Xbox One X: 10 Critical Reactions You Need To Know

The world's most powerful console...for a price.

By Jack Pooley /

Microsoft

It's certainly been a long time coming, but the world's most powerful games console is finally here. The Xbox One X is now available the world over, and over the last few days critics have been drip-feeding their in-progress impressions of the unit.

Advertisement

It's safe to say that the console is a major coup for Microsoft in many ways, and though far from a perfect 4K gaming device, will be an undeniably irresistible temptation to those wanting to get involved with cutting edge gaming without requiring a PC.

Though the console itself performs well technically, the ultimate gauge of the One X's success won't be realised for a while, as it depends entirely upon how Microsoft rebounds next year after a rather lackluster 2017, at least as far as meaty exclusives are concerned.

Advertisement

The One X certainly proves they've got the technical horsepower to drop some AAA megaton reveals at E3, so hopefully they'll take full advantage. Right now, though, nobody could blame you for holding off on buying Microsoft's shiny new device, because it clearly has plenty left to prove...

10. It's An Incredible 4K Gaming Device

Microsoft
"The Xbox One X performs exactly as advertised: Games look great across the board. Whether you’re using a 1080p TV with the Xbox One X or playing in 4K HDR, games look fantastic on the next-gen console... Games you might have played a year ago now look absolutely stunning on Xbox One X. Free updates for Rise of the Tomb Raider, Star Wars Battlefront II and Forza Motorsport 7 will help them look their absolute best when they arrive in the coming weeks and months, while Gears of War 4, Quantum Break and Super Lucky’s Tale have already been treated to the visual upgrade." - Techradar
"One of the biggest improvements I noticed when an Enhanced for Xbox One X update arrived was Assassin's Creed Origins. It looks stunning on the Xbox One X, with a 4K resolution and HDR support. It’s way less blurry than on my Xbox One S, and I’d say it’s closer to looking like it does on my PC thanks to the obvious improvements in textures...I hope this is a shining example of what’s to come from developers on newer games." - The Verge
"Gears 4 is one of Microsoft’s flagship games, and it’s a showpiece for the capabilities of the Xbox One X. The 2016 shooter is stunning in Visuals mode, which runs at native 4K with graphical bells and whistles like a higher draw distance, better 'god rays' and HDR...But I prefer Performance mode, which leaves the resolution at 1080p while targeting a frame rate of 60 frames per second." - Polygon

It seems that, for the most part, the Xbox One X absolutely lives up to Microsoft's claim that it's the most powerful video game console on the market, delivering an unrivaled 4K experience.

Advertisement

Praise has been leveled at the console's ability to enhance games both old and brand new, and simply, if you've recently bought a 4K TV, this is one hell of a device to show it off.

If you're serious about getting the most out of your games and don't want the hassle involved with a gaming PC, this is a damn fine system.

Advertisement

9. The 1TB Hard Drive Is Too Small

Microsoft
"Where the One X falters is on its hard drive - a small 1TB drive that comes standard in every system... Its 1TB hard drive might seem like enough room to store your entire library but, consider the fact that all these new Enhanced for Xbox One X titles use 4K image assets, and suddenly 1TB doesn't seem so big any more. Gears of War 4, for example, takes up 100GB on the Xbox One X. Another flagship Xbox game, Forza Motorsport 7, will be about the same when it releases its patch. Quantum Break, the Sci-Fi shooter from the studio behind Alan Wake, comes in at an internet crippling 178GB. Together, three of the Xbox One X’s most popular games will take up around 40% of your hard drive space." - Techradar
"The unit contains a 1 TB hard drive, and only 780.9 GB of it is accessible to users; when I booted it up for the first time, 780.8 GB of free space was available...Count yourself lucky if you already own a large external hard drive, because it almost feels necessary." - Polygon
"When a game does take full advantage of everything the One X can do, there’s a downside: 4K textures are huge...The One X has a one-terabyte internal hard drive (with no larger option), but at this rate that’s going to be consumed just as quickly as the original Xbox One’s 500GB. Storage space can be easily expanded with any USB hard drive, but if you don’t already own one that’s an extra expense you have to account for on top of this already premium-priced console." - IGN

An area where the One X has been almost universally criticised is its 1TB hard drive, which is ludicrously small considering the size of modern games, and moreover, modern games working off 4K textures.

