Rocksteady's Superman: 8 Things We Need To See
The next logical step for the studio is also the hardest to take.
London-based studio Rocksteady, famous for producing the acclaimed Batman: Arkham trilogy, is heavily rumoured to be developing a Superman game. The Arkham series revolutionised both the superhero and the action/adventure genre, with many other studios introducing similar game mechanics in an attempt to replicate Rocksteady's success.
Adapting Superman across any medium has always been a challenge since Christopher Reeve's iconic performance in the 1970s. The Man of Steel has had a poor track record in video games. Gameplay has been a clear challenge, most notably displayed in Superman 64's notorious flight mechanics.
Rocksteady's Batman games were heavily inspired by Bruce Timm's Batman: The Animated Series, and as a result they characterised the Dark Knight perfectly, with many original cast members returning from The Animated Series for the trilogy. If the studio can produce an adaptation true to the Man of Steel, backed up with a gripping storyline and diverse gameplay, the new Superman game is well on its way to being a huge success.
After fleeting appearances in LEGO games and the Injustice series, it's time for the Man of Steel to have his time in the limelight.
8. Truly Great Fighting Mechanics
The bar was raised dramatically in 2009, with Rocksteady's release of Batman: Arkham Asylum. The Arkham trilogy's combat system was revolutionary, and if Rocksteady could come up with another groundbreaking combat mode, this new Superman game could well surpass the success of the Arkham series.
Superman's powers could be used creatively in takedowns similar to the 'fear takedowns' in Arkham Knight, but using the Man of Steel's unique abilities to knock out enemies.
Timing is key - without making timing an integral part of the combat system, it quickly descends into button-mashing mayhem. Fast-moving targets, stunned enemies and combos are the typical solution deployed in the action genre. Another direction would be carefully timing the power of attacks to avoid killing human enemies (who are fragile targets compared to a fully-powered Kryptonian).
The Arkham games broke up generic fist fighting using stealth mode, where Batman would take down armed guards silently to avoid attracting attention. As an all powerful Kryptonian who is impervious to bullets, this clearly won't do. Superman's powers are another route to varied gameplay - as his wide array of abilities could be utilised in combos that promote varied play.
7. A Stylised Metropolis
One of the Arkham games' biggest successes was the artistic style chosen for the asylum and Gotham City. Fans don't want to see the new Superman game set in a typical American city, clearly based off of New York or Washington DC. Metropolis should look otherworldly, with futuristic buildings. Choosing a bold art style attracts audiences and creates a more unique setting, contributing to the overall immersion of the game.
Injustice's Metropolis was futuristic, with statues reminiscent of those in the USSR (showing Superman's departure from traditional American values and his descent into tyranny).
Unique settings are especially crucial to open world games. Audiences have seen too many generic renderings of New York City across a myriad of forgettable open world games.
Alternatively, neo-gothic designs reminiscent of Bruce Timm's Superman: The Animated Series would be welcome. Timm's Metropolis was full of bold statues of gods and men striking pertinent comparisons to Superman's own god-like abilities. Since Bruce Timm's work was such an obvious influence for Rocksteady's depiction of Gotham, it wouldn't be surprising to see a similar approach taken for Metropolis.
6. Get Flight Right
Many computer games simply can't come up with good flight mechanics. Superman games in particular have a bad track record with this aspect of the character, with gamers still complaining about Superman 64 nearly 20 years later. If the flight mechanic is intuitive and fun to use it would be a big selling point of the game, especially if the map was interesting to explore.
The Batmobile mechanics in Arkham Knight, whilst tediously over-used, worked nicely and took little time to learn. Flight adds a third dimension to typical movement/vehicle mechanics, with the easiest solution being either to use the right stick for upward movement or by keeping Superman at a certain height so that the 3rd dimension isn't required.
Moving through the map must be seamless and smooth because players do it all the time in open world games. Movement is often a major selling point for superhero titles, with the gliding in Arkham City, the Batmobile in Arkham Knight and the swinging in Spider-Man 2 (and in Insomniac's new Spider-Man game) being huge sources of appeal for these games.
5. Reasonably Powerful Opponents
Audiences often find the Man of Steel too powerful to be compelling. Unlike Batman, a human being, thugs and goons don't really pose a threat to the Kryptonian, even if armed and in large numbers. Outside of a tutorial, humans can't be used as opponents to Superman (unless armed with kryptonite) because this would either leave Superman too weak or his enemies strangely strong.
One solution would be to have numerous boss fights, maximising the use of Superman's impressive rogues' gallery. Kryptonite is another answer, but a lazy one.
