Star Wars Battlefront 2 Beta: 4 Ups & 7 Downs
Not the sequel you're looking for.
Star Wars Battlefront 2's open beta has been wowing and confounding players in equal measure this past weekend, and it's safe to say that the game is shaping up to be much more divisive than most surely expected a few months ago.
With the surprisingly large beta giving fans a decent slice of the game to test out for themselves, it's clear that DICE's latest is neither a cynical carbon copy of their 2015 smash hit nor the revelatory apology for its lacking features many were hoping for.
It seems to be a game rife with underwhelming and frustrating elements, even if its basic, thrilling appeal to Star Wars fans is pretty much undeniable.
Battlefront 2 is going to sell like hotcakes regardless, but this beta has surely left many pretty iffy and on-the-fence about how the final product's going to turn out, especially with barely a month left until it hits stores.
While it's certainly advisable to wait for reviews before loosening your purse strings for any EA game, it's also worth keeping in mind everything we've already learned from the beta...
Downs
7. It's Full Of Bugs
One of the most shocking and disappointing aspects of the beta is the ridiculous abundance of bugs and glitches. There have been countless reports of players turning invisible upon spawning, spawning without loadouts and the game freezing at the end of a match, not to mention literally dozens of other, smaller issues.
Yes, it is a beta after all, but with the game being mere weeks away from release, is it really conceivable that DICE will be able to fix all of these problems in time? Probably not.
It's not exactly a stellar indication of what the final product will end up like, so you're probably best off waiting on reviews and possibly the first major patch before throwing down your hard-earned cash (if the beta hasn't put you off, that is).
6. There's No Campaign Gameplay
Though the beta does include a preview video of Battlefront 2's much-discussed campaign mode, there's sadly no playable sample, as would've been a great way to sell the game to those who were left disappointed by the 2015 game's fairly lacking amount of content.
As it stands, potential customers are still left wondering whether the campaign will be a low-effort rush-job or something more considered, and it seems that they'll be left waiting to find out until reviews drop.
Yes, the beta is already pretty substantial in fairness, but if EA truly wanted to convince people that the game is going to make up for its predecessor's mistakes, a small section of the campaign should've been included.
5. It's Both Too Simple & Needlessly Complex
It might sound contradictory, but on the basis of this beta, Battlefront 2 is shaping up to be a game both disappointingly simplistic and over-complicated all at the same time.
For instance, there's a depressing lack of spawn options, objectives are dull and repetitive, and teamplay can't even begin to match the brilliance of DICE's Battlefield series. It just feels too restrictive and scaled-back.
In other areas the game meanwhile inundates players with an overabundance of convoluted systems, such as Star Cards, classes, items and special abilities, to the point that it seems to be mistaking quantity for complexity and depth. It makes it harder to just jump in and play, especially if you didn't play the first game.
In attempting to create a casual shooter for the masses, EA and DICE have instead sculpted a schizophrenic product that might be too cumbersome for the most base player but also not nuanced enough for more seasoned genre vets.
4. "Return To The Combat Area" Is Still A Problem
In an attempt to control spawn camping and dictate the flow of the game, DICE's shooter titles have all been plagued with the infuriating "return to the combat area" warning screen should you venture into an area where you apparently shouldn't.
Though the idea is that this is less immersion-breaking than just running into an invisible wall, it's really not by much, especially as in this beta there's a good chance you probably saw the warning pop up with a frustrating frequency.
It's par for the course now when it comes to these games, yes, but the fact that the player funnelling is still so transparent and jarring is pretty embarrassing all things considered.
3. Arcade Mode Is...Pretty Boring
The beta also includes a glimpse at Battlefront 2's Arcade mode, a training arena of sorts where players can test out weapons and skills offline against AI enemies before heading online.
From the little that's shown off in the beta, though, this seems like an incredibly basic, surface-level mode, in which even slashing down hordes of enemies as Darth Maul feels pretty boring.
The mode is to be commended for supporting local split-screen play on consoles, but after more than a few minutes of tinkering around, you'll probably get the itch to get back into some massively multiplayer combat against actual human opponents. Not much to see here, sadly.
2. Loot Boxes Just Might Ruin The Game
Fans were overjoyed when EA confirmed that Battlefront 2 wouldn't feature any of the Season Pass nonsense that received so much flak in the first game...until it became abundantly clear that EA is just replacing one revenue stream with another: loot boxes.
