Red Dead Redemption 2: 10 Most Believable Plot Theories You Need To Know

What if you're going up against Dutch's Gang, not controlling it?

By Kevin McCasland /

Rockstar

Rockstar are one of those developers with the unique ability to keep their games a secret until THEY want you to know everything about them.

Advertisement

It's resulted in a level of mutual respect between fan and creator, meaning that when something as small as the company changing their Facebook profile picture to a red R happened, everyone lost their minds. Then, once the official trailer for Red Dead Redemption 2 came out, the internet was firmly set ablaze. Not that it was up for debate, but this has reaffirmed just how much we're all ready for a sequel to Red Dead Redemption.

Such a sequel has been atop many different "most-wanted" lists for some time, and Rockstar knows that they need to deliver. A game praised for just about everything, with story and characters being paramount, very little is known about RDR2's story at the moment, but even with the few promotional images and single trailer, there's plenty to theorise on.

Advertisement

--

10. Story Is Centred Around The Blackwater Massacre

Rockstar

Taking place in 1889, the Blackwater Massacre saw a confrontation between lawmen and lawbreakers that caused up to 30+ casualties, possibly including Bonnie MacFarlane's brother and many others. Landon Ricketts was one of the survivors of the event too, and whilst the cause of the incident remains unknown, it seems that RDR2 could provide many new details.

Advertisement

The Massacre was discussed multiple times throughout Redemption, with John Marston even recalling that he knew the Landon Ricketts name, because of the event. Considering that John was about 26 when this massacre took place, it's certainly possible that he may have been on the opposite side of the struggle (or at least his former acquaintances were). If the story includes this event or offers a closer examination of it, it could allow players to connect with the characters in the midst of a rather intense and brutal situation.

Depending on whether or not this installment will involve past characters or will focus on new ones, this theory seems to be a viable basis for the narrative.

Advertisement

If it involves Marston, and they confirm that Bonnie's brother DID die while fighting on the criminal side, then all those conversations between Bonnie and John in Red Dead Redemption just took on an entirely new layer. If it's a new group, then it can be a powerful introduction to how dangerous the life of an lawbreaker can be.

9. Set Across Multiple Time Periods

Rockstar

This theory ties in with another that will be elaborated on later, but this one discusses the possibility of seeing a steadily progressing setting across several time periods. It's unclear whether it would just spread across a single year or multiple, but it sounds like the passage of time may not always be completely straightforward.

Advertisement

Hopefully, this would allow for a multi-faceted story that can show off a constantly changing environment, along with a society that is gradually adapting to new technologies. Redemption saw Marston and society starting to grasp the concept of vehicles, yet still in disbelief that a man could ever fly. A consistently changing time period would allow for these intriguing moments in which players get a glimpse into simpler, less advanced times.

Considering the visual variety shown off in the environments, it may end up being more of a varied landscape than actual separate time periods, but the environmental differences will be much appreciated regardless. Besides, Redemption had a couple of time jumps (John going to the ranch, Jack going from teenager to grown adult) and made them fit very naturally, so it wouldn't be too surprising if they can pull it off once again.

Advertisement

8. Seth & Irish Could Be Playable

Rockstar

Coming from a supposed 'Rockstar insider' back in 2015, this rumor came up back in the days where RDR2 had yet to be confirmed.

Advertisement

During an anonymous Reddit post, this insider stated that the game would be called Red Dead Redemption 2: Legends of the West (close enough), that it would take place twelve years prior to Redemption, and that you'd be playing as one of three characters: Seth, Irish, and a completely-customizable third character.

The Reddit post also went into detail on the potential backstories of both Irish and Seth. Irish (naturally) grew up in Ireland, and he moves to the game's setting when he turns twenty-one. Seth works as a bank teller with a wife and kids, but upon hearing about a grand treasure, he uses up all of his life savings to find it. The story would then show him steadily lose his state of mind and his connection with his loved ones as he continually fails to find the treasure and eventually becomes the grave-digging creep that he is in Redemption.

