Resident Evil: Ranking Every Major Protagonist Worst To Best
Yeah Leon is pretty cool, but has he ever punched a boulder?
After decades of producing some of the best and worst video games the survival horror genre has ever seen (though arguably the series divorced itself from that title as early as the fourth release), Resident Evil has never faltered in spinning a long-running story that fans just love to lose themselves in.
From the initial haunting at the Spencer Mansion to the recent soft-reboot that saw Ethan Winters being tormented by a psychic old lady (it's scarier than it sounds), Capcom have constantly added to the ever-expanding lore even through a multitude of genre changes. Arguably, there's one key element that's allowed them to succeed despite the constant gameplay and tonal changes: the characters.
The franchise's cast is one of the most extensive in gaming, so to stop this list becoming more bloated than the series' canon itself, it only includes characters who've starred in games considered part of the "mainline" narrative. If spin-offs also happen to include these picks then that's fine, but they had to be first playable in one of the core franchise entries. Sadly, that means no Barry Burton, despite him probably being the number one pick in all our hearts.
13. Piers Nivans
Piers Nivans is such an afterthought that it's actually difficult to find an image of the character without Chris Redfield being the main focus. Redfield's BSAA teammate, who's seemingly only there because Capcom wanted all three main Resident Evil 6 campaigns to be playable in co-op, Piers is your run-of-the-mill military type, with barely a sliver of personality to call his own until the story's final missions.
Eventually Chris and Piers' companionship does come into play when the two are put in mortal danger, and Piers' eventual sacrifice is surprisingly affecting considering how little he adds to the narrative prior to that point.
Had the entire campaign featured moments where the two were working off each other like this then Piers might have avoided being dead last, but as it stands, it's going to take a massive misstep for Capcom to create a less compelling playable Resi character going forward.
12. Helena Harper
Between Helena and Piers, it's pretty evident that Resident Evil 6 had trouble coming up with new characters to bounce off core heroes. For what it's worth, Helena does fare better as a partner, and her dynamic with franchise staple Leon is far more fleshed out and intriguing on the whole. More of a naive, by-the-book agent compared to Leon's jaded zombie vet, there was at least some palpable chemistry between the two characters that was missing in Piers and Chris' relationship.
Her search for her missing sister, Deborah (and its tragic resolution), also adds an extra layer to the hero as well. Aside from her ideals, she genuinely has something to fight for, and a strong motivation for carrying on with Leon once that's taken away from her.
Of course, it helps that she had a better campaign to headline overall as well, rather than one that's 90% the most generic third-person shooter of the Xbox 360 generation and 10% actually any good.
11. Billy Coen
Despite not resonating all that much with critics or audiences at the time, Resident Evil 0 has enjoyed something of a resurgence over the past few years, perhaps in part thanks to a pretty stunning remaster.
Still, while that re-release could polish off the textures and up the atmosphere, it couldn't really do too much to make Billy Coen a more interesting character. Resi's first foray into having multiple heroes playable within the same campaign, 0 came up with the unlikely partnership between rookie agent Rebecca Chambers and Billy, an on-the-run criminal whose entire character is built on early 2000s cool guy cliches.
He's essentially Snake from The Simpsons, at least initially.
Fortunately he gets a little more interesting following his introduction, and the dynamic between him and Rebecca, both in the story and their differences in actual gameplay (with him being the stronger, more combat ready of the two), is more than enough to carry this underrated gem.
10. Ethan Winters
Ethan Winters is one of the most unique Resident Evil protagonists, but it's kind of telling that you probably had no idea what he even looked like before seeing the above image. In a way that can't be used too much against him as, after all, his debut was the first in the franchise to adopt a first-person perspective, but it does reflect how little of an identity he had inside the title.
In their attempt to bring more Western attributes to the series, Resi 7's horror is much more grounded (well, as grounded as a series about bio-weapons, Matrix-eseque baddies and psychic old ladies can get, anyway), and that meant Ethan had to be a far more relatable protagonist than the quick-witted super agents of games gone by.