Playing matches in the game will net you crates, which contain new weapons, abilities and cosmetic bonuses, and while the full of extent of how the microtransaction system will work is still unclear, players will obviously be able to pay real world money to acquire more of these shiny boxes.
The implication obviously is that players who shell out will get a palpable advantage over those who don't, and regardless of what EA might promise on the matter, balancing that equation in a satisfying way for all parties is extremely difficult.
Simply, unless you absolutely must have the game in your hands day one, maybe wait and see how badly the loot boxes affect the game for those who won't dig any further into their wallets.
1. It Won't Win The Series Many New Fans
Ultimately, a lot of people seemed optimistic that Battlefront 2 would be a huge apology for the disappointing previous game, to the point that it would even win over those who played the 2015 beta and decided not to buy the full title.
Unfortunately, that's not really the case here, as convincing as EA's PR offensive has been in recent months. Though the game does offer some solutions to a lot of the first game's problems, it also comes with a litany of its own issues, and even introduces a few that seemingly weren't present the first time.
Basically, if the first game didn't click for you, it's hard to imagine this one making up for it, so you might just want to stick to the original 2005 Battlefront II, which has just had its servers re-activated on PC.
Disappointing though this beta is in many ways, there are undeniably some areas where it absolutely excels...
Ups
4. It Looks & Sounds Fantastic
Yes, there will be those who rightly complain about the game's chromatic aberration and vignetting, but for the majority of players, Battlefront 2 will be widely appreciated as a gorgeous visual feast.
The original game remains one of the best-looking online shooter titles to date, and though this sequel doesn't represent a huge technical leap by any means, it is at least consistently beautiful and immensely faithful to the look and feel of the Star Wars world.
It also sounds great, from the use of signature Star Wars music to the solid voice acting throughout and, yes, those ever-familiar franchise sound effects.
For all its problems, the game is at least technically impressive, and for many that will be one of the major selling points.
3. Starfighter Assault Is A Huge Improvement
Aerial combat might turn out to be the most improved element of Battlefront 2, introducing Starfighter Assault mode, which proves to be effortlessly superior to the previous game's rather underwhelming and basic Fighter Squadron equivalent.
After Fighter Squadron's lack of epic space battles was widely criticised, Starfighter Assault rectifies that right out of the gate, and even the small slice of gameplay available in the beta feels far more enjoyable and exciting than anything in the previous game's version.
Dogfights are more urgent and chaotic, and the mode simply seems that much more like you're taking part in something meaningful within the Star Wars universe.
The controls could be tighter, but don't be surprised if you find yourself glued to this mode as much as the more conventional ones. Speaking of which...
2. Galactic Assault Is (Mostly) Fun Mayhem
Galactic Assault is Battlefront 2's meat-and-potatoes mode, a big-scale, 40-player, objective-driven sandbox of mayhem, and the beta's single map (Naboo's city of Theed) re-affirms that, even with its issues, this mode is a ton of fun.
It's chaotic, it's beautiful, and it does result in some undeniable wish fulfilment, even if you might hope that the game didn't spawn players so far away from the action, as gorgeous as the expansive environments are.
While it remains to be seen whether or not the game's nine other Galactic Assault maps will prevent the mode from feeling too repetitive like its predecessor, this is at least the mode that's sure to make casual shooter fans the most happy. Just run in the vague direction of the objective, shoot, die and repeat (or something like that).
1. The Massively Improved Reward System
And finally, Battlefront 2 does a fantastic job of rectifying the first game's rather irritating reward system, whereby hero and vehicular pickups were just randomly found scattered around the map, granted more by luck than ability.
Thankfully BF2 changes this completely, as players will rack up points over the course of a round which can then be used to purchase heroes and vehicles to wreak havoc on the opposite team.
You can certainly argue that this means that the best players will simply get more tools to tear things up, but it's certainly more rewarding to gain control of Darth Maul because you've been ably playing the objective or racked up a huge killstreak, than because it just fell into your lap.
For everything Battlefront 2 seems to be doing wrong, at least EA and DICE have made a few smart choices. Now comes the waiting for the final consensus.
What did you think of the Star Wars Battlefront 2 beta? Shout it out in the comments!