Until Dawn 2: 10 Improvements For The Perfect Sequel

It's just a matter of time.

By Jackson Osterhout /

Until Dawn largely flew under the radar back when it was released in 2015, due in part to the massive release of Metal Gear Solid V less than a week later. The concept was simple:

Advertisement

Ever hated the stupid decisions characters make in horror movies? Well, now you, the player, are in full control of them. Good luck!

Developers Supermassive Games are currently developing The Inpatient, which is set to be a direct prequel to the events of Until Dawn, and will provide PSVR support. Eventually, however, Until Dawn will become a full-blown franchise. With that brings a new formula of providing a new set of teens dropped into a new horror movie scenario.

To that end, there is a lot that should be carried over when designing the sequel. A phenomenal cast (including Hayden Panettiere, Peter Stormare, Rami Malek, and Brett Dalton), superb writing, terrifying jump scares, bone-grindingly suspenseful gameplay and truly difficult choices are just a handful of elements fans would want to continue.

With every strength that Until Dawn had, however, there were a number of shortcomings, which really reflects in its only above-average reviews. It was these things that prevented it from being a truly excellent game. Improving upon these weaknesses could make Until Dawn 2 into the quintessential horror experience that it has the potential to be.

Also, beware of some upcoming spoilers for Until Dawn.

10. Improve The Camera

Unlike many other games with camera issues, Until Dawn does not give the player any control over the camera, with the angle instead being determined by where the player is in a room.

Advertisement

There is a reason behind this: Until Dawn is attempting a more cinematic feel in order to emulate classic horror movies. Additionally, the camera angles obscure the environments during parts of the game, so that certain jump scares have a greater effect.

The downside to this is that navigation can be downright clunky. Trying to navigate through narrow passageways or around obstacles (especially in pitch black environments) quickly becomes a chore, especially as so much vital information of the game depended on the player's ability to track down clues.

The developers have the right idea by keeping the camera stationary. But drastic improvements must be made for the sequel. For example, make the camera angles more contextual to the environment, and include more whenever a player needs to navigate a tight space or pick up an object.

Wandering around in the dark in a horror movie should be terrifying, not frustrating.

9. Add Difficulty Settings

Until Dawn is too easy. At least when it comes to quick time events.

Advertisement

It's almost a guarantee that every time a character in a playthrough died, it was either to due to poor decision making, or failing a "Don't Move!" segment (more on those later). While it was technically possible for characters to die for failing QTEs, it almost never happened.

Of course, there are players that prefer this, preferring to watch the story to play out. On the flip side, there are also players that want a bigger challenge, constantly kept on their toes through challenging QTEs.

There is a solution here, and luckily there is already a game that has used it. Heavy Rain, another game that popularly used QTE based gameplay, had multiple difficulty settings. The hardest setting included things such as more QTEs in a given time period, more complex button presses, and a shorter time window. Until Dawn 2 could adapt that, and add in smaller boxes for the "Don't Move!" segments, forcing players to be more skilled and finessed.

One of Until Dawn's greatest strengths was its replayability. At approximately 10 hours long, players were encouraged to replay in order to get every ending and trophy (including the ever-popular "Kill Everyone" option).

Including difficulty levels for the sequel would improve the incentive to pick the game back up again and again.

8. Reconfigure Totems

The totems in Until Dawn are an intriguing addition. Essentially, the items are scattered throughout each of the chapters, separated into five different categories (death, danger, guidance, fortune, and loss). Each totem provided a brief vision of a possible future event. There's no feeling quite like seeing a brief scene of the brutal murder of one of the characters, but having zero context to how it could happen.

Advertisement

The main problem with these comes from the "guidance" totems. While the other ones simply provide a POSSIBLE scene that may or may not come true, the guidance totems effectively break the choice-making mechanic, directly telling the player which outcome is best.

Once a player figures this out, it's less about making a logical decision, and more about scouring every inch of a level just for a chance to find another guidance totem.