Advertisement
Rockstar

Although the concept of multiple playable characters with an option for a customizable character seems possible, it's difficult to see Seth and Irish being the selected characters for RDR2 to focus on. Both of them were entertaining personalities to be around, but it's hard to see the main story focus on them. A cameo appearance from both would be great, but a full game wouldn't be necessary.

7. Appearances From Several Red Dead Revolver Characters

Rockstar

Keeping with tradition, it would make sense for Rockstar to tease potential connections between Red Dead Redemption and Red Dead Revolver.

Advertisement

In Redemption's multiplayer, players could play as Red Harlow, Jack Swift, Shadow Wolf, and more, offering Revolver fans an opportunity to play as some old favorites. Although it may seem like that'd be the most significant inclusion of Revolver's characters, there's a possibility that these characters officially cross-over with Redemption's world. When examining the group shot of the seven gang members, it certainly seems like there may be some Revolver characters in that image.

Again, the image is likely purposely ambiguous so that it's not possible to definitively identify each character (especially if any of them aren't carryovers from previous games), but several of the character outlines hold similar physical resemblances to Red Harlow, Jack Swift, and possibly even Shadow Wolf. If they were to be included in the gang, then it would finally confirm that Revolver and Redemption exist in the same world AND offer up some fun interactions between numerous memorable characters.

Advertisement

That being said, those three outlines seem to be the most ambiguous of the bunch, as there are numerous possibilities as to who those characters could be. While it'd be great to see these characters make some sort of appearance, it'll likely be in a minimalistic fashion at most.

6. The Main Character Is A Marshall Or Sheriff

Rockstar

A key element of just about every Rockstar game is that the player is always very anti-law enforcement.

Advertisement

Whether you're pulling heists in GTA or slingshotting prefects in Bully, the games' main protagonists are hardly a representation of any law-abiding citizens. However, if Rockstar showed anything with L.A Noire, it's that being a law enforcer CAN work (if done properly). With one recent theory offering up the possibility of RDR2's protagonist being a law marshall or a sheriff, law enforcement itself may become even more appealing than ever before.

What would set this potential scenario apart from a game like L.A Noire, would be the increased freedom of choice. Unlike a 1940's detective, a sheriff in the Old West is allowed plenty of liberties within the law. Outlaws can be dealt with in whatever way the sheriff sees fit. There aren't many questions of morality, and doing things 'by the book' isn't exactly a necessity.

Advertisement

This would allow players to choose what kind of officer they want to be: good-natured, or just someone who does as they please.

Since Redemption was more about the theme of the dying Old West, perhaps this could allow for a theme of combating corruption in a world that only seems to reward the non-innocent. It would allow the 'Wanted' side missions to make a comeback AND it would open the door for some co-op play in which multiple players and their personal law enforcers can take down assorted gang hideouts. A realistic interpretation of a modern-day officer would be enjoyable, but being a sheriff in the Old West would offer up even more wild possibilities.

Advertisement

5. The Protagonist Is An Entirely New (Possibly Customisable) Character

Rockstar

A possible first for a Rockstar game, but the opportunity to create your own cowboy to control through a Rockstar-caliber narrative would offer players an experience unlike any other.

Advertisement

This theory also stems from that promotional image of the seven gang members where the middle-most member is the only one that has proven to be indistinguishable for internet theorists. He looks unlike any previous character in either Revolver or Redemption, so if his central placement within the image is anything to go by, chances are high that he will be the game's main protagonist.

Add in the theory that this is Dutch Van Der Linde's original gang, and players will be able to witness its gradual downfall, alongside being one of the characters whose fate is already pre-determined. Redemption players know what happens to John, Dutch, and Bill, so having the player be someone never before seen, allows for some unpredictability with what will end up being their final fate.

Advertisement

4. It'll (Sort Of) Be A Prequel To Mafia 3

Rockstar

Thanks to that leaked map released back in mid-2016, players may already have a decent idea of what kind of open world they'll have to explore. However, it wasn't until certain people examined the map closely that they discovered that some of the listed locations have the same names as locations in Mafia 3 (another 2K-published game). This would imply that RDR2 has, in some way, a direct connection to Mafia 3.

