The Best GTA Game Rockstar Will Never Make
Forget Vice City - the 'long 1960s' is the PERFECT setting for the next Grand Theft Auto.
It's only a matter of time until Rockstar lift the lid on their next project, and so far, all signs point towards it being another entry in the ludicrously successful Grand Theft Auto franchise.
The prevailing rumour so far is that the game - developed under the working title 'Project Americas' - will be set across multiple eras and pull heavy inspiration from shows like Narcos and Scarface, giving players the opportunity to take control of a drug runner as they perform missions between Latin America and the United States, rising through the ranks as they go.
And it all sounds very exciting. If those rumours are to be believed, it looks as though Rockstar are taking everything they learned working on both GTA V and their epic old west tale, Red Dead Redemption 2. There's meant to be a heavy focus on realism and immersion, as well as a number of cities to explore in what will supposedly be Rockstar's most ambitious open world to date.
By all accounts, if those rumours are true, then it's everything the series' fans are after - right on down to the purported setting of eighties America, which was famously utilised in the fan-favourite GTA: Vice City. Even so, there is one setting that I feel Rockstar would benefit from immensely if they were to ever utilise it in one of their own titles, and one that would benefit GTA in particular - that of the 'long' 1960s, or more specifically, the golden age of America's post-war boom.
In the years following World War II, the United States embarked on a rapid and radical transformation. The economy was booming, living standards increased, but intense disquiet bubbled beneath the surface, with social inequality and the Cold War coming to define the era in a great many ways. TL;DR, it was far from the serene, nostalgic slice of Americana folks liable to call the cops on their neighbour's barbecue love to harken back to.
Of course, the 'long' 1960s - defined by historian Phillip Jenkins in 'Decade of Nightmares' as beginning midway through the 1950s before crashing to a halt in 1972 - is a period that's almost synonymous with the crime genre. Francis Ford Coppola's first two Godfather films employed the setting to great effect at the beginning of the seventies - as have certain works by director Martin Scorsese - while Donald Westlake's Parker novels went to great lengths to apply a noir filter to the pastel pinks and yellows of the era. (More on both of those later.)
In essence, the contrast between the outfacing image of the US pre-1962 - one of prosperity and tranquility - and the darker, historical reality of the time, has provided ample fodder for creatives for decades.
It's a setting ripe for exploration, and one tailor-made for Rockstar's flagship franchise. Here's why.
[Article continues on next page...]
4. Red Dead And L.A. Noire - Why Rockstar's Natural Home Is The Past
Rockstar are unique in the video game industry. They don't operate like other studios or publishers and they do games differently - exemplified best by their most recent effort, Red Dead Redemption 2.
Red Dead 2 is one of the most ambitious video games ever made, and one that elected to tell its narrative in a uniquely character-driven way. Cutscenes are left to detail key narrative moments, but a lot of the relationships the player develops as Arthur Morgan over the course of the game occur in real time, mingling in the camp, or doing certain missions. Factor in the level of immersion on offer mechanically, with players being forced to look after themselves, their weapons and their camp, and it's safe to say there isn't an experience quite like it.
As a western epic, Red Dead 2 also grapples with a lot of historical themes. It's not the first by any means, and one could even argue that the narrative thrust of both that title and the first Red Dead Redemption was lifted straight from works like The Wild Bunch and Unforgiven - that being the end of the Old West - but it's still immaculately handled, and typifies why the studio seem to work best when submerged in the past.
If any word were to describe Red Dead 2, it would be 'authentic', and the same goes for the studio/publisher's other most recent effort set in the past - L.A. Noire.
Developed by the now sadly defunct Team Bondi, L.A. Noire was set in 1947 and took heavy inspiration from film noir, putting players in the shoes of golden boy Cole Phelps as he peeled back the lid on prosperous post-War America, investigating grisly crime after grisly crime as a part of the LAPD. Ironically, it would also transpire that Cole himself harboured his own dark secrets; a reflection, perhaps, of Tinsel Town after World War II.
Red Dead and L.A. Noire stand out to me as the two most compelling offerings from Rockstar over the last decade, and I think it comes down to both series' settings. Both those titles ultimately seem more confident in their approach, grappling with historical themes and capturing the respective zeitgeists of the Old West and 1940s Los Angeles, than GTA does with its scattergun approach to satire in the here and now. Granted that's part of the series' charm, but fans are ready for a more mature Grand Theft Auto, one that pools inspiration from Rockstar's more considered works.
[Article continues on next page...]
3. Post-War America - The Perfect Storm
But why the 1950s and '60s? What exactly about that era would lend itself to a Rockstar title? Well for starters there's the clash of imagery. There's a general misconception that the US post-WWII and pre-JFK's assassination was a land of diners, drive-ins and youthful innocence, a perception no doubt exacerbated by the immense economic growth the country underwent following the war.
While it's true that a great many Americans became more prosperous, the reality is far more complex. The Red Scare, spurred on by the US' burgeoning conflict with the other super-power of the time, the U.S.S.R., engendered a culture of political persecution and wild anti-communist hysteria. Black servicemen returned home from overseas only to be met with de facto and de jure segregation and a resurgent Ku Klux Klan, and the women's liberation movement was still a decade away from becoming a genuine force.
