DLC #3, Playable Character #47, Superstar #40. The key to selling DLC is having DLC wrestlers that people will actually pay for. The Enigmatic One would definitely be a hot seller, including an alternate Hardy Boyz attire.
67. Jey Uso
Playable Character #48, Superstar #41. One-half of the current Tag Team Champions.
66. Jerry Lawler
DLC #4, Playable Character #49, Superstar #42. Lawler should be an NPC in-game as a commentator, but should have a retro wrestling version available for DLC.
65. Jimmy Hart
DLC #5, NPC #5, Manager #4. A DLC Jimmy Hart could come with the ability to yell into an opponent's ear with his megaphone just like in Legends of WrestleMania.
64. Jimmy Snuka
Playable Character #50, Superstar #43. Complete with Superfly Splash.
63. Jimmy Uso
Playable Character #51, Superstar #44. The other half of the reigning WWE Tag Team Champions.
62. Jinder Mahal
Playable Character #52, Superstar #45. The final member of 3MB.
61. John "Bradshaw" Layfield
Playable Character #53, Superstar #46. JBL would be an NPC as a commentator at ringside, but should also be an unlockable legend.
60. John Cena
Playable Character #54, Superstar #47. WWE's top-marketed guy is the first person who should be in the game no matter how divided the fans are when it comes to loving or hating him.