Super Smash Bros. Ultimate Review: 5 Ups & 3 Downs
Both ultimate and unfortunate.
If you own a Nintendo Switch or have a close friend who does, there's a strong chance you've spent a good amount of the last few days playing the hugely anticipated Super Smash Bros. Ultimate.
Effectively the last major AAA release of 2018, Ultimate is a hot-ticket holiday item and a major boost for the Switch, which on the whole has had a disappointingly quiet 2018.
The brawler's current 93 Metascore makes it the fourth best-reviewed video game of 2018 to date, and while it absolutely is a game well worth owning, it's also not without its head-scratching issues.
Granted, the majority of the mainstream reviews went live before the new Smash could be tested in a live environment, but the rough online functionality is just one puzzling design misstep in a game which, given its pedigree, probably should've tried a little harder in some key areas.
These bizarre and distinctly Nintendo decisions aside, Super Smash Bros. Ultimate soars on the strength of its epic roster and top-tier beat 'em up gameplay...
Downs...
3. Online Multiplayer Is A Mess
Granted, stable online multiplayer has never really been Nintendo's strong suit, yet despite launching their online subscription service recently, they've offered little to suggest they're going to put those fees to work crafting a stable online ecosystem.
Simply put, the first few days of Smash Ultimate online have been a mess. The most frustrating thing is the total lack of consistency: sometimes games will be buttery-smooth, more often there will be debilitating lag, and often you may well end up with the infuriating "communication error" preventing you from even starting a match.
It's well-documented that the Switch's WiFi functionality is mediocre at best, but even tested with an Ethernet adaptor on a 100Mbps connection, the results are still disappointingly spotty.
You can't even really pawn the blame off on the game's P2P connectivity, because other Switch titles have managed this fine since day one (Splatoon 2 in particular).
That's not to forget the disappointingly piecemeal matchmaking options, which really shouldn't be a problem for any game releasing in 2018.
Simply, given how brilliantly crafted the core gameplay is, it's frustrating that the online experience alternates violently between great fun and rage-inducing trash.
2. Unlocking Characters Is A Pointless Chore
This criticism is sure to be divisive among fans, but it's absolutely baffling that in a game designed primarily with local multiplayer mayhem in mind, players only start with eight of the 74 players unlocked, requiring them to grind their way to collecting a full set.
You can of course do this the hard way by slogging through World of Light mode or playing Classic mode ad nauseum.
Many players, however, have resorted to using an "exploit" of sorts, of playing a round of Smash, immediately killing themselves, battling the Challenger who shows up, defeating said opponent to unlock them, resetting the game to negate the 10-minute unlock cooldown and then repeating the process.
This can get you roughly two-thirds of the fighters in a few short hours, though after this point the unlocks start to become more scarce as the player is required to have travelled a certain distance before a new Challenger will emerge.
Also, some of the later unlockable fighters can prove extremely difficult to defeat. There's nothing quite like battling Ganandorf down to his final throes, only for him to deliver a one-hit kill out of nowhere.
The blow clearly would've been softened if perhaps 15-20 fighters were unlocked from the start, but whatever way you go about it, getting the full 74 is more of a job to get done than it is enjoyable.
In the very least, could there not have been a delineated practice mode where all the fighters were already unlocked for the sake of fast, easy local multiplayer?
1. World Of Light Is A Repetitive Slog
This also will prove a contentious opinion among fans, but Smash Ultimate's campaign mode, World of Light, is an intensely mixed bag of ambitious and undeveloped ideas.
You start the story mode as Kirby, the sole survivor of an attack from the evil monster Galeem, which has turned the other 73 fighters into soulless shells of their former selves.
It's up to Kirby to battle these husks in order to return them to life - though more often you'll fight one of the thousand-plus Spirit augmentations - in turn unlocking the characters if you haven't already.
It's certainly fun at first, and the map is much larger than it initially appears, but after a while the central loop becomes so transparent and unfixed that it ends up feeling quite listless and boring.
Clocking in at anywhere from 15 to a reported 40 hours depending on your level of perfectionism, the cinematic quality promised by the opening cut-scene basically isn't there, and even with some occasional gimmicky fights thrown in for good measure, the core of this mode is fundamentally rote.
