10 Classic Rock Albums That Got Better Over Time

Music like a Fine Wine.

By Tim Coffman /

It's safe to assume that most things that fall under the term classic rock are mandatory listening for every rock fan. Since the explanation is right there in the title, there's no reason to think that these records won't hold up as legitimate classics that should withstand the test of time, right? Well, it turns out that not all classic rock artists have albums that are treated fairly.

Advertisement

As much as we might like to divide up the love amongst the best records of all time, there are always those few albums that are sidelined as bad or are just treated as a lesser entry in an artists' catalog. Even though it's pretty clear to see why these might not have taken off at the time, the years have been nothing but kind to these records going forward. For all of the faults that the fans may have had with them at the time, everything has seemed to smooth out in recent years, with these becoming some of the greatest pieces of work in the bands' catalog.

While it might be easy to clown on something in the moment, these were dragged through the mud only for them to be praised to the moon and back later. They might not be giving the stone cold classics a run for their money or anything, but they certainly deserve more love than what they got back in the day.

10. The Man Who Sold the World - David Bowie

As much as we like to believe that Ziggy Stardust may have beamed down onto Earth, David Bowie's transformation wasn't necessarily that smooth. After breaking out with Space Oddity in the late '60s, things were slowly building until the glam rock alien finally touched down to make first contact. In between that time though, Bowie actually got a taste for the heavier side of rock on the Man Who Sold the World.

Advertisement

Granted, the reason why people were turned off by this album may have been the cover itself, with the world not really being ready for this kind of androgynous rock star just yet. When you sit down with the music though, Bowie is actually a lot heavier on this album than before, taking the acoustic foundation that he had on some of his previous albums and turning it up to almost Black Sabbath levels of noisy.

Even though this album contains many members that would eventually become a part of Ziggy's backing band, you can tell that this is them working out the bugs and finding what sticks, and having a lot of gold to sift through at the end of everything on songs like Black Country Rock and Width of a Circle. Considering how many leaps and bounds that Bowie would make throughout his career, it's no surprise that this was the album with songs that would eventually be covered by Nirvana 20 years later.

9. Madman Across the Water - Elton John

In the age of vinyl, it felt like the radio stations were a little more lenient on the kind of music that could be played on stations. Hell, if a song like American Pie could reach the top of the charts in all its 9 minute glory, than anything was possible, right? Elton John certainly benefited from this with the song Tiny Dancer... now can we get the same kind of praise for the rest of the album that it came from?

Advertisement

When people bring up Madman Across the Water, they normally don't look at it past the monumental opening track. Long before Goodbye Yellow Brick Road though, this is where the songwriting partnership of Elton and Bernie Taupin started to reach perfection, with songs that have almost a cinematic bent to the way that they're structured. Since Bernie was always a wordsmith, this is the first time where you see him really put stories into his songs, like the bittersweet sounds of Levon or the heartbreaking tale of Native Americans in Indian Sunset.

Along with the lyrics, Elton really pulls out at the stops on this record, going for broke on every single track to make them feel like the soundtrack to the greatest '70s movie that never got made. If you were to look at any picture of Elton from around this time though, you weren't going to necessarily call him subtle, now were you?

8. Hard Promises - Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers

If there's one album that always feels destined to be forgotten in an artist's catalog, it's the one that comes after your classic album. It just stands to reason that since you've reached perfection of one on your albums that you're not expected to just do the whole thing over again. And while Hard Promises is clearly a different record than Damn the Torpedoes, the flaws are what really make this record a lot more enjoyable.

Advertisement

Compared to the experience had just to get Damn the Torpedoes off the ground, this is where the fatigue really sets in for Tom, with a lot of the songs either being downtempo or a lot more dark than the time before. That's not to say that it's devoid of its charm though, with the Waiting being one of his best singalongs in concert and Kings Road being a lovely ode to the first time that the band went to England.

