10 Amazing Songs By Terrible Artists

Jewels Among the Trash.

By Tim Coffman /

Not every band is necessarily the Beatles when they step into the studio. Hell, most people can just try to walk into the recording booth and hope for the best every time they put out a new album. As much as some bands can cough it up on record, there are always those few moments where they come out on top.

Advertisement

First of all, though, are all of these artists necessarily bad? Well...not necessarily. Everyone has their own taste, and some of these guys might be on your list of the greatest artists of all time. That being said, there's no denying the amount of hate that these artists receive, often for being too derivative of what came before or just talentless hacks who happened to find their way into the music industry.

Regardless of the trash talking though, these are those few occasions where you can't deny the chops they have, where everyone collectively does a double take and realizes the potential these guys actually possess. It may not have gotten them very far, but at least it got them to one good song. Even though it might all be diminishing returns from here, these are the few diamonds in the rough that are worth searching for.

10. Machinehead - Bush

Ok...so this one is probably the least offensive band of the bunch. After all, Bush was never really a terrible band...they just found themselves looking like a discount Nirvana from the minute they started. As much as something like Glycerine might seem a little bit dated nowadays, the crunch of Machinehead has still managed to keep its teeth after all these years.

Advertisement

That's not to say that the actual song is a masterpiece or anything, with most of the riffs being pretty stagnant throughout most of the record. Gavin Rossdale does sell it though, sounding like what Kurt Cobain might have sounded like if he were told that he was fronting a glam band instead of Nirvana. The distorted effects aren't too shabby either, sounding more robotic nowadays than they did upon first release.

Hell, even the heavy hitters of the grunge scene couldn't find too much to hate about this song. While most might have pled indifference, we still have Courtney Love proclaiming this as one of the greatest songs of the decade. Even though it's not advisable to trust Ms. Love at all times, this is still a nice little throwback jam that you can save for your '90s nights at the bar.

9. Walking on the Sun - Smash Mouth

Any goodwill that Smash Mouth had was pretty much snuffed out the minute that people started memeing All Star a while back. From that moment on, this was the doofy band from the '90s that would remain a punchline and a staple of the state fair circuit for years to come. If it was a different song that became a hit though, we could have been in for one of the weirder acts of the late '90s.

Advertisement

Granted, it's not like Walking on the Sun is exactly a masterpiece. The weird flow of the rhyme scheme doesn't always land the greatest punch and Steve Harwell's voice isn't Michael Jackson or anything, but it still feels like a free flowing good time whenever it comes on. Hell, it even has a sinister edge in the music, with a lot of the guitars sounding like they could have come off of a B-side from the Doors circa 1968.

Also, are we just going to forget how dismal the rock scene looked at this point in history? With grunge dying out and nu metal getting more angsty by the hour, it's nice to have at least one song that didn't have to be tortured to get on the air. Memes aside, this is still the one Smash Mouth song that most people can listen to without cringing too hard.

8. Hard to See - Five Finger Death Punch

At this point, Five Finger Death Punch has become more of a caricature for the rock scene more than anything else. Aside from just making the same midtempo schlock over and over again, this is just the kind of music that is made for the guy who bench presses way too much and hangs out at Buffalo Wild Wings well after closing time. Still, it's not like these guys didn't have potential when starting out.

Advertisement

Although Hard to See is far from the most progressive song in the hard rock canon, you can see why it got popular, with the guitar playing being pretty solid and Ivan Moody bringing a lot of charisma behind the microphone. Yes, you heard that right. Before he was the guy that fluctuated between old man growls and half asleep cover songs, this was the Moody that we fell in love with, who can go for a hell of a shout if the time called for it.

Hell, the only reason why this one holds up to the passage of time is because it was the one good song that they burrowed into the ground. While not every song since this has been awful, it's clear that Moody is trying to repeat the formula instead of making something actually original. For a brief moment though, it looked things just might be looking up.

7. For the Movies - Buckcherry

Even with as many genres that the rock sphere has, it feels weird trying to label Buckcherry. Given their dated glam metal pastiches and the smut they put in their lyrics, this is kind of stuff that Steel Panther would write if they weren't in on the joke. Then again, sometimes even the most heinous of acts manage to tug on one heartstring.

Advertisement

Long before the era of 15 and Crazy B*tch became a thing, Buckcherry's debut actually had a decent power ballad with For the Movies. Compared to the usual doofy lyrics that you would get out of them later down the line, a simple song about trying to rekindle a spark with your old flame is oddly mature for them to tackle. It gets especially weird when this is the song that comes after songs like Lit Up and Check Your Head, neither of which are going to go down as the greatest songs ever written or anything.

But there's a strange sense of free spirit in this song. Maybe these two aren't going to work it out or even achieve all of their dreams...but at least they're making an effort and going for broke regardless. If they had continued down this road, who knows? They may have actually stuck the landing.

6. In the End - Black Veil Brides

And...this is the moment where you start to get clapback from all of the goth fans out there. As much as their aesthetic is amazing, Black Veil Brides have never been the greatest band of all time, often feeling like the generic radio schlock with a semi-decent singer at the helm. Credit where it's due though...they did manage to score one mammoth chorus.

Advertisement

Towards the end of Wretched and Divine, Black Veil Brides created a monster singalong with In the End, which actually shows Andy Black flexing his vocal chops a bit more than usual. While a lot of the previous BVB songs felt like style over substance, this is the one time where they feel like they're actually writing songs rather than the faux darkness you'd get on their other records.

