10 Horror Movies That Switch The Main Character Halfway
Wait, who's the hero again?
Even though horror can be rife with clichés, the genre always finds ways to catch everybody off-guard. Jump-scares, plot twists, and vibrant gore have been utilised, not just to scare the audience, but to unnerve them.
However, an easy way to throw off horror fans is to remove one element that's often considered to be set in stone; the protagonist. No matter how many monsters, ghosts, or killers are thrown at the lead, viewers are confident that character will make it through, since they are the anchor of the narrative.
And yet, some films flip the script by discarding the hero or so-called Final Girl at the halfway point. Not only does this decision challenge traditional storytelling conventions, it can amplify the scares, since it demonstrates the principal character is (or was) just as vulnerable as anyone else. Although horror can be bogged down by tropes, pulling a narrative shift like this can reinvigorate the story, since viewers won't know what's going to happen next or who to root for.
Though the entries on this list are classified as main characters, they didn't maintain that role for very long.
10. Feast
In Feast, a group of strangers are barricaded inside a remote bar, which is surrounded by flesh-eating monsters.
The set-up for this underrated horror-comedy couldn't be simpler, but the way it plays out is anything but. Viewers will know things aren't what they seem when the supposed protagonist, who's simply called Hero, has his head lopped off before the minor characters get introduced. The spotlight then switches to his wife, Heroine, who attempts to take charge of the dire situation.
As the tusked beasties pick off the patrons, everyone is counting on Heroine to see them through. But when she meets her maker, the survival rate of the remaining ensemble starts looking pretty slim.
Suddenly, Tuffy the waitress goes into Leader Mode, banding the group together and destroying the critters once and for all. This moment comes out of nowhere, since Tuffy appeared irreversibly traumatised after the monsters slaughtered her son.
What makes this unanticipated turn better is how Tuffy's transition is presented. As she starts kicking butt, a text appears on-screen, changing Tuffy's name to "Heroine 2". In that moment, she officially discards her role as a bit-part, and embraces her new role as a messiah.
9. Barbarian
Upon its release, Zach Cregger's Barbarian instantly became one of the most talked about films of 2022. Because of this psychological thriller's subversive structure and misleading setup, it's best to go in blind.
Barbarian kicks off with two strangers, Tess (Georgina Campbell) and Keith (Bill Skarsgard) discovering they have both booked a rental home on the same night. Due to Keith's seemingly creepy nature, Tess is immediately suspicious of him. And when she discovers a hidden room and a subterranean tunnel in the basement, it feels like her worst fears are about to be realised.
Although viewers are expecting Keith to be revealed as the hero or villain, it turns out he is neither. After he decides to explore the tunnel, a naked woman appears from behind Keith, pulverising his skull into a rock.
Before viewers have a chance to process what they just witnessed, the scene cuts to a completely different scenario, involving a new character called AJ (Justin Long). From here on out, AJ serves as the new joint-protagonist, alongside Tess.
However, many watchers struggled to follow AJ's storyline at first, since they're still reeling from Keith's abrupt departure.
8. Death Proof
Quentin Tarantino's grindhouse feature opens with our "protagonist" Julia hanging out at a bar with her gal-pals. While they catch up, professional driver Stuntman Mike (Kurt Russell) manages to worm his way into the ladies' conversation.
Because a good 40 minutes is spent fleshing out this lot, there's little reason to doubt they are the main ensemble.
However, anyone with that mindset is in for a rude awakening. When the bar closes, Mike agrees to give a lift to Julia's friend, Pam. Once he splits her skull in half, the deranged daredevil sets his sights on the rest of the group. After catching up with Julia's car, Mike rams his vehicle into hers, eviscerating the women in glorious fashion. In that moment, every central character is dead, save for the villain.
And yet, the movie still has over an hour to kill. Death Proof suddenly cuts to a year later, with Stuntman Mike hunting another quartet of females. This assemblage fairs far better than Mike's previous victims, killing the maniacal stuntman during the picture's climax.
Even though Tarantino is known for his disjointed stories, Death Proof's jumbled narrative threw everyone for a loop.
7. Identity
Even after 20 years, Identity's ingenious bait-and-switch has lost none of its power. The story centres around Ed Dakota (John Cusack) and nine other strangers stuck in an isolated motel during a storm. When people start dying, the group realise there is a killer among them.
To add to the confusion, the film keeps cutting to a psychiatrist called Malick speaking to the authorities about convicted serial killer, Malcolm Rivers. On the first watch, viewers haven't a clue how this subplot is connected to the overall story. When Malick brings out Malcolm later on, viewers are left scratching their head, since he doesn't resemble any of the characters from the motel.
When Dakota seemingly blacks out, he finds himself in the presence of Malick and the police. To his horror, Dakota discovers he and everyone else in the motel is a figment of Malcolm's imagination. Due to his troubled childhood, Malcolm's personality split into fragments, one of which happens to have murderous tendencies.
Although viewers speculated on what role Malcolm would play when he was introduced, nobody was expecting him to be the secret main character.
6. From Dusk Till Dawn
In Robert Rodriguez's supernatural thriller, bank-robbing siblings Seth (George Clooney) and Richie Gecko (Quentin Tarantino) find themselves on the run after a botched murder. The pair kidnap pastor Jacob Fuller (Harvey Keitel) and his kids, ordering the family to drive them all to Mexico.
After getting through the border, the criminals and Jacob's family settle in at a sleazy nightclub. When the club's patrons and hosts turn out to be bloodthirsty vampires, the Geckos and the Fullers form an unsteady alliance to survive.
