WWE 2K24 Review: 9 Ups & 4 Downs

2K's three-year plan pays off with one of the best WWE games ever made.

By Jamie Kennedy /

2K Games

WWE 2K20's disaster was the best thing that could've happened to 2K's series.

Advertisement

That's a controversial statement, because it obviously wasn't fun for those who spent cash on the game and were promptly left disappointed. However, it forced a complete rethink from the developers and has led to a three year cycle of excellence that's now peaked with 2K24. Spoiler alert: This is a very good game.

The sheer wealth of modes 2K serves up is impressive. 2K24 also features one of the most varied rosters ever seen in a pro wrestling title, and there's more to come on that front with various DLC packs and bonuses. That's all before one digs into the soon-to-be-bustling Community Creations hub as well.

Advertisement

New match types, a souped up WrestleMania-themed Showcase, incremental improvements to familiar modes like MyRise, MyGM and Universe, subtle yet brilliant gameplay tweaks - yep, 2K has been busy since last year. Everything comes together to create one of the most robust and rewarding packages yet.

Not everything is perfect, of course. Pesky visual inconsistencies and some in-mode restrictions can annoy, but 2K24 is a sheer delight to experience overall.

Advertisement

Here's all the good and bad!

Advertisement

Downs...

4. Varying Visual Quality

2K Games

First, some negatives.

Advertisement

This is a bummer to point out, but the quality of character models across the board isn't too consistent. Some, like Bayley, look noticeably low-res compared to a graphical powerhouse like Roman Reigns or Cody Rhodes. Hell, even this guy's CAW looks one million times better than poor ol' Bayley.

Admittedly, a few of the legends have faces that look ever-so-slightly off too, which is a pity and might detract from Showcase if you're a stickler for that sort of thing. Being fair, this is perhaps understandable due to the sheer weight of numbers on offer, but it'd be nice to see everyone on the roster get the same attention to detail.

Advertisement

It's hard to imagine Bayley (in particular) will be too chuffed with her character model this year. The woman looks like she hasn't slept! A quick fix patch may be in order there. Generally, 2K24 is a gorgeous game from head to toe, but some visual inconsistencies do stand out.

3. The Downsides To Showcase

2K Games

Disclaimer: Showcase Mode is a lot of fun and well-worth experiencing. The following two 'Downs' aren't designed to lambast it, but instead add balance by pointing out some minor niggles.

Advertisement

2K's heralded 'Slingshot Tech' is an impressive bit of kit. It splices in-game with real-life footage from the archives, and the whole thing works seamlessly. However, it is worth saying that the archival match footage does tend to take over a little too often during some matches in this year's '40 Years Of WrestleMania' retrospective.

As a result, you'll see moments during matches like Hulk Hogan vs. Andre The Giant or Hogan vs. The Ultimate Warrior and think, 'Hey! I should be playing that bit!'. That's not a mode-breaking problem, but it is well worth bringing up as a whispered warning before you get stuck in.

Advertisement

It's also a bit crap that modern day ring announcers like Mike Rome make match-winning calls on classic bouts. It would've been lovely to have iconic refrains from voices like Howard Finkel instead. That's a puzzling choice, and feels a little cheap considering the historical purpose of Showcase.

Ready for one final Showcase grumble?

Advertisement

2. Another Showcase Issue Worth Mentioning

2K Games

There's been a lot of talk pre-launch about the '40 Years Of WrestleMania' Showcase "only" featuring 21 matches matches from select versions of the famous event. 21 doesn't appear to be enough for some folks, but it's important to remember the amount of work that goes into crafting even one of these things.

Advertisement

Even so, a few of the match picks will bug some fans.

Iconic battles like Randy Savage vs. Ricky Steamboat, Steve Austin vs. The Rock and Hulk Hogan vs. Andre sit rather awkwardly next to matches like Bianca Belair vs. Asuka, put it that way. That match sticks out as much weaker than some of the others. Maybe that's just because it happened recently.

Advertisement

Obviously, 2K had to be selective and politically savvy, but it doesn't sit right that a match like Belair vs. Asuka is here and Daniel Bryan's amazing title win at WrestleMania XXX isn't. He's in AEW now, sure, but 2K24's Showcase feels less exhaustive for excluding some bigger 'Mania memories.

1. MyGM Remains A Struggle

2K Games

Whilst it's defo amazing that 2K brought GM Mode back, it's also fair to say they've still got some work to do before MyGM is special. It's very restrictive, and the overwhelming, stat-heavy menus feel a little clunky and lifeless at first too. Prepare to do a lot of reading and see a ton of Xavier Woods popping up as your guide.

