Xbox Game Pass: 10 Best Horror Games You Must Play
Cosmic horror, dark fantasy, psychological terror? Game Pass has everything.
With over 350 titles to choose from, finding something on Game Pass to suit your mood often leads to endlessly scrolling through the collection, and when the horror mood strikes, that’s precious time you could be spending getting the crap scared out of you instead.
There’s also the inevitable stinkers in amongst the gems on offer.
Spending hours perusing the library and finally downloading a game that looks promising, only to stare at the title card in regret every time you boot up your Xbox can be frustrating.
So, whether you’re after jump scares, cosmic horrors, or somewhere in between, we’ve saved you and your bandwidth some time and picked ten of the best spine-tingling titles currently available on Game Pass. EA Play titles are included, which are available to play by subscribing to Game Pass Ultimate.
10. Five Nights At Freddy’s
The video game equivalent of a haunted house tour, if you're after jump scares, look no further.
If you've somehow avoided this internet phenomenon since its 2014 release, FNAF has you take control of the newest night time security guard of Freddy Fazbear's Pizza. It would be a pretty easy job, if not for the animal animatronics trying to break into your office and give you the mother of all jump scares.
The only mechanics of the game have you checking the cameras to see if the animatronics have moved, and closing the doors to the office when they get hair-raisingly close. It’s simple, but effective.
FNAF can be one of the tensest experiences you can have in gaming, if you resist the urge not to look up solutions. A feat easier said than done by the time you get to night four and Foxy tries his best to give you a light heart attack ad infinitum.
Perfect for dipping in and out of, so it won't take up too much of your time, and if you survive Freddy's five nights, Game Pass has every sequel available to squeal along with as well.
9. Dark Pictures Anthology: Man Of Medan
If you’re a fan of Supermassive Games’ Until Dawn, or trapping your Sims behind four walls with no toilet, Man of Medan is here for you
The only mechanics the game has are quick time events, and player choice. With this limited scope, Supermassive is able to create a choose-your-own-adventure slasher that has you playing director and actor. There are dozens of different character deaths available, and multiple endings, so the short 4-5 hour playtime can be replayed multiple times to get the full picture of the Man of Medan story—or for your own sick glee at all the creative deaths.
Unlike Until Dawn, Man of Medan doesn’t excel in its single player story, but is brought to life with a fun co-op mode. This means you can communicate with your partner, or stay silent and see how both your decisions play out, adding even more choice to the game. So if you’re feeling a little let down by the single player, try playing online with a friend, or passing the controller for some couch co-op.
Man of Medan doesn’t quite hit the high notes of Until Dawn, but it’s still a fun slasher romp with a mystery to uncover, and hours of different playthroughs to discover.
8. Carrion
Ever wanted to play as an amorphous blob of death and destruction? Carrion’s got you covered.
A retro-inspired 2-D side-scroller from Phobia Game Studio, who describe it as a "reverse-horror game", Carrion is a morose dip into gameplay satisfaction. You’ll uproot scientists from desks and toilets, adding them to your fleshy mass, growng in size and opening up different gameplay options.
If you don’t care about the Metroidvania elements having you backtrack for optional upgrades and collectibles, Carrion offers a couple of hours of smooth, grotesquely satisfying gameplay. There are a few puzzle elements to the game, forcing you to cycle through your attacks in search of the right move to open a door, or how to effectively combat the tougher enemies thrown at you in later stages of the game. If you're not a puzzle fan, don't worry, Carrion is mainly a human-eating simulator.
With a short playtime, and an on-point execution of taking control of a horror creature, Carrion is a perfect pick-up for a quick horror fix in between games.
7. Blair Witch
Bloober Team's Blair Witch is the only sequel that manages to capture the same slow-building dark folk tale aspects of the 1999 film, The Blair Witch Project.
Set in the same Black Hills Forest as the film, Blair Witch sees you take control of troubled former policeman Ellis Lynch, who enters the forest in search of a missing boy with the aid of a flashlight, a dog named Bullet, and a superb 90s phone, loaded with the old Snake and Space Invaders games to keep Lynch entertained—in between bouts of psychological horror.
Blair Witch is built on atmosphere more than gameplay, but there are occasional puzzles that need solved to progress in the story. You might get a little lost at times, but the journey is worth persisting with to experience the whole game start to finish—and what a finish it has. The last 5-10 minutes of the game will make your stomach churn in horrible anticipation of what's to come.
With more than one ending available, and a short runtime, Blair Witch is great to replay. Once you've recovered from the first ending, of course.
6. Alice: Madness Returns
Calling all dark fairytale and fantasy lovers, this title is just your cup of Mad Hatter's tea.
An EA Play title, Alice: Madness Returns is the sequel to American McGee's Alice. Although the sequel reviewed worse than the original, it has received further praise over the years, and is far more accessible to jump in and play than the first entry, due to its updated controls and mechanics. You don't need to have knowledge of the first game to enjoy Madness Returns, but if you would rather start with the first, it is handily included in the download with its sequel.
The hack-and-slash gameplay is fun, but the real selling point of Spicy Horse's sequel is its overarching dark fantasy design and inspiration. Teeth are collected to trade in for weapon upgrades, cities float on clouds of cogs, teapots with red eyes attack you, and Alice in Wonderland characters are peppered throughout the narrative.
The graphics are dated, even by 2009's standards, and the invisible walls are annoying, but these are small grievances in an otherwise very enjoyable platformer.
Madness Returns is all about Alice's dark memories of her past, and whether they should be forgotten or not, and you certainly won't forget your memories of gliding, slicing, and pepper-grinding your way through Wonderland.
