10 Famous Rock Albums That Were Almost Called Something Else

Had things gone differently, music fans would be talking about these albums in very different ways.

By Jacob Simmons /

"What’s in a name? That which we call a rose by any other name would smell as sweet."

Advertisement

This is a quote from William Shakespeare's classic play Romeo & Juliet, spoken by the latter in reference to her and her lover being from warring family lines.

But let's face it, everybody knows that Big Bill was really writing about some of the biggest rock albums of all time and the names they were almost given! It's blatantly obvious!

Coming up with an album name might seem simple, but it's actually a proper pain in the backside. Something so minute can have a huge effect on a record's success, as if it's got a bad or unattractive name, then people will not be listening.

These bands found that out the hard way, as their original ideas for album titles were all thrown out for one reason or other. In some cases, this led to a less interesting name being used, but, most of the time, this was actually a blessing in disguise.

In the words of Shakespeare once again, all's well that ends well for these legendary recordings.

10. Black Sabbath - Paranoid (Almost Called “War Pigs”)

Though their self-titled debut is regarded now as one of the most important heavy metal albums ever made, Black Sabbath's most famous album is arguably the follow-up to that record, Paranoid.

Advertisement

Released just seven months after the debut, Paranoid capitalised on the group's momentum and established metal as a genre to be reckoned with. The album of course takes its title from the song of the same name, which has gone on to become one of the band's calling cards, but it was almost named after another track.

Sabbath were told that they needed a three-minute piece of filler to complete the album, so they cobbled together a simple tune to plug the gap. This would turn out to be Paranoid, which the record company correctly assumed would be a massive hit.

As a result, the album took on that name, but it was originally intended to be called War Pigs, after the song that would open the record up. Funnily enough, War Pigs itself also went through a name change, as it was initially going to be called Warpulgis, after the Satanic festival of worship.

All this chaos less than a year after their debut release - sounds exhausting.

9. Iron Maiden - Piece Of Mind (Almost Called “Food For Thought”)

When it comes to metal bands, you don't get them more British than Bruce Dickinson and his squadron of flying hellraisers, aka Iron Maiden.

Advertisement

Not only were they formed in the UK, but the band have gone to great lengths to preserve British history in their songs, writing extensively about various conflicts that the country has been involved in over time.

All this considered, it should come as no surprise that the group came up with the name for their fourth studio album in that most British of locations - the pub.

Whilst staying in Jersey, which is a British crown dependency, despite the fact that it's closer to France, Maiden decided on a title after concluding that the album's artwork would show Eddie, their mascot, following a lobotomy.

Piece of Mind makes perfect sense in this grim context, but the name Food for Thought was previously considered, as it too was a play on words.

Food for Thought is an okay name and all, but Piece of Mind was definitely the right choice. It's clever and it fits with Maiden's gruesome MO, without implying that anyone got fed a slice of their own brain.

8. Sonic Youth - Daydream Nation (Almost Called “Tonight’s The Day”)

Alternative icons Sonic Youth had been together since 1981, but it wasn't until 1988's Daydream Nation that things really started to take off.

Advertisement

Their fifth album got so popular it earned the tenured performers their first ever major label deal. Songs like Teen Age Riot and Silver Rocket introduced many young listeners to a previously unheard world, opening the doors for the alt revolution of the 1990s.

Daydream Nation is a great title; it's evocative, it's memorable, it does everything right. So imagine how different things might have been had the band gone with a name that was basically a parody of a Beatles' title from nearly 30 years earlier.

Tonight's the Day, which came from a lyric in the song Candle, was initially considered, as it alluded to the Neil Young album, Tonight's the Night. Mercifully, Sonic Youth instead opted to name their work after a lyric to another of the album's songs, Hyperstation.

It wouldn't have been a disaster had the other name been chosen, but it would have been a bit of a let down, plus Mr. Young and The Beatles might have given their lawyers a call.

7. Arctic Monkeys - Suck It And See It (Almost Called “The Thunder-Suckle Fuzz Canyon”)

Whilst not as super famous as the other albums on this list, the alternative names for this Arctic Monkeys album from 2011 were just too good to ignore.

Advertisement

And yes, that's names, plural.

What ended up being called Suck It and See, after an old English expression meaning "to give something a try", went through several different monikers before it hit shelves.

In an interview with NME, the band confirmed there were many working titles considered, including The Thunder-Suckle Fuzz Crayon, The Rain-Shaped Shimmer Trap, and Thriller.

All of these fit in with the Monkeys' cheeky chappy, nonsense poet personas, as demonstrated by the fact that there's a song on this album called The Hellcat Spangled Shalalala.

Suck It and See seems like the most tame of those options, but even that landed the group in some hot water. In the USA, the album's title was obscured by a sticker when on sale in major retailers, as they considered it too rude to be displayed in public.

Would they have done the same thing if this album had been called The Thunder-Suckle Fuzz Crayon instead? Probably not.

6. Pink Floyd - The Dark Side Of The Moon (Almost Called “Eclipse”)

Thanks in part to its all-time great album cover, The Dark Side of the Moon by Pink Floyd remains a fixture of pop culture even though it came out all the way back in 1973.

Advertisement

It may as well be engraved on a stone tablet, it's so old.

With estimated sales figures of between 25 and 45 million units worldwide, this is one of the best-selling albums in history, but all those customers very nearly handed over their cash for a record called something else.