Advertisement

In terms of the story or RDR2's characters, this connection remains unclear. Outside of the games taking place in the same location spatially, would Rockstar be interested in including an ancestor/distant relative of a Mafia 3 character? Another possibility is that it could involve some elements of racial tension like Mafia 3 had, except it could deal more with the Native American struggles in a predominantly white Old West.

In the end, if this even turns out to be true, it'll likely amount to a cool easter egg and little else. A signature Lincoln Clay jacket and haircut would be a nice touch as well.

Advertisement

3. Jack Marston's Story Continues From Red Dead Redemption

Rockstar

If Rockstar wishes to treat the '2' in Red Dead Redemption 2 as a representation of where this story takes place chronologically, then it seems like continuing Jack Marston's storyline would be a natural next step in the overarching narrative. Considering where Jack's story concluded in Redemption, he's got plenty of paths to go down for future storylines.

Advertisement

Perhaps Jack is still dealing with the events in Redemption, leading to outbursts and a strong mean streak, should anyone bring up the tragic events that occurred. With all of the trauma and issues that plagued Jack's childhood, he'd certainly be different from John, personality-wise. This would allow him to not feel like a rehash of John and instead a wholly new character that stands apart from dear old John.

However, it all depends on whether or not both gamers and Rockstar feel that Jack can carry a game by himself. He was only controllable after the game's conclusion, so he still remains somewhat untested. Depending on how you felt about him, this could be a great idea, or one that's a bit too divisive to try.

Advertisement

However, if that group picture is anything to go by, and since Jack doesn't really fit the outline of any of the gang members, fans aren't likely to continue Jack's adventures in RDR2.

2. Multiple Playable Characters

Rockstar

Ever since GTA V tried out their multi-protagonist system (to great success), many players have been clamouring for Rockstar to implement this system in future games outside of the GTA series. Since Red Dead is the next game on Rockstar's lineup, it's the latest game to get people hyped for another group of controllable protagonists.

Advertisement

When examining how much this system allowed GTA V's storytelling to excel and develop in an original way, Red Dead seems like it could only benefit from the implementation of this system. However, part of what made Red Dead Redemption work so well was that John Marston was the lone wolf type that had to go against his instincts and rely on his allies to help him achieve his goals. If this system were to be put into the game, the character types would have to stray from that formula, or it would feel like too much of a retread.

Imagine having one character that's the typical cowboy, and then include a heavily-discriminated Native American character to offer players two extremely different perspectives of how the Old West treated people back then. This system could work out for RDR2, so long as Rockstar avoids using familiar character arcs and archetypes.

Advertisement

1. It's Dutch/John Marston's Gang, Pre-Redemption

Rockstar

This seems like the likeliest scenario, as it's difficult to deny that those characters look awfully familiar.

Advertisement

Besides, considering all of the rich history that was teased during each of John's interactions with his previous gang members, it'd be a shame not to utilize this opportunity. Seeing how Dutch was prior to his downfall, seeing if Bill Williamson was ever likeable and seeing pre-Redemption John Marston would allow a greatly fulfilling experience to those who were hoping to see more of these characters.

Digging deeper into them would serve to further enrich this universe and help us further empathise with characters like Dutch, who clearly lost his way at one point or another. Dutch, Javier Escuella and Abigail Marston definitely deserve more screen time, and Rockstar have the opportunity to provide just that with RDR2.

Advertisement

The group dynamic would be immediately engaging, and being able to see how everyone interacts with each other would be both intense and quite enjoyable, thanks to the wide array of personalities. If Rockstar doesn't end up going for a clean slate in regards to the world and its characters, then a reunion of the ol' Dutch Van der Linde gang would offer up another amazing experience for both old and new fans alike.

--

Advertisement

What/who do you hope to see in Red Dead Redemption 2? Let us know in the comments below!