10 Hard Rock Debut Albums That Suck
Green Day really did start off with one hell of a thud.
It's never easy making your first record. After slogging it out playing one club after another, the idea of working on your first ever major piece of work tends to be a bit daunting. Though many have knocked it out of the park from the word go, it's not always that easy.
From the beginning of time, there have been thousands of bands that really haven't put their best foot forward on their debut. Whether it was because of a changing lineup or some random sound that wasn't coming together, these records are definitely not the best these guys have to offer. That's not to say that all of these records are misfires. While some of them have prepared bands for a lifetime of mediocrity, the reason why a lot of these records end up sounding bad is because the other material they would make down the line sounds so much better by comparison.
Even though these records tend to sound a bit like amateur hour at the best of times, it wasn't much longer until we heard what these bands could really do (or couldn't do). Regardless, this is far from the greatest look for these guys. There's hitting the ground running...and then there's just hitting the ground.
10. 39/Smooth - Green Day
In all of punk, no other band has been both loved and hated as much as Green Day. For all of the fans they earned off the strength of albums like Dookie and American Idiot, there have always been those who prefer their old stuff before they "sold out." Then again, it's not like these guys were necessarily great right off the bat.
Across their debut record 39/Smooth, you can tell that these guys are just having fun trying to figure out what the hell they are. Whereas Billie Joe Armstrong has an impressive knack for writing melodies on I Was There and Going to Pasalacqua, the rest of the record is a bit too slipshot to actually be taken seriously. Even though Mike Dirnt delivers a killer bass performance as to be expected, the sloppiness of original drummer Al Sobrante really shows, as he trips over fills and always sounds like he's racing to keep up with the rest of the guys.
Even though Tre Cool would be brought in later, there was pretty much no chance of this iteration of Green Day actually succeeding out of the Bay Area punk scene with Al still in their ranks. While most of this record is just a passable punk release, all great acts have to take their baby steps somewhere.
9. Styx - Styx
There's always a bit of contention surrounding Styx as a whole. Hell, there are probably still a certain subsect of fans who argue that these hard rock darlings were never even that good in their prime. Despite having some great tracks that have withstood the test of time, their first album was a bit too much for your average joe to handle.
Compared to what they would be delivering on albums like The Grand Illusion, Styx's self-titled is in a totally different musical galaxy. Being descendants of prog rock giants like Yes and Genesis, you can definitely hear them wearing their influences on their sleeve a bit too much, with the closest thing to a hit being Best Thing, which would later be re-recorded altogether once the band gained a bit more traction. For those going back to hear more stuff like Renegade and Come Sail Away, all this album offers is some generic musical movements and even an interpolation of Aaron Copeland's Movement for the Common Man.
However, the biggest crime of this album is the fact that Tommy Shaw isn't even in the group yet, leaving Dennis DeYoung as the real captain of the musical pieces. Though DeYoung is serviceable for what he is, this kind of record just sounds like it's aching for that little extra spark to send it over the edge.
8. Peter Criss - Peter Criss
At the end of the '70s, the original lineup of KISS was really starting to get cracks in it. After their venture into the world of acting on KISS Meets the Phantom of the Park led to one of the most unwatchable rock and roll movies imaginable, Ace Frehley and Peter Criss were ready to hang up their makeup and costumes for good. To put a bandage over the situation, management thought it would be best if everyone cut their own separate solo albums.
While Frehley's ended up being the most successful out of them all, Peter Criss' debut still lives in rock infamy. Compared to the others, Peter had the most unique voice, with a rasp just sharp enough to rival someone like Rod Stewart. Instead though, we got treated to mostly soul music on this solo outing, with Criss using an outside co-writer on nearly every song.
To his credit, Peter does give a fantastic vocal performance on every one of these tracks...it's just a shame that they're not good songs. Even the KISS army couldn't really find it in themselves to compliment it, with the massive fan reception being either confusion or outright hatred right off the bat. The Catman may be a blast to watch while onstage, but this goes to show you that not all of his nine lives need to be in the spotlight.
7. Trouble - Whitesnake
It's virtually impossible to think of the hair metal movement gaining as much traction if it hadn't been for Whitesnake. Though David Coverdale's band of misfits had already had their fair share of hits under their belt, the release of songs like Here I Go Again and Is This Love is what really brought them into the big leagues of rock gods. On the other hand, we will not being seeing said magic on Trouble.
Long before Whitesnake was even a group, it was originally just the name for one of Coverdale's solo albums before metamorphosing into an actual band. While Trouble is by no means a terrible album from back to front, it just is not what you come to Whitesnake for. From one track to the next, you can still tell that these guys are trying to work out the bugs, with most of it being just a bunch of bluesy licks with Coverdale's voice slapped on top. Their cover of the Beatles' Day Tripper still remains one of the weirder ventures they have even taken on.
Seeing how this was produced by the same guy who manned the boards for Deep Purple's records, you can tell that Coverdale just wanted to play it safe and try to get by on the goodwill of his previous band. You're definitely getting there, but David, buddy, you know you can do better than this.
6. UFO 1 - UFO
UFO still remains one of the many undiscovered gems of the '70s hard rock scene. Though the band did give the world one of the greatest soloists of all time in Michael Schenker, you were hardpressed to find them on rock radio even at the best of times. So if they can't even get on the air with some of their greatest work, what chance do they have when they're still working out the bugs?
Yeah, instead of the bluesier hard rock of songs like Lights Out or Rock Bottom, UFO 1 is a different beast entirely. Whereas Schenker would make a riff that could tear your head off, this album takes the moniker quite literally, with songs that are much more space themed than rock based. Though there are some hints at their later potential on their cover of the Bo Diddley song Who Do You Love, it just isn't on the same level of what they would be when Schenker was brought into the fold.
