10 Cover Versions That Are Absolute Masterpieces
Elevating other people's work to new heights...
The cover version has had a varied reputation over the years. Depending on your outlook it can be considered as either an exercise to interpret another's work in your own way, or merely an admission that you do not have enough original material of your own to record.
Once the staple of any upcoming wanna be pop singer in the 1950s and 60s, today a cover version is treated, at best, as a tribute to a revered artist from the past rather than an original interpretation of another person's music. At worst, a cover can sound like a pastiche and an acceptance of a contemporary artist's limitations.
But, put in the right hands a cover version can become a great piece of work. It can highlight both the strengths of the original song and those of the artist performing the piece.
Then there are the rare occasions when a solo artist, or group, takes a piece of music and then transform it into something far greater than the original composer could ever achieve or imagine. In fact their versions are so good that they become the definitive version themselves, the ones most known in popular culture.
10. I Say A Little Prayer (Aretha Franklin)
Aretha Franklin never intended to record Bacharach and David’s hit. The song was just one that she would sing with her backing singers, The Sweet Inspirations, for fun. Whilst in the studio rehearsing tracks for her forthcoming album Aretha Now, it became apparent that they were singing the song that well they had to record it.
Backed by Clayton Ivey on piano, Franklin set about rearranging the Dionne Warwick original. Changing how she delivered the lyrics and letting The Sweet Inspirations sing the majority of the chorus the result was a more soulful rendition far superior to Bacharach’s rather kitsch production. Released in July 1968 the song - like a few others on this list - was only intended to be a B side to the single The House That Jack Built. After significant airplay by DJs the song was released as a single properly in October reaching number ten in the Billboard Hot One Hundred.
It was one of the few cover versions that Bacharach preferred to his own version. He was never really happy with how Dionne Warwick had sung it, feeling that the whole production had been rushed. In fact he did not want the song released. Yet, if it had not been for Warwick’s imperfect original then there would not been any possibility for Franklin to improve on it.
9. Wild Is The Wind (David Bowie)
In 1975 David Bowie was in the midst of his Thin White Duke persona. Fueled by a diet of cocaine, milk, and green peppers, he set about recording his next album in Los Angeles. With his growing fascination in the occult and the Jewish mystical system, the Kabbalah, the resulting Station To Station gave a tantalizing insight into his confused state of mind. Yet, the one track that stands out in contrast to the rest of the album is his version of Dimitri Tiomkin and Ned Washington’s Wild Is The Wind.
Recorded by Johnny Mathis in 1957 it was later covered by Nina Simone and released in 1966. It is Simone’s version that inspired Bowie. He had met her in 1975 and decided to record the song as a homage to the American singer.
Basing the song around a sparse arrangement of guitar, drums and bass, Bowie imitates many of Simone’s mannerisms letting the song build up slowly. His vocals are somewhat detached yet at the same time extremely emotional showcasing Bowie’s extraordinary skill of acting a persona in a song.
In later years it would become a highlight of his live tours with the audience often joining in to sing the line "Don’t you know your life itself" with him.
8. Hallelujah (Jeff Buckley)
Today it can sound as if Jeff Buckley’s take on Leonard Cohen’s Hallelujah is a little too overused. It can be heard on countless film and TV soundtracks usually in some moment that needs to emphasize an emotional scene. Yet, it is the absolute mastery of Buckley’s version that makes it so ubiquitous.
Compared to Cohen’s original it is a thing of beauty. While Cohen sounds cold and almost uninterested in his singing, Buckley, gives the song the emotional depth and turmoil that the subject matter of the lyrics deserve.
What makes Buckley’s take even more interesting is that it is a cover of cover. Much in the same way that Bowie based his version of Wild Is The Wind on Nina Simone’s cover, Buckley based his interpretation of Hallelujah on John Cale’s recording of the song.
Accompanied by only his guitar Jeff Buckley sings the song to perfection never once making the nearly seven minutes running time seem overlong or unnecessary. Sadly, Buckley would die only a few years after its release but the song is his lasting legacy, and a frustrating glimpse of the heights he might have achieved had he still been with us today.
7. Unchained Melody (The Righteous Brothers)
Originally written for a little known 1954 prison film called Unchained (hence the song's title), this song was a major hit for several artists a decade before The Righteous Brothers put their name to it.
Les Baxter, Jimmy Young and Liberace all had success with the song and other artists such as Perry Como and Gene Vincent had recorded their own versions. In 1955 there was four different versions of the track in the Billboard One Hundred alone. It was also in nominated for the Academy Award for Best Original Song. Yet, it wasn't until The Righteous Brothers' recording that it was elevated to the heights we commonly hear today.
Another song originally released as a B side, Bobby Hatfield chose to sing the song. Both he and Bill Medley were allowed one solo track each per album. With Hatfield at the microphone Medley set about producing the recording. Normally Phil Spector would produce the duo's singles but as he considered the song as filler he let Medley take the reins.
What ensued was a classic take on an already well-known song. Again, radio DJs preferred the B side to the intended A side and a hit was born.
6. With A Little Help From My Friends (Joe Cocker)
Before finding commercial success with this version of a Beatles classic, Joe Cocker was a little known singer from Sheffield, UK. He had been doing the rounds on the music scene for most of the 1960s and already had a failed record contract under his belt.
Radically different from The Beatles original, Cocker changed the beat and the tempo for his rendition, even changing the chords in the middle eight. Beginning with an organ heavy introduction with Jimmy Page playing lead guitar the result was a slower, more expressive track in stark contrast to the playful, pop melody of the original.
