Red Dead Redemption 2: 8 Disturbing Secrets & Locations You Totally Missed
You don't need Undead Nightmare 2 to scratch that zombie itch...
Red Dead Redemption 2 has been out for well over half a year now, and it's the gift that keeps on giving. Perhaps unsurprisingly given how long the title was in development, the open world Rockstar crafted is home to countless little details, stories and mysteries that players keep stumbling across.
Even with thousands of hours dedicated to exploring every nook and cranny, and plenty of articles already written covering the exhaustive amount of easter eggs that were crammed in, even the most die hard RDR 2 fan will have plenty of cool secrets they totally missed while playing. Even better, a good chunk of these are the kind of skin-crawling details that made Rockstar's version of the Wild West so intoxicating and atmospheric back at launch.
We already know that everything from vampires to serial killers to g*ddamn ghost trains are haunting the plains of Rockstar's world, but those terrifying realities only scratch the surface of the kind of disturbing things you can run into. From creepy tie-ins to the developer's other franchises to tragic ends for characters you totally forgot about, there's plenty of reasons to saddle back up for another haunting journey through Lemoyne.
8. The Fate Of Bonnie's Husband
Bonnie MacFarlane is a major protagonist in Red Dead Redemption 1, the owner of the MacFarlane ranch that serves as something of a home base for John and the player throughout the early part of their journey. We get to know the character a little bit as the two forge a strong relationship, learning that Bonnie was once married.
However, we only find out what happened to this marriage in RDR 2, where you can stumble upon an apparent corpse of a man lying at the edge of Flat Iron Lake. Inspect the body and it will briefly jump back to life, giving you the "Letter to Bonnie MacFarlane" item before dying for good this time.
There's nothing happy to be found on the inside, only apologies from the man for not being there for his former wife, and a desire to be better and return to his family with riches and wealth to keep them secure. Of course, that didn't work out quite like he planned, and it's unclear if the letter ever made it to who it was signed to. It's all very tragic, but this passage is particularly haunting in light of how everything turned out:
"Dear Miss MacFarlane, I'm sorry. I said it. I'm sorry. You're right. I do let things get out of control in my head. I always have. I see that but I love you. We are meant to be together. It is our destiny. I know it is. I saw us in a dream, raising kids. You were very happy as my wife and I was proud to be your husband. Dreams don't lie and neither do I."
7. The Face In The Rock
Now this one is a little tricky to find, as it's essentially hidden in the mountains located north of Moonstone Pond, but also difficult to miss once you find the right path. Look for a narrow pathway between the mountains and look out for a wooden, man-made structure that will take you up to a huge carving of a face in the rock.
That's already weird enough, but adding the mystery you'll also find a man hanging from the neck underneath the scaffolding. Do a little digging and you'll find out that this guy was the artist responsible for the glorious sculpture of the woman in the side of the mountain, but, as always, his display of affection ended in tragedy.
Search for the man's suicide note and it reveals that this act of romance didn't go as planned, and actually soured the woman on him. Realising this, and without anything left to live for, he killed himself.
Who can blame him, though?
He was stuck between a rock and a hard plac- [I've removed the end of this for the good of us all - Scott, Editor]
6. The "Night Folk"
You might go the entirety of RDR 2 without encountering the so-called "Night Folk". Hell, in my playthrough, I only saw one of them, carrying a dead body to god-knows where, and assumed he was just a random murderer; a one-off interaction I'd stumbled upon.
It turned out, however, that the murderer was actually part of a strange cult who haunts the swamps of the Bayou at night. You can come across gangs of these ravagers, usually covered head to toe in skin diseases, cuts and dirt, on the prowl for their latest victims. They're like an even more aggressive version of the Murfree Brood you find in the North of the map, talking only in grunts and moans, with it being rumoured that they're not actually human.
You probably don't want to stick around and check that out for yourself, as they'll attack you on sight, and are usually surrounded by the grisly remains of their previous victims.
5. Charlotte's Stalker
There are plenty of terrible, perverted people in Red Dead Redemption 2, making a career out of preying on helpless victims and inviting people into their homes so they can drug them. With that on the table, it takes something pretty evil to be singled out.
