Ranking Every Video Game Joker From Worst To Best

Which iteration was a cut above the rest?

By Callum Marsh /

In the inundated landscape that is Batman media, there have been more villains than storylines. But despite the oversaturation of numerous adaptations, a multitude of new nemesis' being spawned over nearly 100 years of continuity and a vast amount of recreations of requisite plots, there remains one villain who has never been dethroned as the caped crusader's all-time arch nemesis.

Advertisement

Whether he goes by Jack Napier, Arthur Fleck of even Le Joker, it's not only arguable that he's the pinnacle of comic book villainy, it's debatable that he's bigger and more influential - if not more iconic - than the eponymous Batman which produced him. Both within the pages of the comic and in terms of the brilliant writing from Bill Finger and Bob Kane.

Since making the jump to video games in the late 1980s, there have been countless manifestations of this purple clad sadist to choose from, with some being malignant to a positive reception and some just being viciously bombarded with existential criticism.

Which one will prevail over the rest? Well, there's only one way to find out.

And... here... we... go.

11. Commodore, 8-Bit, Game Boy And Early 16-Bit Iterations

Games: Batman The Caped Crusader, Batman (1989/1990), Return of The Joker, Revenge of the Joker, Batman: The Animated Series.

Advertisement

In the early days of companies gaining a penchant for the lucrative sensibilities of video games becoming genuine revenue generators, almost every popular license in existence was being outsourced to different developers.

Coincidentally, Batman just happened to have a gargantuan pop-culture resurgence around the same time, and with Tim Burton's theatrical interpretation exploding in the box office, plans to create tie-in video games were quickly being made.

The predominant issue that plagued a lot of these titles, both at the time and retrospectively, was that gaming wasn't anywhere near as technologically advanced as cinema, and a fair few elements were lost in translation due to this.

Mainly, the maliciously joyous personality of Nicholson's show-stealing performance as the Crown Prince of Crime. The main antagonist that featured in every video game accompaniment to the source material.

Perhaps people were able to heavily rely on their imagination more prominently during this infantile era. As the deplorable lack of personality imbued here - depending on your stance - is either laughably bad, or no laughing matter. The first appearance(s) of the Joker - despite being profitable - are not exactly prolific.

10. Batman: Dark Tomorrow

Voiced by: Allan Enlow

Advertisement

Somebody call a doctor, something is seriously, seriously wrong. This isn't a reference to the Joker's impaired psychological megalomania, it's instead a judgemental finger pointing at the sheer insolubility of what can only be referred to as a botched face transplant, an abhorrently pain-inducing set of vocal cords - and not in a good way - with the biggest offence being the static, lifeless model used to represent such a classic character.

Not only is the model perplexing as it is non-articulate, the personality is just simply embarrassing. For whatever reason, the developers thought it would be feasible for the Joker to be playing an organ like an old lady in a church, which admittedly is a first, with the surrounding interactions between him and Batman feeling more like a friendly reminiscence between old friends than it is a man fighting his enemy.

If this was the only vocal performance ever put to media, Jared Leto would have not only won an Oscar for his piss poor portrayal, but he'd probably be considered the definitive version of the character. Which speaks volumes as to how insincere and shockingly absurd this forgettable waste of time really is.

9. Mortal Kombat Vs. DC Universe

Voiced by: Richard Epcar

Advertisement

The most underwhelming game in the Mortal Kombat series - only canonically, not including spin-offs - was completely downtrodden, if not outright scrutinised by critics and fans alike upon release, and ironically, the DC characters have a pivotal part to play in all of this overabundant criticism.

Despite the DC roster containing murderous psychopaths in the form of The Joker, Deathstroke and Lex Luthor just to name a few, the corporate fat cats over at Warner Bros. decidedly put a veto on any of the characters from their influential intellectual properties when it came to delightfully barbarous execution. Regardless of the character's nature.

So, you can imagine just how disappointed many people - with a lot likely buying this game to see what maniacally tasty bloodshed could be utilised by characters like Joker - were when they witnessed him subtly kill someone off-screen, with little to no implications of extreme violence.

The insipid irony of this is that the year was 2008 and prior to this, the Joker had murdered Jason Todd in cold blood, crippled Jim Gordon's daughter (with the insinuation of potential sexual violence) and even poisoned a group of children with candy floss, but apparently all of that doesn't compare to murdering another homicidal maniac.

