th generation's best games in the form of Wind Waker, Super Mario Sunshine, Smash Bros Melee, F-Zero GX, Metroid Prime and more. There’s little reason to invest in a Gamecube console now when the Wii is fully backwards compatible but the extensive software library is definitely worth revisiting.
7. Super Nintendo Entertainment System (SNES)
With the late 1980s seeing 16-bit rivals release in the form of Hudson’s Turbografx-16 and Sega’s Mega Drive, it became clear these presented a threat to Nintendo’s market dominance when compared with an aging NES. As such, Nintendo saw fit to introduce the Super Nintendo Entertainment System in 1990, releasing a year later in North America.
Boosted by a 16-bit processor, it became a hit and presented a worthy competitor to Hudson and Sega, with the Mega Drive/SNES rivalry becoming famous for their aggressive advertising campaigns. For the most part, these consoles were equally matched. Nintendo’s console also allowed for limited 3D graphics through enhances like Mode 7 and Super FX, giving it the edge other its contemporaneous rivals.
SNES may have been more of an evolutionary upgrade but great software pushes hardware sales and this generation introduced series like Donkey Kong Country, Mario Kart, Star Fox, F-Zero and Pilotwings. Seeing re-releases across the Wii, 3DS and Switch, its legacy has endured and remains one of Nintendo’s best consoles.
6. DS
Nintendo didn’t initially plan the DS to succeed the Game Boy line. Originally marketed as a “Third Pillar” between the Advance and Gamecube, it was backwards compatible with the Advance, expanded on the SP’s foldable design and introduced two screens, utilising one of them as a touchscreen. It reconfirmed Nintendo’s dominance in the handheld market against the Playstation Portable, becoming Nintendo’s best-selling console of all time at 154 million sales.
Launching in 2004, the DS successfully tapped into the casual market with titles such as Brain Training, Nintendogs and Animal Crossing selling millions. Not one to leave its core franchises behind, it was also home to three generations of Pokemon releases, multiple Mario sub-series, Metroid and more, boasting an impressive library.
It was also their first handheld with built-in Wi-Fi connectivity, allowing online multiplayer and wireless local play within a short distance. It provided unique ways to play through the touchscreen, setting the basis for the Nintendo Wii’s launch in 2006 and still holds up to this day.
5. Wii
Nintendo left the Gamecube era knowing it wasn’t enough to simply match the competition's hardware power alone, with Gamecube only reaching 21 million sales when compared to the PS2’s 155 million. The lateral thinking approach continued to guide Nintendo with the Wii, focusing on gameplay over graphics. Introducing motion controls to mainstream gaming, Wii launched in 2006 to critical acclaim.
Boosted by pack-in title Wii Sports that demonstrated the console’s abilities, the success of this and Wii Play saw the “Wii Series” launch that aimed at the casual market, ranging from Chess and Music to fitness sensation Wii Fit with its balance board. It broke the mold in many ways and the fact that it still sees new releases today via Ubisoft’s Just Dance series confirm the strong impact Wii left on casual gaming.
Whilst Nintendo continued to focus on core franchises, this new casual focus turned away some hardcore gamers, not helped by the power difference between its HD competitors, the Xbox 360 and PS3. It wouldn’t be until Wii U that Nintendo moved to HD but this didn't stop Wii becoming Nintendo’s most successful home console, reaching 100 million unit sales.
4. Nintendo 64
The SNES may have tested the waters with 3D graphics but it wasn’t until the Nintendo 64 that the company made its true jump to 3D gaming. Utilising a 64-bit processor that gave the console its name, the N64 released in 1996 to critical acclaim, becoming the first major console to have four built-in controller ports for multiplayer but saw criticism from some developers.
A major point of contention was Nintendo’s decision to remain with cartridges over CD-ROMs. This approach provided better performance but smaller storage space, forcing some companies to move their games onto the PS1 - Final Fantasy VII being a prominent example. As a consequence of third-party developers flocking to Sony's PlayStation, the console saw fewer than 400 games release in its lifetime.
It became the old argument of quality over quantity and major releases like Super Mario 64, Goldeneye 007, Banjo-Kazooie and Ocarina of Time are widely considered some of the best games ever made. Combined with its multiplayer capabilities, its legacy has endured and remains fondly remembered.
3. Game Boy
Having established a foothold in handheld gaming through the Game & Watch, Nintendo realised they’d need to evolve beyond it to stay relevant. Featuring changeable game cartridges like the NES and an 8-bit processor, the Game Boy launched in 1989 across Japan and North America. Being bundled with Tetris in North America made it a public sensation.
Game Boy wasn’t a cutting edge console for its time, being technologically inferior to its competitors at launch but following Yokoi’s Lateral Thinking philosophy, it didn’t need to be. Using 4 x AA batteries as a power source, it was praised for the long battery life and quality of software, establishing Tetris as a cultural phenomenon that ended up selling 35 million copies worldwide.
It's legacy lives on to this day, widely being recognised as a cultural icon of the 1990s and cemented Nintendo’s position within the handheld market. Combined with the sales of its successor, the Game Boy Color, it ended up selling 118 million units, a feat that went unsurpassed until the release of the Nintendo DS in 2004.
2. Nintendo Entertainment System (NES)
Gaming has a lot to thank the Nintendo Entertainment System for. Following the video game crash of 1983, the United States saw a large-scale recession within the industry. It was caused by a lack of quality control, competition from home computers and a flooded console market, then dominated by Atari. Launching in 1983 in Japan and the US two years later, the NES was significant gamble for Nintendo but turned out to be an incredible hit.
Utilising a swappable game cartridge system, Nintendo moved from arcade development to home consoles, launching the NES with 17 different titles that included Super Mario Bros, Duck Hunt (With the now iconic NES Zapper), Excitebike and Ice Climber, each of which became widely acclaimed.
It helped re-establish trust in the gaming industry and positioned Nintendo as a major force outside of Japan, bringing in 61 million sales worldwide. Combined with an iconic software library, this alone makes it one of their most influential consoles ever released.
1. Switch
It may be premature to call it Nintendo’s best console but the impact Switch has had on the industry is undeniable. Looking at the commercial failures of Wii U and the evergreen success of the 3DS, Nintendo took the unprecedented move to create a hybrid system, allowing for both portable and home play to capture both markets. Launching in 2017, it brought Nintendo back as a relevant force in the industry.
Overtaking the 3DS as Nintendo’s main portable, the Switch launched with a 720p screen built-in and detachable controllers, allowing for up to five hours portable play and a dock for TV use that provides an extra power boost. It’s clear Nintendo learned from their failures here and the Switch proves to be the console the Wii U should’ve been, bringing console quality games to a portable platform.
Featuring a strong first-party library, not to mention the large number of Wii U ports many gamers otherwise missed, it’s already estimated to have passed Xbox One sales (Which launched in 2013) and became a natural home for indie games on consoles. It’s not as powerful as the PS4 or Xbox One, there’s no denying this, but the portability trade-off has been a game changer for Nintendo and looks to have a positive future.