Outside of those few moments though, you have songs like Something Big and Insider, each of which show portraits of people that have burned the candle at both ends and have to pay for it, either with their life or having to leave their old flame behind. While these songs definitely deserve a place among the best that Petty has to offer, you're not going to go into this record and hear a lot of happiness from back to front.

7. Draw the Line - Aerosmith

Whether the band wanted to admit it or not, Aerosmith were about to hit a major brick wall at the end of the '70s. With most of the group getting strung out on drugs, they would not come out of their defining decade intact, with Joe Perry getting into a huge scrap with Steven Tyler and leaving the band. Just before they crashed into the shore, they made the one album that puts all of that excess into a neat ball.

Advertisement

As much as Draw the Line might sound like a good time, there's a lot more sinister bite to some of these songs than you probably realize. If you ignore the god awful cover art for the record, this was the kind of hard edged version of Aerosmith that we had seen on Rocks, only with a lot more junk in their veins. When you listen to something like I Wanna Know Why, it practically feels like the song could fall apart at any moment, which they were pretty close to doing around that time as well.

Recording in a former penitentiary did also bring out their epic side as well, like when Steven Tyler writes a full blown viking tale on the song Kings and Queens, which is one of the most underrated slowburns that the band would ever create. Though it's a miracle an album like this even exists, it didn't necessarily point to great things to come or anything.

6. Desperado - Eagles

It's hard to really talk about an album getting better over time when it has some of the band's greatest hits on it. For most fans of the Eagles, Desperado is where things started to get a lot more mature, with Glenn Frey and Don Henley really recognizing their strengths as a songwriting team. If you were to ask their higher ups back in the day, this was the album that ended their career for good.

Advertisement

Coming off of their LA-flavored debut, this is the kind of cowboy record that should have been the total antithesis of what was happening in rock at the time. As you peel back the layers of everything, you have to give the guys credit for making a full blown concept album out of these songs, bringing in some new songs and fleshing out old ones to create a vivid picture of the modern outlaw. If you listen to something like the title track and Certain Kind of Fool, you can definitely get a sense of these folks from the wrong side of the tracks that are probably going to lose their lives in a shootout.

Even on some of the mellower tracks like Tequila Sunrise and Bitter Creek, you can hear the subtle nods to the pleasures of the lifestyle, using alcohol as a means to calm your nerves every once in a while. What it all amounts to is a record that makes for a great companion for those who find their home in the open road, whether that be on the run or on tour.

5. The Who Sell Out - The Who

If there's one thing that Pete Townshend will be commended for until the day he dies, it's going to be Tommy. Although songs like My Generation have etched themselves into rock history pretty prominently, the story of a deaf dumb and blind boy finding his calling through rock and roll is the kind of lightning in a bottle idea that no one saw coming. As any writer will tell you, you don't get that kind of idea without putting in the work first.

Advertisement

Long before Tommy was born in Townshend's mind, the Who were already looking to get more experimental than their contemporaries on the Who Sell Out, which stands as their first real concept record. Being inspired by the pirate radio stations that were popping up around the same time, this entire record plays out like a radio broadcast, complete with skits from the band connecting some of the tracks together.

Though the band would definitely get better from here, this is the record where they are the most zany, with songs like Odorono and Tattoo being a little bit tongue in cheek compared to the rest of what was going on during the Summer of Love. You can see the seeds of what's coming here as well, with Rael being one of the first long term pieces Pete would write and I Can See For Miles taking the idea of volume to its most logical conclusion. If anything, this album deserves its place in history just for Paul McCartney going on to make Helter Skelter specifically to try and best what the Who did here.

4. October - U2

There are more than a few rock fans who would much rather take a taser to Bono's nostrils than to listen to another minute of U2's music. Along with some feeling that they were overexposed, it's easy to see Bono's holier than thou outlook on rock and roll to be a little too pompous for its own good. If you think it's bad now, you can only imagine what happened when they took on religion on only their second time up to bat.

