What 10 Great Video Games Look Like Without Visual Effects
Epic boss fights are less cool when you know the monster is a duvet.
Even more so than film, the world of video game visual effects has evolved massively over the past couple of decades.
As 3D graphics capabilities expanded and the fidelity of what developers could capture in-camera reached further than ever before, actors in particular benefitted from the newfound freedom. Now, a video game motion-capture session is virtually indistinguishable from a film set.
Of course, gaming worlds are more often than not made up of fantastical creatures as much as they are with humans, and that means directors need to get inventive when it comes to transforming mo-cap takes into finished scenes. And whether they were working out of a cupboard or the latest state-of-the-art studio, it's always fascinating to see how much effort goes into creating immersive gaming experiences.
On top of that, it's just fun to see how rudimentary a lot of these pre-vis scenes are.
Who'd have thought the way to bring a dragon to life in a game was to just film a bit of wood with a carpet wrapped around it?
10. Injustice 2
While there's some great in-game pre-vis footage from Injustice 2, the highlight reel released showing how the announcement trailer was made perhaps better conveys just how cool making this fighter must have been.
What stands out in particular is just how well choreographed the fight between The Flash and Superman is, and how much of it was actually captured in camera. When it comes to depicting superhero punch ups, the assumption is that most of the stylish flair is added later, but here every "blow" and movement accurately conveys the physicality of these larger-than-life characters.
Even more interesting is how all of the real-life camera movements make it over to the final digital-footage as well. Again, you might assume that some of these movements - the shakes, pans and zooms - are done digitally after the fact, to make the fight seem more brutal and visceral, but they're all present in the original recording.
You can even see the monitor the director is using to visualise how the fight will look in the trailer, using unfinished character models as reference.
9. Devil May Cry 5
This is a bit different from the rest of the entries on this list, because the extensive, two-hour behind-the-scenes video released from the making of Devil May Cry 5 doesn't cover the actual mo-cap sessions, but something far wackier.
Instead of using regular animated storyboards to use as a reference for cutscenes, the devs on this long-awaited sequel actually filmed them all in real time, using real actors and props (and even some rudimentary visual effects), giving the studio a framework they could follow.
Every cutscene was therefore rehearsed and acted as it is in the final game, and the results are wild. The live-action rendition of Dante's now infamous Michael Jackson dance is a particular highlight, with the actor performing the entire thing in-camera, even wearing the same cowboy hat. And for some of the more fantastical scenes, they just used a Dante figurine. It's madness.
Two hours is a big time sink, but this entire thing is a genuine joy.
8. The Last Of Us
The Last of Us' behind-the-scenes sessions aren't the most immediately striking on this list, but they offer fascinating insight into how much this game succeeded due to the performances of its actors.
Troy Baker and Ashley Johnson, who play leads Joel and Ellie respectively, are as captivating to watch perform these scenes on set as they are in the finished game. Which is saying a lot, considering they look like they're wearing their pyjamas, are using toy guns and are surrounded by rigging.
The scene where the two characters argue shortly after arriving at Tommy's community in particular is a highlight (8:00 in the video above). Here, Baker and Johnson's performances really shine, and the intensity of the former is arguably even more palpable than in the final release.
Even a quick glance at these sessions proves that The Last of Us was always something special, and here's hoping the behind-the-scenes footage for the sequel is just as extensive.
7. L.A. Noire
In 2020, getting lifelike performances from actors is relatively easy, and every quiver of the lip or scrunch of the nose can translate perfectly from the sequence captured in-camera to the one digitally rendered in the final game.
Back in 2010 though, that level of fidelity was virtually impossible. This proved a problem for L.A. Noire, an ambitious detective game that made judging whether people were telling the truth in interrogations a major part of its gameplay. While grilling potential suspects, the player is encouraged to judge their responses, looking for any facial tics or giveaways that might lead to further lines of questioning.
Back when the title was in development though, capturing an actor's performance that accurately wasn't possible, and the devs at Team Bondi actually had to invent the technology to make it happen.
It took a lot of time, effort and money, but the devs eventually got it working via a huge set up that meant cutscenes had to be filmed twice.
One session would take place on set, and capture the actor's physical performance, while the other would take place in the new 'depth analysis' studio, where the actor's facial movements and voice would be recorded. The face was then transferred to the first character render, and the scene would be finalised.
6. Death Stranding
The best thing about the behind-the-scenes mo-cap sessions for Death Stranding is knowing that all of the actors really were together on set performing this script together.
