Spider-Man PS4 Turf Wars Review: 3 Ups & 4 Downs
Is the latest entry in The City That Never Sleeps worth the money?
There's no denying that Insomniac Games' Spider-Man is a game of the year contender, or that it is probably one of the finest comic book video games ever to release. The studio illustrated an immense understanding of the Marvel mythos back in September (we called it a "pure, wonderful, affecting love letter" to the wall-crawler in our review), but their first wave of post-release content for Spider-Man - titled, the City That Never Sleeps - is unfortunately struggling to recapture the same magic of the main release.
The first entry, The Heist, positioned a new version of Black Cat in a starring role and, despite a strong story and some interesting features, fell short in several areas. That's partly what makes its successor, Turf Wars, such a frustrating piece of content, because it improves on certain aspects of that first piece of DLC while taking several steps backward in the process.
It's very much a mixed bag, but it's not all doom and gloom. There's still plenty of charm to Insomniac's rendition of the Marvel Universe, and though Turf Wars does feel like something of a stop-gap until news comes of a Spider-Man sequel, there's enough in this latest piece of content to satiate even the most fervent of web-heads out there.
Ups...
3. Insomniac's Storytelling Continues To Be Top-Notch
Just as Insomniac's narrative team knocked it out of the park when it came to the main game's story, they've done so again here. Whereas The Heist drew most of its strength from the dynamic shared between Spider-Man and Black Cat, Turf Wars instead draws from the relationship between the wall-crawler and Yuri Watanabe, who took on a supporting role in the main game. Yuri gets plenty to do, and easily emerges as the DLC's most compelling figure by the time the credits start to roll.
But first, a quick retrospective; Turf Wars picks up shortly after The Heist, with Felicia Hardy's fate still unknown, and with New York's Maggia crime families engaged in all-out warfare on the city's streets. At the centre of the carnage is Hammerhead, who is looking to consolidate his grip on NYC's criminal underworld with a whole new arsenal of stolen Sable tech, with Black Cat having scuppered his attempts to blackmail his rivals into submission.
Spider-Man did, of course, venture into dark territory in its main story, but things get even more sinister here. Hammerhead is a truly ruthless adversary, and seeing Spidey take on the mob serves as a nice counterweight to the more fantastical nature of the main game's plot.
Characters do, however, get left behind in the wake of Hammerhead's carnage. MJ is restricted to a few brief phone calls, as is Miles, but the story remains captivating all the same.
2. Hammerhead Is Genuinely Intimidating
When True Believers tend to consider the best Spider-Man villains, Hammerhead is rarely counted among the best. He's a mobster with a thick-plated skull, and Tombstone - arguably - does whatever he does only twice as good, owing to the dynamic shared between that character and Daily Bugle staffer Robbie Robertson.
Ironically, it is Insomniac's commitment to portraying Hammerhead as an old-school career criminal that makes him such a sinister force on camera in Turf Wars. Right from the very get go, the game establishes him as a cop-killer willing to do whatever it takes to outmuscle his rivals. He's thoroughly despicable, and his presence addresses one of the biggest flaws from The Heist - that being the lack of a tangible antagonist.
The addition of Hammerhead also begets a shift in tone. Gone are the sunny skyboxes of the main game - in their place are grey skies and rain, while the sound of gunfire permeates the atmosphere. It's an unexpected shift, but it illustrates Insomniac's excellent comprehension of Spider-Man's world, and their willingness to portray all its aspects - both the good and bad.
1. The New Suits Are Some Of The Best Yet
Marvel's Spider-Man came with dozens of immaculate costumes when it first released in September, all boasting an immaculate level of detail and each lovingly selected from the wall-crawler's almost 60-year-long history. The Heist followed that up with some equally formidable outfits, including the latest incarnation of the Scarlet Spider suit, but Turf Wars goes one step further in bringing three fan-favourite costumes from the web-slinger's wardrobe to the party.
Fans of the nineties Spider-Man cartoon will no doubt recall the silver and black armoured outfit from the show's inter-dimensional Season 5 story-arc, and it's been recreated lovingly in Turf Wars. Players will unlock it almost immediately after completing the first story mission, and after that comes the Iron Spider costume from the Civil War comic, lovingly displayed in all its red and gold glory.
