Red Dead Online: 7 MAJOR Issues Rockstar Must Address

Is Red Dead Redemption 2 repeating GTA Online's biggest mistakes?

By Ewan Paterson /

Rockstar

Red Dead Online - or at least its beta - has finally launched this week, and fans are understandably excited. GTA Online proved to be one of the most successful (and lucrative) experiments in Rockstar's history, and though it certainly had its issues, players were more than willing to let them slide, with the mode affording most a large amount of freedom to do what they want, when they want, how they want.

Advertisement

So, with that in mind, the million dollar question on everyone's lips must surely be whether or not Rockstar have managed to recapture the same appeal of that mode with Red Dead, and the answer - at least currently - isn't yes.

Yes, Online is still in the earliest of stages, and it took months for GTA's multiplayer to get to its absolute best, but there are a whole number of concerns that have emerged in the wake of its first day, and some sound worryingly similar to the issues that plagued GTA Online during its later years.

Advertisement

It's early days, but given GTA Online's track record, there is cause for concern...

7. Once You've Picked Your Character, That's It

Rockstar

GTA Online's character creator may not have been the most robust tool out there, but it was easy enough to get to grips with. Then, even if you weren't happy with your character, you could create another all over again, and have multiple characters to select from at a given time.

Advertisement

Red Dead Online differs here, sadly. Once you've picked your character, that's it - and if you aren't content with how they look, you have to delete them and start from the very beginning, which means replaying that tedious opening all over again.

Online's customisation options are pretty nifty, with the ability to choose your own body-type a particular highlight, but there's something uncanny about most of the faces players can create. Maybe Rockstar should've brought back the ancestry system from GTA?

Advertisement

6. Other Players Can Ruin Your Fun Easily

Rockstar

Towards the latter stages of GTA Online, most of the game's content revolved around active missions taking place in the open world. This was fine, for a little while, until it became apparent that the missions could only be completed in a lobby full of other players who could net their own little reward for pretty much ruining your own fun.

Advertisement

The same mechanic returns for Red Dead Online, and it's about as frustrating as you can imagine. Instead of having any sympathy for their fellow players, dishonourable outlaws will make it their number-one priority to make sure you don't complete a given stranger encounter, whether that be delivering cargo, picking up mail, or just something else entirely.

It's frustrating, if not entirely predictable, but it is an issue. Having a posse full of people is an effective deterrent, but not everyone who hops into Online will want to link up with other players, and certainly not when they're just getting to grips with the mode's mechanics.

Advertisement

5. Progress Might Not Even Carry Over From The Beta

Rockstar

Perhaps in an effort to avoid repeating the same mistake GTA Online did when it first launched, Rockstar have been keen to emphasise that Red Dead Online is, in its current state, a beta. A lot can change in a few months' time, and given the amount of bugs and glitches that are currently in the open world's multiplayer component, the studio have almost certainly made the right decision in making it a beta.

Advertisement

However, one thing that's not been emphasised enough is that all of the progress the player accumulates in the beta may not even carry over once Online transitions into its next phase. It's a big risk, and with so many players already sinking hours into the feature, there are plenty who could be left disappointed once things do change, should they grow particularly fond of their online avatar.

"We hope that all player progress during this early period of the Beta will be able to remain intact long term, however as with many betas for large scale online experiences such as this, there is always the chance that we may need to implement rank or other stat resets in case of issues."

In short, don't get too attached to that coat or repeater you just unlocked, because you might not get to hold onto it once the mode progresses.

Advertisement

4. Survival Mechanics Just Don't Work Online

Rockstar

In Red Dead Redemption 2's single-player, survival was a priority. As Arthur Morgan, players had to ensure that not only they stayed fit and healthy, but that the camp did too. It added a whole new level of immersion to Rockstar's typical blend of third-person open world exploration, and though there were occasions were it proved tedious, for the most part, it proved to be a success.