Using a villain like Darkseid or Braniac with an army of parademons or bots would be another quick-fix, where Superman could fight non-human enemies who may pose more of a challenge physically.
Villains whose conflict rests mostly in terms of ideology (Batman may fall into this category) may make for an interesting story but wouldn't be able to pose a sustained physical threat throughout the game, greatly limiting gameplay outside of a TellTale-style thriller. This is a direction Rocksteady are unlikely to choose.
4. Feature An Interesting Villain
Superman has a solid rogues' gallery, and the main antagonist must be interesting enough to make players care about the story. Rocksteady's Arkham trilogy used Mark Hamill's Joker to create interest, a trick that worked brilliantly for the first two games and became stale in Arkham Knight. The trilogy's storyline drove the plot forward effectively, and the main threat was suitably menacing in every title.
Every Arkham game featured a myriad of villains, something that we would hopefully see carry on into Rocksteady's Superman game. Secondary villains can be used in side missions which pad out the story and help players hone their abilities. Furthermore, the main antagonist must have access to some kind of army powerful enough to challenge Superman.
Lex Luthor is Superman's most famous arch nemesis, but his lack of an army might relegate him to a compelling side mission or future threat (I wouldn't be surprised if we saw a twist that revealed Lex Luthor was behind the invasion or main threat in the game). It could well be that Rocksteady want Lex Luthor to be like Hamill's Joker was in the Arkham games: a common thread that was an integral part of every main plot point.
3. Use A Wide Array Of Powers
Superman is famous for having so many different powers. Whilst some critics see this as boring, leaving the Man of Steel overpowered, for many fans this is one of Superman's greatest selling points. To see this absent from the game would deter a large portion of its core audience.
This variety should be utilised creatively by Rocksteady to diversify gameplay. Recent adaptations of Superman frequently limit his range of powers as a short-cut to vulnerability and a 'reinvention' of the character. Fans want to see as many different powers as possible being incorporated into the game, even if some of them are reserved for glorified mini-games equivalent to the Riddler trophies of the Arkham series.
The Arkham fight mechanics incorporated Batman gadgets into fights. A similar technique could be used with Superman's abilities, using heat vision to attack enemies further away, super breath to knock enemies into each other, and flight for takedowns.
Powers could also be used to environmental interactions such as clearing the way for hostages or unlocking collectables (something Rocksteady are a big fan of, with gamers spending hours wasting away trying to find all 245 Riddler trophies in Arkham Knight).
2. A Gripping Story
It can be difficult finding a story that makes Superman feel vulnerable or challenged. Rocksteady did a stellar job designing a compelling plot in the Arkham series, so hopefully this success can continue in their Superman game. Something lacking from the Arkham trilogy was a deep exploration of the duality between the hero and his alter ego, something even more prominent in Superman where there is a large contrast between the powerful Man of Steel and the meek Clark Kent.
Seeing Superman balance his heroism with his normal life as Clark Kent would be refreshing and break up the gameplay nicely. As the story progresses, Clark's relationship with Louis could develop, perhaps giving players the decision as to whether to reveal their secret identity and continue building the relationship, or to keep distant and maintain secrecy.
Too many games in the genre have boring stories that act mostly as a scaffold to allow for action and gameplay sequences to the extent that some games almost dispatch with a plot altogether, such as Spider-Man: Shattered Dimensions.
Rocksteady are clearly the studio for the job, and their story-telling is impressive, especially if they sign on writer Paul Dini (who worked on Superman: The Animated Series and the Arkham games).
1. A Lighter Tone
Superman's outlook on life is much more optimistic than Batman's. This is one of the best things about the character. His optimism is what allows Superman to inspire hope in people. The Arkham games played nicely into Batman's Gothic world and his demented villains, but Superman lives by an entirely different code.
The Superman game shouldn't be dark or scary, nor should it be gritty and violent. In many ways, Superman is the opposite of Batman as a protagonist. Metropolis is developed and clean, whereas Gotham in dirty and in decay. Superman inspires hope, whereas Batman inspires fear.
It is very important that Rocksteady recognises the difference between these heroes and doesn't try to 'Batmanify' Superman. Zack Snyder's Man Of Steel tried to take a slightly more serious approach to the character, and was met with a lukewarm response.
A Superman game shouldn't be rated mature because it shouldn't contain disturbing scenes. Superman is supposed to be an inspiring figure, and the game should try to replicate that as much as possible, and it must steer completely clear of any of the grit of the Arkham series (and especially none of the Gothic horror seen with characters like Professor Pyg).