10 Bands That Ripped Off Themselves

Musical déjà vu.

By Tim Coffman /

It's no secret that the music business is about money at the end of the day. Regardless of how much artistic integrity a band has, it all comes down to finding something that you think will be sold to the masses for long after you're gone. While some may ride the trend wave for the rest of eternity, others have just gone back down to the well for what worked the first time.

Advertisement

There's nothing wrong with drawing from what made you good to begin with, but these songs are almost carbon copies of songs these acts have already perfected in the past. Does that mean their bad songs? Not really... they just might not be bringing anything new to the table. Even though it might seem like a desperate plea for these musicians to maintain control of their audience's attention, there's a bit of scale when it comes to songs like these.

Some may improve upon the initial song, some may just continue a story that you've heard before, but the worst of these just end up sounding like the band on autopilot praying that their listeners don't notice that they wrote the same track again. Despite being promoted into the ground, some of these songs may have worked much better as outtakes.

10. Footsteps - Pearl Jam

Footsteps is an interesting case study when it comes to the grunge rock lore. As opposed to being a great tune, at the end of the day, this song actually became the foundation for two totally different bands. While it's understandable to have some cross influence in the Seattle scene, it's another thing to just do a song all over again.

Advertisement

After losing Mother Love Bone vocalist Andy Wood to an overdose, guitarist Stone Gossard started shopping around for a new singer with the initial licks of what would become Footsteps. Though the band that would later be Pearl Jam found their man in Eddie Vedder because of this tape, they ended up running into trouble when Chris Cornell took a liking to the track when cutting material for the grunge tribute record Temple of the Dog.

While the song ended up being released as Times of Trouble on the TotD record, Pearl Jam also released the song as a B-side to their single Jeremy, with completely different lyrics by Vedder continuing the story put forth on the PJ tunes Alive and Once. Instead of reworking the music, the acoustic guitar slides and hazy energy remain virtually unchanged on the original song. It's one thing to try to pass off your riff in two separate bands, but this is the kind of recycling that was a little too close for comfort.

9. Bad Guy - Eminem

Every hip hop fan remembers where they were the first time they heard Stan by Eminem. In just a few short minutes, Slim Shady was able to write a detailed description of how far fan obsession can push someone, with the titular character going over the edge and killing his young girlfriend and himself to impress his idol. While many fans would have killed to have the songwriting caliber of this stature come back to Em, no one was really expecting something like Bad Guy.

Advertisement

Appearing fittingly on the second Marshall Mathers LP, this next delve into fan obsession actually picks up right where the original Stan left off. As opposed to having to deal with a completely different persona, the new character in this one is Matthew, the little brother of the original Stan mentioned all the way back in 2001, who has come back to do justice to the man who cost his brother his life.

Something like this would usually come off as a cheap way for an artist to get back in touch with their roots (which it is), but the horror style of vocals feels much more raw now that Em has gotten older, as he's being thrown into the situation again after not receiving closure from the first one. In lesser hands, this would have been pandering to the lowest kind of fan, but to have something this triumphant in the later part of your career was enough to leave die hard Slim fans cheering in their seats.

8. Numb - Linkin Park

Numb by Linkin Park is one of those few songs that hasn't aged a day. While the nu metal styles present in the video may reek of the '00s nowadays, the pure pain in Chester Bennington's vocals on this track is still relatable to any young teen who has ever felt left out or marginalized in their lives. Even though these guys had one of the best selling rock singles on their hands, that didn't stop the subtle retreading from seeping in.

Advertisement

When taken out of the context of Meteora, this track just feels like another attempt to rewrite In the End, only with a more radio friendly twist to it. Using the same kind of drawn out type of chordal arrangement, it almost feels like the choruses of both songs could easily be transposed against each other without many fans even noticing the difference.