Advertisement

To this day, even the band seems to admit that making October so quickly after their first album may have been a rough bargain, being a lot more serious than some fans may have been willing to take. Although some people think that the album falls on the wrong side of preachy sometimes, the actual tunes at the heart of these tracks are still miles above what most others were capable of, like when Bono goes for long high notes on I Fall Down.

While songs like Gloria may be a lot to take in all at once, this is the definition of an album that was meant to grow on you, since you're only able to peel back the layers after spending some time with the record. More than anything, this feels more like the turning point for the U2 that we know today. It might have been called the sophomore slump at the time, but if the band hadn't gotten this little stumbling block, we probably wouldn't have gotten records like the Joshua Tree later.

3. Nebraska - Bruce Springsteen

90% of the appeal that comes from Bruce Springsteen is the power that he squeezes out of the E Street Band. As much charisma as this one Jersey boy has in his body, having someone like Clarence Clemons and Stevie Van Zandt by his side is what played into the myth of this storyteller of heartland rock. So when you strip him of every bit of his onstage confidence, how does he hold up when he's left with just an acoustic guitar?

Advertisement

Coming off of the massive sounds of something like Darkness on the Edge of Town, Nebraska almost feels hollow by comparison, being just a set of demos that Bruce decided to release in their raw form instead of taking them into the studio. While you can definitely tell that something's missing on these songs, they're the kind of stories that benefit from having only one man singing them.

Even though the Boss was getting tagged as the next version of Bob Dylan, he sounds like his own man painting these tales of sorrow, whether it's a man not getting closure from his past sins on My Father's House or a cop having to come to terms with losing his relationship with his brother on Highway Patrolman. Whereas the other albums got us used to what Springsteen was like as an electric frontman, this is the first moment where we got a glimpse at Bruce as a person.

2. Led Zeppelin III - Led Zeppelin

Led Zeppelin is one of the few bands that have come close to having a perfect career in the world of hard rock. Since the death of John Bonham put their studio career to a stop, the first slew of albums tend to have that golden sheen where everything seems to be in its right place. Out of the self titled saga though, Led Zeppelin III has always been known as the red headed stepchild of the group.

Advertisement

Although the album starts off with the Zeppelin classic Immigrant Song, you're not going to get the same amount of grit on the rest of the record, being much more downtempo and focusing more on the folksy side of the band's sound. That's probably enough to trigger alarm bells in the people who loved the hard hitting aspect of Zeppelin, but this has the same type of muscle...just in a different way.

After being soaked in the blues on their first few records, this is where we get hints of the more exotic side of their sound coming out, like the strange sounds of Gallows Pole or their delves into world music on a song like Friends. While this might show up last when ranking all of Zeppelin's self titled records, these were the songs that had to get made so we could listen to a song like Kashmir later down the line.

1. RAM - Paul McCartney

Almost every rock critic known to man has gone on extensively about how much the Beatles were ahead of their time. Even when they were making music that firmly found its place in the Summer of Love, they were still laying the groundwork for what the rest of us could do. When the Fabs were fractured in the '70s though, Paul McCartney wasn't done being experimental on RAM.

Advertisement

You wouldn't know that for the reviews though, with most Macca fans and even his fellow Beatles being more amused than anything about what was on here. Since he had adopted a life of domestic bliss on his farm, this is the kind of zany and weird album that Paul felt most comfortable with at the time, putting together mini epics like Uncle Albert/Admiral Halsey beside something like Heart of the Country or Eat at Home. There are even a few songs that almost defy genre altogether, like Monkberry Moon Delight sounding like a cowboy song that had taken a hit of bad acid.

Of all the different faces that this album has though, it does fit into one niche, and it didn't even exist yet. Whether Paul intended to or not, this is the kind of off the wall album that would have fit perfectly in the indie rock scene just a decade later, with him throwing everything he can against the wall and seeing how everything plays out when he's done. While this might have been a change of pace at the time, Paul hadn't lost his way by any stretch. If anything, we all had to keep up with him.

Advertisement