Red Dead Redemption 2: 8 Things It Must Fix From GTA Online
Can Red Dead Online avoid GTA Online's worst feature?
Red Dead Redemption 2 is shaping up to be another legendary release in Rockstar's grand catalogue of legendary releases, but to say that the studio have gotten everything right during their existence would be letting them off lightly.
Grand Theft Auto V - what many would consider to be the jewel in Rockstar's crown - was a triumph when it released in 2013. It also wasn't without its issues, with the game's multiplayer mode, GTA Online, falling afoul of criticism as it gradually developed into a cash cow of monolithic proportions.
Rockstar lent continuous support to GTA's multiplayer component, but as the years went on, the studio found it difficult to provide genuine reasons for why players should stay invested. Updates amounted to little more than glorified adverts to invest in Online's virtual currency, which had kept the game's DLC 'free' from start to finish, and for those who opted not to, it soon became apparent that gameplay had devolved into a repetitive grind.
Red Dead Online can change all of this though, by learning from both the good and bad of its predecessor, and taking notes from the community. Here’s what needs to change to make it genuinely worthwhile.
8. The Inflation Of Virtual Currency
Make no mistake: GTA Online undoubtedly improved as the years went by. The addition of heists proved to be a massive success (when they eventually arrived), and gradually, with each update, a community began to develop. New cars, clothing and gameplay features all helped GTA keep moving forward, but with the need to strive for bigger and better things Rockstar lost sight of what made those initial updates so successful - their accessibility.
Unfortunately, from 2015 onwards, GTA Online's economy inflated on an exponential scale. In order for players to access the new content, most of which became predicated on a 'high society' theme, they either had to grind for hours doing heists, or grind for hours completing the same sequence of missions included in the base game. The easier option was to buy a 'Shark Card' using real life currency, and though these updates were all technically free, the only players who had a chance of reaping their benefits either had the time to grind, or didn't mind forking out money to get an instant injection of cash.
Eventually, those able to fully enjoy Online's DLC became a very exclusive club, with Rockstar having effectively put up a paywall in front of their 'free' updates.
Needless to say, Red Dead Online needs to change this. Ditch the high life themes, the gold plated merch and get on with making a compelling online world players can return to without having to worry about grinding out for the next update.
7. Servers For Different Kinds Of Players
Open up GTA Online and, on a bad night, you're likely to spend most of your time outrunning a player jetting around blowing everyone up. The only alternative is to enter 'passive mode', in which case you become a ghost and are unable to participate in any other in-game activities. On a good day, you might be able to get away with a skirmish or two, but - for the most part - the servers were populated with trolls, griefers, and the kinds of people who leave their microphone in and think blurting a non-stop stream of Eminem is considered 'a good time'.
The only way to get around this was to link up with your own pals and enter a server of your own, but as new missions had to be completed in a public server with others, it made it virtually impossible for players to get a stress-free experience.
This is why Red Dead Online should have as wide a selection of servers as possible. Introduce a free-aim server, where those who toggle off auto-aim can test their marksmanship against each other; a Co-Op server, where PVP combat is disabled; or even just do a better job of lumping in toxic players with other toxic players - anything to ensure players can get the most out of their time online.
6. Make Heists A Focus
It's absolutely bonkers to think that it took Rockstar over a year to introduce Heists to GTA Online, and yet that was very much the case. Four ended up being included in that initial update, and what was there was enjoyable - even if the idea of planning your own caper was never taken to a genuinely compelling conclusion.
The problem, however, was that there simply wasn't enough of them. The Doomsday DLC suffered from the aforementioned paywall problem, and at no point did Heists ever afford the player the level of freedom one would expect when planning their own caper.
The solution to this would be to open up Heists to the community. Let players plan their own getaways, from the prep-phase all the way to the conclusion, and introduce a resource where people can open up a page, look for the kind of Heist their after, and download it. Such an approach worked wonders for Halo back in the day, and if Rockstar gave players the tools to truly personalise their own Western heists, Red Dead Online would genuinely be incredible.
5. Ditch The Weapon Wheel Altogether
For Red Dead Redemption 2's single player Rockstar have opted to lose the weapon wheel altogether. Gone are the days of your protagonist being able to pull out an RPG from their coat pocket - now, players genuinely have to think about what kind of weapons they want to carry, and about what play-style they want to use.
