The Division 2 Review: 10 Ups & 4 Downs

A (mostly) terrific sequel.

By Jack Pooley /

Ubisoft

Ubisoft's The Division 2 finally hit storefronts this past weekend, and the early consensus from critics and players alike appears to be that it's a damn fun time...if you're a fan of the looter shooter genre, that is.

Advertisement

Indeed, the game makes no apologies for its loot-obsessed gameplay loop, but thankfully it's contained within a richly absorbing open-world, boasting a surprisingly sturdy campaign and fantastically slick drop-in, drop-out multiplayer mayhem.

It's certainly too early to declare The Division 2 the king of the looter shooter, but having spent almost 30 hours with the game since launch, it's clear that this is one of the best and most meticulously crafted games of its kind. Sorry, Anthem.

Advertisement

At a time where there are more games than ever vying for your hard-earned cash, Ubisoft and Massive Entertainment's latest offering makes a compelling argument, as it keeps soulless grinding to a minimum and focuses on atmosphere, world-building and squad-based fun.

If only all AAA Games-as-a-Service titles were both this packed with content and this mechanically satisfying. But first, here's what the game doesn't get right...

Advertisement

Downs...

4. The Plot & Characters Are Totally Forgettable

Ubisoft

Like almost every "live service" game ever made, The Division 2's story and characters are almost completely unremarkable.

Advertisement

Thankfully Massive smartly hasn't placed much emphasis at all on a conventional narrative story, preferring to immerse the player through the world and "emergent gameplay", but even so, the plotting and characterisation here are hilariously piecemeal for the most part.

Even after hitting level 30 and completing the main story, I found myself hard pressed to recall a single character's name, to say nothing of a plot that never does anything interesting outside of the typical post-apocalyptic sci-fi wheelhouse.

Advertisement

It's lucky that the core gameplay is so strong and the sheer atmosphere is so thick, then, because as low-effort as the narrative is throughout The Division 2, it's actually not that bothersome.

Perhaps had the game forced players to sit through relentless cut-scenes after each mission, it might be somewhat more difficult to forgive (again, looking at you, Anthem).

Advertisement

3. There's No Matchmaking For Side Missions

Ubisoft

The Division 2 makes so many smart design decisions, particularly in relation to its snappy co-op multiplayer, that it's utterly baffling that there's no ability to matchmake for side missions.

Advertisement

For regular story missions and other activities such as bounties and open-world exploration, there are distinct matchmaking options, but for the game's side missions, you have to simply start the mission, put out a call for backup and just hope for the best.

It's frustrating because the game's side missions are surprisingly in-depth, and having to rely on a random maybe answering your call mid-mission really isn't good enough.

Advertisement

Sure, you can jump into an exploration lobby and suggest to your teammates that you tackle some side missions, but that's adding extra steps and assumptions that players really shouldn't need to.

Why Massive made such a glaring omission is anyone's guess, especially as the side missions are surprisingly well-crafted and can net players massive amounts of XP.

Advertisement

2. Too. Many. Bugs.

Ubisoft

As slickly enjoyable as The Division 2 mostly is, it does also feel a tad rough around the edges, as is pretty much de rigeur for multiplayer-focused AAA titles.

Advertisement

Players are likely to encounter a number of recurrent bugs throughout their play sessions, from bounties failing to spawn, collectibles not appearing and perhaps most egregiously, skills such as turrets and drones dismantling on their own out of nowhere.

The latter is especially frustrating as it can fatally impact the core experience, especially if you're playing solo.

Advertisement

It seems unlikely that many of these glitches will stick around for long, but it still indicates a slightly un-polished launch experience.

If you're particularly sensitive to this sort of thing, you might want to wait a few weeks until Massive has ironed out the big nagging issues.

Advertisement

1. The UI Is Frustratingly Messy

Ubisoft

In fairness, the game's user interface isn't bad: it's certainly functional enough in terms of getting to where you need to go fast, but like so many games in the genre, it also feels like it could have a neater and more consistent design.

Advertisement

The main issue is that there are so many aspects of The Division 2's various gameplay systems that the game doesn't really bother explaining.

The new PVP mode Conflict, for example, is barely mentioned in-game, and so you can easily miss the fact that it's tucked away in the left-hand side of the main map menu. This might explain why, in my experience, finding 8 players for a game of Conflict has proven a bit tricky.

