10 Cover Songs Much Better Than The Original

Just because it's first, doesn't always mean it's best.

By Jacob Trowbridge /

In most instances of a musician re-recording another artist's song, the best you can hope to say about the new rendition is that, well, at least it's different. The notion that another artist can come along and genuinely improve on the original is rarely vindicated, especially when the original song isn't total garbage. There's also an incredibly varied opinion among music fans as to what constitutes a song being "better," since music is perhaps the most subjective form of entertainment. So don't expect to see a song on this list unless it's unequivocally considered a superior version. (Sorry to fans of Johnny Cash's "Hurt" and Muse's "Feeling Good," they're amazing but not necessarily better.)

Advertisement

But much like Adam Sandler is destined to release a watchable movie now and again, and Chris Pratt is bound to eventually do something to knock himself down to the second most charming person on the planet, it's not impossible for a reworking to come along that completely blows the first iteration out of the water.

These artists have the consensus where it pertains to their surpassing the song's creators, earning a Gold Medal in the (unfortunately non-existant) Music Cover Olympics.

Advertisement

10. Kim Carnes - "Bette Davis Eyes" (Jackie DeShannon)

Advertisement

This was first recorded by Jackie DeShannon (who you may know as the singer behind "What the World Needs Now Is Love" and "Put a Little Love in Your Heart") for her 1974 album, ironically titled New Arrangement, and is a much jauntier, Motown-lite song. DeShannon also displays zero passion or enthusiasm, crafting a hollow pop song only meant as a good-time record for the dance clubs.

But a few years later, Kim Carnes would get into the studio with her sultry, raspy vocals and drip her sex all over the track, turning it into a lustful, fiery anthem featuring a synth-heavy sound. She's basically a female Rod Stewart, with all the sexual reverberations that statement implies.

Advertisement

9. Noah Guthrie - "Sexy And I Know It" (LMFAO)

Advertisement

The bar for this one is so low that it's almost not even fair to include it, but I have to...because it's my job. Sometimes you just have to pick the low hanging fruit, guys. Although it seems absurd to strip down an obvious, novelty dance track like LMFAO's "Sexy and I Know It"--particularly because there doesn't appear to be anything of substance in the lyrics--the simple refrain fits surprisingly well when it's cloaked in a deep, bluesy, soulful rasp.

The arrangement is nothing special, but simply cutting out all the extra electro house beats and blips to focus on the bare, acoustic chords makes a world of difference.

Advertisement

8. Santana - "Black Magic Woman" (Fleetwood Mac)

Advertisement

Look, there's nothing wrong with the Fleetwood Mac original, but Santana made "Black Magic Woman" into five minutes of complete perfection. The rhythm gets jazzier as Santana saunters all over the place with his seductive guitar lines, and the vocals are a little smokier under Gregg Rolie's direction.

Again, Fleetwood Mac did a fine job on this track, nicely mixing together blues guitar and rock vocals, but it sounds a little too understated and rigid, like everyone was trying too hard to be perfect, instead of letting it all ooze out on its own. That's what Santana did, every note sounding as if he it was being pumped through him by a higher, more musically-inclined power.

Advertisement

7. Eric Clapton - "Cocaine" (J.J. Cale)

Advertisement

A number of Cale's songs would be covered by various artists, usually to the detriment of the original artist. (Sadly, few people credit Cale with the writing of "Call Me the Breeze" and "After Midnight," both songs that Eric Clapton would cover as well, to much worse effect than this example.) J.J. Cale is a real cool dude, but he was almost too cool to perform this song.

Although both versions of "Cocaine" follow almost the exact same arrangement, Cale's comes off as uncommonly chill, with a weird disco influence to it. This certainly isn't a bad song in Cale's hands, but Clapton manages to give it a bigger spark. There's a dirty swagger to Clapton's guitar work and a playful gruffness to his voice that's missing from the original.

Advertisement

6. Johnny Cash - "One" (U2)

Advertisement

There are a lot of songs from Johnny Cash's American Recordings collection that could have found their way onto this list, but a few are that are commonly lauded as superior (namely "Hurt" and "Personal Jesus") aren't unequivocally better so much as they are wonderfully different. That, however, is certainly not the case with his cover of U2's "One." Johnny Cash's version is just plain better. Hands down.

There really was only one guy who could take a Bono track, blend it with country, rock, gospel, folk, and a healthy dose of heartache, and then absolutely own that !*$% song. It's hard to listen to U2's "One" these days--which sounds a bit too self-important and needlessly grandiose by comparison--without pining for Cash's take.

