10 Bands That Broke Up For Bizarre Reasons

Forget breaking up over money, some of these band splits are petty and downright hilarious.

By Aaron Chandler /

It’s been said before and it’ll surely be said again; getting to the top of the mountain in music is easy, staying there is the true test. While some bands have endured the perilous terrain of the industry through thick and thin, others have found themselves on thinner ice than they were comfortable with. In many instances, these touchy times saw members turn on one another, causing the band to implode and disappear from stardom.

Advertisement

In most cases, bands will fall out over serious issues such as royalty distribution, creative differences, politics, or even criminal charges. But why let something as trivial as money be the downfall of your band when there are so many more exotic options available? Say goodbye to falling out over royalties and hello to dissolving your group because a bandmate stood on your birthday cake. Why suffer with perilous and endless substance abuse in your band when you could simply split up the first time somebody shows up drunk? And what better reason to go on hiatus than to avoid the Apocalypse?

All these phenomenal reasons for bands splitting up and more are being placed under the music microscope for this article, as the spotlight is on some of the weirdest reasons bands have decided to split up.

10. The Everly Brothers

For decades, rock music has held a love/hate relationship with alcohol. Some bands such as Motorhead and Metallica were renowned for their consumption, while other acts like Minor Threat earned notoriety for their outright rejection of it. Either way, there is no denying that alcohol has changed rock music and, as The Everly Brothers discovered, these changes weren’t always positive.

Advertisement

As the first of two duos to feature in this article, The Everly Brothers formed in 1956 and found commercial success almost immediately. The brothers' second single, ‘Bye Bye Love’, became an international superhit in 1957, topping the chart in the US while also reaching the top ten in Canada and the UK. Within 12 months, they had scored further chart success with ‘Wake Up Little Susie’ and ‘All I Have to Do Is Dream’. 

However, commercial success began to falter in the late-'60s when their record deal expired and they released a live record to a lukewarm reception. Underlying tensions between the brothers became apparent in light of their slow decline, and everything imploded in 1973. The siblings had already agreed to break up after a two-night show at Knotts Berry Farm, California, but they never made it to the second night. During the first night, Don Everly was visibly drunk and forgot the lyrics to several songs. Frustrated, Phil smashed his guitar and stormed off stage, leaving Don to perform as a solo act on night two. The duo wouldn’t perform together again until 1983.

9. Refused

Music is cruel. Some bands will set out to take on the world armed with abundant talent, only to peter out when their dreams don’t materialise. These ambitions are usually somewhat realistic, but that rule doesn’t apply to Sweden’s Refused, who set themselves the minor task of destroying capitalism. 

Advertisement

As one of punk rock’s most divisive bands, people generally see Refused as either landscape-shifting pioneers or inexplicably overrated, with the middle ground rarely being visited. Refused formed in 1991 and had enjoyed a steady rise until the release of their third album, ‘The Shape of Punk to Come’, in 1998. No matter what your opinion of Refused is, there is no denying that this groundbreaking album sounded the death toll for the band. The members expected it to spark a globe-engulfing revolution with its anti-capitalistic undertones, bolstered by their bold manifesto for the future. But when it became apparent that they weren’t going to end capitalism, they immediately threw the towel in.

The last live show Refused played before disbanding in 1998 was broken up by police, acting as an underwhelming last stand for the rampant punk group. In the aftermath, Refused remarked that it was “a last feeble attempt to break the linear timeline that the modern ways of production has forced upon us”. Despite their sudden disappearance, Refused later reformed in 2014 and their latest album, ‘War Music’, was released in 2019.

8. Oasis

At their peak, Oasis were one of the most dominant bands in British history, eclipsing the entire world with their overwhelming stardom and inescapable cultural presence. However, the hostilities between brothers Liam and Noel Gallagher were always in the spotlight, and the only surprise of Oasis’ demise was that it took so long to happen.

Advertisement

Oasis formed in 1991 but didn’t gain traction until the release of their debut single, ‘Supersonic’, in 1994. Within 18 months of this, the band’s first two albums, 'Definitely Maybe’ and ‘(What’s the Story) Morning Glory?’, had sold an astounding 38 million copies worldwide. All the while, Liam and Noel struggled to stay on the same page regarding creative direction, the press and touring. In one infamous incident, Noel attacked Liam with a cricket bat for bringing strangers to a recording session. In spite of all the adversity they overcame, a comparatively small obstacle was the band’s undoing. 

