10 Bands That Fell Out Over One Song
Songs That Left Scars.
The entire songwriting process can be a very delicate exercise for any artist. Even though it might seem like the easiest thing in the world to just make up a song on the spot, it sometimes has to be the right time and the right chords aligning before you have something that’s going to have some real hit potential. It’s hard enough to get one person to be satisfied with the final product, so just imagine how it would sound when one of your band members doesn’t like what you made.
Although some of these songs do have their fair share of problems, each of them ended up causing some major tension in the band, either through the creative direction that they were moving in or just the dynamic of the group falling out of whack because of the song. Despite their problems though, these songs did end up seeing the light of day, and ended up turning into some of the biggest hits that the band ever had in some cases.
Now that you’re playing some of these songs night after night, that resentment only grows deeper for some of these artists as time went on, leading to them getting into fights about keeping it in the setlist and even quitting on the spot in some places if they were to play this song again on tour. There’s normally a lot that goes into a band deciding to call it quits, but as far as these acts are concerned, these were the songs that are the embodiment of all that resentment boiling over.
10. Again - Alice in Chains
After 1995, Alice in Chains were on the verge of collapse. Fans already had a pretty grim picture of how far Layne Staley had sunk into his addiction, but the self titled Dog record was a different beast, with Staley sounding like a shell of himself and Jerry Cantrell carrying most of the singing. Layne still did have a say in things though, and that caused a bit of friction going into one of the bands’ final singles.
While most Alice fans remember Heaven Beside You, Again was a more uptempo song that was more reminiscent of Alice’s early days…until the breakdown. In the early versions of the songs, Staley’s suggestion was to put ‘doot-doos’ in between the sections to keep the momentum. Even though producer Toby Wright wasn’t a fan of the change, Layne put his foot down and insisted that they be in the final product.
Considering how torn apart his voice sounds during the rest of the song though, just having a bit of levity in the mix helps balance things out. The Dog Record is already pretty depressing as it is, but for a couple seconds, it at least sounds like they’re having fun in the studio.
9. Wrapped Around Your Finger - The Police
After The Police got to Synchronicity, the creative tensions were already running high. Sting was already blossoming into a phenomenal songwriter inn his own right, and it was harder to get any more input from the other members of the band on songs like Every Breath You Take. Everyone does need to know how the song goes though, and Stewart Copeland had an eternal headache trying to dissect Wrapped Around Your Finger.
On the record, this is one of the more sinister songs that Sting would ever write, being about someone who wants to dominate their partner psychologically. When the band were laying down the basic track of the song though, Copeland did not take to the downtempo rhythm that the song is supposed to be, saying that it got to be like pulling teeth trying to get the right feel for the song.
Once they got out on the road though, Stewart said that he gradually learned how to keep the whole thing rolling, inventing new ways to play the song so that it would flow a lot better than it did in the studio. While he is proud of what the song became, Copeland still doesn’t look back on the finished product fondly. Now that he knows the intricacies of the song, he said he would love the chance to rerecord the song how it was supposed to be.
8. All of Siamese Dream - Smashing Pumpkins
No band is safe from a few micromanagers in the studio. Even if you think that you have what it takes to get the job done, there are always going to be producers, labels, and other middlemen saying that you can improve and want to discount what you did as crap. It’s a different story when those middlemen are in the band though.
While Siamese Dream has all the makings of a great Smashing Pumpkins album, Billy Corgan went a bit too far to achieve everything he wanted. While the whole band took shape in the studio to lay down songs like Disarm and Today, Corgan actually came in behind the scenes to tighten up a few performances, including wiping Darcy Wretsky and James Iha’s parts and playing them how he thought they should go. Despite being one of the biggest back stabbings of the ‘90s, the results speak for themselves, with Billy’s parts moving in and out of each other in a much more fluid way than what we would have heard live.
This was the start of the end for the core Pumpkins though, with Iha and Wretsky getting more and more agitated until they finally left the Pumpkins for good, leaving Corgan as the sole member of the Pumpkins who has been a part of every single lineup. Anyone can get a little bit OCD when under pressure, but that doesn’t give you an excuse to replace everything.
7. Don't Stop Me Now - Queen
Once Queen took off, nothing stood in the way of Freddie Mercury having a good time. Even though he had the audience in the palm of his hand every time Queen lit up the stage, he was as much of a party animal off the stage, with the backstage parties getting more and more out of hand when sex and drugs reared their head. You can be playing a dangerous game with that much drugs, and Brian May took exception to one song that Mercury made about his exploits.
As much as Don’t Stop Me Now is a Queen classic, Freddie’s original vision for the song was to make it a celebration of the hard partying times that he was having behind the scenes. Though the lyrics ended up being about any kind of good time you can find yourself in, May wasn’t that much of a fan of Freddie glorifying this behavior, thinking that his friend was going down a dangerous path and would find himself in bad shape if he did eventually take it that one step too far.
While Mercury did clean up a little bit towards the end of his life, Don’t Stop Me Now still stands as one of the best pop hits they had, being more of an ode to innocent fun than wallowing in sadness. Now that Mercury is no longer with us, this is a song for us to remember the good times.
6. Bring It On Down - Oasis
The entire recording process going into Definitely Maybe turned into absolute hell. Although the Gallagher Brothers liked to brag about themselves being part of the biggest band in the world, they had little to show for it in the beginning, with every pass they made in the studio sounding weak compared to what they did live. It also doesn’t help when you have a drummer who can’t keep in time that well.
When the band were cutting the beginning of their punky thrasher Bring It On Down, drummer Tony McCarroll kept screwing up the main drum part that opens the song, always speeding up or leaving some hits out trying to keep up with everything. While the band had started working on a pretty good take, Noel Gallagher was not going to wait until Tony got himself together, getting a session drummer to come in to play the beat correctly.