Then again, this might be one of the few times when the new version is actually an improvement over the original. Although In the End has the endlessly quotable verses, the more subdued role from Mike Shinoda and powerhouse performance by Bennington make the entire song feel like an emotional punch to the gut. At a time when Numb could have fell on its face, it became the rallying cry that proved that Linkin Park were here to stay.

7. Don't Look Back - Boston

Most bands of the '70s could only dream of having an album that was as successful as Boston's debut. Across just a handful of tracks, Tom Scholz packed every song with so much ear candy that nearly every song became a hit. Then again, if this was the big hoorah for Boston hitting the big time, Don't Look Back was the start of the long fall back down.

Advertisement

From the opening title alone, never has a song been more aptly named, with most of it being a blatant redo of the old bag of tricks that made the group successful in the first place. Though it's never a bad thing to play it safe when releasing a first single from a new project, this is the kind of song that goes too far the other way and just makes you want to turn on something like More than a Feeling again.

Even the band themselves weren't really looking to venture too far out of the box on this one, with some members saying that they hoped to use this song to coast off of the goodwill of the fans. This is still the high quality rock music that you want, but for the life of you, take the band's advice and try not to pay attention to the much better stuff on the album before.

6. Cryin' - Aerosmith

Aerosmith is one of the few rock bands that actually made it through the '90s pretty gracefully. Even though grunge had sent most other bands packing with the gnarly sounds coming from Seattle, these Bad Boys from Boston gave it a fair shot with Get a Grip, with songs that gently toed the line between emotionally potent and commercially viable. However, the end of the record showed that the group was playing it a little too safe.

Advertisement

Coming as one of the leadoff singles from the project, Cryin' became the one of the emblematic songs of the group's resurgence, with Steven Tyler reaching deep in the back of his throat to get the more emotional side of the song across. The success ended up working so well that they just tried to do it again on the EXACT SAME ALBUM. As opposed to the more dramatic parts of Cryin', Crazy is actually a much better song, making the glitz and glamour of the original look too over the top by comparison.

To add insult to injury, even the video follows the same type of formula, down to band once again casting Alicia Silverstone for a shoot. It's one thing for a band to remain consistent, but when you have a rewrite that's clearly better, why release both?

5. Stop When the Red Lights Flash - Green Day

Most Green Day fans have come to grips with the fact that the Uno Dos and Tré trilogy was a bit of a misfire. While not every track on those were full-blown stinkers or anything, even Billie Joe Armstrong himself has stated that the rollout seemed like a bit too much too soon. Though many Green Day fans had their fair share of catchy tunes, it gets a little dicey when you end up cribbing from your greatest album.

Advertisement

On the surface, Stop When the Red Lights Flash sounds like a decent Green Day rocker, with a catchy guitar line and a vocal that matches it with the punchy chorus of "I'll make you surrender." However, the real problem here is when you realize that you've actually heard that guitar line before. While the tempo has sped up by a little bit, the central riff of this song is a direct rip from one of the transitional sections of their opus Homecoming off of American Idiot.

Billie Joe may have subconsciously borrowed the melody from one of his other songs, but the fact that one of the bridge parts from one great song is good enough to be another Green Day song unto itself was bound to raise a few eyebrows. Despite having some pretty interesting moments, songs like this are why the trilogy feels like Green Day on easy mode.

4. All the Wrong Reasons - Tom Petty

Tom Petty seemed to be on Cloud Nine at the start of the '90s. After making some of the greatest heartland rock of the '80s, he shacked up with Jeff Lynne for a few weeks to create the solo smash Full Moon Fever, which yielded some of the greatest hits of his career, from Free Fallin' to Runnin Down a Dream. While it would have been fine to have an album like that in your discography, there was a bit of musical deja vu once the Heartbreakers were brought back into the mix.

Advertisement

As an album, Into the Great Wide Open almost has the ability to surpass Petty's first solo joint, from the weightless Learning to Fly to the blunt criticism of fame on the title track. On the other hand, in the middle of the record All the Wrong Reasons arrives, sounding like a slice of life in between the speakers. The acoustic guitars send you reeling , as Petty starts to wax poetic about people down on their luck choosing to go down fighting.