Considering the calibre of the talent acquired, you might have assumed that performances were captured in isolation or with stand-ins, and then pieced together in post-production. These videos make it clear that, for the most part, Kojima's cast were all together, which is ultimately what made the eventual game's cinematics so believable.
Again, what's immediately striking is how much of Kojima's distinctive cinematography was solidified in the real-life shoot. He maximises the use of space, swooping the camera in and out to emphasise intimate moments or to create tension, and all of those movements are worked out on a real set.
Also, watching Norman Reedus perform all of the odd, fourth-wall breaking gestures in the safe room, as well as riding a cardboard bike operated by a bunch of dudes, is hilarious.
5. Red Dead Redemption 2
Sadly, there isn't a whole load of footage out there covering the actual human performances in Red Dead Redemption 2, but how the team at Rockstar managed to bring the game's horses to life has been revealed in a bunch of videos.
The original game set the bar for realistic horses in games, and that was done essentially by drawing a few dots on a horse and filming it galloping around a pretty small set. Cut forward ten years and the scale of the operation grew massively, and this time around the horses had their own mo-cap suits, and were ridden by human performers in their own suits to ensure the most lifelike movement around real, obstacle-filled racetracks.
In interviews the actors revealed some tidbits about how far performance capture evolved during the two games as well. For instance, on the first Red Dead, cutting between angles on set was impossible, which meant all cutscenes had to be accomplished in a single take. Thankfully, that was remedied for the sequel.
4. Marvel's Spider-Man
With the exception of the horse tech in Red Dead Redemption and the cardboard motorcycle in Death Stranding, for the most part these pre-vis scenes have mostly covered dialogue scenes, but that all changes with Marvel's Spider-Man.
As you can imagine, it's a little more complicated to capture the high-flying feats of a human spider via motion capture, but the team at Sony and Insomniac pulled out all the stops to make sure the old web head's movements not only looked spectacular, but appeared believable, weighty and realistic.
What's particularly interesting is hearing the devs talk about wanting to capture the action in a way that mimicked comic-book panels, something which they experimented with extensively in pre-production to make it look natural in the finished product.
3. Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order
A great mix of acting and physical performance, going behind the scenes of Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order highlights how the game's lightsaber battles were brought to life.
The assumption when you see action sequences in games is that they must have been performed in the studio by stuntmen, and then the actor's performance is layered over the top, a bit like how L.A. Noire was created. Hell, that's pretty much exactly what lead Cameron Monaghan thought before he signed up as the lead for Respawn's game, as the actor states in the video above.
Instead, Monaghan was involved every step of the way, learning the choreography and performing the final fights with the other actors. The cameras not only captured his movements, but also his facial performance during the action, adding to the overall intensity of the scenes.
Despite being a game, it's probably not that far away from working on a real Star Wars set.
2. Monster Hunter: World
Remember those live-action storyboards for Devil May Cry 5? Now, times that insanity by one million, swap out a reference for the actual motion-capture performance, and you have an idea of how crazy the pre-vis cutscenes were for Monster Hunter: World.
Obviously, there aren't any real beasts you can drag in to stick a motion capture suit on, and doing the same to a real life wild animal is just asking for trouble, so actors stepped in to play these roles, and perform opposite another 'monster' (that in reality is essentially just a pole with a duvet wrapped around it).
That's right, some of the most brutal moments of Monster Hunter: World were created by capturing dudes performing wrestling moves on a bedroll.
There's a bit of Andy Serkis or Benedict Cumberbatch to the performances as well, and the actors truly embody these terrifying beasts, contorting their bodies and growling to give an extremely demanding physical performance. Sure, you can laugh at how it looks before the visuals are added, but it's undeniably an impressive thing to commit to when you're surrounded by a crew.
1. Mortal Kombat
From the latest cutting-edge tech to the oldest game on this list, creating the original Mortal Kombat looks like a crazy process in 2020. Back when that seminal fighter came came out, the devs opted to swap out the colourful sprites of Street Fighter for realistic character models that were actually FMV recordings of real people performing the moves.
As you can imagine, that process was a little rudimentary, and essentially amounted to a bunch of people being suited up in ninja costumes, pushed to the back of a dingy office, and forced to perform punches, kicks, and fatalities against a wall.
What's fascinating is that there was only a tiny space the actors could perform in to make sure their characters didn't take up too much space in the game, and thus some of the more agile moves had to be pieced together in imaginative ways. Running attacks, for instance, were filmed with the actors on a treadmill, while jumping kicks had the fighters balancing on portable stairs.
In way, it's not too different to how performance capture is filmed now, only on a massively downscaled level.