Shenmue 3: 10 Things It Needs To Be Successful

Out of development hell and onto Kickstarter, it's going to be a bumpy ride...

By Bryan Langley /

Before the Kickstarter, before that Sony press conference, you either used to heave the idea of Shenmue III out of your mouth over a sad pint with a friend, or tense up with anger at the unfairness of another unfinished saga.

Advertisement

This was a game series that provoked all kinds of media desires during the long years in the wilderness between the release of Shenmue II in 2001, and the June 2015 announcement that there would in fact be a real Shenmue III. Fans had endured so much waiting and the added indignity of a failed online version. Indeed, Shenmue III was something longed for, pined for on a day to day basis.

And here we are: starting 2017 some nineteen months after Shenmue III was formally announced. It's still some ways off, admittedly as the official release date is pencilled in as December 2017, but despite the original great news that it had been the most successful Kickstarter campaign ever in the video game category, there are still fourteen unfulfilled stretch goals.

Things could still go very wrong, (though I hope not). Here are 10 ways Shenmue III can ensure it succeeds.

10. Effective Marketing

Japan-centric games can be marketed in a very hit-and-miss fashion in western territories.

Advertisement

Take, for instances, the unforgettable slogan for the UK advertising of N64 smash hit, The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time: "Wilt thou get the girl... or play like one?"

Not exactly forward thinking in the dying years of the 20th century. The marketing behind the original Yakuza on PlayStation 2 (a.k.a. Ryo Ga Gotoku) didn't fully push the fact it was a type of reborn Shenmue, either. Despite being an open-world, action brawler, instead the story was the main message, and gameplay didn't get a chance to shine.

Shenmue III needs to go mainstream with its marketing if it wants to reach a critical mass of an audience and build to something mass market. Yes, there are almost 75,000 combined backers via Kickstarter and the Slacker Backer programme but 75,000 sales does not a successful game make - especially when you're budget is in the millions and you've got development and publishing partners relying on you.

9. Fewer (Or Intelligently Placed) QTEs

QTEs will never go away because they're a handy way to force the player to react to a certain scene in a pre-determined way given a set amount of time. In Shenmue, they're often using during chase sequences or when fights are about to break out.

Advertisement

They've spread successfully to other games, too. Resident Evil 4 had plenty of action-movie set pieces such as dashing down slopes to get away from conveniently spherical shaped boulders or the old classic "hammer a button to avoid being stabbed in the chest with a knife mere inches away" QTE.

QTEs, then, are accepted despite their poor reputation. And, to an extent, Shenmue III needs QTEs to make it feel genuinely like Shenmue. But they really need toning down. We don't really need them for dodge moves anymore, nor should we be forced to add them in so frequently when on the run or chasing down a hoodlum.

They should be used sparingly, and there should definitely be alternatives for those players not willing or able to respond quickly enough. It could take cues from Nintendo and Rockstar: fail a set number of times and you can skip or have it made easier. Some slick slow-motion, perhaps?

Let us know in the comments what your views on QTEs in the modern gaming landscape are.

8. Crossover DLC Or Crossover Characters

Probably one of the best current games for this is, surprisingly, Sonic Lost World for the Wii U.

Advertisement

Offering Hyrule-themed content via The Legend of Zelda and Yoshi's Island content where the game transforms into a hybrid of Mario and Sonic (without an Olympic contest in sight), Lost World demonstrates that games can blossom beyond the core mechanics and characters. Thankfully, SEGA also offer Nights from Nights into Dreams - another great throwback character giving the game variety.

A ton of crossover fighters are nothing new since Street Fighter, Smash Brothers and Sony's All-Stars have all offered one or more titles in this vein.

Shenmue is ripe for this - the fact that Shenmue started life as a Virtua Fighter RPG offers a whole roster of SEGA hard-hitters. They could even appear as story characters. Personally I'd love Ryo to have some serious fisticuffs and/or training with old drunken Shun Di.

Or even have a cameo whereby Akira is running a Lucky Hit stand. Why not have Kage-Maru as a trainer for Ryo? The possibilities are endless!

7. Make Sure There's A Demo

This always produces more work for the development team, but I truly believe this is necessary for Shenmue. We're talking about a game that had its last mainstream console edition released for Xbox in 2002 - fifteen years ago!

Advertisement

Older gamers need convincing that the Shenmue name still has worth in the flooded modern marketplace and younger newcomers need to know what makes Shenmue unique in terms of its combat and storytelling.

A demo would be the perfect chance to collapse the huge environment into a small area, giving players a chance to test out the controls, try their hand at combat and minigames and soak up the charm only a Shenmue title can offer.

Why not even include an arcade or two? They're always a great added bonus. If done well, a demo should translate to greater overall sales and get the word-of-mouth out prior to release.

6. Get The Release Date Right

In short: Don't do a Titanfall 2, which sandwiched itself between Battlefield 1 and Call of Duty: Infinite Warfare.

Advertisement

To be fair, this one is less of an issue as perhaps Shenmue III's closest competition will be from games that are already out like Final Fantasy XV and Mass Effect Andromeda.

Its unique nature means there's less out there to have a serious rivalry with. This is no FIFA 18 versus Pro Evolution Soccer or Call of Duty versus Battlefield. But nevertheless, going up against another big open-world game would be a mistake as Joe Public will ignore Shenmue in favour of what they already know.