Advertisement

Even to players well-acquainted with the original, this game can be a daunting experience with the sheer wealth of content and mechanics it throws at you, and a more unified UI would help to tie everything together in a more coherent fashion.

Again, this isn't a deal breaker and you do get used to it after some time, but a blockbuster AAA game such as this really should be able to do better when it comes to intuitive menu design.

Advertisement

These gripes aside, The Division 2 is however a mostly great game, and here's every reason why...

Ups...

10. The Satisfying, Varied 25-Hour Campaign

Ubisoft

The game's core campaign is lengthy and absurdly entertaining for the most part, and Massive deserves credit for minimising both the XP grind and general sense of repetition.

Advertisement

For though the game's campaign missions are level-gated to an extent - you need to be within two levels of the requirement - it generally never takes more than an hour of playing through side content to get to the next main mission.

This is ultimately a neat, unobtrusive way to encourage players to tackle peripheral content without turning it into an hours-long slog, and the result is a 25-ish-hour main campaign that's diverse and dynamic even though the story is, as mentioned, pretty much worthless.

Advertisement

It helps that much of the storytelling is told through the gorgeously-rendered world, with the campaign hurling players into a number of recognisable Washington monuments.

A late-game mission set inside a bunker, for instance, is surely among the most visually elaborate and downright artful missions from any looter shooter game ever made, and enhances the atmosphere so much that you likely won't much care about the nothing narrative.

Advertisement

Most of the missions do generally come down to similar steps that are ultimately resolved in epic shootouts, but they're generally more varied and involved than in the first game, making that "mission complete" screen feel so damn satisfying.

9. Washington D.C. Is An INCREDIBLE Open World

Ubisoft

The first game's New York City setting was always going to be tough to top, but Massive just might've done it with its depiction of a desolate Washington, D.C. reclaimed by nature.

Advertisement

Manoeuvring around this beautifully-crafted world is an absolute joy, and so meticulously is D.C. recreated here that you may well find yourself avoiding the fast travel option at all costs.

While many similar games tend to boast lush exterior environments only for the interior "dungeons" to feel low-detail and samey, that's thankfully not the case here. Many of D.C.'s marquee attractions are slavishly recreated, perhaps most mesmerisingly the Air and Space Museum.

Advertisement

Whether inside or out, though, The Division 2's vision of Washington is one that's easy to get lost in, and only enhances the ridiculously addictive, compelling nature of the core gameplay loop.

8. The Intense, Addictive Gunplay

Ubisoft

Easily the strongest aspect of the first game was the gunplay, even though many (rightly) complained that enemies were too bullet-spongey for their own good.

Advertisement

Thankfully Massive has listened to this criticism and given enemy encounters a significant re-design.

For starters, the sponginess is massively tone down, with elite enemies instead coming to battle with armour which needs to be broken, after which they can be easily felled.

Advertisement

Even the game's most ferocious enemies are a good deal less of a chore to battle than the late-stage bosses of the first game, but thanks to mob A.I. that's both more aggressive and more intelligent, the game still poses a solid challenge even in squad play.

The moment-to-moment shooting feels weighty and impactful in a way so few games of this type can master, and that, above all else, is really why people will be able to lose dozens if not hundreds of hours in what The Division 2 has to offer.

Advertisement

7. Multiplayer Is Ludicrously Entertaining

Ubisoft

The Division 2 is best played with a team of three friends, no question, but whether you're with pals or three randoms, the core multiplayer experience is a ridiculous amount of fun.

Advertisement

Teaming up to sink thousands of bullets into mighty foes, especially later in the game, is a fantastic shared experience, especially if your comrades have dared to don microphones for the occasion.

But simply exploring this vast, teeming world with others is also a real joy, and even after around 30 hours sunk into the game over just a few days, the allure hasn't even begun to wear off.

Advertisement

With the endgame content set to expand the challenge and also the scale of the battles - with 8-man Raids due to arrive later in the year - it's safe to say that the best of the multiplayer experience may be yet to come.

6. Solo Play Is Also Great Fun

Ubisoft

Though there's no denying that the game was built for four-player squads, those who prefer to go it alone shouldn't be deterred either.

Advertisement

To be clear, The Division 2 is a much tougher experience solo, especially if you encounter the aforementioned skill bug, but thanks to the crunchy gunplay and generous array of combat options open to the player, it's still a ton of fun.

