20 Recent Horror Movies That Made ONE Huge Mistake

These horror movies all got ONE thing really wrong.

By Jack Pooley /

Getting any movie, no matter how good or bad, to the finish line and actually releasing it is a basically Herculean feat, typically requiring hundreds of artists and crafts-folk to put their skills towards the same end-goal.

Advertisement

But sometimes it's clear that a film just fundamentally doesn't work because of one big issue - an issue that probably should've been ironed out during some stage of development.

And that's absolutely the case with these 20 recent horror films, which despite their praise-worthy aspects, ultimately fell short of the mark due to one big creative gaffe they made.

It might be a refusal to trim the runtime down, iffy casting choices, baffling marketing decisions, or any number of other factors that arise during the creative process of making and releasing a film.

In some instances these mistakes totally ruined the film enough that most probably won't bother watching them again, while in others it simply placed a ceiling on how far the movie could go.

Either way, if these issues were rectified before release, they would've surely been embraced far more enthusiastically...

20. The BRUTAL Runtime - Lee Cronin's The Mummy

While it's fair to say that Lee Cronin's The Mummy was largely deemed a disappointing follow-up to his Evil Dead Rise, critics and horror fans alike might've been more eager to overlook its myriad flaws were it more editorially disciplined.

Advertisement

It's pretty rare for horror movies to clock in at more than two hours in length, and with a beefy 132-minute runtime, Cronin's film needed to absolutely earn that extended play.

But ultimately many came away from The Mummy feeling that it could've shed 20-30 minutes without losing anything substantial - quite the opposite in fact.

Again, the oft-questionable character decisions would've been easier to overlook if this was a pacy 100-minute sprint, but instead its issues are compounded by the fact it's also a stamina-obliterating slog.

Every movie should of course be as long as it needs to be, but it's honestly shocking that Warner Bros. didn't force Cronin to kill his darlings and bring this in well under two hours.

19. Using Generative AI (And Lying About It) - Ice Cream Man

Eli Roth's new slasher film Ice Cream Man could've simply been another critically panned horror flick that came and went in the blink an eye, if not for the firestorm of controversy Roth ignited with the film's craven use of Generative AI - and his decision to initially lie about it.

Advertisement

In the lead up to the film's release, Roth claimed that several animated sequences throughout the film were created using hand-drawn animation, only to later claim that he "misspoke" and confirm that AI was used in their creation.

But Roth only issued this statement after the AI visual effects company Dark Half was noticed in the film's credits, leaving many to understandably assume that Roth hoped to at-best downplay the level of Gen AI use in the final movie.

Ultimately Ice Cream Man was a critical and commercial flop, and while AI use likely had little impact on its bottom line, it ensures the film has an extra black mark against it beyond just, y'know, being absolutely terrible.

18. Firing Melissa Barrera - Scream 7

Watching Scream 7, it's so thunderously obvious that the end product was slapped together in a rush by Kevin Williamson following the senseless firing of Scream star Melissa Barrera in late 2023 for making pro-Palestine social media posts.

Advertisement

Given that Barrera and co-star Jenna Ortega - who also left the production following Barrera's dismissal - were effectively installed as the series' new leads as of the Neve Campbell-less Scream VI, their dual departure required a massive pivot for the sequel.

And so, Spyglass dumped a whopping $7 million on Campbell's lawn to convince her to return following the pay dispute which saw her sit out Scream VI, and while Campbell acquits herself just fine here, the film as a whole is an abject mess.

From the formulaic introduction of Sidney's generic daughter Tatum (Isabel May) to the corny AI subplot and franchise-worst killer reveal, it's painfully clear that firing Barrera was the worst thing that could've happened to the movie.

Spyglass might disagree, though, given that despite landing the worst reviews of the series, Scream 7 became its highest-grossing entry to date.

17. The Mary Shelley Framing Device - The Bride!

Maggie Gyllenhaal certainly swung for the fences with her bold reimagining of Bride of Frankenstein, though it's ultimately with good reason that the movie's marketing shied away from revealing its totally baffling framing device.

Advertisement

As it turns out, Frankenstein author Mary Shelley is actually a character in the film, also played by Jessie Buckley, who speaks to us from beyond the grave, explaining that there was another story she wanted to tell after Frankenstein.

And then Shelley proceeds to quite literally possess the film's protagonist, Ida (Buckley), a downtrodden woman living in 1936 Chicago.

It's an inherently puzzling choice and one made more inexplicable by the glimpses of Shelley that regularly peer through, Ida having over-the-top outbursts where her accent shifts from American to English and then back again.

Buckley certainly gives it her all in the role, but ultimately this erratic approach is more grating than compelling, quickly becoming an irritating albatross left hanging around the film's neck.