5. Alien: Isolation
A killer concept (sorry) has you take control of Ellen Ripley’s daughter, Amanda, who boards the space station Sevastopol in search of clues to her mother's disappearance.
Unfortunately, there just so happens to be a Xenomorph on board, and the game quickly evolves into survival horror.
Creative Assembly has crafted an atmosphere of pure terror in amongst its retro throwbacks to the cinematic style of the first two Alien films: all the tech looks grimy, there's a great replica of the Nostromos to walk around at the beginning, and the start-up 20th Century Fox and Sega logos even get a nostalgic makeover.
The real appeal of Alien: Isolation, however, is its titular Alien, who has you pulling out your motion detector in reactionary fear at every bump and clank aboard the Sevastopol. You get other tools to help you survive against the Alien, but none of them will ever make you feel truly safe, as the Alien can't be defeated.
Other enemies roam the space station, but they are one of the weaker aspects of the game. Like the synthetic Worker Joe's, who have a satisfyingly eerie look to them, but are incredibly annoying to fight or evade.
The high tensions of being stalked by a Xenomorph outweigh any negative aspects of Alien: Isolation, and its a must-play for any horror fan.
4. The Medium
The newest horror entry arriving on Game Pass is Microsoft’s first Xbox Series X/S exclusive, owing to it’s unique split screen mechanic which shows the real world and the spirit world simultaneously at certain scripted sequences. Marianne is the titular medium, and we follow her in the wake of her adoptive father’s death, as she gets sucked into the mystery of Polish workers' resort, The Niwa.
Bloober Team's graphical design for both worlds is effectively creepy, especially the spirit world. Taking inspiration from the polish artist Zdzisław Beksiński, its oddly beautiful, but also has some gross-out moments included in the environments. The music is equally stylish. Akira Yamaoka (of Silent Hill fame) takes composing duties for the spirit world, creating a constant unnerving feeling as you explore, and Arkadiusz Reikowski scores the real world, which is beautiful and dreamlike.
The Medium is primarily a puzzle game, but what sets it apart from similar games is its use of the spirit world. Certain items or pathways are only available in one world, forcing you to decide which one to traverse. This mechanic makes for unique puzzle solutions, and even the game's only enemy, The Maw (disturbingly voiced by Troy Baker), is a puzzle.
The only downside to the game is that there isn't more of it. The Medium can be completed in two or three sittings.
3. Alan Wake
A tour de force of atmosphere, Alan Wake is one of the best games Remedy has ever made—and with their back catalogue, that’s saying something.
Exploring the various areas of Bright Falls while listening to Wake's Stephen King inspired voiceover invokes a horror vibe that is unique to the game.
Remedy are never afraid to take whatever weird subject material they have based their game on seriously, and Alan Wake’s commitment to making the small town of Bright Falls weirder and more horror based over time keeps in line with this ideology. Wake’s best friend and agent, Barry Wheeler, is on hand to provide the role of Funny Best Friend, and he does a good job at providing levity to Wake’s pondering prose.
Enemies are typically fought by using a flashlight to lower their defence, and then unloading bullets into them. It’s not too difficult, even on the harder difficulties. The hardest part is keeping track of your ammo, and annoyingly, resources are taken from you after each chapter of the game. A weird inclusion, but only a slight downside to this brilliant game.
Alan Wake still holds up today, despite being originally released in 2010 for the Xbox 360. If you've ever enjoyed a Stephen King book or adaptation, you need to play Alan Wake.
2. Control
David Lynch mixed with a Saturday morning cartoon, Control cements Remedy as the king of eerie atmospheres.
You play as Jesse Faden, a reluctant guest of The Oldest House, a mysterious compound occupied by the American government, which takes the general architectural design from such government buildings. Jesse is searching for her brother, Dylan, who she hasn’t seen since a mysterious incident occured when they were children.
The game is a smorgasbord of horror sci-fi, offering constant background whispering, neo-noir phone calls, giant cosmic horror bosses, mad scientists, and a killer fridge--to name a few. All of this, and much more, occurs as you hone Jesse’s abilities, which include levitation, mind control, and telekinesis. The game is as weird as it is good, and with its vertical level design opening up halfway through, an absolute blast to experience.
Jesse’s inner dialogue lets us get to know her better, and she turns out to be a delightful goofball at times. She finds the goings on at The Oldest House as weird as us, and offers funny or insightful commentary when needed.
The game’s atmosphere is hard to put into words, but Jesse sums it up best in response to a particularly memorable action sequence; “That was awesome”.
1. Dead Space
A sci-fi survival horror treat from the Xbox 360 days, EA Redwood Shores' original Dead Space was pretty unique in its time for not letting you pause the game. It displayed ammo count, maps, and health all in-game, ensuring that even the inventory management was a tense experience.
Set on the spaceship Ishimura, you take control of engineer Issac Clarke who is searching for his missing girlfriend, Nicole. The game has survival horror elements to it, but the real scares come from what you have to spend your resources on.
The Necromorphs are Cronenberg-esque body horror atrocities. Uniquely, Dead Space has you strategically blasting limbs off to over power the Necromorphs. So be prepared for panic shooting and tense moments when you get suddenly swarmed.
With a claustrophobic feeling throughout, and a focus on creepy sound design, Dead Space is a very scary take on action that holds up unbelievably well, 12 years after its original release.
Both sequels are also available on EA Play (via Game Pass Ultimate), but they are more action based than the original offering. They are great games in their own right, but neither come close to the horror of Issac’s original grotesque space adventure.