"Until You're Mine" plays like a power anthem from an early-2000s action-drama film. And I mean that solely as a compliment. The sweeping nature of the verses leading into the sudden thumping chorus takes the listener on a perfectly melodramatic journey, even up to the lingering cliffhanger of an ending. A darker edge lurks beneath the surface here, primarily in the composition's subtle hopelessness. This feels like it could fit snugly in Kelly Clarkson's discography, which further shows the direction in which Lovato skews as an artist.