16. The Killer's RIDICULOUS Voice - Psycho Killer

Though the writing was firmly on the wall that the long-delayed Psycho Killer was going to be a dud pre-release, what prevented it from merely evaporating from memory in record time was the laughable vocal choice of its antagonist.

Advertisement

The film revolves around a serial killer known as the Satanic Slasher (James Preston Rogers) - a hulking brute of a man who, not content to look terrifyingly imposing, rocks a comically gravelly voice.

The voice is so over-the-top in its attempt to come off menacing that it actually induces the polar opposite effect, and it sounds jarring enough that you might even assume it was added in post-production in a desperate effort to enhance the flat vibe.

When a creative decision makes you laugh when you're supposed to be scared, you know the filmmakers really whiffed it. 

But if not for this silly voice, there'd be almost nothing to remember about this total non-event of a horror flick.

15. Lin Shaye's Limited Screen Time - Insidious: Out of the Further

When the sixth Insidious film was first announced, fans were excited to learn that the brilliant Lin Shaye would be once again reprising her role as fan favourite medium Elise Rainier, in what was said to be a "lead role."

Advertisement

Even though Elise died in the very first Insidious, she's appeared in some fashion in every single sequel, and though Shaye had just a tiny cameo in the previous film, Insidious: The Red Door, the casting announcement seemed to suggest that she'd have a meatier part this time.

So what a disappointment it was that Insidious: Out of the Further ultimately only gives us about five minutes of Elise, and though Shaye absolutely crushes those minutes as expected, it's just not what many fans were expecting.

It's all the more bizarre considering that Shaye was instrumental in getting Insidious 6 made, given that she wrote a letter to Sony's Tom Rothman when the film was at threat of being cancelled during a business regime change.

And above all else, with Shaye turning 83 years old this October, these films absolutely need to make the most of her while she's still here, because the franchise will be so much poorer without her.

14. Too Many Jump Scares - Passenger

Passenger, the new supernatural horror film from Troll Hunter filmmaker André Øvredal, was a watchable but ultimately forgettable romp that most are likely to remember for one thing above all else - those damn, dirty jump scares.

Advertisement

Though there's nothing inherently wrong with jump scares, they're far too often used as a crutch by filmmakers who perhaps lack confidence in what they're doing and feel the need to cheaply jolt the audience.

And Passenger's jump scares are certainly of the desperate, lazy variety - the film's absolutely chock full of them, and they're largely just repeating the same tired formula ad nauseum.

There's little genuine suspense or tension to be found elsewhere, and so it's painfully clear that these moments were all gassed-up in post-production in a last ditch attempt to give the film more visceral impact.

Again, not the worst film you've ever seen, but a disappointingly by-the-numbers effort coming from a skilled genre craftsman.

13. Not Revealing The Twist In Trailers - They Will Kill You

In a commendable but ultimately misguided move, the marketing for They Will Kill You declined to reveal the film's deliciously fun early twist, that the cultists who Asia (Zazie Beetz) faces throughout the film are immortal as a result of making human sacrifices, meaning they're resurrected every time Asia "kills" them.

Advertisement

The trailers make no suggestion of this whatsoever, instead selling it as Ready or Not-esque romp, and because it ended up releasing just a week after Ready or Not 2: Here I come, it's hardly surprising that audiences simply didn't turn up for it.

They Will Kill You failed to even recoup its $20 million budget, but had the marketing played-up its nutty reveal, then audiences might've actually been compelled to go see it.

Much as modern movie trailers are generally far too spoilerific, it definitely would've behooved the studio to make some noise about the movie's real dramatic hook.

12. The PG-13 Rating - Predator: Badlands

Even though Predator: Badlands was actually pretty damn good, it inherently rubbed many dyed-in-the-wool fans the wrong way because of the decision to go the PG-13 route.

Advertisement

The rating announcement swiftly invoked the fanbase's ire, given that every other film in the franchise had been rated R, suggesting that Badlands would be a sanitised attempt to broaden the series' reach.

Now, that PG-13 does come with the asterisk that there are no human characters in the movie, and so with all the violence being meted out against androids and aliens, Dan Trachtenberg was able to push the violence further.

All the same, a Predator film without gory red spine-rips just isn't a Predator film to some fans, as likely contributed to the film underperforming at the box office, ending its run with a mediocre $184.6 million against a hefty $100 million budget.

Even though Trachtenberg did a laudable job effectively trojan-horsing an R-rated movie into a PG-13, there are those who couldn't help but see it as a cynical commercial ploy, ensuring the discourse surrounding the movie was tainted from the jump.

11. Too Much CGI - Bodycam

The new found footage film from cult genre filmmaker Brandon Christensen (Z, Superhost) is a mostly solid outing, following a pair of cops who are called to an apparent domestic disturbance at a rundown house, only to discover something far more horrifying inside.

