20 Horror Movies That Fall Apart In The Final Act
Saw X's final reels needed a rethink.
A frustrating trend throughout all of horror cinema is this: so many films can't quite stick the landing, even ones that are otherwise really great. The thing is, when an entire story builds up so much suspense and fear, it can be difficult to pay all of that off in a satisfying way. For example, there's a good reason we never saw the Witch in The Blair Witch Project - nothing could've lived up to such a build-up.
Unfortunately, many other horror movies fail to come up with good final acts, and the following 20 pictures are some dispiriting examples of this. They vary heavily, ranging from remakes to sequels, from big studio productions to smaller indie flicks - what they've all got in common is that they reaffirm how difficult it can be to end a horror film.
And the worst thing of all? A lot of these movies were actually pretty darn good before they fell apart in the final stretch, making them wildly disappointing viewing experiences. You really do hate to see it. Kicking off with a little something from James Gunn...
20. The Belko Experiment
We often complain about movies being too long, but what about when a movie is too short? That's definitely a thing as well, and a good example of this is the James Gunn-penned death game horror The Belko Experiment, in which 80 office workers are forced to fight to the death.
This one is only 90 minutes long, and it should've been at least two hours. The first hour takes its time and builds up the tension and workplace dynamics really well, but around the hour mark, it all descends into a mindless kill streak that quickly becomes exhausting to watch. This means any real characterisation falls to the wayside and the picture ultimately concludes with a rather contrived sequence in which sole survivor Mike (John Gallagher Jr.) kills the soldiers who oversaw the game.
The very end of the film did set up a sequel, although none has ever materialized. If a belated follow-up did indeed emerge - and, given the recent popularity of other death game stories such as Squid Game, that isn't impossible - then hopefully next time the story would be given more room to breathe. Come to think of it, maybe a TV season would suit the material better?
19. Watcher
For its first two-thirds, Chloe Okuno's debut feature Watcher is awesome. Telling the story of Julia (Maika Monroe), an American living in Bucharest, who becomes convinced that Daniel (Burn Gorman), a creepy neighbour, is a serial killer, this takes admittedly familiar material and turns it into something special with the aid of nail-biting direction and another cracking performance from Monroe, who continues to prove herself as one of our greatest modern scream queens.
Much of this echoes Alfred Hitchcock in the best kind of way, but alas, Watcher can't quite sustain itself all the way to the end.
After toying with the audience's expectations throughout, Watcher goes down the most generic route. It eventually turns out that, yes, Daniel is indeed a serial killer who, of course, goes after Julia in the form of a bog-standard climax that's so much less interesting than all of the excellent material earlier in the film. In this particular case, it would've been better to try and do something different, for this really was the most predictable of final acts.
18. 13 Sins
13 Sins, a remake of the Thai horror comedy 13 Beloved, starts out as a solid enough Death Game horror, yet it goes too far by the end and veers into overly icky territory that contrasts excessively with the rest of the story.
In this one, salesman Elliott (Mark Webber) loses his job and finds himself in dire financial straits. He then receives a phone call saying that, to kill a fly, he'll get $1,000. He does so and is then told to eat the fly, thus earning him even more money. The caller then gives him a challenge: complete 11 more tasks, and he'll receive a huge sum of money. If he fails to complete any, interferes in the game, or reveals the game to the authorities, he forfeits it all.
And so, Elliott is forced to complete a series of increasingly horrid challenges, and while these stay on just the right side of uncomfortable for much of the story, it eventually goes overboard. The last challenge is to kill a family member, and it's revealed that Michael (Devon Graye), Elliott's mentally challenged brother, is also competing in the game and tries to kill his own brother, forcing Elliott to kill Michael in self-defence.
This was all just far too uncomfortable, and much like Elliott when he ate that fly, audience members will have a nasty taste in their mouth when 13 Sins finally concludes.
17. Censor
Censor, the debut feature of Prano Bailey-Bond, is a rather mixed affair. There's a lot of great stuff within it, but the disparate elements of the story never quite gel together.
The movie revolves around Enid (Niamh Algar), a censor for the BBFC who's screening films at the height of the Video Nasty crisis, and she faces various controversies and threats due to her work here. She's also dealing with her trauma regarding the childhood disappearance of her young sister, who she may or may not have killed herself.
Censor juggles these two plotlines with limited success, meaning that this flick often feels like two different stories fighting for prominence, before the stuff involving Enid's work as a censor - the far more interesting element of the picture - largely falls to the wayside by the end.
