Alongside Naughty Dog, Rockstar are one of those industry heavyweights that can dictate their own artistic direction when it comes to sequels and iterations on established franchises, rather than going down the Ubisoft route and churning one out every year. It's precisely because they hold onto their properties until they're polished to a mirror sheen that they end up doing so well upon release. Which is why the idea that they're already very far along on the development process of Red Dead 2 is so exciting. Another sequel to the Red Dead name, few of us forget due to Redemption's staggeringly high benchmark for open-world gaming, that it was actually a sequel itself - Red Dead Revolver was a very different beast indeed. That was mainly down to Revolver actually being developed originally by Capcom, with its more arcade-style feel being cast away for Rockstar's signature take - turning into 'Grand Theft Horse'. Easily one of the greatest games of all time and beloved by critics and fans alike, publisher Take-Two CEO Strauss Zelnick stated Red Dead is to be thought of as a "permanent franchise", thereby setting the rumour mill spinning again as to just how they could capitalise on Redemption's success.
10. The Name
So let's get that name out of the way. In scouring the internet for anything concrete in terms of press releases or interview slip-ups the only thing that remains a constant is that the game won't be called 'Red Dead Redemption 2'. Instead it can be assumed from the switch between Revolver to Redemption previously, Rockstar will continue tradition this time around. Although it must be said Red Dead Redemption has a hell of a lot of weight these days when anybody mentions it, so they could continue down that path for the sake of brand recognition. The name that everyone seems to be settling on for now is 'Rebellion', which as any who've finished Redemption will know, could mean it factors into the main narrative in a huge way. We'll elaborate on the inner workings of the title's significance over the following points, but as Zelnick mentioned the series is a "permanent franchise", so at some point they'll have to start numbering them, surely? Another potential title that's floating around the internet is Red Dead Revenge, which definitely has more bite to it, but we think Rockstar can do better. Which direction would you take in naming the third instalment?
9. A Grand Theft Auto V-Sized World
This one is pretty much a given after the phenomenal success of GTA V, proving to Rockstar's powerhouse development team that putting that much effort into just a game's world can be fully appreciated by consumers. For the most part Redemption's world - although extremely expansive and tone-setting - was restrained in terms of scope by the trappings of the time-period itself. We all loved hopping on our steeds to traverse the back o' beyond whilst offing a couple of random bandits along the way, but the challenge will be to take the heft of GTA V's scope and apply it to such an initially barren landscape. Will that mean more detailed interiors? Incredibly complex character models? Perhaps destructible environments that remain in a state of repair depending on how much firepower you put into them? Time will tell, but the setting itself is going to dictate how much of a challenge Rockstar will face in making something like the Old West feel like it belongs on next-gen hardware.
8. A Prequel
From Revolver to Redemption we switched main characters from Red Harlow to John Marston, with the latter easily being one of the best protagonists the industry has ever seen. Some people - potentially nitpicking depending on your view - choose to say Marston's actions in-game don't always correlate with how he presents himself in cutscenes. It's the GTA IV problem (check out ludonarrative dissonance if you want to sound fancy), although it's pretty easy to assume that a reprisal of Marston in the form of a sequel would still be received very well. Rumour has it that Rockstar are setting up the most violent times of Marston's life for the main thrust of the narrative though, showing exactly what and who he was trying to get away from in his first game. In a way this could do a disservice to the events of Redemption, being that part of the appeal of his mysterious past was the very fact that it was so non-specific in the first place. Still, if the potential 'Rebellion' in the name is actually to do with warring factions and the eventual alignment with crooked sheriffs, that could make for a pretty sweet evolving narrative dynamic.
7. Multiple Characters
This is something that's came from how different-feeling Revolver was back in 2004, in that throughout the campaign you'd switch between six different characters, all converging in that game's explosive finale. Rockstar have led the 'silent protagonist kills everything'-charge since GTA III, and for the most part it's been routinely perfected by themselves, as well as being done to death. That's part and parcel of why GTA V's three-character setup was such a genius move, it let them give us guys like Trevor who more nihilistic players could embody to torch everything around them, or you were free to act a little more sanely as Michael or Franklin. Everybody's happy. For the most part this solution would work perfectly in Red Dead too - depending on whether Marston stays as the main character or not - as even if we go with the prequel idea it's doubtful Marston could be the total monster in cutscenes we'd play him as, only to turn out as well-adjusted as he does overall. Give us multiple sides of the same coin simultaneously by projecting player's potential whims on to different characters, and let certain gameplay elements and missions dictate who and when varying subsets of missions can be tackled. It's the perfect way to flesh out the world itself alongside satisfying all sides of the open-world player-base.
6. In Development Since 2010
The world of gaming in 2014 is a drastically different one of 2010, which according to rumours is when development on Rebellion started. Since then we've seen Rockstar turn their attention towards L.A. Noire, publishing Team Bondi's divisive detective thriller and making it at least appear to look like one of their own despite its developer's potential intentions. Aside from that the only other game the team have put out across their multiple studios - forgoing GTA V - is Max Payne 3; another questionable title that many loved depending on how much they were a fan of the Remedy-developed originals. We mention all of this, because between L.A. Noire, Max Payne 3 and GTA V the industry has seen a huge leap forward in terms of narrative drive and immersive characters, all helped in no small part by Redemption's spectacularly open-ended 'true ending'. Rockstar where one of the first developers to pioneer the idea of a player-made narrative choice in-game truly matter on a level where you were heavily emotionally invested, and although GTA V pretty much played it safe in terms of forward movement - forgoing that torture scene - all eyes are on the next instalment of this titanic franchise to deliver something meaningful. Speaking of which...