Advertisement

Christensen pulls off a ton of effectively low-fi frights, but as is so often the case with lower budget genre fare, things get tricky when attempting more conceptually ambitious, effects-driven fare.

There are several reality-bending sequences in the film which require the use of CGI, and while the ideas are great, the visuals themselves are simply too low-rent to fully pass muster.

This is especially true of the digital creature glimpsed at the end of the film, which looks cheap enough to be more of a distracting detriment than something that in any way enhances it.

Sometimes less is more, and where micro-budget filmmaking is concerned, VFX needs to be deployed with a huge amount of consideration for what can actually be realistically achieved.

10. The TERRIBLE Post-Credits Scene - Evil Dead Burn

Evil Dead Burn wasn't terrible by any means but it was the first entry into the impressively consistent franchise that felt genuinely pedestrian - a by-the-numbers Evil Dead flick that didn't nearly realise its nasty potential.

Advertisement

And that feeling of perfunctoriness was capped off by a head-scratcher of a post-credits scene which seemed to imply the series' more cynical ambitions moving forward.

The scene reveals the surprise resurrection of Ellie Bixler (Alyssa Sutherland), the iconic Deadite from previous film Evil Dead Rise, who returns to life at the crematorium where her unclaimed ashes are housed, as she promptly kills the crematorium manager's daughter.

This is less an enticing tease of future Evil Dead projects than a confusing, even embarrassing one. 

For starters, Ellie died incredibly violently at the end of Evil Dead Rise, so her revival here invites all sorts of questions, while undermining any sense of stakes the series has.

Plus, Ellie's return rather undermines the franchise's refreshing trend towards standalone stories as of late, implying that, at some point, we're going to get a direct sequel to Evil Dead Rise.

As iconic as Ellie is, this just screams of desperation, especially when the series is doing just fine as a collection of grisly one-off horror stories.

9. Casting Sophie Turner & Kit Harington - The Dreadful

Ignoring the boldness of titling a film The Dreadful that ultimately went on to receive largely negative reviews, this Gothic horror film follows a peasant woman and her mother-in-law as they strive to eke out a living in medieval England, just as a man from the woman's past re-enters her life.

Advertisement

The peasant woman and the mysterious man are played by Sophie Turner and Kit Harington respectively - a dual casting choice which naturally brought the film a ton of added attention, given that they previously starred together on Game of Thrones.

But ultimately it feels like the pair were cast for this reason and this reason only - to give the film a fighting chance at getting an audience even though it's unfortunately just not very good.

And that's in large part due to the flat performances from Turner and Harington who, no disrespect to them, simply don't have any palpable chemistry here whatsoever.

Somebody saw dollar signs by reuniting the pair on screen, but in artistic terms the film suffered for it.

8. It's Too Damn Dark - The Devil's Mouth

Amazon's new killer shark movie The Devil's Mouth was blessed with impressively overqualified leads in Kathryn Newton and Lana Condor, yet you'd barely know it considering how dimly lit almost the entire film is.

Advertisement

Once the central friendship group enters the titular cave about 25 minutes into the movie, audiences are basically left struggling to see what the hell's happening for the remainder of the runtime, the characters scarcely visible amid a sea of murky, barely lit visual sludge.

While a cave system would of course not be well-lit in reality, remember when movies were more interested in visual intelligibility than the illusion of realism? 

The audience will generally accept unrealistic lighting if it means they can actually see what's happening, and in this instance, it's tough not see it as a cheeky attempt to conceal the film's not-great creature effects.

If you're making the audience strain their eyes to even make sense of what's going on visually, you've already lost.

7. Chris Elliott's Barely In It - Scary Movie

The sixth Scary Movie was every bit the low-brow spoof fans of the franchise expected, and save for a few genuine laughs, largely settled for picking low-hanging comedic fruit.

Advertisement

One of the most inspired gags in the marketing, however, saw the great Chris Elliott reprise his role as Hanson from Scary Movie 2, now known as "Shorthand" - an obvious parody of Longlegs.

However, Elliott ends up appearing in the main movie for one brief scene where he gets a couple of lines, with another sequence being confined to the middle of the credits, after much of the audience will have presumably already headed home.

Considering this was one of the film's few genuinely inspired parodies on paper, it's maddening that most of Elliott's role was seemingly left on the cutting floor for some reason.

As large portions of the film were reworked in April, just two months before release, it's entirely possible Elliott was a casualty of this creative rejigging. What a waste, though.

6. The TERRIBLE Editing - The Last House

Given that Netflix's new sci-fi horror film The Last House has a 112-minute runtime, you'd be right to assume it gives its story a decent amount of breathing room.

Advertisement

But this is one of the most haphazardly, hurriedly edited major movies released in quite some time, director Louis Leterrier rushing from sequence to sequence without giving even the most basic character moments more than a second or two to breathe.