In 2009, Oasis split up moments before they were due to perform at the Rock en Seine Festival in France, with Noel stating that he "simply could not go on working with Liam a day longer". Noel later revealed that the final straw was Liam wanting to promote his new clothing brand while on tour. Noel claimed that it was unfair to force the clothes on fans who were there for the music, and when Liam wouldn’t budge he made an immediate exit, thus bringing an undeserving ending to a truly generational band.

7. Creedence Clearwater Revival

Creative conflicts and disputes within bands have always been commonplace occurrences in rock music. No matter the era, origins, style or fame of a band, they are all susceptible to falling apart from the inside, even when the other members are your own family. Roots rock icons and cultural pioneers Creedence Clearwater Revival sadly learned this the hard way. 

Advertisement

Initially forming in 1959 and performing under a number of questionable names, the swamp rockers finally settled on Creedence Clearwater Revival in 1967 and changed the music industry forever. In five blistering years, CCR released seven albums packed with some of the most enduring tunes ever created, such as ‘Bad Moon Rising’, ‘Fortunate Son’, and ‘Have You Ever Seen the Rain?’. With great success, though, came great conflict within the band, mainly between brothers Tom and John Fogerty. 

After the release of ‘Pendulum’ in 1970, the other members accused John Fogerty of not allowing them to make creative contributions to the group. Frustrated, Tom quit in 1971 and John reluctantly allowed the remaining members to write three songs each for their forthcoming record, ‘Mardi Gras’. The album disappointed and is viewed by most to be the band’s worst record. It charted lower than the band’s five preceding records, and to this day is their only album not to be platinum certified. Angered by the lacklustre performance from his bandmates, John Fogerty immediately dissolved CCR in 1972 and they never released an album again.

6. Pixies

Few bands can match the polarising, widespread, and enduring influence of Pixies. With the likes of Nirvana, Radiohead, the Smashing Pumpkins, and more all citing the alt-rock megastars as key influences, it’s no wonder why Pixies are so revered today. However, many modern fans are seemingly unaware of what caused the demise of this awe-inspiring group.

Advertisement

Founding members Joey Santiago and Black Francis met at university in 1983, but didn’t formally create a band together until 1986. In the search for a bass player, they placed an advert in a local newspaper and received only one respondent; Kim Deal. Despite the fact Deal had never played a bass before and arrived at the audition without one, she was accepted into the band. With the recruitment of David Lovering later that year, the line-up was complete. 

Things were going well for Pixies until it became apparent to Francis who the fan favourite was. Even in the early 90s, a female bassist was a relative rarity, meaning Deal gained almost magnetic media attention that was bolstered by her skill as a performer and songwriter. Kurt Cobain stating that the Kim Deal-written ‘Gigantic’ was his favourite Pixies song in 1992 may have been the final jealousy-tainted straw for Black Francis. Envious of her popularity, Francis blocked Deal from having any creative input on the band's final albums. His sour grapes response wasn’t well received, and a year later Francis disbanded Pixies via a fax message to the other members. 

5. Simon & Garfunkel

A common misconception amongst music fans regarding Simon & Garfunkel is that the iconic folk duo never liked each other. In actuality, Paul Simon and Art Garfunkel worked cohesively for the majority of their early careers. In the years since though, they have disbanded and reunited several times, with their first major falling out being in the spotlight here.

Advertisement

Jealousy is a running theme through this article, but the source of this feud may be the pettiest of the bunch. The gradual alienation began when Paul Simon was approached to create film scores for Midnight Cowboy (1969) and Brother Sun, Sister Moon (1972), though he rejected these offers. Meanwhile, both he and Art were cast in Mike Nichols’ dark war comedy Catch-22, but Simon’s part was cut while Nichols kept Garfunkel. Simon was left with a sour taste in his mouth, and it quickly became apparent that Art had ambitions beyond the music industry.

Catch-22 and the duo’s aptly named studio album ‘Bridge Over Troubled Water’ were both released in 1970 to great acclaim. In spite of the record’s incredible global success, the cracks were beginning to show and the end was imminent for the folk megastars. Recording was a difficult process for both men, and the death toll was sounded when Garfunkel accepted another acting role from Nichols without telling Simon. 

Feeling betrayed, Paul Simon quit the group later that year and. despite reuniting several times in the decades that followed, the duo never recorded another album.

4. Witchrot

While most bands on this list are remembered despite their bizarre break-ups, Witchrot are primarily remembered because of theirs. In a surreal social media statement, vocalist Peter Turik announced that "due to the unfortunate reality of our guitarist f****** my girlfriend of almost 7 years, WITCHROT will be taking an extended hiatus."