The final act, which sees Enid trying to find an actress who resembles her missing sister while she completely loses her grip on reality, has some terrific visuals but is ultimately a bit of a mess, showering the viewer with a load of abstract surrealism that doesn't actually say anything very much, making this a frustrating and confusing watch in the worst kind of way.
Furthermore, Censor seems to imply that Enid's work watching extreme movies has driven her mad. Given how much censorship certain films have faced and continue to face due to unfair controversies about their content, this message is questionable at best and grossly misjudged at worst.
16. The Pale Blue Eye
The Pale Blue Eye, a horror-mystery about detective Augustus Landor (Christian Bale) teaming up with a young Edgar Allan Poe (Harry Melling) to investigate a series of murders at a military academy, joins the long list of initially promising movies ruined by a bad plot twist. You'll see a few others further along this list.
We all love a good twist, but it's far better to play things straight than to ruin everything with a contrived reveal that negates the preceding film altogether. A twist just for the sake of it is no good at all, as The Pale Blue Eye reaffirms. Prior to the third act, this is an absolutely solid mystery with two dynamite lead turns from Christian Bale and Harry Melling in particular, and it was so frustrating to watch the movie implode in the final stretch.
While the murders initially seem to have been committed by a family practicing dark magic, Poe subsequently deduces that Landor killed the soldiers instead. The three victims had assaulted his daughter, leading to her suicide, and he was seeking revenge.
To give credit where it's due, this was an ambitious twist, but it just didn't work overall. It negated the rest of the story by suddenly making the main character the villain, and it felt more like a smug attempt to seem clever than anything else.
15. Candyman (2021)
2021's Candyman legacy sequel is in a similar boat to The Belko Experiment, in that 90 minutes wasn't enough time to tell the story this movie wanted to tell.
In this one, Chicago-based artist Anthony (Yahya Abdul-Mateen II) becomes obsessed with the Candyman legend, and this inadvertently releases a new wave of Candyman murders, albeit ones carried out by a different spirit to the one seen in the older films. As this movie explains, there's actually a Candyman Hive, with multiple ghosts of wronged African-Americans wreaking vengeance on the living.
For a while, Candyman (2021) is absolutely fine, then it stuffed around an hour's worth of story into the final half-hour, and the whole enterprise fell apart. Things such as Anthony transforming into a new Candyman and the reveal that a supporting character named William (Colman Domingo) is trying to facilitate this are painfully rushed, too many things are left unexplained (for example, why did Anthony start transforming into Candyman after being stung by a bee?), and the original Candyman (the late, great Tony Todd) is given an insultingly brief cameo of just a few seconds.
Unsurprisingly, no further Candyman movies have emerged since.
14. Halloween (2007)
Rob Zombie's Halloween remake is an over-hated flick and then some. Sure, it misses the point of the original by giving Michael Myers (here played by Tyler Mane) a backstory, but at least, unlike most horror remakes from this era, it bothered to do something different and to be its own thing. Furthermore, the first half of the movie is punchy and effective in its own right, and it has some of the Halloween franchise's most unsettling outbreaks of violence, too.
Unfortunately, it does run out of gas once it catches up with the original film and tries to recreate Michael's Haddonfield rampage. In contrast to the original film's bravura sequences of sustained tension, the remake's equivalent is a scare-free affair that coasts along on gore and gratuitous female nudity. It also drags out for far too long and becomes increasingly repetitive.
Apparently, Rob Zombie was far more enthused about the idea of making a prequel about Michael Myers' early years rather than a straight-up remake, and that definitely shows in the finished film. There is so much more passion and artistic flair in the earlier sequences.
13. Last Night In Soho
Edgar Wright's Last Night in Soho is visually exquisite and excellently performed, but the script needed a rewrite or two. In stark contrast to the ingenious writing of the Cornetto Trilogy, this screenplay had multiple issues, the most prominent one being a misjudged final act that upends the story and contradicts its themes, too.
In this one, fashion student Ellie (Thomasin McKenzie) starts having visions of Sandy (Anya Taylor-Joy), an aspiring model in 1960s London who was forced into prostitution and then murdered by an abusive club manager named Jack (Matt Smith).
A slowly unravelling Ellie tries to find Jack and avenge Sandy. At first, Jack appears to be a regular in the pub Ellie works in (played by the late, great Terence Stamp), but as we only learn at the end, this was all a massive red herring. In fact, Ellie's seemingly harmless landlady Ms. Collins (Diana Rigg, another late British great) is Sandy, and she killed Jack, not the other way around. She's been killing other men who abused her for years.