There are systems layered on top of the usual Smash gameplay - such as using Spirits to raise your power level and a skill tree - but it's ultimately fairly simplistic and too often mistakes volume for depth.
World of Light is probably best enjoyed as something you play for 30 minutes a day when you're bored or on the commute to work, because having played it in numerous hours-long stretches, the central loop just isn't addictive enough to excuse the repetition.
Unless you're especially in love with grinding for loot, it otherwise may not hold your attention for long.
So, Super Smash Bros. Ultimate is pretty damn far from perfect, but when it's great, it's really great. Here's everything it nails...
Ups...
5. The Core Gameplay Is As Brilliant As Ever
If it sounds like we're dumping on the game, fear not, because when boiled down to its most fundamental elements, Smash Ultimate's gameplay is absolutely spectacular, and arguably the most slickly enjoyable it has ever been.
Appearing to run noticeably faster than the last few Smash games, there's also a greater fluidity to the combat: fighting doesn't feel quite as stiff, making it easier to switch-up your approach mid-battle.
The sheer amount of combat options available to you is mind-boggling - the suite of pick-ups is pretty much endlessly entertaining - ensuring that regardless of whether you're playing solo or with pals, this is one of 2018's most ludicrously addictive games.
It's also a pleasure to report that the game runs incredibly well in both handheld and docked mode, and though it's a little tougher to keep track of all the fighters on a smaller screen, it does little to dilute the heft of that signature Smash gameplay.
4. The Huge Variety & Amount Of Content
Even if you never touch the online multiplayer or World of Light, there is a mind-boggling amount of content here, and Nintendo absolutely deserves a hand for going above and beyond what most fans could've expected for the next entry into the series.
In addition to the colossal 74-fighter roster including every single fighter from every single Smash game, there are more than 100 levels to salivate over, not to mention more fighting presets than ever, the much-loved tournament modes and a wonderful new Survivor Series-esque team-based mode called Squad Strike.
As a package, Smash Ultimate presents literally hundreds of hours of possible gameplay - especially if World of Light sinks its hooks in you - and from a value-for-money perspective, there are few better gaming purchases you could make right now.
3. Local Multiplayer Is AWESOME
The core of the Smash series has always been the local multiplayer, because there are few gaming experiences more fun than huddling around a Nintendo console with a group of pals and duking it out with the company's finest (and some special guests).
Incredibly, Smash Ultimate supports up to eight players on a single Switch, and though most players are likely to get more mileage out of four-player mayhem, the result either way is deliriously brilliant chaos.
The huge number of presets, and also the ability to save those presets, is a welcome addition, ensuring you can quickly dive into whatever you and your friends desire.
It's the perfect setup for a party where the drinks are flowing and people can drop-in and drop-out as they please, delivering the same sturdy brilliance it always has. For this reason it's a bit easier to tolerate the messy online multiplayer, even if it's (obviously) entirely dependent on you having frequent access to a group of friends to play with.
2. The Vibrant, Colourful Graphics
Smash Ultimate sure does look nice, that's for sure, and while the Switch is obviously a bit of a dinosaur in the technical department, you'd barely know it from the slick gorgeousness of this game.
Maintaining a mostly smooth frame-rate during even chaotic combat - and as mentioned, it's a breeze in both handheld and docked modes - while serving up eye-popping animations and beautiful renditions of your favourite characters, this is a real pleasure to the eyes.
Though the game has been subject to some technical criticism due to Ultimate's increased input lag - which appears to be a bizarre, intentional choice on Nintendo's part - few are likely to take issue with how sleek the fighters and environments look, and how gracefully even the most insane manoeuvre is rendered.
1. It Truly Is The Ultimate Smash Bros. Game (So Far)
It's once again worth reiterating that Smash Ultimate is extremely far from a perfect game, and in fact, there are plenty of things about it that don't register as great or even particularly good.
But at the same time, where it matters the most, the game feels like a summation of everything the series has achieved up to this point, largely thanks to its gigantic roster and dizzying amount of content.
The core gameplay has never felt quite so satisfying, and while the next Smash can certainly improve the online multiplayer and campaign offerings, the basic thrill of beating the snot out of the Wii Fit Trainer really speaks for itself. And the whole "playing with friends thing", too, of course.
Should you buy it?
Absolutely, as long as you temper your expectations about the game doing much to improve the franchise's long-standing weaknesses.