It might be fair to say that DC have always made some rather bemusing choices...

8. Batman: Vengeance

Voiced by: Mark Hamill

Advertisement

You thought that Arkham asylums Joker had a ridiculous plan? Well, he pails in comparison to this iteration of the skinny twiglet trying to take on Batman in hand to hand combat on more than one occasion.

In this initial 3D rendition of Batman's most infamous nemesis, you can be assured that not only does the incarnation look abysmal due to the clunky textures and low-poly graphics - akin to an alpha version of a final product - but it disappointedly collapses in the execution of the character overall, as to opposed to only one issue causing restraints.

The lacklustre writing certainly doesn't help, as his plan is obviously going to be thwarted by the world's greatest detective as it always is, but even somebody with the cognitive capabilities of The Condiment King could've likely defeated him with his extremely limited arsenal of abilities. The voice acting definitely helps to relieve some of the incoherence, but ultimately not even Mark Hamill can save this travesty.

Though it was nice to see the mythical Joker being fully realised in his three-dimensional form for the first time, and alongside Harley Quinn nonetheless, it's excruciatingly underwhelming just how little passion he was crafted with. They say something has to be funny in order to be a joke, but you can rest assured, no one is laughing at this, only wincing with cringe.

7. Mortal Kombat 11

Voiced by: Richard Epcar

Advertisement

Opposing the abysmally clunky design that was shown in beta stages which made him look more like a bouncer than a provocateur of the murderous arts, Joker went from looking like a hench man, to, well, a henchman. But in one of the few appearances in which the malicious madman is actually playable, you could do a lot worse when it comes to other options.

In Joker's second delve into the Netherrealm, he doesn't only stand out from the crowd based on aesthetic design, he's also unprecedentedly an overpowered bestial force. After entering the roster later in the game's life, he shook up the foundations of the game by instantly becoming a fan favourite, with many players opting to use him as their main and for a plethora of extremely good reasons.

His zoning ability is top tier, the versatility - and humour - of his move set is essentially unmatched by the majority of other fighters and his finishing moves are so inline with his sinister cynicism that it leaves the player with an unquenchable thirst for their opponents blood each time they pick up and play.

You know what they say, what doesn’t kill you, simply makes you stranger!

6. Injustice/Injustice 2

Although his design is probably the closest iteration of the late great Heath Ledger's legendary portrayal in the much coveted dark knight, his characteristics and overall necessitation in the game he appears in are considerably minute in comparison.

Advertisement

Yes, his initial malevolent act of having Superman accidentally, and sadistically, murdering a pregnant Lois Lane is essentially the reason for the events to be perpetuated into motion, but, after this occurs, Superman immediately murders him and thus, the Joker is deceased throughout the substantially large remainder of the story that follows.

Which seriously puts the writers in quite a bind for the inevitable sequel.

The lacklustre design of the original Injustice game's Joker is, admittedly, vastly improved, but his overall presence within the game and the series going forward feels somewhat forced. His subdued role in the second game - which is a single hallucinatory fight in Harley Quinn's story chapter - feels like an afterthought, rather than something that feels wholly intentional.

Understandably, it is a predicament for the development team, as they couldn't really justify adding Joker as a DLC character in a DC-based fighting game, but it simply begs the question, how on Earth are you going to bring him back for the third title? In a dream?

5. The Adventures Of Batman And Robin

It's amazing that a title from the 16-bit era irrefutably contains a vastly superior incarnation of the villainous mastermind as opposed to some of the substantially larger-budgeted, more expansive 3D experiments that proceeded it decades later, and 28 years since it was distributed onto store shelves, it simply remains too charming to chalk down.

Advertisement

This is predominantly down to two imperative elements:

Identifiably, it's the first game in which we can confidently comprehend that we are indeed fighting the Joker, rather than a pixelated stack of ambiguous features.

But more complimentary to the character's design, it ingenuously feels like the most adherent and faithful adaptation of both the comics the character initially originated from, as well as the much beloved cartoon that conceptualised this version of the character.