The Dark Side of the Moon was the original working title for the album, but plans were changed when it was discovered the band Medicine Head had released a record with the same name the previous year. In response to this, the Floyd work was retitled Eclipse, after the song of the same name.

However, once the Medicine Head album failed to sell, Floyd relished the opportunity to re-claim the title, and the rest is history.

Why was the Machine Head album such a failure? Was the music not very good? Or had Roger Waters been out at night, stealing copies from local record stores to sabotage them? Both are plausible.

5. Bon Jovi - New Jersey (Almost Called “Sons Of Beaches”)

If there is a level higher than Cloud 9, then Bon Jovi were on it following the release of Slippery When Wet.

Advertisement

A worldwide sensation, the album catapulted the long-haired rockers to megastardom; a perch they haven't come down from since. It sold 12 million copies in the US alone, and several more million worldwide, thanks to songs like You Give Love a Bad Name, Wanted Dead or Alive, and Livin' on a Prayer.

When the time came to release something else, Bon Jovi had the choice to give it a serious name or carry on with the suggestive imagery. You can see where this is going.

The original title for the band's fourth album was the hilariously rubbish Sons of Beaches, which really doesn't need any explaining. More sensible heads eventually prevailed and the idea was canned, but, if anything, Bon Jovi went too far the other way and gave the album a really boring title instead!

New Jersey? Sure, it's their home state, but really? That's the best they could come up with? Everyone knows that Bruce Springsteen had the Jersey music market cornered years before 1988!

Maybe Sons of Beaches wasn't such a bad idea after all...

4. The Smiths - The Queen Is Dead (Almost Called “Margaret On The Guillotine”)

One of the forerunners of the modern indie rock movement, The Smiths were never one to shy away from expressing themselves in their music. They had an album called Meat is Murder, for crying out loud; how much more unsubtle can you get?

Advertisement

Led by Morrissey's singing and Johnny Marr's expert composing, The Smiths ruled the roost for just five years before disbanding in 1987. One year before that, they released their third album, The Queen is Dead.

As controversial as that title was, things would have been way more heated had the band gotten what they originally wanted. When in the studio, the working title for the record was Margaret on the Guillotine, in reference to British Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher.

Mrs. Thatcher had drawn the ire of many working class British people for her perceived lack of support for those on the breadline. Hating her was very much in line with The Smiths' salt of the earth beliefs.

There was no way that a title like this would have ever been greenlit, so a phrase from the Hubert Selby Jr. novel Last Exit to Brooklyn was chosen instead.

3. The Beatles - The Beatles (Almost Called “A Doll’s House)

It might officially be called The Beatles, but The Fab Four's seminal 1968 double album is more widely known as The White Album, due to its distinctive plain cover.

Advertisement

Created off the back of the band's visit to India, The White Album is the group's wildest collection of songs; from the deeply introspective Julia to the satirical Piggies to the full-on heavy metal track Helter Skelter.

Instead of a simple title or one assigned to it by other people, The Beatles was nearly called A Doll's House, which might have been an allusion to the various different songs "living" inside of it. But alas, somebody else got their first.

Psychedelic band Family released their debut album, Music in a Doll's House, just four months prior to The Beatles' record's release. Not wanting to get the two albums mixed up, the Liverpudlians opted for the much simpler title that everyone knows and loves today.

Would the cover have still been plain white had it been called A Doll's House? Would "The White Album" as it is now exist had Family not come along? As with many Beatles-related questions, nobody will ever know for sure.

2. U2 - The Joshua Tree (Almost Called “The Two Americas”)

Rather than plants on which people called Josh are grown, Joshua trees (scientific name yucca brevifolia) are an extremely tenacious form of flora native to the desert areas of the Southwestern United States.

Advertisement

U2 came across one whilst shooting the cover for their upcoming fifth album. Bono was taken by the tree's religious connections, as it took its name from the biblical prophet, and decided that it should also be used as the record's title.

And when Bono says something, you make it happen!

The band were in the desert because they wanted an image that showcased the contradictory nature of the United States; life flourishing in a harsh and unforgiving landscape. They were location scouting when they came across the tree, which resulted in a complete change in what the album was going to be called.

Originally, it was going to be named either The Two Americas or The Desert Songs, in reference to those aforementioned themes of civilisation in a tough environment.

Rather than those blunt, on-the-nose descriptions, the band opted for the far more subtle option and, in doing so, paved the way for their best-selling album ever.

1. Metallica - Kill ‘Em All (Almost Called “Metal Up Your Ass”)

James Hetfield and Lars Ulrich were both just 19 years old when Metallica's first album came out, which might explain why they wanted to call it something so gloriously infantile.

Advertisement

Kill 'Em All, as it came to be known, was what set the ball in motion for the world's biggest metal band. Songs like Hit the Lights, The Four Horsemen, and Seek and Destroy changed the game, bringing thrash to a new audience and turning Metallica into one of the coolest groups in the world.

Whether this opinion would have remained had the album been given its original name is up for debate.

Because of course they did, the band wanted to call their studio debut Metal Up Your Ass, complete with a picture of a dagger emerging from a toilet on the front cover. Thank God, Satan, and every other mystical being going that Jon Zazula, the head of Megaforce Records, managed to talk them out of it.

That man should be in the Rock 'n' Roll Hall of Fame for this achievement alone.

Imagine if Metallica's career had begun with an album with a toilet on the front cover? Doesn't even bear thinking about.

Advertisement