On hearing Cocker’s interpretation Paul McCartney was blown away. He was so impressed that he sent a telegraph to Cocker to congratulate him. The Beatles even placed an ad in the music papers praising the song.
It went to number one in the UK singles chart and in 1969 Cocker performed the song live at Woodstock. It was on that stage, drenched in sweat, that Cocker cemented his reputation as a live performer with the song being included in the documentary film of the festival.
It soon became an anthem for the counterculture movement and gained even more fame years later when it was used as the theme song for the television series The Wonder Years
5. Hurt (Johnny Cash)
When Nine Inch Nails’ Trent Reznor was asked if Cash could record his song Hurt he was initially flattered but hesitant. He was worried that the idea of the country music legend covering this track sounded too much like a gimmick but he agreed to it anyway.
Initially skeptical of recording the song himself, it was producer Rick Rubin who convinced Cash to record the track. Rubin saw the song as the perfect fit for the veteran musician.
With his health seriously deteriorating due to autonomic neuropathy brought on by diabetes, Rubin noted that Cash sounded broken during sessions. Undoubtedly it was his fragile physical state that helped him interpret the song in a new way. Were Reznor had written the song from the viewpoint of a young adult on a downward spiral to self-destruction, Cash sung the lyrics with the knowledge of someone who knew they were at the end of their life.
Accompanied by a heart breaking video the song was a fitting last goodbye from Cash, a man who had suffered his fair share of hard times during his life. He would die only a few months after its release.
4. Respect (Aretha Franklin)
Listening to Aretha Franklin's version of Respect you can clearly hear her strengths as an arranger and not just as a performer. Not only did she change the arrangement of this song, she also changed the meaning of the lyrics and added the "R-E-S-P-E-C-T" refrain turning the song into the classic we love today.
In Otis Redding's original, his lyrics come from the viewpoint of a hardworking man who demands respect for being the breadwinner of the household. His protagonist is desperate and the respect he receives from his wife is all he has to look forward at the end of the day.
Franklin made the inspired choice of turning the viewpoint of the lyrics around. It is she who demands the respect from her man. She never does him wrong and knows she has everything he wants. It is a declaration from a strong, confident woman. Another element she added was the backing line of "Sock it to me" which quickly became a household expression.
The song became a huge hit and earned her two Grammy Awards. It also became an anthem for the burgeoning Civil Rights and Women's Rights movements at the time.
3. All Along The Watchtower (Jimi Hendrix)
When Bob Dylan released his John Wesley Harding album in 1967 it was seen as a return to his acoustic roots. Acquiring a copy before its official release, Jimi Hendrix knew he had to cover one of the album’s tracks.
After some consideration Hendrix chose All Along The Watchtower. He had always felt a close affinity to Dylan’s music, claiming that his songs "... are so close to me that I feel like I wrote them myself."
This was definitely the case with All Along The Watchtower and he was in the studio laying down his version in less than two months. He quickly cut a large number of takes on the first day and even reportedly took over on bass guitar when original bass player, Noel Reading, left proceedings.
Dylan was overwhelmed when he heard Hendrix’s version and claimed that the visionary guitarist had improved his song. In an acceptance speech in 2015 Dylan said "We can’t forget Jimi Hendrix ... He took some small songs of mine that nobody paid any attention to and brought them up into the outer limits of the stratosphere, turned them all into classics."
2. I Heard It Through The Grapevine (Marvin Gaye)
The intro to Marvin Gaye's version of this Motown classic is probably one of the most instantly recognizable in pop music. The trickle of percussion followed by the keyboards chords slowly building up to until the drums and bass kick in as Gaye sings the opening line.
Written by Norman Whitfield and Barrett Strong the song was offered to various Motown acts, such as Smokey Robinson and The Isley Brothers. In 1967 it was given to Gladys Knight And The Pips to record. Their version had more a funky sound and was intended to rival Aretha Franklin’s Respect. It became a hit and reached number one on the Billboard R&B chart. Although it is undoubtedly easier to dance along to, it, nevertheless, fails to have the same emotional punch of Gaye's rendition.
Whilst in the studio, Gaye, took instructions from Whitfield, who was producing, to sing slightly higher than his normal vocal range. The result was a performance that was perfect for the song’s lyrics of a man in disbelief after hearing about his girlfriend’s infidelity.
It was only intended to be an album track but repeated playing by radio DJs convinced Motown owner Berry Gordy to release it as a single were it reached number one in the charts, staying there for seven weeks.
1. I Fought The Law (The Clash)
Joe Strummer and Mike Jones first became aware of this song whilst recording The Clash's second album at The Automatt studio in San Francisco. Hearing it on the studio's jukebox the two of them immediately became fans and decided to record it.
Originally written and recorded in 1959 by Sonny Curtis and the Crickets, it is the song's second release that has gone down in infamy. A hit for the Bobby Fuller Four in 1965 the eponymous Bobby Fuller was found dead in his mother's car from asphyxiation. The police ruled it as suicide but some people have speculated that he was murdered by the mafia.
Yet, it is The Clash's version surpasses that of the previous two recordings. Whereas the previous versions are catchy but unremarkable cuts The Clash give the song a stronger, yet rawer, sound. The intro starts with the building up of Topper Headon's drums before the earsplitting riff kicks in and Joe Strummer spits out the first lines in his own unique style.
Released in the UK on their The Cost OF Living EP the song helped them break in the USA. It was their first single to be released in the United States gaining them airplay along the way.