Advertisement

The mode's algorithms don't allow for much player freedom either. Thus, you're almost forced into booking the same match types over and over again, and discouraged from experimenting with seemingly obvious combos just because some fighting styles don't match and result in automatic failure.

2K should change that, because it doesn't make sense that Drew McIntyre vs. Roman Reigns gets a lower rating than Drew vs. Drew Gulak, or something like that. That's just a clumsy example, but you get the point. There's so much more the devs could do to make MyGM a joy to mess around with.

Advertisement

Maybe next year, eh?

Ups...

9. A Huge & Varied Roster

2K Games

Right, enough doom and gloom. Onto the positives!

Advertisement

Picking someone to play as may become an exercise similar to deciding on something to watch via Netflix. Oh yes, the roster in WWE 2K24 is bloody massive. It serves up a lovely mix of current stars, legends and genuinely fresh faces. Some of them, like NXT's Gallus, were rather unexpected.

The coming DLC packs will add yet more variety, and Community Creations will blow the whole thing wide open with AEW, New Japan, TNA, WCW, ECW and more. Before that, something is worth saying: It's legit staggering how many playable workers 2K has squeezed on-disc here.

Advertisement

Many of the wrestlers feel unique to control as well. Pick a powerhouse giant like Omos, and you'll be ambling around the place hoping to pin opponents into a corner. Choose a faster-paced striker like Seth Rollins and the entire gameplay loop changes instantly.

2K deserve praise for that spectrum of play styles.

Advertisement

8. That New Camera Angle

2K Games

Strictly speaking, this isn't actually new for WWE games, but it is for 2K. Being able to swing the camera around to face the entrance is a lovely touch that conjures up images of the old SmackDown titles. This fan can't wait to download a Royal Rumble 2000 arena and reimagine the retro MSG setup too.

Advertisement

It's the little things in life.

It'd be awesome if 2K could expand on this and add even more angles to the lineup in future games. Saying that, being able to take complete control of the cam and go literally anywhere in the arena whilst waiting to enter a Rumble or watching an AI match is some laugh. Seriously, give that a bash.

Advertisement

Bizarrely, you can even go up and out of the stadium or through the floor and view the action from underneath. 2K will almost certainly patch that out of the game soon, so experiment whilst you can. Some of the visuals you can get playing around with the free roam cam = sensational.

7. Super Finishers

2K Games

If you're anything like the dude writing this, then you tend to waste finishers as soon as you've earned them. It's just too tempting to hit a Stunner early in the match even when it's guaranteed to result in a near fall. 2K's new Super Finisher mechanic could change that, and for the better.

Advertisement

Now, there's a risk and reward vibe to these new souped-up moves. Show enough patience (and restraint) and you'll be able to land a mega-powerful finish that's almost guaranteed to win the match. All you have to do is resist spamming finisher icons and store three of them at once.

Some of the Super Finishers look unbelievably good.

Advertisement

Rhea Ripley's super Riptide is already a firm favourite, because there's something so satisfying about nearly driving rivals through the canvas from the corner turnbuckles. The trade off, as aforementioned, is that patience really is key.

Good luck with that.

Advertisement

6. The Subtle Tweak To Tag-Team Matches

2K Games

Tag-team matches in 2K's series have always had a clunkiness that's hard to ignore. The formula for success was typically do enough damage to one opponent > stop them from making tags > hit a finisher > knock partner off the ring apron > go for the pin. Leave that partner on the apron and...you'd get a two count at most.

Advertisement

Not anymore.

2K has made a subtle tweak to tag bouts that means partners can only run in to save someone's skin once before they're temporarily hard-locked in position and unable to interfere. That sounds like a small change, but it adds a tactical layer to the match type that was sorely missing before.

Advertisement

It'll also stop the AI from constantly breaking up your pins unless you forearm them in the chops first. That's still possible, of course, but now it isn't mandatory and a shortcut to victory. This will be particularly helpful when playing with friends or online.

5. New Match Types Are Welcome

2K Games

2K spent a lot of time hyping up new match types like Ambulance, Casket and Special Guest Referee before 2K24 hit shelves/digital storefronts. Rightly so. Fans have been crying out to see some of these additions for years now, and there's some more good news. They're all fun for different reasons!

Advertisement

Sure, Ambulance and Casket bouts play out largely the same way. Your goal is to stuff an opponent inside then battle it out via a button-mashing mini game to win. The system works well for both, and it's sweet to see the old coffin gimmick get some proper love in a WWE game again.