In essence, totems are an interesting addition (although unless a sequel sticks with Native American folklore, it would have to be changed to something more related to the plot). Removing the guidance totems for Until Dawn 2 would put more pressure on the player to really think through their decisions, without the hand holding involved.

Also, make sure that the totems don't spoil who the real monster is before it gets revealed to the player. That's also important.

7. Upgrade The "Don't Move!" Mechanic

The "Don't Move!" mechanic is one of Until Dawn's biggest draws. In a game full of moments that make players jump out of their seats, and pulse-pounding action often requiring a player to move a controller around, the "Don't Move!" mechanic forces players to remain completely still, keeping the controller's light bar inside a very narrow box, or suffer the consequences.

Advertisement

For players that actually do this, it was excellent at raising tension. Trying to keep completely still while blood is pumping in your ears and adrenaline is racing through you is no easy task.

The problem that arises is quite obvious. Players would just set the controller down, and no effort would be required whatsoever, effectively ruining the tension by taking advantage of the mechanic.

This is one feature that absolutely must be included in the sequel, but with an upgrade. One change could instead force players to keep the light bar of the controller inside of a very slow moving box. As stated earlier, the size of the box would potentially depend on the difficulty setting.

Being one of the few games released to ever make use of the battery-draining light bar on the PS4 controller, Until Dawn 2 should continue to build upon this feature to make it into a classic horror experience.

6. Timed Walking Segments

In order to describe this problem, it is best to use an example.

Advertisement

In Chapter 4, Mike runs after Jess, who has just been kidnapped by an unknown entity, chasing the two of them, eventually ending up in an abandoned mine. Jess' survival here depends on two factors: whether the player has Mike take dangerous or safe paths, and how proficient the player is at QTEs.

Once the QTEs are completed, the player is given control of Mike to walk around the mine in order to find Jess. Here-in lies a problem. In order for Jess to live, Mike must have arrived at the mine quickly enough. However, once Mike gets there, it doesn't matter if it takes him 30 seconds or 4 hours to find Jess, her fate has already been decided.

This is just one example of many in the game where walking segments are given no time limit, defying all logic in the process.

For improvements, let's turn back to Heavy Rain. The game is full of sections where not completing a task quick enough had consequences. Everything was on a timer.

In order to truly go for a cinematic approach, something similar could be done here for Until Dawn 2. Instead of a killer breaking down the door once reaching a corner of the room, instead give the player 30 seconds to find a way out or die.

In a horror game all about creating tension, time limits would add to that.

5. Increase Importance Of Psychiatrist Scenes Or Ditch Them Entirely

If Supermassive Games can figure out a way to get Peter Stormare to come back for Until Dawn 2, they should definitely try. Not only did Stormare put in a great performance as the Psychopath's psychiatrist, but he could also serve as a bridge between Until Dawn and the sequel.

Advertisement

The psychiatrist scenes were interesting at points. Choosing your biggest fears, then having them show up later in the game as jump scares was a stroke of genius (do NOT pick spiders). There was a ton of potential to have them completely change the game.

Unfortunately, these scenes were largely phased out about halfway through, and had become pointless long before then.

In order to remedy this, one of two things must be done. First: Make these scenes more impactful, either by affecting the game or providing some insight in how the player is playing the game. Until Dawn tried this, accusing the player of giving answers to questions that contradicted their play style. It wasn't overly successful, but the effort was admirable, and the potential was big.

Failing this, the scenes must be removed entirely. Although occasionally a welcome reprieve to the constant scares of the main game, they eventually became more tedious than anything. With many of the chapters ending on a cliffhanger, removing pointless interludes is definitely the right move.

4. A Less Obvious Reveal

Until Dawn's biggest twist was not the identity of the Psychopath. Its biggest twist was the fact that the Psychopath was not the real killer.