For many, however, the suit that takes the cake will be the Spider-Man from the Marvel Mangaverse. He looks great, but those who want it will have to complete all the DLC's district activities in order to unlock it.
Downs...
4. There Are Still Dialogue Bugs
As opposed to the base Spider-Man title, both pieces of downloadable content haven't been entirely bug-free. The Heist had some issues with dialogue where subtitles would appear seconds before audio, and Turf Wars has the added doozy of dialogue not playing at all.
In several instances, when dialogue was required to advance the story, nothing would play. There was one occasion where I couldn't actually leave a mission area until a phone call played, but it took almost a minute for anything to happen once the character's icon appeared.
It's nothing game-breaking, but it is frustrating when the base title boasted such a great degree of polish.
3. The Episodic Format Just Doesn't Fit
As was noted in our review of The Heist, one can't help but feel as though it was the wrong decision to release these DLCs in an episodic format, as opposed to just one big content dump in December.
Currently, the story for each episode clocks in at around two hours. Additional side-content brings that number up to around three or four, but still, it's not particularly brilliant when each episode sets players back $9.99 respectively. The season pass - which includes all three episodes - brings this figure down to $24.99 (although the PSN's Black Friday sale is currently on), but currently, The City That Never Sleeps just doesn't feel like value for money.
There's also the added frustration of those month-long intervals making the overarching narrative feel just a little bit disjointed. Turf Wars opens with a recap on The Heist, but Black Cat is scarcely mentioned by Peter in the story and her "death" feels glossed-over, with the final confrontation with Hammerhead lacking any of the emotional weight you imagine it would, given Hardy was once very close to Pete.
2. There's An Infuriating New Enemy Type
In The Heist, Insomniac introduced a new type of enemy called the 'minigun thug'. They added a new wrinkle to combat and they return in the following episode, but it never felt like they slotted effortlessly into the selection of enemy types already present in the title.
Unfortunately, the same issue rears its head in Turf Wars. As was previously mentioned, Hammerhead has acquired Sable tech left behind by Sablinova's old security forces, and has taken the liberty of outfitting his thugs with their weaponry. This gives way to a new enemy type, who boast a shield, a jetpack, and leave behind a gadget-nullifying trail of electrical goop in their wake.
In principle, this should be okay. Except in the latter stages of the DLC Hammerhead deploys several of these enemies in select encounters, and it wreaks havoc on Spider-Man's combat. There's no discernible pattern to their charges, and when more than one is present on the battlefield, they make manoeuvring a nigh-Herculean task, as the player is forced to dodge repeatedly until they inevitably fall into the red trail left behind from their attacks and leave themselves susceptible to a new barrage of whatever else is onscreen at that given moment.
Factor in the shield, the dozens of other combatants present and the fact they do immense damage upon connecting with Spidey, and combat encounters begin to feel less and less challenging, and more frustrating and chaotic instead.
1. Gameplay Still Feels Repetitive In Places
Ultimately, Spider-Man still looks and plays superbly. Traversal feels great, combat (when there aren't any of those shield guys) is still brilliant. The main problem with the game, however, currently stems from the litany of side-content present, whether it be the array of street-crimes players can tackle, or the generic hideout-clearing side-missions that replace the Demon and Fisk bases from the base game.
In this regard, The City That Never Sleeps isn't exactly innovative. While it might be asking too much for DLC to improve in such a drastic way, the current selection of side-missions on offer - street crime, Screwball Challenges and Maggia Hideouts - just don't provide enough variety. The hideout-clearing sections in particular feel almost routine at this point, and it's a shame, given the sheer amount of potential Spider-Man illustrated just a few short months ago.
Currently, The City That Never Sleeps isn't the stellar continuation of Spider-Man that fans have been seeking, and though it is certainly serviceable - and worth seeing play out for the story alone - there are clear issues that prevent this chapter in Spider-Man's story from being the perfect epilogue to Insomniac's trailblazing title.