I hate to say this, but it may be more favourable for YS Net to delay until the Spring of 2018, so the release calendar is clear and there's less competition. Or even make it the summer blockbuster of 2018 by releasing between June and August.

5. Ensure The Gameplay Is Smooth And Modern

The great news is that Shenmue III is to be a PC and PlayStation 4 game first and foremost; this means it's being built on the most powerful hardware currently available.

Advertisement

This should mean that Yu Suzuki's team at YS Net can utilise Unreal 4 to showcase something special. This needn't mean photorealism, however, as Shenmue always had a stylish look - somewhere between cartoonish and realistic, as that was what the hardware of the time, the SEGA Dreamcast, produced. It should run solidly, however; Shenmue has a reputation for being a little pedestrian in its pacing, and doesn't need framerate issues slowing it down further.

One big potential stumbling block was noted by the ever-excellent John Linneman in his Digital Foundry Retro video series. Motion blur was added for the combat in the Shenmue II port for the original Xbox. This was necessary for performance, but absolutely horrendous to play when switched on as fights became muddied and far too blurry - especially when facing off against multiple foes.

To really ensure Shenmue III stands out it must retain its graphical style, completely ditch the motion blur (or make an option to switch it off) and give the game a sense of pace by nailing the overall speed of the game: both Ryo's walking speed and the framerate around him.

If it feels clunky, players will switch off.

4. Improve Route-Finding And Minimize Player Frustration

Personally, I loved the fact you had to actually walk up to physical map signs whilst walking the streets of Hong Kong and zoom in using analogue triggers to look and scan the street names. I also liked the fact you could buy maps to help find your way. But it did take time.

Advertisement

Time is ever more precious as gamers grow older, start careers, have families or otherwise get busy with adult life. Nobody truly has time to learn to such a degree.

I'm not saying we need satellite navigation as with Grand Theft Auto nor a line painted on the ground to show exactly where to head next. And we especially don't want NPCs jabbering in the ear about where we should be heading next.

Indeed, part of the joy of Shenmue is definitely in the possibility of getting lost or disoriented and having to find your own route around the town, city or village you're in. But an optional slightly easier navigation system might help ease new players into the game: perhaps the giant floaty arrow as seen in games like Bioshock or Crazy Taxi? Just a thought.

3. Bundle Shenmue And Shenmue II Into The Box

Admittedly, there's been no mention of this in any of the financial reward tiers on Kickstarter, nor the Shenmue III official website - so at this point it's highly unlikely to happen from YS Net's side.

Advertisement

But do you remember the Dreamcast Collection? That lovely little bundle of games released for PC and Xbox 360 that was just crying out for some Shenmue? It had SEGA Bass Fishing, Crazy Taxi, Sonic Adventure and Space Channel 5: Part 2. Shenmue and its sequel never had a port nor a HD edition during the PlayStation 3/Xbox 360 console generation and there's been no word on any possible remastering despite the PlayStation 4/Xbox One generation feeling like it's one long list of remasters, remakes and re-releases.

Wouldn't it be just awesome (not to mention helpful when marketing) if Shenmue III also came with the prior games to bring lapsed fans and the general public up-to-speed with the saga? Just this month there are interesting domain registrations going on, so who knows?

2. Don't Force Multiplayer Or Promise A Feature That's Undeliverable

This is a byproduct of being a Kickstarter funded project more than anything else. So many projects have failed to reach their lofty aims. Other projects have been ripped apart despite commanding a loyal initial fanbase. Some have been delayed or have taken an outright age to make.

Advertisement

Shenmue III cannot afford, as such a high-profile title so beloved by the games media, to make mistakes with its features. Whether it's overreaching and muddying the waters by packing in too many gameplay elements or forgetting what made the games special in the first place, Shenmue must tread carefully.

It needs to modernise in certain ways to ensure it sells well but it must stay traditional to please a fanbase that has been waiting (patiently) some fifteen years for a sequel. The combat and exploration, really, are the two essential elements that it must nail. They need to be smooth, responsive and fluid.

Thankfully the latest screenshots show it's coming along beautifully and hopefully the gameplay matches the lovely visuals. With industry veterans on-board, here's one writer hoping it'll all come out fine in the end and needless doubting at this stage were simply misplaced fears.

1. Keep The Retro Arcades

You cannot argue with the power of Yu Suzuki classics. Outrun, Hang-On, Afterburner and Space Harrier: all icons of the 1980s arcade scene and all games playable in Shenmue and Shenmue II.

Advertisement

Now, I'm not familiar with the number of arcades open in the Guilin of 1987, but I'm hoping that if we're beginning in Bailu Village then we'll be headed for the big city to smoke out ol' Lan Di himself at some point during Shenmue III.

And what better way to prepare for a big confrontation than playing some video games? A quick spot of Heavyweight Champ and you're ready for fisticuffs at dawn! (Or, whatever time the actual fight will occur). I mean, if Super Monkey Ball 2 is reputedly good enough to improve surgeons' reaction times than how can Ryo refuse?

Arcades are a must. It's hip to be retro right now so SEGA are hopefully open to this.

--

What do you want to see in Shenmue III? Let us know in the comments!

Advertisement