What makes this version memorable, rather than illusively grandiose in comparison to surrounding counterparts, is just how innovative, imaginative and creative the developers managed to become. Utilising the character in a variety of different environments with various effects that were simply groundbreaking for the time, it managed to add an additional layer of personality to every interaction encountered between Batman and the Joker. It's rather incredible just what they were able to do with such limitations and it gives the game a real sense of timelessness.

4. Lego Batman (Series)

Voiced by: Christopher Corey Smith (Lego Batman 2/3)

Advertisement

With the inception of the original Lego Batman, in one fell swoop, Joker went from violent antagonist to silent antagonist, which doesn't exactly sound like it would correlate to a character that normally resonates with the darker side of people through personality alone. Dependent on who you ask though, some may argue that the serene silence made the body language-based melodrama more expressive before the Lego games imbued voice acting.

If you're not one of those that found the more elucidative, elusive nature of silent Joker encapsulating, then you'll be pleased to know that his personality perseveres in the two sequels.

Of course, with the target demographic being young children, he's more subdued as opposed to murdering people in cold blood for sheer pleasure. That doesn't mean that his zany tenacity has been purged from the character - nor his antics - as this version of the character is insatiably delightful to watch.

Full credit to Christopher Corey Smith, who takes the looney nature of Lego Joker and absolutely sprints off with it.

3. Batman: The Telltale Series

Voiced by: Anthony Ingruber

Advertisement

This interpretation deserves props for the idea alone. Since the inception of the Joker, there have been many conceptualised versions, but never have we seen one birthed from being a corrupted innocent by the likes of Batman before. And other than the stellar Arkham titles, this is easily the most horrific representation within the video game realm, as we watch the Joker go from self-assured hero all the way to confused psychopath.

After initially meeting Bruce Wayne in a mental asylum - where they're both patients - a rather docile man by the name of John, or so it seems.

As the story unfolds, John gradually spirals further and further into madness, devolving into what he was destined to become, and what he becomes is one of the most phenomenally groundbreaking, original interpretations of the Joker seen in the last few decades.

The story is fantastic; the acting is very much on par with the aforementioned story and the ferocity of the character materialises at the perfect times.

2. Batman: Arkham Origins

Voiced by: Troy Baker

Advertisement

After the seminal Arkham Asylum blew critics away, Arkham City followed it by substantially raising the bar. So, where do we go from here exactly?

Backwards, apparently, and while this radical shift of the timeline and disengaging form of gameplay that came along with it comparative to the expansive open-world premise that the former two games had in spades, the outsourcing of the project to another company didn't instil much confidence in fans either.

While the reception to the game was lukewarm upon release, the use of a younger, creepier version of the Joker was a major highlight. Taking both the bat and the clown back to their earlier days created some fantastic moments, with the prolific Troy Baker's performance standing out amongst everything else.

His exceptional take on the character, to a degree, does come across like a copy and paste job of Mark Hamill's legendary iteration, but that's not exactly a bad thing when considering just how immense he is anytime he undertakes this role.

While it doesn't quite measure up to the OG Joker voice actor - and let's be serious, who does? - it's a sincere and adept attempt at breathing life into the character, and a meaningful imbuement of everything the Joker is.

1. Batman: Arkham Asylum, City, Knight

Voiced by: Mark Hamill

Advertisement

Potentially Mark Hamill's best voice performance, or perhaps to some, even his most inspired performance in any medium (including his portrayal of Luke Skywalker) comes in this reprisal of his exceptional take on the murderous marauder in what is possibly his most glorious depiction in all of media.

After the trend of mediocre Batman game after Batman game deplorably profiteering egregiously from devoted fans, until a fairly unknown company by the name of Rocksteady came along to buck said trend.

While a lot of the critical praise comes from the flawless dynamicity of the gameplay, a lot can be attributed to the series' prime antagonist.

Despite a minor flaw in the endgame of the first title, which can be considered nothing more than a nitpick.

As you traverse the Asylum as Batman, like Alice in a severely discombobulated, idiosyncratic Wonderland, you can always feel the Joker bearing down on you, like he's watching your every move. When he isn't taunting you, his presence is always felt, giving both a sense of claustrophobia and incommodiousness, and whenever he appears, he simply steals the show.

Easily one of the best, if not the singular most exemplary Joker-centric saga ever written in the nearly 100 year history of the character.

Advertisement