This ultimately tramples over not only the basic characterisation but also the otherwise solid performances from Greta Lee and Wagner Moura, while additionally undermining any attempt to muster genuine suspense.

The Last House certainly rocks a compelling setup, but from the end result it's easy to assume that Netflix advised Leterrier to "tighten" his edit, resulting in a film that's frantic to a fault.

And if you want to be even less generous about it, perhaps the film was sliced to ribbons to accommodate our ever-wavering attention spans. Either way, not good.

5. The HUGE Exposition Dump - Keeper

As talented a filmmaker as he is, in his last few movies Oz Perkins has proven himself a little too reliant on lengthy third act exposition dumps in order to bring the audience up to speed on quite what the hell is going on.

Advertisement

And his most recent film Keeper is his most egregious example yet, as the film basically slams into a brick wall in act three as Malcolm (Rossif Sutherland) reveals to his partner Liz (Tatiana Maslany) that he's actually hundreds of years old, the result of feeding people to a strange creature which grants him an extended lifespan in return.

Though this is all inherently intriguing, the delivery system is painfully banal and demonstrates a blatant lack of trust in the audience to follow what's happening.

And more than this, the relentless exposition sucks all the dread-soaked energy out of the film, undoing so much of Perkins' strong atmospheric work up to that point.

4. Not Enough Hippo - Hungry

The title of this killer hippo movie, obviously nodding to the classic game Hungry Hungry Hippos, made it clear that it wasn't taking itself too seriously, and it's probably just as well.

Advertisement

All Hungry really needed to deliver, then, was some neat creature effects and a bunch of creatively grisly kills, but sadly, it largely ends up delivering neither.

For one, Hungry is bafflingly rated PG-13, placing a "family-friendly" ceiling on the aforementioned death scenes, which are largely lacking in the gore you'd reasonably expect.

But the bigger issue is that the hippo itself is barely in the film outside of its fleeting, sanitised maulings. 

It's only in the last 20-or-so minutes of the film that we get much of a sustained look at the big guy, and though it actually looks pretty solid for a low-budget creature feature, many will have no doubt lost interest in the dull human characters and repetitive suspense sequences long before this point.

3. Wasting Djimon Hounsou - Thrash

Tommy Wirkola's recent Netflix shark film Thrash is certainly well-cast, with Phoebe Dynevor ably portraying protagonist Lisa - a pregnant woman who finds herself trapped in a coastal town when a hurricane hits, leaving her fending off ravenous sharks.

Advertisement

The other major name in the movie is the ever-great Djimon Hounsou, who plays marine researcher Dr. Dale Edwards, and while Hounsou basically can't help but bring gravitas and authority to any role he plays, what a waste of his talents this was.

Hounsou - who, remember, is a two-time Oscar nominee - is largely relegated to regurgitating tired exposition while fighting to rescue his niece Dakota (Whitney Peak).

Hounsou's recent career has seen him far too often consigned to throwaway supporting roles in junky genre films such as this, but in the very least you'd hope these filmmakers would give an actor of his caliber some juicy dialogue or fun action to sink his teeth into. 

2. Taking WAY Too Long To Come Out - Ready or Not 2: Here I Come

Considering that Ready or Not was a solid box office success and only grew in esteem over the years, many assumed that the sequel would build on this momentum and deliver one of the year's big genre hits.

Advertisement

But Ready or Not 2: Here I Come ended up underperforming commercially, for while it easily recouped its $14 million budget - more than double that of the original, admittedly - its worldwide total was a tepid $43 million, well below the original's $57.6 million.

General response to the film was fine, though there was a consensus among many that filmmakers Matt Bettinelli-Olpin and Tyler Gillett simply waited too long to make the sequel.

A seven-year gap for a horror sequel set immediately after the first is certainly an odd choice, and if it wanted the best chance of success, it really should've come out within two or three years of the original.

1. The Totally Unnecessary Plot Twist - Killer Whale

On the face of it, Killer Whale seemed like a total meat-and-potatoes creature feature set to deliver the basic goods and nothing else.

Advertisement

But oddly, the film saddles itself with an utterly absurd, laughable late-stage plot twist that bogs the entire endeavour down while detracting from the killer whale shenanigans everyone actually paid money to see.

Early on, we learn that protagonist Maddie (Virginia Gardner) is recovering from being caught in the middle of an armed robbery - an incident which killed her friend and left her with hearing loss.

But in the third act, Maddie's friend Trish (Mel Jarnson), who she's trapped with on a remote lagoon while fending off said whale, reveals that she orchestrated the aforementioned robbery to pay her student debts.

It's just an outrageously unnecessary rug-pull for a film called Killer Whale, almost as though the filmmakers were struggling to reach a feature length runtime and so decided to inject this utterly ridiculous conflict into the mix totally out of nowhere.

Advertisement