Advertisement

It won't take long at all for a hard drive to fill up, and so it's recommended that if you've splashed cash on the console, you may as well throw a little more around to pick up a larger hard drive too.

This is especially bizarre as the Xbox One S has a 2TB model, yet there's no such option for the One X. It's further odd considering a lot of people purchasing the One X will be people who don't want the fiddling and tweaking involved with setting up a gaming PC, yet may end up forced to install a new hard drive in their shiny new console...or settle for an external.

Advertisement

8. 4K Media Support Is Strong

Netflix
"Like the One S before it, the One X is now the most appealing console for home theater enthusiasts thanks to its ultra-HD Blu-ray drive and Dolby Atmos audio support. That ability to play 4K movies off of physical media is something the competing PS4 Pro strangely doesn’t offer." - IGN
"Beyond gaming, the console is also perfect for media junkies - there’s 4K Netflix on-board alongside a 4K app for YouTube, Amazon will make its Prime Video app UHD compatible starting on November 7 and, when all else fails, there’s a 4K Blu-ray player built into the box - a feature that no other console maker has at the moment. The console also supports Dolby Atmos audio, among other audio formats, making video playback sound as good as it looks." - Techradar
"Aside from games, the Xbox One X is also an entertainment center of sorts. The 4K Blu-ray drive will bring you crisp movies with Dolby Atmos and HDR 10 (but no Dolby Vision) support, and it’s an addition the PS4 Pro lacks." - The Verge

Though Microsoft has taken a few steps back from their arguably excessive obsession with media support in the past, the One X nevertheless takes good care of users who want to watch 4K video content on the platform.

Advertisement

In addition to the litany of apps, the console comes with a 4K Blu-ray drive, something even the PS4 Pro hilariously doesn't have, ensuring that you can play UHD Blu-rays without needing to buy an expensive additional player.

Simply, the One X is a great all-rounder, primed not only for 4K games but eye-popping 4K video also.

Advertisement

7. Loading Times Are A Mixed Bag

True Achievements
"In terms of loading times, we saw an extended Witcher 3 load drop from one minute 45 seconds to just 45 seconds - remarkably, Xbox One X shaved off an entire minute. A fast travel jump in the same game also saw loading times drop from 45 seconds on a base Xbox One to just 19 on Xbox One X." - Eurogamer
"Loading the first campaign level of the native 4K-enhanced version of Gears of War 4 took the One X roughly 20 seconds, compared to 10 seconds for the standard version on a One S. On unenhanced games, loading times appeared inconsistent in our tests so far. Some were quicker on the X than on the S, and others were slower. We’ll keep testing this on other games." - IGN
"On a launch Xbox One, Middle-earth: Shadow of War took 51 seconds to load a save from the main menu; the Xbox One X cut that almost in half, to 28 seconds...The Xbox One X’s loading advantages were much more marginal for Xbox 360 games. The system shaved just two seconds off the loading times for a Battlefield: Bad Company 2 campaign mission and the open-world racer Burnout Paradise. And I couldn’t tell much of a difference in terms of performance or image quality, at least for those two titles." - Polygon

One of the more interesting responses from the reviews so far is the wildly mixed response to the unit's loading times.

Advertisement

In slightly older games without 4K enhancement, load times seem to be substantially reduced, while games with 4K enhancements enabled sometimes take longer than the One S due the additional required texture load-in.

As for backwards compatibility, the loading difference sadly seems to be pretty negligible, and though overall there's not a clear, objective conclusion on how the One X performs under every loading condition, it's fair to say that it's impressive and disappointing in different areas.

Advertisement

6. The Design Is Fantastic

Microsoft
"Let’s start with the basics. I’m really impressed and surprised at how much power Microsoft has managed to squeeze into the Xbox One X’s small case. While the original Xbox One was a big, black box about the size of an old-school VCR, the Xbox One X matches the impressive design of the Xbox One S." - The Verge
"If you’ve never seen a One S before, the Xbox One X is a rectangular box the size of a large Blu-ray player that’s coated with a matte space grey color. It’s a far cry from the bulky VHS player-stylings of the original Xbox One, and the design only becomes more impressive when you consider what’s under the hood." - Techradar
"The console measures 30 x 24 x 6 cm (11.8 x 9.5 x 2.4 inches), which technically makes it the smallest Xbox console yet. This is really impressive when you consider the fact that it has an integrated power supply unit, like the Xbox One S before it. This means that you don't have to deal with an obnoxiously large external power brick like with the original Xbox One." - Gamespot

It's borderline-insane how incredibly well-designed the One X is, packing such a ludicrous amount of hardware into such a small unit, all the more so considering how bulky the original Xbox One was.