It's tough to imagine many bothering with the game if they're strictly in the market for a single-player campaign - especially as the forgettable narrative might prove more of an issue without the boost of the multiplayer experience - but for those who do, there's still plenty here to enjoy.

Advertisement

5. The Stunning Graphics

Ubisoft

Make no mistake, The Division 2 is one hell of a handsome game.

Advertisement

Played in 4K HDR on PC, this is quite probably the most visually impressive AAA looter shooter ever made. Volumetric lighting is absolutely stunning throughout, and even with a few-dozen hours logged, the "wow" factor has yet to wear off.

It helps immensely that the game's art direction is masterful, complimenting best-in-class world design to make traversing Washington an absolutely intoxicating experience.

Advertisement

Walking through the empty D.C. streets the morning after a rain storm and observing how absurdly photo-realistic the damp pavement looks is a simple pleasure, perhaps, but one that many players won't soon forget.

In terms of heightening the immersion, the game's first-rate visuals do a remarkable job.

Advertisement

4. Side Content Is Surprisingly Meaningful

Ubisoft

Side content is where so many games of this type fall down, relying on excess repetition and basically making it clear that the developer couldn't be bothered to populate the world with things actually worth playing.

Advertisement

Thankfully, that isn't the case at all here.

There is so much to do in this world, from the XP-rich side missions, to growing settlements, taking on assassination bounties, wrestling control points away from enemy factions, "random" events you'll stumble across out in the wild and hoovering up collectables.

Advertisement

The result is a rare game of this kind where getting to the level cap of 30 isn't remotely boring or frustrating. XP rewards are extremely generous, and as mentioned, main mission gating doesn't force players into hours and hours of repeating the same old missions.

In addition to all this, there's also the Dark Zone PvE/PvP multiplayer, which presents a unique challenge to players but can also reward them with epic, rare loot. And furthermore, there's Conflict PVP, which represents a more conventional, 8-player shoot 'em up experience.

Advertisement

It's tough to imagine anyone complaining that the game doesn't give you enough to do, and surprisingly, precious little of it feels like busy-work.

Given that this is a Ubisoft game, and they've got a history of forcing chore-like collect-a-thon tasks on players, The Division 2's peripheral material is fun and engaging.

Advertisement

3. The Terrific Sound & Music

Ubisoft

If you've got a decent surround sound system or a nice pair of headphones, The Division 2 is an absolute aural joy.

Advertisement

First and foremost, gunfire sounds are splashy, impactful and dynamic at all times, with weapons sounding markedly different depending on the acoustic environment in which they're fired, and there's a decent amount of diversity between the various gun sounds also.

Perhaps the real star of the show, however, is Ola Strandh's pulsing musical score, which does a fantastic job amping up the tension during main story missions.

Advertisement

And even with the game's length, it's impressive that the more familiar incidental music doesn't begin to feel tiresome or repetitive.

2. Endgame Content Is Encouraging (So Far)

Ubisoft

We'll keep specifics to a minimum here, but having spent a few hours with The Division 2's endgame content, it seems like Massive has endeavoured to learn lessons from the first game's much-complained about post-game.

Advertisement

While the original was massively lacking in post-story content on launch day, this sequel touts a significant overhaul of the game world once you've beaten the level 30 mission, offering a huge degree of challenge as players inevitably pursue shinier and shinier loot.

It's of course early days in the game's life at the moment, so it's a loop which could become tiresome.

Advertisement

But with three free story DLCs being released later this year - including one set inside the Pentagon - not to mention 8-player Raids, it feels like The Division 2's going to have a far less-troubled post-game life than its predecessor.

1. It's A Solid Improvement Over The Original

Ubisoft

In pretty much ever fibre of its being, The Division 2 is a considerable - if not quite meteoric - improvement over its already solid, if flawed, predecessor.

Advertisement

Massive has clearly listened to player complaints about spongey enemies and a lacklustre out-of-the-box endgame, while also streamlining the main campaign with less filler and placing a greater emphasis on engaging side content.

Will the game do much to change the minds of those who weren't too enamoured with the original?

Advertisement

Absolutely not, but if you enjoyed the first game even in spite of its flaws, a far richer and more rewarding experience awaits you with this meticulously engineered sequel.

It's not without its own issues, of course, but given how cynically so many of us are conditioned to view AAA loot-based games - and usually with good reason - this is a rare one that's clearly been crafted with real love and care.

Advertisement