Advertisement

That being said, it's unlikely many players were asking for the survival mechanics to be brought across to Online, where death is infinitely less impactful and a repetitive occurrence. No one wants to spend their hard-earned dollar on oatcakes and tins of baked beans when they want to dive in and outfit their character with a whole host of different looks, and given GTA Online placed no restrictions on letting players do just that, it's disappointing to see Red Dead do the exact opposite.

Surviving out in the wild with your pals sounds like a great idea, but if Rockstar are dead set on retaining the feature, it might be a good idea to segregate servers based on those who want to mess around with hunger meters online, and those who don't.

Advertisement

3. Everything Is SO EXPENSIVE

Rockstar

Now this is where things get especially troubling, as almost everything in Red Dead Online costs twice as much as it does in the single player. On the surface, this shouldn't be an issue. After all, most people's main objective in Online will be to make money, and given how there isn't a shortage of opportunities to do just that, the mode's inflated prices should be easy enough to manage.

Advertisement

Sadly, at this point in time, that just isn't the case. It costs $200 just to create a permanent posse; clothing is too expensive, making it difficult to give your character the look you desire; a decent rifle will set you back $300, and that's without factoring in the expenses of frontier living, with provisions and gun oil a valuable - and frustratingly essential - commodity to invest in.

Still, this shouldn't be a massive issue, right? Those familiar with GTA Online will recall grinding out Contact Missions repeatedly to net a quick profit, but the same rules don't apply in Red Dead Online. Story missions only pay out upon the first completion, and players won't see genuinely great payouts until its closing stages, meaning that if you want to get the most amount of money as soon as possible, you'll end up missing out on valuable parts of the story.

Advertisement

Currently, Red Dead Online's 'Store' icon is locked, but it's easy to see where this is going. Shark Cards made Rockstar millions in GTA Online, and with microtransactions on the horizon, it almost feels as though the entire in-game economy has been built around pushing players to purchase gold with their own real-life money.

2. It Makes No Sense To Lock Clothing Behind Rank

Rockstar

For most of Tuesday, I'd gone into Red Dead Online with the express intent of making my character look like All-Star Western anti-hero Jonah Hex, scars and all, and while the character creation tool afforded me plenty of opportunities to mirror that character's grisly persona, the necessary clothing turned out to be locked behind rank, with some even locked until you approach level 100.

Advertisement

It's a bit silly, and also completely unnecessary. The sooner players are given the opportunity to make their avatar look like what they want them too, the sooner Online becomes an enjoyable exercise. There's also the fact that cosmetic upgrades shouldn't be the focus of levelling up, especially when GTA Online existed just fine by making guns and vehicle upgrades the only rank-based unlockables in-game.

Red Dead Redemption 2 moved along at a slow, methodical pace for its opening chapters, but the same approach feels out of place in an Online setting. The main draw of the mode, surely, lies in letting players make their own avatar so they can posse up with their friends and take part in quick, accessible activities set in the Old West. Instead, they'll be left waiting hours before getting to claim true ownership over their character, and it's exactly ideal.

Advertisement

1. The New Story Isn't THAT Interesting...

Rockstar

Red Read Redemption 2 was a tour-de-force when it came to storytelling, but the same cannot be said of its multiplayer.

Advertisement

It's easy to see what Rockstar are attempting here; you, the player, take on the role of a wrongly accused convict destined for the hangman, but are saved by the widow of the man you were falsely accused of killing. It's the perfect set-up for a typical revenge-driven western, and yet, with a silent protagonist and some random players by your side, it just doesn't gel together at all.

Whereas in GTA Online the player's silent protagonist was quirky and at times downright hilarious, here, in the world of Red Dead, they just feel out of place. Missions see players make honour-based decisions much the same way Arthur Morgan did in the main story, but they're carried out by vote and, in most places, the neutral expression of four silent protagonists contemplating the fate of an NPC isn't charming - it's creepy.

Advertisement

Bear in mind that Red Dead Online is almost certain to change in the months to come, but as far as first impressions go, it hasn't given the best.

Watch Next...

Advertisement