What GTA 6 MUST Learn From GTA 5
Rockstar's GTA 5 is still brilliant, but it's far from the perfect crime sandbox.
The three people who haven't experienced GTA 5's delights are about to have a ball when the latest edition drops on PS5 and Xbox Series X/S. Rockstar moulded a game so well-loved that even millions who bought it back in 2013 (and then again in 2014 on PS4/Xbox One) will plonk down their cash again for one more ride through the dizzying Los Santos.
5 has been milked to the point of excess by now – GTA Online, admittedly, remains a popular money-maker, and it'll easily keep the series purring along until 6 launches in a few years. In the interim, and before the final tweaks are put on the next game, everybody at Take-Two/Rockstar must sit down, replay their last adventure and figure out what GTA 6 can learn from its predecessor.
In short: A LOT.
The colourful capers of Michael, Franklin and Trevor were fun, but 5 wasn't perfect. Sure, that's heresy to some, but it's the truth. Although true developers can glean loads from what the prior title did really well, they can also learn a thing or two from what it did poorly.
10. Offline Single-Player Is Best
GTA Online is a right laugh with the right people, but GTA soars when it’s an offline, single-player experience. That's why it's been so promising to hear Take-Two CEO Strauss Zelnick echo this in interviews – he noted that there's still a market for tightly-focused, single-player experiences.
Too right.
5 did the single-player thing better than most, especially during an era littered with online shooters. Despite the fact that gaming (like every other medium) has definitely evolved since 2013, one thing has remained steady. What is that? Well, people still crave a rich Grand Theft Auto world they can get lost in.
Rockstar don't have to integrate Online into the core experience. That's been discussed on social media, but it'd be a major mistake. No, keeping the offline story separate from all of Online's barmy charms sounds like the best strategy here. Staying true to GTA 6's narrative is vitally important.
9. Multiple Protagonists Works
Refining key systems is also important.
GTA 5 earned a lot of praise for the way it seamlessly handled playing as three main protagonists. Michael, Franklin and Trevor all had different sh*t going on at different times, and that made switching between them a humble joy. Could it be better though? You're darn right it could.
Rockstar brains have surely been working overtime to come up with tweaks that'd make the multi-protag thing work in GTA 6. They don't actually need to go overboard with improvements. A few refinements, like having each character be able to approach the same mission in different ways, would be enough.
Play back GTA 5 in 2022 and you'll wonder why switching between characters on the fly hasn't become a trend in more open world games. It feeds variety, and ensures the player gets to see the game's world through different eyes any time they like.
That's a major plus.
8. Focusing On One Location Isn’t Bad
5's Los Santos was only one area of the wider San Andreas map, but Rockstar developed it and poured love into every corner. There's been a lot of talk about GTA 6 being bigger than ever. Hmm. What good is map space if it isn’t populated with interesting things to see or do though?
6 in a living, breathing Vice City sounds better than 6 spread across multiple locations just so everyone can boast about scale. Using the power of new hardware smartly is preferable to crafting a sandbox with vast chunks of land that are totally useless. Oh look, another identikit garage in the middle of nowhere. Great!
Seriously, GTA 6 doesn't need to spread itself too thin. One well-realised locale would be enough to satisfy players who want the most immersive open world yet. If Rockstar works hard on the lusted-after source material (Vice) and soups it up into something more vibrant, then they'll be onto a winner.
That's what they did with San Andreas in 5.
7. Trevor Isn't Necessary
Right, slight rude awakening here.
The world has changed incredibly since GTA 5 launched way back in 2013. As much as those cheeky scamps at Rockstar love stirring up some controversy in the mainstream media by causing politicians to have coronaries on the spot, they've also got some responsibilities.
6's story doesn't need a character like Trevor from GTA 5. Sorry, but it doesn't. His cutscenes often relied on shocks for the sake of it, and that's not nearly as interesting as any stunning moments which add depth the characters around your protagonist or those that furnish the overall story.
Dan Houser's exit stage left may open up new possibilities for Grand Theft Auto. It's hardly about to grow up overnight, but maybe the producers should leave scene-causing stunts like that torture sequence on the cutting room floor. The game, if properly-realised, won't need such shocks-for-the-sake-of-it storytelling.
6. Sillier Isn’t Always Better
GTA has always had a touch of the daft about it. Dip into the archives for a shot of the original to see Hare Krishna monks being mowed down – when they are, the word “Gouranga” pops up on screen. Then, in titles like Vice City, it's possible to play that famous chainsaw scene from Scarface for literally no good reason.