Advertisement

There's a pretty consistent sentiment of bafflement among critics, who largely deem the form factor a jaw-dropping work of technical engineering, though hopefully its tightly-packed nature isn't to blame for reports of some day-one units failing after just a few hours of use.

5. Supersampling Is Great For HDTV Owners

Bungie
"If you’re a 1080p TV owner, the Xbox One X will do something called supersampling to create better-looking images...The game renders itself in 4K thinking it’s connected to a 4K screen, which means objects are rendered with four times the detail. All this data can’t be displayed because, at the end it’s still being shown on a 1080p TV with a set number of pixels on its display, but the resulting image is one that is more detail-rich...Once you see a game running in 1080p with supersampling it’s very obvious that it looks better than a game running in standard 1080p." - Techradar
"1080p TVs will see benefits to pure performance. I played Destiny 2 on the Xbox One X and it felt a lot smoother than on my Xbox One S. It’s still locked to 30fps, but some of the frame rate dips I’d experienced during Destiny’s raid or public events were gone. Some games without One X-specific updates, like Destiny 2 at this point, will still see performance improvements and better texture filtering on the One X." - The Verge
"We can confirm that of the limited X-enhanced 4K titles we played, they did indeed super-sample down to 1080p, offering exceptional anti-aliasing. It's a boon for sure, but running the X-enhanced Gears of War 4 on a 4K HDR display, the improvement to the experience is simply phenomenal. That's what the machine was built for, and that's where it shines. Clearly, there are benefits running Xbox One X on a full HD screen, but to be frank, it's nothing like the full-fat experience." - Eurogamer

Though the prospect of buying something as expensive as a One X to only play it on an HDTV seems absolutely loony, the results are nevertheless solidly impressive.

Advertisement

Due to the console's impressive supersampling technique, even those playing in 1080p will notice a decent visual upgrade, with textures being crisper and frame-rates of course running smoother.

Simply, if you've bought a One X but are still waiting for your 4K TV to be delivered in a few days, you'll still feel the console's benefits in the mean time.

Advertisement

4. The Launch Lineup Is Underwhelming

Playful
"My biggest issue with the Xbox One X is a lack of stunning 4K games to really show why this is worth $499...Microsoft doesn’t have a single launch exclusive for this console, and while enhancements to old games are great, I often found it hard to even notice big differences because I don’t think some of these games were designed with 4K textures in mind. There’s no big blockbuster game I can only play on the Xbox One X right now, and Microsoft isn’t offering up much hope for the future, either." - The Verge
"While we've had a generous amount of time with the Xbox One X hardware, the fact is that high-profile X-enhanced titles available for us to test during the review period have been disappointingly thin on the ground." - Eurogamer

Another common sentiment among critics was that as gorgeous as games do indeed look on the One X, the lack of big marquee games available for its release is extremely disappointing.

Advertisement

The console isn't launching with any AAA system-sellers day one, which undeniably takes some of the wind out of its sails compared to if, say, Halo 6 were a launch title.

Many critics also lamented the lack of notable X-enhanced titles available during the review period, though in fairness this seems likely to change in the coming weeks.

Advertisement

Fingers crossed the E3 shows off some real jaw-dropping games to make use of the One X's full potential, but sadly that's quite a wait.

3. It's Impressively Quiet

Microsoft
"Hooking up Xbox One X to a 4K HDR display (we tested with a mid-range Panasonic DX750 and an LG OLED B6) and booting up Gears of War 4, what's immediately apparent is that, with our review unit at least, this console is eerily quiet...It would be remiss of us not to mention that, as quiet as the console is under load, it's even more discreet when running in its various backwards compatibility modes." - Eurogamer
"It’s also as remarkably quiet as the One S, even when it’s working hard, and never got warm enough that overheating in a confined space would be a concern." - IGN

With so much being packed into such a relatively small box, it would've been no surprise at all if the One X ended up sounding like a jet engine, especially with so many reports of the PS4 Pro being overly noisy.