This is one of those twists that gets worse and worse the more you think about it. It is an effective shock during the first viewing, but it also breaks the story by raising too many questions. Namely, why did Ellie's visions lie to her? It also undermines what was previously a story that condemned misogyny by turning Sandy into a villainous serial killer who tries to murder the innocent Ellie at the end.
12. Heart Eyes
Heart Eyes is an intriguing and unique fusion of slasher flick and romantic comedy that started out pretty well before coming undone by the end. Why? Well, in terms of its villains, it went down the Scream route of having known characters revealed as the villains at the end, and it fatally bungled this part of the story.
In this case, there are three killers. One is unmasked earlier on, and that one is a character unknown to viewers, but as for the other two? They're so obvious it kind of hurts.
It turns out that the killers are Detective Jeannine Shaw (The Fast and the Furious' Jordana Brewster) and police IT technician David (Yoson An), who are revealed to be a couple that gets off on murdering other couples. This surprised precisely no one, as there'd been an earlier scene where Jeannine had been attacked by the killer, but the confrontation was left off-screen before she showed up later, largely unharmed aside from an injured arm.
As for David, he was only in one scene, but that reveal was predictable as well, as the movie paused to linger on this random character when he was introduced. Both of these twists were duds, and even then, the third act of Heart Eyes is far less interesting than the rest of the film, and it wraps up with a pretty forgettable climax.
11. It Chapter Two
The 1990 TV miniseries adaptation of It has often been criticized for its lacklustre finale, so fans hoped that 2019's It Chapter Two would rectify that mistake. They were all disappointed, for history repeated itself.
In the original novel, the defeat of It revolves around a complicated psychological ritual that would've been difficult to replicate on-screen, so it was always going to be a hard thing to adapt. Having said that... surely they could've come up with something better than this? Surely?
In the end, this climax amounted to a stupendously silly CGI slop-fest that felt more like an F-tier MCU final battle than anything else, while the bathos and garbage special effects that plague the rest of this sequel are also very much in evidence. Eventually, the characters defeat Pennywise by telling him they're not scared of him, and this causes him to lose all his power. Why didn't they do this earlier? Have none of Pennywise's victims ever said something like that before? It made no sense.
This had been a rocky picture from the off, yet it was in the final act that it finally confirmed itself as one of the most disappointing horror sequels ever made. The closing scenes with the adult members of the Loser's Club are touching, sure, but that's not enough to make this one any less of a stinker.
10. High Tension
High Tension is perhaps the poster child for an awful plot twist sabotaging a previously successful work. That assessment is overly generous, as the earlier parts of the movie aren't that good either, but there's no denying that this climactic twist was one of the worst ever put to film, and it positively annihilated any good work the earlier parts of the picture had done.
A film from the French New Extremity movement, High Tension is an uber-gory slasher flick in which a truck driver goes on a brutal killing spree, while protagonist Marie (Cécile de France) tries to protect her best friend and secret crush Alexis (Maiwenn) from the murderer. At least, that's how it all seems at first. In fact, as we learn late in the film, Marie is the killer and the truck driver is just a hallucination. She's obsessed with Alexis and killed her family so that she'd have her all to herself.
Alongside being a pointless twist that didn't add anything of value, it negates pretty much the entire movie, as little of what we'd previously seen was real. It's an ending that gave everyone the finger, and not in a good way.
9. Speak No Evil (2024)
Hollywood remakes of foreign-language movies are usually a terrible idea, and one of the biggest problems is how such remakes tend to sanitize the darker elements of the original films. Some stories from overseas contain material that wouldn't fly in a studio flick, which is yet another indicator that it's better just to leave such properties alone and come up with something original instead.
Hollywood being Hollywood, such remakes are still churned out regardless, and, in predictable fashion, 2024's Speak No Evil remake rewrote the ending of the story to give it a happier conclusion. Both stories revolve around a family of three going to stay with a family they met on holiday, and despite the aberrant behaviour of their hosts, they're too frightened of offending them to actually stand up for themselves.
The original movie, a Danish production, was designed by director Christian Tafdrup to be a satire of excessive politeness. In this particular case, the fear of offending anyone leads to the main couple being murdered by their hosts while their daughter is taken captive by them. It's a nasty ending, but it absolutely works as a conveyor of this thematic message.
Unfortunately, 2024's version sees the heroic couple overpower their tormenters in a generic shoot-em-up finale, and this totally missed the point of the entire story. The rest of this remake is actually really solid, so this was a frustrating waste of potential.