Gauntlets are shockingly fun too, but it's Special Guest Ref that shines most.

Advertisement

Kudos to the developers for adding in limits on how much trolling you can do mid-match before another official comes out to stop the madness and take your place. Being able to switch that mechanic off is welcome too; switch off if you want to be the worst ref ever, basically.

All of these match types will keep you coming back for more, which is a huge plus.

Advertisement

4. 2K’s Creation Suite

2K Games

This will always get an 'Up'.

Advertisement

The sheer number of options 2K's creation suite provides, and the freedom to create any sort of wrestler you like? Fantastic. It says everything about how truly epic the suite is that other game developers could learn a thing or two from WWE's series. It really is that good. Looking at you, AEW Fight Forever.

Dig deep enough and you'll even find some other tasty bonuses. For example, 2K has included gear items for WWE alumni like Bryan Danielson/Daniel Bryan, which makes it easier than ever before for CAW-mad creators out there to make their favourites and upload them. That'll save some time.

Advertisement

The Community Creations tabs aren't busy just yet, but they'll be bustling with content soon and it's exciting to imagine what the best creators out there will be able to knock up using this tool set. Arguably, creating arenas (specifically the graphics side of things) could use an overhaul, but that's nitpicking.

3. The Good Side To Showcase

2K Games

There are downsides to the '40 Years Of WrestleMania' Showcase Mode, but that doesn't mean you won't have bags of fun ploughing through it regardless. So, what's good about Showcase, and why should you make it your first proper stop after playing a few exhibition matches and maybe creating a wrestler?

Advertisement

Honestly, it's a wonderful way to learn 2K24's controls, new mechanics and how the game works. 2K eased up on some of the in-match objectives this year - they're easier than ever to pull off, and you don't even have to tick off absolutely everything to reach those sought-after unlockables.

Corey Graves does a sparkling job of explaining the importance of each match and adding context while you're playing. His narration often splices with the real-life footage to give everything a nice zip. That makes it a real treat to experience legendary landmarks like Hogan vs. Warrior from 'Mania VI, Shawn Michaels vs. Razor Ramon from 'Mania X or Steve Austin vs. The Rock from 'Mania X-Seven.

Advertisement

There's also a bonus right at the end of Showcase that was a nice surprise. We won't spoil that for you in this review though.

2. The Strength Of MyRise

2K Games

MyRise has steadily been earning a spot near the top of the feature set for good reason. This year, 2K's dual campaigns throw you into bespoke scenarios that truly make the most of the WWE sandbox: 'Unleashed' has you playing as a female indy star who launched her own promotion and knocked back WWE before, and 'Undisputed' casts you as a male midcarder who's suddenly thrust into the main event mix.

Advertisement

Why? One Roman Reigns decided to vacate his title and jet off to Hollywood in a bid to top The Rock's body of work. That, dear reader, is tremendous banter, and it shows off the goofy-but-still-grounded tone of MyRise perfectly. Both stories are charming and feel closer than ever before to the old Story Modes of yesteryear.

Multiple save slots mean you're free to experience with branching paths too. It's also a plus that 2K finally moved away from the standard rookie trope and towards characters who are more confident/seasoned. Also also, was 'Unleashed' a nod towards AEW's creation? It just might be.

Advertisement

Again, ace banter if so.

1. A Generous Mix Of Modes/Content

2K Games

Overall, there's so much to enjoy in WWE 2K24. The game has lots to keep you busy for a long time, which isn't always something one can say about pro wrestling video games. 2K have become masters of content, and that should put a smile on anyone's face who lived through the mediocrity pre-2K20 crash.

Advertisement

Each mode in 2K24 offers something different from the others.

MyRise is a love letter to Story/Career Modes from games of yesteryear, MyGM works for those who enjoy micro-management and don't mind being patient, MyFaction scratches an itch for the ‘Ultimate Team’ crowd, Showcase is an on-rails history lesson, and Universe is a customisable, never-ending WWE sandbox.

Advertisement

That's before anyone even so much as dips a toe into multiplayer (with friends or online), the new match types etc. WWE 2K24 is bursting with content, and very little of it feels cheap or peripheral. That's a testament to how much passion 2K's team puts in.

They can be real proud of this series again. 2K24 is an essential purchase for those who have enjoyed the redemption arc since 2K22 kicked it off.

Advertisement

What are you most looking forward to in WWE 2K24? For more wrestling, check out WWE 2K24: 15 Legends Who Must Be Included As DLC and 10 New Directions For AEW After Revolution 2024!