WWE 2K18: 10 Things It Can Learn From Past Games
We basically want No Mercy remastered, 2K...
The never-ending drive towards perfection in wrestling video games has hit a snag. WWE 2K17 did have fun elements, but players had to scratch beneath the surface to find them. Take the major game mode My Career for instance: was an endless slog through dreary matches. Yet downloading old arenas and reliving nostalgic moments via Community Creations was joyous.
2K should absolutely continue improving this customisation aspect, but crucially, they also need to start making core gameplay enjoyable again. After all, what's the point in downloading or creating all your favourites only to grow bored when using them during matches?
Ironically, the past holds the secrets to improve the 2K series' future. Learning what worked previously could just be essential to ensuring that the upcoming game gives players what they want. Over to you, dev geniuses...
10. Real Storylines In Career Mode
WWE storylines practically beg to be turned into interactive set pieces gamers can play through each year. Why then, is there such a focus on turning something so organically exciting into the mind-numbing boredom of Universe Mode and My Career? It just doesn't make sense when there's so much to explore.
SmackDown 2: Know Your Role (released in 2000) was capable of including such gems as Steve Austin destroying the DX Express bus, and later games even included real-life angles like the ECW invasion. These must have been fun to design for the developers, but 2K have oddly elected to step back from using the real WWE in favour of formulaic stories that go nowhere.
2K18 needs a well-produced Story/Career Mode that uses angles fans recognise from WWE programming. For example, why not put Braun Stowman's recent demolition of Roman Reigns in the new game and let players assume the role of either man? That's what these games should be all about.
9. Freedom To Roam
2K17's Backstage Brawl feature felt like a step forward for the 2K series after so many steps backwards. The developers packed a lot of interaction into a dense environment, rather than using wide-open areas that characters could run around in. It's time to expand things.
It's not like the Xbox One or PS4 lack the power to make this happen. Having the freedom to roam around arenas like we did in games like SmackDown: Here Comes The Pain should be mandatory, especially when realising there's really no excuse for 2K to scale down backstage areas. Players want to go everywhere, when and how they wish.
In a Street Fight, it should be possible to fight up the entrance ramp and head backstage. Those blue arrows need to make a long-awaited comeback and allow much more freedom during brawls. Part of the fun in older SmackDown games was in the exploration, rather than playing in the same area over and over again.
8. Looks Are Important
Remember when trailers played for SmackDown: Shut Your Mouth in 2002 and everyone's jaw hit the floor? That wow factor hasn't been seen since, not even when WWE games were launched for future consoles. As sad as it is, the series has been left behind graphically.
Hair still looks awful, animations feel stiff and buggy, and there's just a general lack of polish in 2K's WWE games. That amazement over how good Shut Your Mouth looked compared to Just Bring It just isn't there in the newer titles. For example, did anyone notice a real upgrade between 2K16 and 2K17? Hardly.
The entire engine needs an update, just like it was given for Shut Your Mouth in 2002. Realising how tame Just Bring It had been, THQ worked hard to make the following year's game one wrestling fans could be proud of. Looks are important, 2K, and so are first impressions. 2K18 better have something new to offer.
7. Create-A-Finisher Is Awesome
One of the most confusing things about 2K is that they seem to switch features in and out without much explanation. Instead of telling fans that they wanted to work on the 'Create-A-Finisher' suite in order to make it better, they just whipped it from the feature set for 2K17 and expected people to be happy about it.
When are 2K going to realise that being able to create your own anything is awesome? Sure, creating different wrestlers, arenas, belts and the rest is fun, but so is being able to hand your new star a unique finishing move nobody else in the game uses. That complete customisation is missing from 2K17, and that shouldn't be happening nowadays.
Admittedly, Create-A-Finisher does need some work, but leaving the old system in shouldn't have been a problem for 2K. Once players find a way to work around the fact some animations don't merge smoothly with others, coming up with fresh moves is exciting.
6. How To Emulate WCW Mayhem's Commentary
Commentary is by far one of the worst parts of any WWE game. Not only does it sound uninspired, the announcers sometimes launch into a spiel about something that isn't even happening on screen. Obviously, this does little to immerse fans in the match and leaves most wishing they could just turn it off entirely.
Go back to 1999's WCW Mayhem on the PSOne for some quality in-game commentary. Tony Schiavone and Bobby Heenan sound like they're into what's happening, and they even manage to sell chair shots or other weapon strikes like the vicious moments they are. Why isn't that happening in 2K17?