There are even a handful of decent guitar licks in here as well, with Jinxx and Jake Pitts putting their moments in just the right spots while not getting in the way of the rest of the band. The message isn't half bad either, talking about resistance and rising up against those who try to put you down. Even though this is probably the billionth time that Black Veil Brides have made this song, you can tell that the passion is here on this one.

5. Let Me Down - Limp Bizkit

As the years go by, Limp Bizkit just feels like the sad residue of the late '90s. Though the musicians behind the band were certainly talented for what they were, the colossal frat bro attitude brought on by Fred Durst has managed to become the laughing stock of rock for the past few decades. And on their most contentious album Results May Vary, Durst actually stepped up to the plate and...actually gave us something good?

Advertisement

This isn't an exaggeration either. Let Me Down is probably one of the greatest songs that Limp Bizkit have ever made, even down to the melodramatic lyrics. You can tell that they were even listening to the new school of music, with the nasally tone of Durst sounding closer to Chester Bennington that his normal whines in Break Stuff.

This is also the kind of backbeat that DJ Lethal is great at, with some of the rhythms sounding like he took all of the best stuff left over from House of Pain and put it in here. It's not like you can praise Wes Borland for the guitar work or anything. At the end of the day, this is probably the best that Fred is capable of doing, so why the hell did he make us sit through stuff like Rollin over and over again?

4. Let Her Cry - Hootie and the Blowfish

For any millennial, Hootie and the Blowfish is probably better known as your dad's favorite band. And for good reason, seeing how this is exactly the kind of chill rock music that wouldn't feel to out of place at a backyard barbecue in the middle of summer. Then again, there's a very fine line between being inoffensive and boring, and Hootie has been straddling both ends for their entire career.

Advertisement

One thing you can't take away though is Cracked Rearview, which sold millions of copies off the strength of Let Her Cry. It's not that hard to see why either, with the melody being a perfect little snapshot of what it's like to be in a relationship that's slowly falling apart. Even with Darius Rucker's more melodramatic singing, it actually works in this context, sounding like he's on the verge of tears himself as he sees his ex turn back to her vices to get over everything.

If you look through that rearview nowadays though, there's a reason why they fell out pretty hard, with most of their later years being either too boring to focus on or trying way too hard to recapture their past glory. Even if we have to sit through songs like Tucker's Town live, we can at least have this jam to shamelessly hold our lighters up to.

3. Far Away - Nickelback

People tend to be a little too eager to put a nail in Nickelback's coffin over and over again. For anyone who...well...has ears, their derivative attempts at post grunge and hard rock is what made the genre concave in on itself in the mid '00s. And we probably could have been better off for it if they had just decided to lean into their softer side a little more often.

Advertisement

Though the sound of getting a clean and polished Nickelback might sound like waxing a piece of dogsh*t to some people, Far Away actually has a lot more going for it. As far as the raw song, it's not too bad to hear Chad Kroeger actually dial it back a little bit, as he tries to win back a former flame. There's even a few lifts in the track that feel like they're from the heart rather than just made in a boardroom by record executives.

In fact, you could probably argue that this song has more in common with what was going on in country music at the time. Hell, if this had been released by someone like Trace Adkins around the same time, people probably wouldn't bat an eye. But it's Nickelback, so it has to be bad. In the case of Far Away though, it might be better not to be so close minded.

2. Higher - Creed

Yes...you all can get your yarl memes out of the way right now. For all of the greatness that has come from Alter Bridge over the years, it's practically a miracle that we got that music from the same guys who formed the basis of Creed. Although Scott Stapp's vocal range is definitely an acquired taste, there was at least a few tracks worth seeking out on their early records.

Advertisement

Though Human Clay is the same record that gave us the musical punching bag With Arms Wide Open, Higher is one of the few Creed songs that actually seems to have some power behind it. Being in a major key (a rarity for a rock song like this), Mark Tremonti actually has some pretty amazing licks sprinkled in between the verses. Tremonti always felt stifled on most of their hits anyway, so this is just the kind of fretwork that we were waiting for.

As much as Stapp could be called the liability of the group, his voice is not nearly as overly dramatic as usual, sounding more like a guy who just listened to a bit too much Eddie Vedder back in high school. But if you want to just put aside the rockstar BS to actually write a song, we're going to be the last ones to complain about it.

1. Slow Dancing in a Burning Room - John Mayer

We've all had a John Mayer in our life in one form or another. No matter what kind of social gathering that you find yourself in, there's always going to be that one schmoozer with a guitar who's going to try to get in good with the ladies by playing Wonderwall for the thousandth time. While all of these guys were practicing their pickup lines though, John Mayer actually grew the hell up into an actual musician.

Advertisement

Across the record Continuum, Mayer actually put his chops to good use and created a pop album that relies more on the players rather than the fluff. Although most of the record holds up today, Slow Dancing in the Burning Room feels like those sappy ballads of his early days, only refined with a fine toothed comb.

For all of its melodramatic undercurrents, Mayer actually manages to put a lot of tasteful guitar work into the mix, almost doing what someone like John Frusciante would do if he was asked to write a hit song. You can even hear hints of Jimi Hendrix in his presentation, looking to play the role of the drifter with a guitar moving from one town to the next. It's still the same dorm room rock of before, but this is the kind of stuff that brings up the good memories from college.

Advertisement