Wii U E3 Review

So E3 has been and gone, but how did the only new hardware perform? We take a short look back and see how.

By Lee Burton /

Advertisement
We all knew that this E3 wasn€™t going to come calling to any new hardware, any new hardware that wasn€™t expected of course. Nintendo€™s hardware revolution, the Wii U, had been announced last year but didn€™t surpass the stage of model and concept. We€™d been let on to know that this tablet controller would stream games from the console, allow you to play without the TV, allow you to throw ninja stars at trees and play digital draughts, but beyond that our imaginations were left to run wild. The examples they gave us may not have been so amazing, but it was undeniable that the hardware truly was. So, it wasn€™t surprising that our slow rising anticipation was for uncovering the actual potential of this awesomely glorified tablet controller. It seems though lately that E3 has a tendency to burst our bubble of high promise by announcing things that are expected, uninspiring, or just downright confusing. But let€™s not get too ahead of ourselves, that pre-E3 show displaying the Wii U€™s design changes, the oddly Xbox 360 looking controller and its sociological aims had been intriguing. Especially Nintendo€™s self-awareness of technological isolation, their mention of €˜Alone Together€™ and their want to actually tackle the issue and not see it as a necessary sacrifice for technology to advance - that, for the first time in about 5 years, made me sit up straight, then as soon as they slid into connectivity via Wii texting and TV photo sharing, I immediately resumed the slouch position. Click "next" for part 2...

Advertisement
When Nintendo€™s E3 presentation began I followed a similar procedure; €˜Pikmin 3 reveal!? That€™s promising! and now 23 games!? that€™s almost excessive! ...oh, previously released 3rd party games, back to slouching!€™ I could not help but analyse the purpose of showing Batman: Arkham City after stating how little time they had of showing all these games. Actually, lets condense that, I could not help but analyse the purpose of showing Batman: Arkham City. The needless additions of being able to touch tap the Wii U to set off charges and unleash B.A.T. mode for power boost just shout gimmick. Nintendo may have been proud in announcing partnership with Ubisoft and EA, and it had been an assuming message to industry followers that core gamers are now within their spotlight. But in the end Nintendo€™s first party games have always been their strongest, qualitative line-up, so wouldn€™t it be smart to showcase the Wii U€™s interactive advantages on those games? And ZombiU is only arguably original. Though I€™d like to be pleasantly surprised that the zombie survival genre with the Wii U is breathing new life into the series... breathing new life, oh dear.

But that€™s not to say we didn€™t experience any first party games. Of course the already mentioned Pikmin 3, this looked genuinely impressive and started the show off with a bang. Pikmin 3€™s multiple character mechanics had been made for the Wii U gamepad, and it looked enjoyable and accessible to build bridges, attack armoured caterpillars, destroy walls, and all the other destructing and constructing things you can do with the pikmin, via tapping or flicking the screen. It made the Wii U predominant and mandatory, whereas this hadn€™t been completely convincing with the third party titles. And then there was of course New Super Mario Bro€™s. I don€™t think Super Mario can ever get dull, it has been accepted, and I like to feel very much welcomed, for the past 20 years so I can€™t see it dying out soon. However, seeing it being revealed at an E3 conference causes more of an expected nod of approval than an edge of your chair gasp. And to have Super Mario Brothers on Wii U is only really excelling in that you can play it via the gamepad instead of the possibly already engaged TV. The other rare suitably beneficial title had been Scribblenauts, the very popular Nintendo DS word combination game, so a game that has been built with touch screen in mind. But there has to be something more obviously, an incentive to purchase this otherwise very casual, short burst game on a slightly less portable device. Multiplayer! What that is exactly is uncertain, but it needs to be a focus for drawing in real interest. Read on for the final part...

Advertisement
So, with many non-original conceptions and/or titles on display, and only really one first party title making any interesting use of the Wii U, the press conference felt lacking. Now, this isn€™t biased talk or vengeance from a bitter core gamer, the Wii U looks like the perfect fill for the casual and core gamer split. A device that is originally interactive for reeling in the casual yet capable of offering a traditional gaming experience for the core, it just felt like that perfect balance had been somewhat squandered in terms of entertainment offered. But following the consistent of sequence of single highlights and several ordinaries, Nintendo managed to slip in the announcement of double Wii U gamepad support... to then disappointingly continue talking about unrelated games. That inclusion was amazing and such a sigh of relief, yet a fleeting moment and another let-down opportunity to letting us know how this hardware would be utilised. That€™s kind of what this conference was in the end, not a disappointment out of Nintendo not being capable but a disappointment out of knowing Nintendo have potential but were not showing it here.

Looking at the bigger picture though not all is bad, when has a first line-up of games for new hardware been truly astounding? The Xbox 360, The PlayStation 3 and even the Wii had all suffered from mediocrity. Developers just need a little time to find their feet, and there are glimpses of true inspiration and realisation of the Wii U. The Wii Fit U trampolining and bobsleighing seemed interesting, Sing fixated on the Wii U being a lyrics sheet for karaoke which is unique and Pikmin 3 had been the embodiment of realisation for core gaming, all of these games can be learnt from. If Nintendo can just clarify the Wii U€™s demographic, which seems to be everyone, and its purpose through explicitly stating how two gamepads could be different, how the Wii U can be a true replacement and how the Wii U can convincingly fulfil that vision of not being €˜alone together€™, then the Wii U can still shine. We just need to be able to stop imagining what could happen and pass that job on to the creators who can make it happen.