The crazy stranger you can find close to Emerald Station might just be the worst of them all though, as he has eyes for one particularly innocent target: Charlotte Balfour. Charlotte is part of one of the best quests in RDR 2, as Arthur forms a bond with the widow towards the end of his life, teaching her the essential skills she needs to survive after the death of her husband.
This guy, however, will relay a tale to you about how he's stalking her, something he takes such pride in. Obviously, you shouldn't let that stand, and he absolutely deserves a bullet to the head (or much worse). To make things creepier, check his tent after you've decided on his fate, and you'll find it decked out with a stash of pictures of naked women.
4. The Meteor Devastation
The meteor house in RDR 2 is home to one of the most grisly scenes in the entire game (yes, even worse than the aftermath of a Murfree Brood ambush). Located on a hill west of the marker for Brandywine Drop is a little, unassuming shack overlooking the forest below. It's a prime piece of real estate, but a quick glance at the roof reveals that not everything is as idyllic as it looks.
Something has smashed straight through the top of the building, and making your way through the door will reveal that it was a meteor fragment. It hit the shack with such force that it pretty much obliterated everything (and everyone) in its path, destroying the interior and parting the unlucky souls caught inside from their limbs.
You can actually pick the meteor fragment out of one of the mutilated corpses if you wish, and there's another one to find not too far away as well. Thankfully, this one didn't actually catch anyone in its crosshairs, but it did do a good number on the nearby forestation.
3. GTA V's Michael Is Hidden In The Game (But Nobody Knows Where)
If you were keeping a close eye on RDR 2 at launch, you'll know that it features the great, great grandfather of GTA V's beloved psychopath, Trevor Phillips, but Rockstar's latest also features another cameo from their world-conquering crime epic.
After completing the main story, a bunch of eagle-eyed fans noticed that the voice actor for GTA V's Michael was listed in the credits, leading to him taking to Twitter to reveal that he was indeed in the game, but wasn't totally sure where.
As expected, the search was immediately on, with players wandering around the open world looking for the character, essentially becoming that guy who keeps shouting "Gavin!" around town.
While a whole bunch of evidence popped up on the internet, some of which suggesting he was discovered as a burnt corpse and others finding a photo featuring a character who looked strikingly similar to the GTA counterpart, apparently all of these have been debunked.
The actor's voiceover work was apparently cut, but he insists his character remains - out there... somewhere... wandering in the wilderness.
2. The Creepy Statue Game
There's no real explanation for the strange statue game existing in the world of Red Dead Redemption 2. In between Window Rock and the Granite Pass you should be able to find some markings on the side of the rock pointing you towards the location of the puzzle, which is further south.
If you make your way through a crevice just above the Mystery Hill Horse point of interest, you'll stumble across a bunch of eerie statues all missing fingers. One has a missing arm, which you can find lying around the cave and will give you all the numbers needed to solve the mystery. The idea is that you have to count the fingers on each statue, and then press the ones which have an amount that's a prime number.
Why? Well, it's not entirely revealed who set the game up, or why the only instructions revealing its existence were scrawled onto a rock wall, but it will net you a couple of gold bars for your trouble.
1. The Werewolf Of Roanoke
You might already know that there's plenty of supernatural ghouls waiting to be found in Red Dead Redemption 2. The biggest of these is undoubtedly the vampire of Saint Denis, but there are other, just as disturbing monsters out there. The most terrifying of all, however, might be the werewolf lurking near the Roanoke Valley.
While roaming there at night (when there's a full moon in the sky, for full effect), you'll be able to hear the howl of wolves, before encountering a pack with a strangely humanoid figure amongst them.
The werewolf won't actually attack you here, but you can follow him into his cave/lair where you'll have to fight off a pack of wolves. He'll yell at you to leave, before attacking you in the nude. It turns out he's not a werewolf after all, but rather a regular feral man who's been living with the animals.
Still, it's probably not wise to leave a naked dude who thinks he's a wolf roaming the fields of Roanoke Valley unattended.