Advertisement

As it stands, early reviews suggest that the One X is whisper-quiet to the point that it's honestly unsettling, especially considering the sheer amount of processing magic that's going on underneath the hood.

However many souls Microsoft sacrificed to make this work, it was totally worth it.

Advertisement

2. The Price Is The Biggest Obstacle

Microsoft
"I’ve gotten this far without discussing the console’s $499 price, which is the primary obstacle to its mainstream success — even more so than the issue of how many potential buyers do or don’t own a 4K TV. Microsoft is certainly betting on the Xbox One X’s gaming performance; that’s why the company felt comfortable launching the console a year after the PS4 Pro. But with Sony saying that it left a 4K Blu-ray drive out of the PS4 Pro in an effort to keep the console’s price below $400, you have to wonder why Microsoft didn’t make the same cost-cutting sacrifice." - Polygon
"For most folks, the One X imposes a premium tax on a system that’s only marginally better in most ways than the cheaper Xbox One S...While the Xbox One X has claimed the new top spot, its closest competitors - the PlayStation 4 Pro and Xbox One S - aren’t far behind. Despite not being able to play games in native 4K, these consoles are around half the price and look nearly as good. Their better balance between affordability and performance will make them a better pick for the vast majority of gamers out there, save for the few who see and appreciate the minor differences in premium, high-octane video quality and lower grade, but-still-awesome upscaled 4K." - Techradar
"The One X costs $500, while [PS4 Pro] launched at $400. That high price limits the Xbox One X to diehard Microsoft fans who don't mind paying a bit more to play the console's exclusive titles in 4K. Everyone else might be better off waiting, or opting for the $279 Xbox One S." - Engadget
"While the Xbox One X is an expensive box, from a hardware standpoint, you're getting a very powerful and capable machine. You'll be hard pressed to build a comparably powerful PC for $500. On top of that, you get a 4K HDR Blu-ray player, which can cost several hundred dollars on its own." - Gamespot

Unsurprisingly, the biggest hurdle facing players actually getting the One X in their hands is the price, which while impressive for the hardware it offers, is still outside the reach of most gamers, especially given the cheaper prices of the PS4 Pro and Xbox One S.

Advertisement

It seems unlikely that the One X will get a price drop any time soon as Microsoft seems totally comfortable with it being a unit for tech enthusiasts, so unless you really care about maximum visual fidelity from your console, the One X probably isn't for you.

1. Hardcore Gamers Will Love It, Casuals Won't

The Coalition
"If you game on a 1080p TV and don't have any plans to upgrade to a 4K one, the Xbox One S is going to be a better fit for you...But what if you already own a 4K HDR TV and an Xbox One? In this case, I'd only recommend getting the X if you have the disposable cash to spare for the increased visual fidelity and performance benefits. If you have a 4K HDR TV, don't have a current gen console, and are looking to purchase one, however, the Xbox One X is a great choice." - Gamespot
"The jump from 1080p to 4K isn’t as profound as SD to HD, and I found it hard to always notice the difference at the distance from my TV. Maybe that will change once more enhanced games are available, but I don’t think most people will be able to notice a big difference just yet. Games will need to be tweaked and fully optimized for the Xbox One X hardware, and you already get the benefits of HDR on the Xbox One S." - The Verge
"If you’re the kind of gamer who stops to look at the scenic vistas in games like Skyrim, The Witcher or Dragon Age, or a streamer who can point out a 4 frame-per-second difference while looking at two videos side by side, the Xbox One X is a worthwhile investment. That said, if you’re a gamer who just wants a console that plays great-looking games without digging too deep into your pocket books, the Xbox One X is a bit overkill - save some money and buy yourself an Xbox One S...preferably the one with a 2TB hard drive." - Techradar

All this considered, the advice from most outlets is that more casual gamers and those who don't own a 4K TV should probably leave the One X alone and pick up one of the aforementioned alternatives instead.

Advertisement

Those with a few hundred bucks to burn who have already invested in a 4K TV and don't own an Xbox One yet? This console will give you everything you could possibly want.

This was pretty much the response most commentators expected when the console's specs and price were first announced, and now it's confirmed: the One X has limited casual appeal, and that's perfectly fine because Microsoft clearly knows it.

Advertisement

What do you make of the Xbox One X reviews? Got one yourself? Shout it out in the comments!