In a way that shift worked, and it's incredibly easy to put yourself in the hero's shoes (especially in VR) as he searches for his missing girlfriend, but it also leaves him feeling kinda... blank. There's potential there, but who knows if Capcom will ever bring the protagonist back for another tour through hell.
9. Sheva Alomar
Sheva received so much underserved hate when Resident Evil 5 came out. A new character being introduced in this franchise is always going to be contentious, but a new character who's only seemingly being included because co-op was the design mandate was destined to be loathed.
Which is a shame, because it's only really her A.I. that's deserving of any real vitriol. Yeah, in gameplay she might be a pain to constantly babysit, but Sheva actually has one of the richest backstories of any modern Resi hero, being part of the West African division of the BSAA and part of the action in countries that Resi rarely ever ventures to.
She's not the greatest character, but it's disappointing Sheva hasn't shown up since her first outing.
8. Sherry Birkin
In a lot of ways, Sherry Birkin's inclusion in Resident Evil 6 was something of a passing of the torch for the series, as the character had shown up a few times before, most notably as a main player in Resident Evil 2. Only a child in that title, she was infected with the G-virus by her father and saved by Claire Redfield, but forced into protective custody once the story wrapped.
The sixth game sees her freed from this secret life and embracing her new role as a government agent, brought in to help stop the kind of biohazard outbreaks that her father was responsible for engineering in the first place.
Not only was the novelty of seeing her for the first time in years endearing, but she was one of the few heroes in that sequel with any real character development. At this point, Leon and Chris are so defined that their arcs don't really have anywhere else to go. They're fully defined constructs, but with Sherry in Resi 6, it felt like the writers genuinely wanted to explore some new themes and build up a new generation of franchise heroes.
7. Jake Muller
Along with Sherry, Jake Muller - aka Albert Wesker's son - while a little bit cliched on paper, was actually one of the few redeeming features of Resident Evil 6. That might sounds a bit blasphemous considering how contrived his existence is, but aside from that, he actually tangled with some rather interesting themes.
Both he and Sherry had to deal with the sins of their fathers, living essentially in the shadows of their parents. They'd both grown up in unique circumstances, and over the course of this sixth game attempted to discover who they are away from their notable heritage. It's a surprisingly human draw for someone who literally karate chops zombies to death, and it's a shame it was locked away in a sub-par sequel.
And, as daft as it is, Jake is one of the few Resi protagonists who fundamentally plays differently. His melee focus demands you to approach the game from a different perspective, and makes his campaign's co-op focus the only one that really feels justified.
6. Rebecca Chambers
Appearing in the very first Resident Evil title, Rebecca Chambers was actually canonically one of the first Resi heroes to actually encounter zombies and stumble onto Umbrella's virus project. She was a side character in that initial title, but was promoted in her playable debut, Resident Evil 0, which shed some light on these preliminary, haunting events.
As mentioned previously, her relatively meek characterisation bounced well off criminal Billy Coen, but she was still a captivating hero in her own right. Her unassured disposition fit the situation perfectly; this was the first time anybody had dealt with the undead, and the character's own palpable fear ensured every bit of tension and horror was wrung out of the premise.
Series creator Shinji Mikami has reflected on the character's portrayal (despite her popularity) in interviews before, lamenting the star's lack of real agency and autonomy. However, it's Rebecca's naivety that made her so endearing to fans, and gives her so much room to grow should she reappear in this franchise.
5. Ada Wong
Debuting in Resident Evil 2, Ada Wong was destined to become a fan favourite. The spy's relationship with Leon instantly distinguished the sequel's story from that of its predecessor, with Wong being one of the few overtly "cool" characters the franchise had seen at that point, only getting more outlandish with each appearance.