Advertisement

The statement was an abrupt verbal ambush that exploded across social media, becoming one of the metal community’s most viral posts of 2018. But as the story behind the post started to unravel, it took a number of unexpected, dark, and eventually positive turns. In the same viral statement, Turik announced that not only had his guitarist stolen his long-term girlfriend, but the band’s former drummer had also passed away. In an extraordinary turn of events, it was revealed a few days later that this was entirely untrue. When talking to Alternative Press a week after the post went live, Turik said the following:

"I asked Simon [drummer] if that [the post] was a good idea. He said ‘Yeah, but say I died, no one will give a shit’… Clearly they did."

Another unforeseen twist of fate occurred around the same time as this interview when Turik performed a complete U-turn and said that Witchrot would be getting back together immediately following their newfound social media buzz. The Canadian doom metal act are still active today and are currently in the process of recording a new album.

3. Killing Joke

Although Killing Joke didn’t officially break up, the story behind this unusual series of events is simply too incredible to be left out. In the event of Armageddon, you would think putting your band on hold would be the least of your concerns. Killing Joke thought otherwise. The post-punk trailblazers formed in Cheltenham in 1978, and soon established themselves as legends in the making with their 1980 self-titled debut album.

Advertisement

Following their fiery introduction, they released ‘What’s This For?’ in 1981 and then ‘Revelations’ in 1982. But by the time 'Revelations' was released in July, Jaz Coleman and Geordie Walker were on the run. In the early ‘80s, Coleman gained an occult obsession and predicted that the Apocalypse was imminent. To escape its wrath, he convinced Walker to move to Iceland with him so they would survive. This was too much for Martin ‘Youth’ Glover, who stayed in the UK and promptly left the band. Coleman and Walker formed heavy metal group Niceland while Killing Joke was dormant, before returning to the UK ahead of releasing ‘Fire Dances’ in 1983.

Years later, Coleman claimed the entire story is a myth, and he in fact moved to Iceland so he could start up a drug dealing operation. The operation was short lived, but the money he made allowed him to buy the grand piano he wrote his first symphony on, making this one of the craziest music industry stories you will ever hear.

2. Rage Against The Machine

It may seem hard to believe now, but rock bands once held the MTV Awards in fantastically high acclaim, seeing it as a status-consolidating event that confirmed their place at the top of the music industry. The star-studded nomination list for the ‘Best Rock Video’ category for 2000 included Creed, Kid Rock, Metallica, Korn, Limp Bizkit, and hot favourites to win, Rage Against the Machine.

Advertisement

Everyone knew there would be fireworks, but RATM’s Tom Commerford surpassed all expectations with his infamous antics. When Limp Bizkit surprisingly won the award for their self-directed ‘Break Stuff’ video, Commerford hijacked the stage and climbed the towering structure behind the award podium. A dozen or so stagehands scrambled into view to talk Commerford down, who lurked over Limp Bizkit’s acceptance speech like a gargoyle. Fred Durst probably didn’t help the situation by jokingly telling Commerford to jump, before quickly adding “this guy is rock 'n' roll, he should be winning the award”.

Commerford was arrested and earned himself a night in jail for his actions. Humiliated by Commerford’s antics, vocalist Zach de la Rocha left the band and Rage Against the Machine disbanded later that year. Although the MTV Awards weren’t the direct cause of the band breaking up, it appears Commerford’s protest was the snowflake that started an avalanche. To this day, Commerford maintains that Limp Bizkit are “one of the dumbest bands in the history of music”.

1. The Kinks

The consistent theme of sibling rivalry continues as the surreal undoing of The Kinks claims top spot. The Kinks are one of the most integral acts in the history of British rock and are responsible for some of the genre’s most ageless songs. Unlike other bands featured, The Kinks enjoyed a long, storied career before their calamitous downfall came to fruition in the strangest of circumstances.

Advertisement

Originally forming as the Ray Davies Quartet in 1962 with Rod Stewart as vocalist for a time, The Kinks emerged in their final form in 1963. The group enjoyed major success from 1964 onwards thanks to their breakout hit ‘You Really Got Me’. However, the relationship between founding brothers Ray and Dave Davies was generally turbulent, worsening greatly when the group’s popularity declined in the late 1980s and '90s. Despite receiving some late-career recognition, they continued to flounder commercially and it all came to a head at the unlikeliest of times.

For Dave’s 50th birthday, Ray decided to throw his brother a party which ended up being the last time all members of the band were in a room together. According to Dave, Ray stood on a table and began making a self-indulgent speech. While talking, Ray stood on Dave’s birthday cake and caused a huge row between the brothers. Even though Ray has disputed this story since, the band broke up immediately and the brothers supposedly never spoke to each other again.

Advertisement