Advertisement

Although it won't be spoiled here, when playing through the game, it is extremely obvious who the killer is. From the prologue establishing their relationship with the twins that die at the very beginning, to their very specific inside knowledge about the characters, the killer could be seen from a mile away.

Not even "killing" off the person under the mask halfway through the game deterred from the obviousness.

Making the identity of the main villain less obvious is largely dependent on the game's writing. Figuring out who is under the mask should only be for the very skilled, including only the most subtle of hints and clues. The reveal should be shocking, yet logical, with a clear motivation. Replaying the game should allow players to see the subtle hints and clues and have small realizations throughout.

Obviously, this is no easy feat. Writers of horror movies have been failing at this for decades. However, it is essential for maximizing the best experience. With enough work and skill, Supermassive Games could create one of the best written representations of horror ever in Until Dawn 2.

3. More Death Scenarios

At the end of the day, character deaths are the entire point of Until Dawn, and that should definitely not change in the sequel. The biggest motivation (in theory) is trying to save every character, and failing should "punish" the player by showing some of the most awesome and graphic death scenes in video games.

Advertisement

Best way to improve upon this for Until Dawn 2? Include more death scenes!

One issue in Until Dawn is the fact that two characters are absolutely un-killable until the absolute very ending of the game. Obviously, this is due to the fact that these were the two main characters, but it felt cheap considering how often the two were in danger.

Deaths were also few and far between for way too long. Barring the prologue, no character can die until Chapter 4, and after that a death in Chapter 6 can occur if the player is monumentally terrible at decision making.

The last three episodes were crammed with death scenarios, which, honestly, should be how much of the game is. This goes along with increasing the overall difficulty of the game. Adding the number of ways that characters can die seriously ups the stakes.

2. Tone Down The Supernatural

Part of the charm of Until Dawn before its release was its heavy grounding in realism (or as realistic as a horror game can get anyway). Other horror games had supernatural elements, such as Outlast's variants, Alien: Isolation's Xenomorph, or Slenderman.

Advertisement

This one would be a call back to the 80s, with a human slasher terrorizing a group of teens in an isolated location. Uncovering his or her identity would be a mystery, as would learning the truth about the two girls that died there one year earlier.

Then, halfway through the game, the wendigos show up.

Until Dawn actually had quite a bit of explanation for the wendigo's presence. But introducing a basically invincible monster completely sucked the tension out of an excellent story. It would be like watching the original Friday the 13th, but halfway through Jason vanishes and everyone starts getting slaughtered by space aliens.

It just isn't what people signed on for.

Until Dawn 2 needs a return to basics. The supernatural elements came out of nowhere and ruined a lot of suspense (barring the magnificent ending, of course). Obviously every horror medium dabbles in it, but it definitely needs to be scaled back.

Gone was the realism of teens fighting against something they only had a slim chance against. It was replaced by characters suddenly becoming superheroes in order to fight off an overpowered monster, even by horror standards.

Talk about false advertising.

1. More Impactful Choices

Choices need to have a greater impact on the game, and be less binary as well. One of the toughest decisions comes near the end. One of the characters, Emily, can get bitten by a wendigo. At this point, the player knows next to nothing about the wendigo.

Advertisement

Is it like a zombie? Are bites contagious?

So, when the player is forced to consider killing her to remove the threat, it is a genuinely difficult choice to make. These are the best parts of Until Dawn, where performing a morally reprehensible action may have a better outcome.

Not everything is so morally grey, however. Some of the choices are so obvious it's painful, such as the decision near the end of the game to save Jessica at no increased risk, or leave her behind to die.

Additionally, some decisions could have a greater effect. At multiple points, a character climbs a wall and has the option to take a more dangerous but faster route. Yet, there are no significant consequences for failing the subsequent QTEs. Perhaps in Until Dawn 2, endangering a character and failing injures them, making it more difficult to escape from a killer in the process.

People play Until Dawn for the chance to play as a character in a horror movie and make all the decisions. Let's make those decisions bigger.

Advertisement