Having to guess whose side she was really on became one of her defining features, maintaining an aura of unpredictability every time she was on screen. Her popularity ensured that she eventually became playable as well, starting out in an unlockable mini-game for Resident Evil 4 (another title in which she totally stole the limelight).
However, she wasn't actually the lead of her own campaign until Resident Evil 6 - and even then it was a shorter, secret one that you only unlocked after beating the others. The wait was worth it, however, as her brief journey was the only one that didn't feature co-op.
4. Claire Redfield
While Leon is remembered as the star of Resident Evil 2, Claire Redfield enjoyed just as much success when it came to winning the hearts of fans. Her campaign in that title wasn't totally different from Leon's, but the inclusion of Sherry Birkin for Claire to protect kind of added a cool Aliens vibe to the whole situation.
From here she wouldn't actually appear in another numbered sequel, but still enjoyed headlining roles in both Code Veronica X and spin-off Resident Evil Revelations 2. Even though she was initially only really defined by her search for brother Chris, Claire did grow into her own over the course of the early titles, perhaps having an even stronger drive to survive than Leon.
While others, like Jill and especially Rebecca, had a pervasive vulnerability to them, Claire quickly adjusted to her hero role. Gunning down zombies with shotguns fit her perfectly, and it made the move into cheesy 90s action movie territory with Code Veronica feel like a cogent next step for the franchise.
3. Chris Redfield
Chris Redfield is so good partly because of how so bland he could have been. While he was a little one-note in the original game, with his story not quite matching the quality of Jill's, the character grew into his own over subsequent sequels, particularly in the fifth release.
Though many had issues with the plot of that follow up, it was the perfect fit for an all-American hero like Chris. More straight-laced than the wisecracking figure Leon eventually became, Redfield essentially morphed into The Rock as the series wore on, which more than fit the stories he headlined.
It's been mocked, but in the context of the game, it makes total sense that Chris would be the kinda guy who would punch a boulder twice the size of himself to get it moving. Some fans dislike the action-oriented route the series eventually took, but it would have been so much worse if Chris wasn't there to shoulder the transition.
2. Jill Valentine
Debuting with Chris in the very first Resident Evil, most players then (and still today) gravitated towards Jill Valentine for one main reason: she made the game easier. Starting out with a gun as opposed to a knife, extra inventory spaces and a lockpick, Jill - the master of unlocking - made life that little bit easier for new players.
Of course, while this gave her a bit of a one up in comparison to Chris, it's not the only reason she became so popular. Jill's story in that first game was memorable for both good and bad; her interactions with Barry Burton - Jill sandwiches and all - became the stuff of legend, but even without that cheese it could be argued her story was the better of the two in that original title.
Jill only got better from that first outing as well, turning up again as the lead of Resident Evil 3 to battle Nemesis, and shedding her iconic original get up for a brand new look and supporting role in Resident Evil 5. Through countless redesigns, the fans have always loved her - even when she was turned into a mind-controlled terrorist.
1. Leon S. Kennedy
Who else could it be? From his debut in Resident Evil 2, Leon practically became the face of the entire Resident Evil franchise. Instantly appealing in his first appearance, the rookie cop's inaugural day on the job found him battling against a city of zombies. He was the everyman players could relate to, completely in over his head yet gifted enough to take on the enormous task ahead of him.
While that made him compelling, it was his transformation between Resi 2 and his reappearance in Resident Evil 4 that cemented him as the series' best protagonist.
By this release, Leon had become a special operative skilled enough to be tasked with tracking down the President's daughter from presumed terrorists. His new position brought newfound confidence, and Leon essentially became a too-old-for-this-s**t veteran agent who dealt with life or death situations via quips and jokes. Put simply, he essentially became the Spider-Man of the Resi universe.
He lost a little bit of steam in the sixth game (but then, who came out of that unscathed?), but there's a reason he's been a constant part of the Resident Evil series both inside the games and out.