Nothing too wrong with that synopsis... other than the music is a copy and paste of Free Fallin'. Though there have been some improvements made in the lyrical department, the same key, tempo, and general song construction makes this sound like Petty trying to capture lightning in a bottle again, with even some of the Heartbreakers jokingly calling it "ReFallin." There is a lot of stuff that this song does right... even if it had to take a few cues from its musical older brother.

3. Tomorrow and Tonight - KISS

You couldn't find a hard rock band bigger than KISS in the late '70s even if you tried. Despite having some of the most over the top performances, these four demonic figures out of New York laid claim to the rock throne, complete with one of the greatest stage shows that the rock world had ever seen. Even though fans had flocked to these freaks on their live album Alive!, some of the members started to pick up some bad habits when it came to songwriting.

Advertisement

From a raw production standpoint, the 1977 album Love Gun is an outright classic, with songs like the title track and I Stole Your Love being a fixture of the group's setlist for a long time. Though we were still in hard rock world, Tomorrow and Tonight is plagiarism at its cheapest, with Paul Stanley doing the best he can to rewrite their anthem Rock and Roll All Nite from the ground up.

As opposed to the energetic live feel of the original song, this hook line is filled to the brim with '70s cheese, with what sounds like random back up singers being brought on to add that extra punch line (that they didn't deliver on). Despite being centered around the future, Tomorrow and Tonight became yesterday's news real quick.

2. D'You Know What I Mean? - Oasis

The back half of the '90s seemed to be ruled by Oasis. After the grunge rock started to fade away and most rockers started to get burnt out, these Mancunian misfits led by the Gallagher Brothers ushered in the new era of Britpop, with some of the catchiest tunes of the modern age across albums like Definitely Maybe. While they may have been the biggest band in the world, Be Here Now showed the Britpop locomotive stalling right out of the gate.

Advertisement

Setting you up for something big, D'You Know What I Mean? feels epic, from the long intro to the gigantic soundscape the group created on the studio recording. Then again, it's about how you use the tools rather than the actual tools you have, and this song is practically creative regression.

Though it's filtered through an electric guitar now, the entire chord structure of the verse is lifted verbatim from Wonderwall, only with Liam's voice sounding a bit more snide this time around. Something like this could be forgivable if it's the first single, but the Gallagher Brothers felt the need to keep things rolling for over seven minutes, making this boring piece go on for what feels like an eternity. With many years of retrospect, Be Here Now is one of the biggest misfires in the history of rock music, and given that this was our first taste of what was to come, many fans were right to be worried.

1. King Nothing - Metallica

It took real guts for Metallica to make a sudden career shift like they did in the early '90s. Once the thrash metal titans had run their course playing sonic juggernauts of songs across Master of Puppets and And Justice for All, their self-titled Black Album with Bob Rock gave them more hits than they could have asked for, from the relentless riffs of Sad But True to the modern classic Enter Sandman. While the band did try to switch it up again with their follow-up Load, the first single found everyone's favorite metal band on shaky ground.

Advertisement

For what it's worth, King Nothing still holds up as a great song from an arrangement standpoint, but there's a bit of unintended copying going on with the riff. Written by Kirk Hammett, the tempo, feel, and even note selection of the central riff of the song is almost the exact same as Enter Sandman. I'd be willing to concede that those bluesy riffs are just Hammett's style... if it weren't for the fact that the rest of the song is Sandman Pt. 2 as well.

Pretty much every single arrangement decision is lifted from the band's greatest hit, from the modulation in the pre-chorus to the big chords that dominate the chorus which give way to a solo hook line from James Hetfield. These guys seemed totally in on it too, with Hetfield singing "off to never never land" right before the song wraps up. There have been plenty of sequel songs in metal history, but it seems a bit too on the nose for Metallica to release something this derivative.

Advertisement