8. Escape Room: Tournament Of Champions (Theatrical Cut)
This is an interesting case, as two different versions of Escape Room: Tournament of Champions exist. One version has an entertaining final act with some solid twists. The other, in stark contrast, doesn't just ruin this film, but it also ruins the previous film.
Sadly, and inexplicably, it was the latter version that was sent to cinemas.
In the theatrical cut, all of the competitors in this new game are apparently eliminated until only Zoey (Taylor Russell) is left alive. She finds herself in a child's bedroom and discovers... Amanda (Deborah Ann Woll), one of the players in the original film who'd apparently died in the games. Amanda reveals that she's been blackmailed into designing the escape rooms for this new game and that the organisation now wants Zoey to be their next architect.
What a bloody awful twist. There was absolutely no reason to bring Amanda back, and doing so fatally undermined any semblance of stakes. In fact, Amanda literally says out loud, "If you didn't see it, it didn't happen," just before it turns out that Ben (Logan Miller), the secondary lead, is still alive. Well, there goes any sense of jeopardy.
And then, after the trio manages to escape, we get a bafflingly silly ending where it turns out that the passenger plane Zoey and Ben are on has, somehow, been turned into an escape room. It's no surprise that the series never continued, for there was no coming back from this.
7. Megan Is Missing
Megan is Missing falls into the same category as 13 Sins: its final act goes too far, and the whole thing becomes excessively cruel.
Still, to be fair to 13 Sins, it positively pales in comparison to the horrors that Megan is Missing inflicted on us. This movie is so effed-up it actually went viral on TikTok at one point, and traumatized an awful lot of people as a result.
This found-footage horror follows Amy (Amber Perkins), who's looking for her best friend Megan (Rachel Quinn). Megan went missing after an internet date, and thanks to Lucy's detective work, she eventually ends up being captured by the same predator who took Megan. The final 20 minutes, recorded on a handheld camera, show what happened to the two girls, and it's... a lot.
As seen in the footage, Amy is tortured, sexually assaulted, and then buried alive in a barrel containing Megan's brutalized corpse. This took the movie from a passable watch to a gratuitous and exploitative piece of sadism that might leave viewers feeling genuinely ill. The line in the sand is there for a reason, and sometimes, it's better not to cross it.
6. Saw X
Saw X - in which Jigsaw (Tobin Bell) goes after a group of scam artists who pretended to cure his brain tumour - is one of the best Saw movies, for sure, and most of it is legitimately very good. However, the final act needed work - like, a lot of work.
Towards the end, two of the scam artists break free of their traps and take Jigsaw and his apprentice Amanda Young (Shawnee Smith) hostage. They force Jigsaw and Carlos (Jorge Briseno), a local child whom Jigsaw had befriended, into a final trap before heading into the building's control room to retrieve some money. But, of course, Jigsaw is one step ahead of them, and they've just walked into a new trap, as the room seals and begins to fill with toxic gas, while they activate a tripwire that also frees Jigsaw and Carlos.
In stark contrast to the rest of the picture, this final stretch was just dull, and the traps featured weren't especially imaginative. Furthermore, the main scam artist - Cecelia (Synnove Macody Lund) - suddenly started acting like an OTT, moustache-twirling Bond villain, while these final scenes also make too much of an effort to portray Jigsaw as the good guy, so it all gets a bit weird.
At the very end, Cecelia is left alive and is robbed of a proper ending, further adding to the general sense of anti-climax. The mid-credits scene was good, though, so that's something.
5. Signs
Ever since he blew up with 1999's The Sixth Sense, M. Night Shyamalan has been widely associated with his twist endings. Has this been a good thing for him? Not really.
First up, there is so much more to this inconsistent yet fascinating and over-hated auteur, and worse still, many of his plot twists aren't necessarily all that great. Because he's known as the twist guy, there's an expectation that he has to throw in a plot twist even if said twist completely upends the entire film. That's definitely what happened with Signs.
While there's plenty to love about Shyamalan's alien invasion flick, it's easy to see why it's been so divisive over the years. The big reveals in the third act are questionable to say the least. First up, it turns out that the alien antagonists are susceptible to water... which makes them far too easy to defeat as they have just arrived on a planet that's 70% water.
Secondly, the main twist revolves around a divine intervention saving the main family from a lone alien that breaks into their farmhouse, thus allowing protagonist Graham (Mel Gibson) to regain his faith. Specifically, Graham recalls the death of his wife and her dying words; she said, "Tell Merrill to swing away," and Graham tells his brother Merrill (Joaquin Phoenix) to attack the alien attacker with his baseball bat.