But while this may be the case for the game's single player, we're yet to learn if the same approach will manifest in its online component. One of the biggest issues with GTA Online was that each player was effectively an army of one - they could do so much, and with a weapon for every occasion, it made confrontations dull, repetitive, and fatally boring.
Imagine this though: you assemble a posse of all your friends, and each one has their own speciality. There'd be a marksman, someone who preferred close-quarters fighting, and potentially even a gunslinger - giving players the scope to taylor their own experience and not only providing a more gratifying style of co-op gameplay, but one that seamlessly translates the vision of the single player to the multiplayer too.
4. Ensure Layering Makes Sense
When GTA Online's wardrobe really got going, some of the creations players came up with were spectacular. Outfits based on classic designs from cinema, comics and more all made their way into Los Santos, and one can expect the same to happen come Red Dead Redemption 2's release.
Despite the freedom afforded to players, however, the system wasn't without its issues. Layering could prove especially problematic at times, with there being no rule of what exactly could and couldn't be worn over a given item of clothing, and it sometimes turned an enjoyable exercise into a uniquely frustrating one. Exacerbating these issues further was Rockstar's apparent clampdown on 'glitched' outfits, which they removed even when they didn't affect gameplay.
Needless to say, it would be great if the studio could make sure that players are given more freedom to layer clothing the way they want to, and to encourage them to experiment with different combinations. Few games present the opportunity for gamers to dress up in the garb of the Man with No Name, or the myriad of other famous western protagonists, so giving them the opportunity to alter the most acute detail hassle-free is a must-have inclusion - for the online mode especially.
3. Meaningful Connections To The Main Story
One thing that may have flown over a lot of people's heads is that GTA Online was actually a prequel to the story of GTA V. The two stories never crossover in a worthwhile way, but an attempt was made by Rockstar to make it fit in with with the story of Michael, Trevor and Franklin.
Red Dead Online, whether it be set before or after the events of the main game, should endeavour to manufacture genuine connections with its main story too. A prequel would make more sense, for the sake of ensuring the main story doesn't get spoiled, but it would be great to see players link up with Dutch's gang in some way - even if it is just a fleeting encounter.
The scope for further links with the plot is certainly there, and with heists almost certainly set to feature as well, Rockstar could easily make Red Dead Online a compelling story of its own.
2. Introduce Different Ways Of Making Money
As was previously mentioned, making money in GTA Online - particularly in its latter stages - proved to be needlessly repetitive. You could do heists, the same old missions over and over again or engage in update-specific jobs, which required a massive investment before turning a profit. Those too were marred by the fact they had to be completed in a public session, and it's ultimately what left many players with no alternative but to either quit the game for good, or to invest in micro-transactions.
We've already seen how Red Dead Redemption 2 will present Arthur Morgan with various opportunities to make his way in the world, including tracking down bounties, or completing busywork for various citizens. There's gambling too, which would be interesting to factor into online play, and with a living, breathing ecosystem to hunt and trade, one would hope Rockstar don't make the same mistake they did in GTA Online, and take wildlife out of the equation altogether.
Either way, ensuring Red Dead Online has a world to live in, and for there to be plenty of opportunities to generate in-game currency, is of key importance.
1. Meaningful PVP Interactions
When it came to GTA Online, interactions with other players were... difficult. You could shoot at each other, interact with a few gestures and drive around, but that was about it (unless you forked out the extra moolah for a yacht).
Red Dead Online can change this for the better though. Considering the single player is placing such a massive emphasis on being able to interact with everyone, be it with the tip of your hat or the raising of your firearm, it makes perfect sense to translate that approach to the multiplayer too. Obviously it'll be a lot more combative (that's just the way multiplayer works), but hopefully with a varied selection of servers Red Dead Online could let players interact in a meaningful manner, rather than becoming a perennial vacuum of antagonistic behaviour.
It wouldn't be without combat of course - the defining image of the Old West was built on the idea of duels, and so players should be able to do just that. The idea, however, is that Online should evolve into an open platform where caution is rewarded, and toxic behaviour is dealt with. That's how you develop a new community.