Rockstar introduced a hover bike in GTA Online too. Is it fun and does it work for that mode? Yes and absolutely, but it’d be pretty odd to see things like that added into the main story willy nilly. As much as the jetpack from San Andreas is often cited as essential, it was a one-off treat that somehow fit the game's tone.
6 must be wary of turning down the same dark road that Volition did with Saints Row IV, to be honest. Some of 5's best moments were totally serious and came when characters ditched their own ridiculousness to act like real human beings.
Striking up some balance is gonna be crucial.
5. Pacing Is Important
Pacing can help with that.
Go back and play GTA 5 now. Then, stick on Red Dead Redemption 2. There's a marked difference between both titles; no, Rockstar didn't “grow up” (there's that idea again), and Arthur Morgan's tale might not be for everybody, but the pacing is spot on for what the game is looking to achieve.
Literally everything you do has some room to breathe, and that’s rarely the case in Los Santos. Most tasks, whether they're critical to the story or not, feel like a rush. There's a little voice in your head that screams, 'Push forwards”, and that can come at the cost of enjoying the here and now.
Would it really be such a bad thing if Rockstar amalgamated GTA 5's adrenaline and Red Dead's measured approach? They should slow things down just a tad in 6. That'd help the biggest story beats land without everyone shrugging and asking what's next.
4. Police Aren’t “Always On”
Not sure if Rockstar know this, but...crimes get committed in the real-world daily without cops instantly swarming the scene like they’ve been waiting on it. What once seemed like an excellent feature (the police presence in GTA games generally) has now become outdated and in dire need of a rethink.
More realistic policing mechanics sound great.
GTA 6 could maybe steal from a competitor here. In Mafia 3, which had a ton of problems itself and was by no means perfect either, cops were slower to respond in less affluent areas. That had racial undertones, obviously, but Rockstar don't have to work that ugly side in - they can adapt to suit their own game world.
Police also tend to immediately forget all about your rampages if you enter a safe house, which is hardly fab. Refining the way authorities react to certain things is something GTA should really think about. Squad cars shouldn't be ramming you off the road for petty crimes.
3. RPG-Lite Doesn’t Cut It
Each main character in GTA 5 had a special ability that could be activated by clicking both thumb sticks. Franklin could slow down time and drive like a champ, Michael Could mimic Max Payne by going all bullet time during firefights, and Trevor could "rage". He'd basically become unstoppable.
None of these skills could be developed, and that was a missed opportunity.
In 6, it'd be cool to see the developers take some RPG levelling-up stuff they tried on in San Andreas and bring it bang up to date. Failing that, maybe they could add in the option to play through a "Hardcore Mode". Y'know, like the one that was agonisingly difficult in Fallout? Having to eat, drink, sleep etc would add a new challenge to the game.
Obviously, Rockstar would need to slow the pace right down for this to work. They'd have to give players ample time to address such survival elements without punishing them by fast-forwarding through days too quickly.
2. Side Missions Need Rewards
This writer was a huge fan of the 'Strangers & Freaks' mechanic that became Rockstar's go to from the original Red Dead Redemptions onwards. They went wild with the idea in GTA 5 too, but that was hardly the worst idea. Looking back, there was only really one annoying flaw with it.
Most of these side quests didn't offer up a tangible reward.
Getting secondary characters as a contact on your phone wasn't nearly enough. GTA 6 must give players a reason to seek 'Strangers & Freaks' out, then plough through their mini-stories for some kind of prize. As fun as they were in 5, most were ultimately pointless. That sucks.
Every single side mission in 6 has to dangle a carrot in front of gamers. If weirdos want you to take pictures of distressed celebs, or elderly couples want you to invade people's homes to steal their possessions, then they need to stump up cash, reward you with cool vehicles/weapons/safe houses and more.
1. Environmental Destruction Would Rule
Real-life architects need to study Los Santos.
That place had some of the hardest concrete known to man. Even some small walls were indestructible; they didn't budge when massive trucks were careening into them at 80mph. Did this make a lick of sense? No, of course not, and it's something that Rockstar must change in the next game.
Environmental destruction would open things up tenfold. Imagine seeing construction workers busily piecing a building back together that you and your crew wrecked during a recent heist? That'd make GTA 6's world feel alive, and it's the kind of stuff that was missing from 5.
Not every building, sign, lamp post, wall, road etc has to be breakable, but characters should be able to affect the world around them more than ever before in the next title. This is especially true in the downtown/city centre areas where skyscrapers tower overhead.
Let us blow them up.
What else do you think GTA 6 must learn from GTA 5? For more gaming, check out GTA 6: Everything We Know So Far and WWE 2K22: 10 New Things You Need To Know About!