5. A Dynamic Story
There was a time a few years ago where nearly every game seemed to have a 'moral choice' option thrown in for the sake of immersion, and GTA IV was no different. However for IV it drastically changed the outcome of the game, alongside a couple other choices throughout that decided whether key figures lived or died. Besides that though Rockstar haven't really done a whole lot in the way of letting us dictate our own stories, which leads to two opposing sides: Red Dead Redemption was entirely linear aside from the very last optional mission. For the most part we all killed and got shot by the same people at the same significant points in the story, leading to one of the greatest endings of all time if you sought it out. Thanks to motivations being expertly set up you'll be hard-pressed to find someone who didn't track down Edgar Ross by that riverside. On the other hand is GTA V, where the only meaningful choice again comes at the very end of the game, but is relegated literally to an option on a menu, seemingly thrown in for the sake of replayability, and carrying none of the weight and overall finesse of Redemption's. If Rockstar want to build these gigantic worlds with the illusion of a thousand different stories all happening at once, then let us be a big part of that too - things like saving certain characters or restoring and buying out certain buildings could go a long way in making their world feel like more than just elaborate window-dressing.
4. The Return Of José González
This one edges more towards fan-wishlist than substantiated rumour, as the only basis for it comes from forum posts and Youtube comments - but then again that's how these things get started. You might not know José González by name, but you'll definitely know the moment he changed your life (if you played Redemption that is). One of the most memorable and beautiful sequences in the game - and in gaming history - is when you finally cross the border into Mexico, emerging on the other side of the river following an intense firefight. Mounting your horse and taking off across the new lands as the sun slowly sets, José's fantastic track 'Far Away' slowly comes in, making your ears prick up as Rockstar rarely use songs in their games outside of being contextually appropriate i.e. turning on the radio in GTA.It's an absolutely gorgeous piece of music, and with Gonzalez' soft vocals complimenting the distant sound of your horse's hooves tearing through the dirt, if his formidable talents make a comeback in Rebellion it'll immediately make the new experience perfectly nostalgic and familiar.
3. A Next-Gen Exclusive
It's a bit weird that even now we're referring to consoles that've been out for almost a year as 'next-gen' but at the minute there's not a load of games you can point to as truly feeling like they've heralded in the new machines with any great purpose. With both Rockstar and Naughty Dog's GTA V and The Last of Us respectively proving that the current/'last' generation of consoles could still deliver hugely important and jaw-dropping experiences, it's over to these masters of hardware to truly show off what they can do. Although that's something we'll hopefully get a pretty good idea for come November when the re-release of GTA V hits shelves. Until then it might be slightly 'unfair' on those who still have the older hardware, but its about time developers put all their efforts into developing experiences for the new machines that aren't possible anywhere else (except most likely PC). A teaser or gameplay demo for what has turned into Rockstar's second most popular franchise would be a great place to start.
2. Single-Player Gangs
We've covered multiple protagonists, but what of squad-based combat and team-tactics, along with the actual maintenance of a gang both at base HQ and out on-mission? Rockstar are yet to truly dabble in squad mechanics, with the last time they did being in 2005's The Warriors - although even that didn't feature you commanding your crew in the same way as something like Mass Effect. Sure we don't want an over-reliance on squad-management, but a great way to shakeup the gameplay that's remained relatively the same from GTA IV through Red Dead and GTA V would be to allow us to manage groups of people at once. If the rumour of warring US Army/Native American factions in the game holds true, being right in the middle of the conflict and siding with either opposition to amass a diehard squad of teammates could work a treat. So far aside from GTA: Online Rockstar aren't ones for pushing multiplayer content, and it would be a breath of fresh air to see them realise the idea of multiple heroes on screen at once - a missed opportunity from GTA V all things considered.
1. A Whole New Character - Big Jesse
So, was there anyone out there who didn't like John Marston? For the most part he was damn-near loveable, with a relaxed southern drawl-swagger that made him imminently likeable regardless of his potentially chequered past. One of the most sparsely-discussed rumours so far has been the mentioning of one 'Big Jesse', although so far his existence seems to boil down to intrepid Youtubers posting threads of information and backing them with conviction to get people pumped. The rumour goes that Jesse is an outlaw with an extremely violent past, who after witnessing too much decides to leave the whole thing behind and settle down. Naturally his past comes calling and he's pulled back into the world he left once again - and say it with us - "For one more job." As you can see this is remarkably similar to Marston's story - alongside a great many Rockstar titles and others within the genre itself - but the very idea of a new protagonist that can distance Rebellion from the incredibly high watermark of Redemption can only be a good thing. Whatever Rockstar decide to do, apparently we're going to get an announcement and info-dump before the year's out, so fingers crossed they can put something out that catches us completely by surprise. For now though as we look forward to the sequel we know is coming in some form, we'll leave you with this... So what have you heard, and what do you want to see? Let us know in the comments what you want from the next Red Dead!