But why did a woman have to die just to inspire someone to use a baseball to attack an intruder?
4. Sunshine
Sunshine is a huge outlier on this list, as it doesn't actually start out as a horror film. It does, however, turn into one in the final stretch, and a very terrible one at that.
It starts out as a gripping sci-fi thriller about a crew trying to reignite the dying sun before devolving into a bland, silly slasher flick. Out of nowhere, it turns out that Pinbacker (a wasted Mark Strong), the now-insane surviving captain from an earlier mission to the sun, has snuck onboard their ship and goes on the rampage. It might've worked had the threat of Pinbacker been built up, but here, he was suddenly thrown in and it was jarring as all hell.
It genuinely feels like the real third act of Sunshine was cut out and the ending reels from a different, vastly inferior movie were thrown in instead, making for a viewing experience that's jarring in the extreme. Watching such a promising film collapse into stupidity right before your eyes is a positively painful experience, and this remains a deserving poster child for potentially great movies killed by a terrible ending.
3. Insidious
Insidious is an important horror flick. It cemented James Wan as one of the industry's most talented horror directors, it helped to put Blumhouse Productions on the map, and crucially, in what was a pretty rough time for the horror genre, it was the rare studio horror flick that was actually, you know, really bloody good, not to mention incredibly scary. Who didn't jump out of their seats when that red demon appeared behind Patrick Wilson?
Nonetheless, for all of Insidious' many, many strengths, it dovetails in the final act, as protagonist Josh Lambert (Patrick Wilson) enters a spirit realm called the Further in order to rescue his son, Dalton (Ty Simpkins). In contrast to the sections set in the physical world, this part of the movie is considerably less scary and not nearly as interesting. As for that previously terrifying red demon, once we actually meet him properly, he looks more like a risible Darth Maul cosplayer than anything else, and he and Josh proceed to have a rather silly fight scene.
Once Josh and Dalton return to the living, the movie bounces back to an extent with a bruising cliffhanger ending that reaffirms Insidious as one of the very first great horror films of the 2010s, flaws and all. Still, it's a shame all of that awesomeness in the earlier parts couldn't have been sustained all the way through.
2. Us
In stark contrast to the unrivalled genius of Get Out, Jordan Peele's sophomore feature is not intelligent in the slightest.
Us, which revolves around an army of clones attacking people across the United States, is an example of how plot holes can single-handedly ruin a film, no matter how good the rest of it is. After all, despite the undeniable brilliance of its visuals and performances, Us doesn't make the slightest bit of sense, and as a result, it's hard to take the movie seriously.
It eventually turns out that the people launching attacks across the US are clones that were initially created in a long-abandoned scientific experiment. Somehow, a clone has been created for seemingly every person in the United States (around 340 million people, for the record). Somehow, they've survived in a network of underground tunnels with no food source aside from an apparently infinite supply of rabbit meat. Somehow, they've organized this big revolution even though they don't seem to have any methods of communication down there.
The unanswered questions are too numerous to ignore, and Peele arguably chose the wrong explanation for its monster. A supernatural, less literal origin for the clones would definitely have been preferable.
Be warned, the number one entry contains huge spoilers for Scream 7.
1. Scream 7
Yikes.
Here's a final act so disastrous it didn't just kill the movie, it might've killed the franchise altogether. Scream 7 is by many clear miles the worst movie in a largely terrific horror franchise, which wasn't entirely unforeseen. A shadow has been over this movie for several years, thanks to the unjust firing of lead actress Melissa Barrera, which led to the sequel being hastily reworked.
Sure enough, it was mediocre for much of its run-time, but the final act was immeasurably wretched, as we were subjected to the worst Ghostface reveals ever. There are three Ghostface killers in this instalment, and with all three of them, when they're unmasked, audience members will be thinking "Wait... who's that again?" All three are random characters who appeared in maybe two other scenes at the very most.
Stu Macher (Matthew Lillard) turning out to be alive after all would've been a far better ending, and yes, that is meant in all seriousness.
Furthermore, this entire final act was crushingly dull and unacceptably devoid of the meta humour that defined all of the other films in the series, meaning that Scream 7 ended up being exactly the kind of soulless, cliched film that the Scream movies used to parody. An eighth Scream movie seems inevitable given how much money Scream 7 made, but after this, it's difficult to muster any enthusiasm for it.