2K have to figure out what EA did with Mayhem and how those developers managed to get good commentary in a wrestling game. If they do that, the overall experience in 2K18 will be much better. If other video game genres like football, basketball and ice hockey can do great announcing, then wrestling should be doing the same.
5. Hell In A Cell Is Supposed To Be Fun
It's ironic that the hardest part of a Hell In A Cell match in recent WWE games is wrestling with the controls and limitations imposed on the player. Figuring out how to scale the Cell, or even break out of the thing, shouldn't be an issue. Older wrestling titles didn't have this nonsensical need to make things difficult.
Hell In A Cell is supposed to be fun, but with each passing entry is has become a real chore to enjoy one of WWE's most violent, chaotic creations. That shouldn't be the case at all, and is in fact the complete opposite of how a Cell bout needs to play out in-game. Those 'OMG' moments that only trigger when they feel like it have a lot to answer for.
Breaking out of the cage isn't easy, and that only lessens the desire to fire up Hell In A Cell and play with a friend. When most of the time is spent trying to get on top of the Cell, you know there's something wrong. Take a page out of old games, 2K, and stop focusing so needlessly on simulation.
4. Ladders Should Be Placed Anywhere
Firstly, elephant in the room: Ladder Matches could be a real pain in the rear end in previous wrestling games. Refinement was definitely needed, but that need for improvement didn't involve removing the ability to place ladders anywhere players liked.
In WWE 2K17, gamers only have a select few pre-determined spots they can sit ladders during matches. That flat out sucks and takes away so much of the fun. What's the point in touting a unique physics system if players can't exploit it by rag-dolling opponents onto ladders set up anywhere they damn well please?
If 2K live in fear that players won't set a ladder up directly underneath the title/briefcase they're trying to grab, then maybe restrict things inside the ring. Doing so outside makes little sense, and only makes it harder to perform kickass spots like diving onto the announce table.
3. Shut Your Mouth's Draft Must Make A Return
Shut Your Mouth remains one of the most exciting WWE games ever released on PlayStation. It was arguably the first wrestling title on Sony machines that could match up to those excellent releases on N64 like No Mercy, WCW/nWo Revenge and WrestleMania 2000. Part of that success came due to an amazing Story Mode.
Right away, players were told they'd have to pick separate rosters for Raw and SmackDown during the WWE Draft. Of course, the Draft made a comeback in real life last Summer, so it's logical that it'll be included in 2K18. If so, 2K have to follow THQ's template from 2002 and let gamers make their own roster choices.
Being able to completely customise how the forthcoming Story Mode played out was a real selling point for Shut Your Mouth. Let's hope 2K don't just use WWE's real-life Draft picks and force players to deal with it. That customisation is key to ensuring any Draft feature goes down a treat.
2. GM Mode Rocked
General Manager Mode was removed entirely from the SmackDown vs. Raw series by the time 2009's entry came along. Now that WWE have re-introduced brand-specific authority figures and relaunched the brand extension, it makes sense for 2K to throw their might behind the idea again.
Scrap Universe Mode or remodel it into GM Mode, please. Being able to assume the role of Raw, SmackDown or ECW General Manager rocked. Obviously, ECW wouldn't exist as a third brand in WWE 2K18, so simply choosing between Raw and SmackDown would suffice. This is one feature everyone wants back.
Micro-managing everything about the brand, from roster and pay-per-view output, would be awesome. Even having the ability to compare what happened on the rival show to your own would be a sweet idea, because it removes the largely pointless feel to Universe Mode. Controlling everything would be a lot more fun if it meant something.
1. Simulation Gameplay Doesn't Need To Be Boring
Above all else, 2K need to realise that striving to make the wrestling video game experience a simulation doesn't necessarily mean it has to be dull. Sadly, 2K17 was slower than The Undertaker's offence circa 1991, and that comes at the expense of making the game fun.
No Mercy on the N64 got the balance right. A mix between arcade action and simulation made it a sheer joy to play, so 2K should study the core gameplay there to see what makes a perfect wrestling video game. Combine that with modern graphics or better presentation and 2K18 could be one of the best wrestling games in years, or at least something special.
Slowing things down to a snail's pace makes every match feel sluggish. There must be more emphasis on zipping the action along whilst maintaining some elements of realism. Nobody's advocating a return to In Your House here, we want some wrestling, but it needs to be a bit slicker to play.
What else do you think WWE 2K18 could learn from past wrestling games? Let us know your thoughts down in the comments section below!