And therein lies the central appeal of America's long 1960s for storytellers. The outward facing impression of the era is one so at odds with historical reality that it enables creatives opportunities to confront it again and again. Stories like The Graduate and later Blue Velvet both tackle the tragedy and then horror that the suburbs ostensibly masked, while Coppola's Godfather helped enshrine the notion that such unfettered growth was entwined with criminality.
This in mind, it wouldn't be difficult to envision a version of GTA grappling with both of these themes, along with the other political crises of the time. Hangar 13's Mafia III offers the perfect blueprint in this regard, with the game depicting the story of one Lincoln Clay, a black Vietnam veteran who finds himself out for revenge in 1968 - one of the most tumultuous years in modern US history - all the while dealing with systemic racism in the deep south. Mafia's attention to detail is peerless in that regard, and something Rockstar could learn from with their future efforts regardless of their setting.
[Article continues on next page...]
2. The Retro Aesthetic - Capturing A Sense Of Time And Place
Okay, so, after all that talk about the 1950s and '60s projecting a fake image that masked a darker reality, it's time to admit something - the retro aesthetic is incredibly charming. If it wasn't, then Bethesda's Fallout series wouldn't be nearly as charismatic as it is.
This is where I'm going to take a bit of a tangent, and explain where all of this *gestures vaguely at the preceding pages* came about. One of my favourite comic book creators is the late Darwyn Cooke, an extremely talented writer/artist who first carved out a reputation working on the DC animated shows of the late nineties, and one who sadly passed away in 2016.
After working on on shows like Batman the Animated Series and Batman Beyond, Cooke made the transition into comics and his style distinguished him immediately. It was cartoony and vibrant, and the art-deco stylings of BTAS - pioneered in the 1940s by the Fleischer Superman cartoons - translated perfectly to the page. It wasn't long before Cooke crafted what many would consider to be his magnum opus, The New Frontier, a story that applied the real history of the 1950s and '60s to the DC universe during the Golden and Silver ages of comics, which concluded, incidentally, around about the same time historians generally believe the 'long' 1960s did.
Cooke's love for the visuals of that era were more than apparent in that story, but obviously I'm not suggesting that the next GTA should take inspiration from a superhero comic. No, the comic I AM suggesting it take inspiration from is another of Cooke's works, those being his adaptations of Donald Westlake's Parker novels, which released between 2009 and 2013.
For those not familiar with Westlake (who wrote the books under the pseudonym of Richard Stark), the author created the character of Parker - a master thief - in 1962, with his debut story being The Hunter. A number of follow-up books came after, and so too did a number of unofficial movie adaptations. Cooke's graphic-novelisations however stand head and shoulders above all the others, mainly because they're so beautiful to look at and adhered to the original setting of the novels, with the events of The Hunter taking place in '62.
It isn't difficult to see how Rockstar could take advantage of a Parker-esque story, or especially the aesthetic of the comics. Classic sports cars and retro fashion would be great to mess around with in a fully fledged title, as would period-accurate weaponry and architecture. Plus, given we've seen Rockstar take immersion to new heights in Red Dead, there should be no worries that they'd be able to do the same with the fifties and sixties, both narratively speaking and gameplay-wise.
[Article continues on next page...]
1. Is Nostalgia For Vice City Driving The Next GTA?
This is where things start to get a little bit messy. You see, while I'm still very much looking forward to whatever Rockstar have planned next, no matter the setting, if the rumours are true that we're going back to Vice City in and around the 1970s/80s, I am a little concerned that it'll be driven primarily by nostalgia.
The nostalgia pendulum swings every two or three decades, and so you'll have probably noticed that the eighties and nineties are very in vogue currently - more so the latter than ever before. There's also a general level of nostalgia for games released on the sixth generation of consoles as of late, with remasters and remakes growing in frequency with every year.
In regards to GTA specifically, it seems as though every year fans beg Rockstar to conjure something to do with Vice City, the series' stand-in for Miami that captivated imaginations in 2002. With that in mind, rumours that the next game will head back to Vice City shouldn't be all that surprising, especially when you consider how Rockstar already returned to Liberty City and Los Santos in GTA IV and V in 2008 and 2013 respectively.
The issue here isn't so much that I don't think Rockstar have genuine cause to revisit Vice City, or even that they won't be able to do anything interesting with it - in fact it's quite the opposite. It's more just that it feels like the most predictable move they could make right now, taking into account current nostalgic trends and the yearly demands from fans to head back to the eighties and rekindle memories of Tommy Vercetti, Lance Vance, and the old Pegassi Infernus.
And look, I get it. I really do! Watching Don Johnson in re-runs of Miami Vice sets off that urge to jump back into Vice City all over again, and I have no doubt that Rockstar could make another great GTA game set in that era. I just think it's time for something new, in the vein of L.A. Noire or Red Dead, that delves into a relatively untapped era of US history - at least when it comes to video games.
--
What setting do you want to see the next Grand Theft Auto use? Let us know in the comments below!