When the session drummer started to have some problems though, Tony exploded in a fit of anger and ended up nailing the drum take in just a few takes. While Tony might have been vindicated that particular time, the writing was on the wall that he was going to leave when the next album rolled around. The punky thrash of McCarroll was what the band needed for their debut, but there was no way he was going to be able to pull off songs like Champagne Supernova and Don’t Look Back in Anger with the same setup.
5. Free Fallin - Tom Petty
In the late ‘80s, Tom Petty needed a break from being Tom Petty. After someone tried to murder him by setting his house on fire, the next few years saw him doing a bunch of projects outside of the Heartbreakers, including working with fellow rock legends in the Traveling Wilburys. While he used some of the Heartbreakers on his first official solo release Full Moon Fever, not everyone was happy about being called into work.
Made up primarily of Petty, Mike Campbell, and producer Jeff Lynne in the studio, the rest of the Heartbreakers felt left out and couldn’t really gel with the feeling of the record. When bassist Howie Epstein came into record a bass part one day, he actually said that he didn’t like the song that he was being asked to play on and packed up for the day.
Tough luck for Epstein though, since the song that he said no to turned into Free Fallin, which gave Petty’s career a second wind and became one of the biggest hits that he would ever have. The biggest fracture that happened with this song was with drummer Stan Lynch, who expressed feeling like he was in a cover band when he was on the road before being fired a few years later. Petty might play by his own rules, but it’s sometimes hard to reconcile when you have your bandmates to work off of.
4. Comfortably Numb - Pink Floyd
Towards the end of the ‘70s, Pink Floyd was quickly turning into Roger Water’s baby. After Syd Barrett had to step down in the ‘60s, Waters’ vision for the band seemed to be informed by Barrett’s absence, writing songs about what makes people mad and the frustrations that drive people crazy on albums like The Dark Side of the Moon and Animals. The Wall was a much different beast though, and Roger was determined to make his grand vision by any means necessary.
During the recording of the song Comfortably Numb, Waters and David Gilmour both got into disagreements about how the drums should sound, down to discussing whether or not a kick drum should be used in one section of the chorus or not. While Gilmour had his own say on the matters, the rest of the band weren’t as lucky, with keyboardist Richard Wright being fired in the middle of the sessions after not being able to gel with the rest of the band.
Even though Wright returned to the band to finish off the album, he would be paid only as a session player. That wasn’t even the last sacking that happened this album cycle, with drummer Nick Mason putting down his sticks after not being able to get the timing right for Mother. Any band is going to have to compromise sooner or later, but nothing was going to get in the way of Roger’s vision.
3. Girls of Summer - Aerosmith
The end of the ‘90s started the beginning of the end for Aerosmith, the rock band. After getting their first mainstream #1 hit with I Don’t Want To Miss a Thing, Steven Tyler thought the band’s new calling should be about making pop songs, with Just Push Play having a far more polished sheen than the Bad Boys From Boston were used to. While the rest of the band were able to deal with a couple of poppy songs here and there, no one was ready for what the Girls of Summer had in store.
Though this song has the Aerosmith name on it, this may as well be a Steven Tyler solo song, written about the summertime and having a sound that screams the early ‘00s. Even if the band had some problems with Just Push Play, the rest of them hardly even played on this song and didn’t even bother to appear in the video for the tune either.
It’s not like they weren’t right to be pissed, since this was going out with their band name and sounding like it should be some forgotten rock leaning cut on a Backstreet Boys record. The core mentality behind Aerosmith at this point is just sticking together, but this was a pretty clear picture of how divided the band were at the time.
2. Victim of Love - Eagles
Once the Eagles got to making Hotel California, there was no time for filler. If the band had made a song that they thought was just passable, it wasn’t going to make it onto the final version of the record. Every song had to measure up to the album’s potential, and that meant Don Felder having to give up the reins on Victim of Love.
While Felder had written the track for the song, Don Henley and JD Souther helped finish the lyrics off. The song had the potential to be great, but Felder’s insistence on singing it didn’t sit well with the rest of the band. The rest of the band relented and let Felder sing it in the studio, only to ask their manager to take Felder out to dinner while the rest of the band stayed behind to put Henley’s vocal on the song.
Even though this was the better move for the studio version, Felder felt the rift between the rest of the band start with this song, thinking that Henley was taking the song away from him and him having less of a say in what the Eagles were supposed to be. Then again, even if Don Felder delivered a kickass version on his own, there was no way anyone was going to argue that a Don Henley vocal should be wiped out.
1. Revolution 9 - The Beatles
After Sgt. Peppers, the Beatles had started to go in different sonic directions. While the Fab Four had started to work independently from each other, The White Album was the first time where it felt like a bunch of songwriters coming together to make one album. Although everyone brought something to the table that worked, Paul McCartney took issue with Revolution 9 being included on the final edition.
More of an experience than a song, Revolution 9 is John Lennon’s follow up to the Revolution single, sprawling out over 8 minutes and talking about what revolution means to him. While the idea behind the song may have been interesting at the time, hearing this on a Beatles album really broke up the flow, leading to George Martin and McCartney thinking that it should be scrapped. Lennon didn’t make a song like this just to throw it away, and insisted that it be included on the White Album, sounding like a cacophony of noise through its entire runtime before segueing into Good Night from Ringo Starr to close out the album.
Though each Beatle had a respect for the avant garde, this song is a good thought experiment being put in the exact wrong place. The White Album may have been tension fueled for most of the sessions, but the fallout over this one song signaled the beginning of the Fab Four going their separate ways.