Even though these guys were as green as they come at this juncture, it just reads like they wanted to spend their time making a cheap knockoff of an ELO record. You can't really hold their next albums against them, but if this was their A-material, it was no wonder that they couldn't get arrested in the beginning.
5. Shades of Deep Purple - Deep Purple
You never really knew what to expect when it came to Deep Purple. At the start of the hard rock revolution, these seasoned pros were taking all the bits and pieces from jazz, blues, and even classical music and mixing it into their own glorious ball of noise. That is...if you're talking about the classic version of the band.
Whereas some people talk about the virtues of Ian Gillan and Roger Glover or even Glenn Hughes and David Coverdale, that's not how these guys originally started out. Brought up in the jam band scene, much of Shades of Deep Purple tends to play out like a second-rate version of someone like Vanilla Fudge or Humble Pie, with half of the songs being reimaginings of classic rock songs like Help and Hey Joe. Though the guitar prowess coming from Ritchie Blackmore is spot on, it doesn't really fit when put next to Rod Evans' warbly low register.
While the single Hush did give them their first hit on the charts, it was only a matter of time before they realized they were in need of a change. After a few more albums of the same schtick, these guys made the conscious decision to go in their own direction, ditching Evans and bassist Nick Simper for Glover and Gillan. There may have been a lot of potential in the beginning, but if they kept going down this road, there's a good chance they would have been known as one hit wonders today.
4. The Rolling Stones - The Rolling Stones
So...how does this slot go to one of the most celebrated bands of all time? I mean, ever since the Rolling Stones first reached American shores after the Beatles, they practically have a halo put around everything that they do, right? While there are some choice Stones cuts on here, this is one of the first times we get a glimpse at The Rolling Stones as a cover band.
At this juncture of the group's career, a good chunk of their material was nothing but specializing in bluesy covers that they would deliver right back to the American public. Though the Stones would use this to great effect by covering acts like Robert Johnson later down the line, it gets a little old when nearly every single track is exactly the same thing. Though Brian Jones is certainly showing himself to be one of the best guitarists of his generation, Mick Jagger and Keith Richards haven't really gelled as a songwriting team just yet.
Then again, it's not like they do a bad job with the covers, with Route 66 actually going over pretty well along with their incredible version of I Just Want to Make Love to You. Even though this was amazing at the time, this self-titled debut is an album that's only essential if you're truly doing a deep dive into the Stones' work.
3. Metal Magic - Pantera
Pantera is one of the few bands whose songs sound like they can cut through steel. Once the '90s alternative scene exploded, these metalheads from Texas came along and made their own unique brand of kickass one lick at a time. However, there's a whole different side of the group that many would prefer to keep under wraps.
While many would like to think that Cowboys From Hell is their debut record, their real beginning comes in the form of Metal Magic, which is one of the most unintentionally hilarious bait and switches you'll ever hear. Compared to their heavier period later down the line, this is a glam rock tunesfest that the Abbott Brothers made when they were first starting Pantera in their teens. Though the songs aren't offensively played or anything, it's just not what you come to this band for. It also doesn't help that pretty much every song is such a Van Halen knockoff that it's hard to take seriously.
If you told any common metalhead that the minds behind these songs would eventually make something like Walk or I'm Broken, they'd probably laugh you right out of the room. Even though Dimebag Darrell and Vinnie Paul certainly had chops back in the day, it would take a little while before they reached their full potential.
2. Pretties For You - Alice Cooper
Alice Cooper has never really been known as the most radio-friendly of artists. Even when the proper group was having massive crossover hits with School's Out and I'm Eighteen, their macabre look and bloody live shows earned them just as many angry parents as they did loyal fans. While plenty of people pegged them as having no talent, they may have had a point if they're talking about Pretties For You.
Right off the bat, this album was not really meant to be a commercial explosion. Long before Cooper and his group of misfits hooked up with Bob Ezrin, he was under the wing of art rock legend and general weirdo Frank Zappa. As it stands, we get an Alice Cooper record that's really trying to be a Frank Zappa record, with the results being borderline incoherent. Since Cooper was always known to have a bit of weirdness in his music, just piling more outlandish noise into the mix doesn't really solve the problem.
That's when the record even has a mix, with some songs sounding like they were recorded live from the bottom of a damp well. Though Reflected from this album would be reworked into Elected on Billion Dollar Babies, it's a good indicator of this record's shoddy delivery, with every production detail either pushed to the max or ignored entirely. Whereas the best of Alice Cooper is always fun to listen to, these songs could leave your ears bloodied and bruised at the worst of times.
1. Rocka Rolla - Judas Priest
Judas Priest never seem to get enough credit for being the world's first great metal band. Whereas acts like Black Sabbath or Deep Purple get the award for making the first metal songs, the genre didn't really have a name until Priest burst onto the scene with tracks like Hell Bent for Leather and Victim of Changes. On the first record though, we were exposed to Judas Priest: metal's greatest bar band.
Then again, it's almost hard even calling this a Judas Priest album considering the bulk of it wasn't even written by any of the core members. Instead, these songs were written by original vocalist Al Atkins, who quit before the album was even being made. As such, Rob Halford sounds so out of his element on this outing, with the lower register required for some of these songs not really giving him a chance to shine.
It also doesn't help that Atkins wasn't necessarily the greatest songwriter, with a lot of these tracks sounding like second-rate versions of the typical rock and roll you would find playing out of a dumpy dive bar at 2 in the morning. Though Rocka Rolla is technically proficient for what it is, when you know it's coming from the almighty Priests of metal, this feels almost blasphemous.