Now, there's no question Seth is a scumbag. But since this foul-mouth degenerate is nifty with firearms and has no qualms with killing, he proves to be an exceptional vampire slayer.
Although Jacob would be the hero in a more conventional story, he's simply not as resourceful as his kidnapper. And when Jacob becomes vampirized, Seth is the only one capable of getting out of this mess.
At the break of dawn, Seth and Jacob's daughter, Kate, are the only ones left standing. Even though things started with Seth being the antagonist, circumstances indirectly turned him into the story's saviour.
5. I Came By
I Came By follows a political activist and street artist called Toby (1917's George MacKay). At nightfall, Toby breaks into the houses of elite aristocrats, spraying graffiti on the walls to denounce their hypocrisy.
After entering the home of respected judge Hector Blake (Hugh Bonnerville), George discovers a tortured man has been imprisoned in the basement. In a panic, Toby heads home and calls the police, telling them what he found at Blake's home.
When his claims are dismissed, Toby warns his mother Lizzie about what happened, but she refuses to listen. Taking matters into his own hands, Toby heads back to the house to free Blake's prisoner. Shortly after arriving, the insidious judge bludgeons him with a cricket bat.
With Toby is out of the picture, it makes sense that his mother would become the new lead. And since the narrative shifts to Lizzie's perspective at this point, that seems to be case.
But almost immediately after Lizzie becomes the main character, she's killed off! After that, Toby's best friend Jay becomes the third protagonist. Although there aren't many films that change the main character halfway through, I Came By is one of the few to switch it up twice.
4. Annabelle: Creation
Annabelle: Creation is the sequel to the first spin-off of The Conjuring.
After Samuel and Esther Mullins open their home to a group of orphans, the house is plagued by strange occurrences. One child - polio-stricken girl Janice - notices the paranormal phenomena stems from a doll called Annabelle, who harbours a dark spirit.
Because she's often isolated from the others, Janice proves to be easy pray for the demon. Before she has a chance to uncover the truth, the evil entity possesses Janice, using her body as a conduit to attack others.
With Janice out of commission, her best friend Linda does all she can to destroy the malignant fiend. Realising the threat she poses, the supernatural being uses Janice's body to target Linda, forcing the friends to fight each other.
Unable to free Janice from the demon's influence, Linda leaves her friend, never to see her again. After Linda is taken in by another orphanage (with no demons this time), it looks like she got a happy ending.
Sadly, the same can't be said about Janice. The epilogue cuts to 12 years later, with the malevolent spirit still in control of her body, with the Janice that Linda once knew long-gone.
3. 28 Weeks Later
28 Weeks Later opens with Don (Robert Carlyle) and his wife Alice being attacked by a horde of Rage-infected maniacs. To save himself, Don flees in a boat, leaving Alice to die.
When the outbreak is neutralised six months later, Don is brought to a safe zone, where he finds his children Tammy and Andy. Shortly after, the family discovers Alice survived her encounter with the Infected.
Not only that, Alice is revealed to be asymptomatic to the Rage virus, meaning her blood can create a vaccine. With Don's family reunited and the crisis supposedly averted, things are starting to look up.
But after Don kisses his infected wife, she passes the Rage onto him. After Don turns into a mindless monster, he slaughters his wife immediately afterward.
Don then creates a new legion of Infected, leaving the city in total anarchy. From this moment on, the plot focuses on Tammy and Andy trying to escape before the military firebombs the city.
Because Robert Carlyle is an A-List star and his character opens the film, it's a safe bet the story would revolve around his character. As a result, watching Don succumb to the virus and transform into the main villain was a shocker.
2. Alien
For over 40 years, Ellen Ripley has been an icon of not just in sci-fi, but of cinema, period. Because of her resilience, independence, and adaptability, it's easy to see how this Xenomorph-killing badass has stood the test of time.
But when she debuted in Alien, there was little reason to believe she was a primary character, not to mention the sole survivor by the end of the film. Although there is no definitive protagonist at first, Ripley is near the bottom of the pecking order. Dallas is the spaceship's captain, Kane is the head officer, Lambert is the navigator, and Parker is the chief engineer. Because Ripley is a warrant officer, she has less responsibility or clout than anyone else.
Despite her low station, Ripley repeatedly proves to be the most resourceful and determined, which is why she outlives her crew and defeats the dreaded starbeast singlehandedly.
Ripley's transition into a protagonist was also unexpected because... well...the 1970s were a different time. Since it was commonplace for sci-fi to depict women as fetishised damsels in distresses, it was groundbreaking for Ripley to break gender stereotypes and triumph over an unkillable antagonist after everyone else failed.
1. Martyrs
In Martyrs, a child called Lucie escapes from an undisclosed location where she was maliciously tortured for years. After befriending young Anna at an orphanage, Lucie vows to punish the people who made her life a living hell.
As an adult, Lucie tracks down her tormentors, a seemingly regular family, and kills them with a shotgun. When their deaths bring her no peace, Lucie takes her own life, despite Anna's best efforts to save her.
Since the major conflict revolves around Lucie, her sudden exit is a massive WTF moment. Because Anna isn't as compelling, first-time viewers might think the film will take a nose-dive after she takes centre-stage.
Astonishingly, Martyrs becomes more gripping (and far more disturbing) once Lucie kicks the bucket. While Anna tries to make sense of it all, she finds herself caught in the middle of a global conspiracy. Although Lucie experienced unspeakable horrors, it is nowhere near as unsettling as what this sinister cabal has planned for Anna.
At first, it was disappointing to see Lucie bite the dust, since she was such a riveting character. However, her demise was crucial, since it opened the doorway to an even more heart-wrenching story.