Advertisement

5. The Beatles - "Twist And Shout" (The Top Notes)

Advertisement

People can (and probably will) argue for eternity whether The Isley Brothers or The Beatles performed a better version of "Twist and Shout." Some are adamant that the Fab Four's appropriation of R&B was disingenuous and shallow, while others claim John Lennon made that song with his crazy, gravelly vocal style.

And although we may never come to an agreement on this, here's something we all can agree on: Both versions are better than the 1961 original recorded by The Top Notes. The groovy, Phil Spector-produced tune is a cutesy surf rock jam that sacrifices a lot of heart and soul for the sake of capturing the "sound of the day," and even the writer of "Twist and Shout" hated the way it came off. Meanwhile, both the Isleys and the Beatles knocked it out of the park. I personally prefer The Beatles' version, if only because those damn vocals literally scream rock and roll, but much respect is due to The Isley Brothers for transforming it into a classic sing-along.

Advertisement

4. Pearl Jam - "Last Kiss" (Wayne Cochran)

Advertisement

Once again, there are bound to be a few people who disregard Pearl Jam's minimalist cover of "Last Kiss" to be too similar to the classic J. Frank Wilson version of the 60s for it to be considered "better." I would argue that Vedder's vocals are as on-point with "Last Kiss" than any original PJ jam, and the rocked-up instrumentation gives this story song the weight it lacked in Wilson's.

But REGARDLESS, the debate between who did it better is largely irrelevant once you realize that it was actually the super-couffed Wayne Cochran who originally recored "Last Kiss." His Elvis-lite vocals never really allowed this song to shine the way it should. (Simply reading the story in the lyrics is more likely to tug the heartstrings than Cochran's subdued vocals.) Again, my personal preference would be for Vedder and company's 1999 version, but I understand this isn't as uniformly shared of an opinion as the others on this list.

Advertisement

3. Aretha Franklin - "Respect" (Otis Redding)

Advertisement

This is one of those that will send a lot of people to Youtube or Wikipedia, saying to themselves "That can't possibly be a cover," but just trust me on this one and allow me to blow your mind for a minute. Otis Redding originally recorded "Respect" in 1965 as a relatively misogynistic track (though it would never be defined as such back in that era), using "respect" as a metaphor for sex. Redding's song is a compromise to his woman, suggesting that she can do whatever she wants while he's away at work, but when he comes home, dammit he's gonna want a strong showing in the bedroom. Classy, isn't it?

Aretha's version, released two years later, is a rallying cry for strong, independent women to demand equality because deserve R-E-S-P-E-C-T! (That spell-it-out chorus was added by Franklin, by the way, as were the "sock it to me" chants of the backup singers, as if you needed another reason to believe this was a better recording in every way than Redding's.) But Aretha didn't just improve on a slightly bitter ode to diligent sex, she transformed it into a feminist declaration and one of the greatest songs of the era.

Advertisement

2. Led Zeppelin - "Babe I'm Gonna Leave You" (Joan Baez)

Advertisement

Zeppelin gets a lot of crap for stealing bits and pieces of other people's tunes and appropriating them into their own discography ("Dazed & Confused," "Whole Lotta Love," and "The Lemon Song" all reportedly plagiarized portions of lesser-known songs), but no one ever gives them credit for straight-up covering songs like bosses. "Babe I'm Gonna Leave You" is as clear cut case as there is of a band outshining the original version to such an extent that no one even bothers to mention the Joan Baez original, because no one wants to make Joan feel bad about herself.

Whereas Baez dove deep down into the sorrow pit when she sang "babe, I'd like to stay here," Robert Plant makes it sound like the decision to leave is literally ripping his heart right out of him. And of course, Page, Bonham, and Jones do their part to make it a typically epic Zeppelin track.

Advertisement

1. Jimi Hendrix - "All Along The Watchtower" (Bob Dylan)

Advertisement

It's extremely rare for a Bob Dylan to be completely outclassed by another musician, but if there's ever an example where Dylan had his humility blown up for all the world to see, it was when the folk legend admitted that Hendrix's version of "All Along the Watchtower" is the definitive interpretation of the song. In fact, Dylan was so impressed by it that he now feels obligated to perform it Jimi's way in concert. In the booklet accompanying his 1985 compilation, Biograph, Dylan writes:

"I liked Jimi Hendrix's record of this and ever since he died I've been doing it that way... Strange how when I sing it, I always feel it's a tribute to him in some kind of way."

When a cover song is so good that it makes the original artist change the way they perform the song, it's pretty hard to argue that it isn't superior.

Advertisement